WEALTH PLANNING AND MANAGEMENT
topic 8
Retirement
Prof Datuk Dr Syed Othman Alhabshi/Shaikh Hamzah
1
© INCEIF 2012.
2
© INCEIF 2012.
3
© INCEIF 2012.
CONTENTS
4
© INCEIF 2012.
CONTENTS (Cont’d)
5
© INCEIF 2012.
CONTENTS (Cont’d)
6
© INCEIF 2012.
CONTENTS (Cont’d)
7
© INCEIF 2012.
CONTENTS (Cont’d)
8
© INCEIF 2012.
INTRODUCTION
9
© INCEIF 2012.
INTRODUCTION (Cont’d)
10
© INCEIF 2012.
INTRODUCTION (Cont’d)
11
© INCEIF 2012.
INTRODUCTION (Cont’d)
12
© INCEIF 2012.
THE NEED FOR RETIREMENT PLANNING
13
© INCEIF 2012.
THE NEED FOR RETIREMENT PLANNING (Cont’d)
14
© INCEIF 2012.
THE NEED FOR RETIREMENT PLANNING (Cont’d)
15
© INCEIF 2012.
Definition of Retirement Planning
16
© INCEIF 2012.
Retirement Planning Process
Formulate retirement goals and determine the life style desired in retirement. Similar to personal financial plan, a retirement plan must have goals which are specific, realistic and in measurable terms i.e. the amount required and the time parameter. At this stage, priorities for planning are established, such as the date of retirement, lifestyle change, any residence change, risk tolerance and planned employment after retirement, if the need may arise.
17
© INCEIF 2012.
Retirement Planning Process (Cont’d)
Obtain Necessary Financial Information to Determine Retirement Needs
18
© INCEIF 2012.
PHASES OF RETIREMENT AND RETIREMENT PLANNING PROCESS
19
© INCEIF 2012.
Retirement Planning Process (Cont’d)
20
© INCEIF 2012.
Retirement Planning Process (Cont’d)
This method assumes that changes in the cost of living will be reflected by changes in the individual’s income, and the post-retirement income needs can be estimated from the individual’s pre-retirement income. The standard of living prior to retirement is therefore the determining element in the standard of living post retirement.
21
© INCEIF 2012.
Replacement Ratio Method (Example)
22
© INCEIF 2012.
Replacement Ratio Method (Example)
23
© INCEIF 2012.
Replacement Ratio Method (Example)
24
© INCEIF 2012.
Expense Method
This method constructs a budget for post-retirement living. The budget consists of basic requirement such as housing costs, food, clothing, and other necessities e.g. medical expenses, etc. The budget would be tabulated more accurately the closer the person is to retirement age.
Mr. Syed Umar from Example 1 above would need to list out all the expenses he may need during his retirement years, i.e. from age 56 onwards, as per the table below:
25
© INCEIF 2012.
Expense Method (Cont’d)
26
Expenses | Monthly in current RM | Yearly in current RM |
Food House insurance (takaful) House assessment/quit rent Utilities (Electricity, telephone, water, ISP, etc) Home maintenance (repair, gardening) Clothing and personal care (both husband & wife) Medical expenses (general check up with GP, dentist) Transportation (car, petrol, parking, toll, road tax, insurance) Entertainment Hobbies (club fees) Travel (once overseas and twice locally) Personal insurance (takaful) Miscellaneous TOTAL | 1000 200 500 200 200 600 200 300 200 500 | 12000 2400 1000 6000 3000 2400 2400 7200 2400 3600 16000 2400 6000 66,800 |
© INCEIF 2012.
Expense Method (Cont’d)
27
© INCEIF 2012.
Expense Method (Cont’d)
28
© INCEIF 2012.
�Analyze Information and Calculate Savings Needed to Meet the Objectives�
a) Determine the lump sum retirement goal required at retirement age
29
© INCEIF 2012.
Analyze Information and Calculate Savings Needed to Meet the Objectives (Cont’d)
30
© INCEIF 2012.
Analyze Information and Calculate Savings Needed to Meet the Objectives (Cont’d)
31
© INCEIF 2012.
Analyze Information and Calculate Savings Needed to Meet the Objectives (Cont’d)
b) Calculate the future value (e.g. age 55 for Syed Umar as in Examples 1 and 2) amount of current funding vehicles such as the EPF, endowment policies, shares, properties and other invested assets which are used to fund the amount in a) The rates of return would vary with each funding vehicle.
c) If the amount in b) exceeds the requirement in a), then the client has sufficient funds to fulfill his retirement needs. However, if the amount in b) is below a), then there is a gap to fill in order to meet his retirement funding. The financial planner would now need to review the client’s financial health to see if there are other areas where this shortfall could be met.
32
© INCEIF 2012.
Analyze Information and Calculate Savings Needed to Meet the Objectives (Cont’d)
33
© INCEIF 2012.
Plan The Distribution, Ascertaining The Best Method To Distribute That Is Best For The Client.�
34
© INCEIF 2012.
Capital Retention / Principal Intact Method
35
© INCEIF 2012.
Capital Retention / Principal Intact Method (Cont’d)
36
© INCEIF 2012.
�Capital Liquidation Method�
37
© INCEIF 2012.
Capital Liquidation Method (Cont’d)
38
© INCEIF 2012.
Capital Liquidation Method (Cont’d)
39
© INCEIF 2012.
DISCOUNTED CASH FLOW CALCULATIONS Pre-retirement
40
© INCEIF 2012.
DISCOUNTED CASH FLOW CALCULATIONS Pre-retirement
41
© INCEIF 2012.
DISCOUNTED CASH FLOW CALCULATIONS Pre-retirement
42
© INCEIF 2012.
DISCOUNTED CASH FLOW CALCULATIONS Pre-retirement
43
FV = PV (1 + r)
© INCEIF 2012.
DISCOUNTED CASH FLOW CALCULATIONS Pre-retirement
44
© INCEIF 2012.
Implement the Plan
45
© INCEIF 2012.
�Review the Plan�
46
© INCEIF 2012.
�Availability of Non-Funded “Safety-Nets”�
In Malaysia, there are hardly any non-funded “safety nets” other than
47
© INCEIF 2012.
�INVESTMENT STRUCTURE FOR RETIREMENT�
48
© INCEIF 2012.
INVESTMENT STRUCTURE FOR RETIREMENT (Cont’d)
49
© INCEIF 2012.
INVESTMENT STRUCTURE FOR RETIREMENT (Cont’d)
50
© INCEIF 2012.
INVESTMENT STRUCTURE FOR RETIREMENT (Cont’d)
51
© INCEIF 2012.
INVESTMENT STRUCTURE FOR RETIREMENT (Cont’d)
52
© INCEIF 2012.
INVESTMENT STRUCTURE FOR RETIREMENT (Cont’d)
53
© INCEIF 2012.
INVESTMENT STRUCTURE FOR RETIREMENT (Cont’d)
54
© INCEIF 2012.
INVESTMENT STRUCTURE FOR RETIREMENT (Cont’d)
55
© INCEIF 2012.
RETIREMENT SCHEME
56
© INCEIF 2012.
RETIREMENT SCHEME (Cont’d)
(a) Defined-Contribution Pension Scheme: In this scheme, both the employer and the employees contributed a defined amount of contributions to the funds. This method is sometimes referred to as the “money purchased pension scheme” because the participant’s in the account is traditionally employed to purchase an annuity from an insurer to provide pension payment during the retirement.
57
© INCEIF 2012.
RETIREMENT SCHEME (Cont’d)
58
© INCEIF 2012.
RETIREMENT SCHEME (Cont’d)
The salient feature of this scheme is that the pension benefit is pre-determined at the inception, taking into consideration the post retirement standard of living of the retiree. Due to this reason, this type of scheme is considered more desirable by employees. This however requires more cumbersome and administration work on the part of the employers. define benefit plan is tax deductible
59
© INCEIF 2012.
RETIREMENT SCHEME (Cont’d)
60
© INCEIF 2012.
RETIREMENT SCHEME (Cont’d)
61
© INCEIF 2012.
RETIREMENT SCHEME (Cont’d)
62
© INCEIF 2012.
RETIREMENT SCHEME (Cont’d)
63
© INCEIF 2012.
RETIREMENT SCHEME (Cont’d)
64
© INCEIF 2012.
RETIREMENT SCHEME (Cont’d)
65
© INCEIF 2012.
RETIREMENT SCHEME (Cont’d)
66
© INCEIF 2012.
RETIREMENT SCHEME (Cont’d)
67
© INCEIF 2012.
RETIREMENT SCHEME (Cont’d)
68
© INCEIF 2012.
RETIREMENT SCHEME (Cont’d)
Share options are offered to employees to purchase the company’s share at a certain price that has to be exercised before a particular future date. If the taken up price is lower than the market price, the employee can make a profit by selling the shares. In Malaysia, the gain is taxable in the hand of the employee as it is deemed capital asset.
69
© INCEIF 2012.
RETIREMENT SCHEME (Cont’d)
A company may opt to provide a share allotment to its employees as part of its compensation program to retain productive workers. This kind of compensation does not have favorable tax treatment to the employers as this is not a tax-deductible expenditure to the company – as it is deemed that no expenditure is incurred in the transfer of ‘paper shares’ to the employees. However, the benefit is not taxable in the hand of the (golden parachute)
70
© INCEIF 2012.
RETIREMENT SCHEME (Cont’d)
Gratuities are payments and rewards for the services rendered to employees when they retire from active work or no longer able to work due to illness or disability. In the case where the employee is deceased, the gratuity payment will be made to their beneficiaries.
A gratuity would be exempted from tax if it is on retirement from an employment and the employee has served the company for more than 10 years and when retirement is due to illness.
71
© INCEIF 2012.
RETIREMENT SCHEME (Cont’d)
The design of a retirement benefit will depend on the needs and the circumstances of the employers in mind. Some are designed to meet full retirement needs whereas some are designed to meet partial needs. The defined-contribution and defined-benefits are designed to meet specific needs such as a pension scheme. Some schemes have smaller retirement benefits but take bigger consideration in compensating and rewarding the employee as part of the retention scheme or motivating the employees towards achieving the company’s profit target.
In the Islamic context, the setting up of a pension plan by the employer to fulfill the needs of the employee during retirement is extremely encouraged as this forms part of the social security system.
72
© INCEIF 2012.
RETIREMENT SCHEME (Cont’d)
For a retirement plan to succeed, there must always be accomplished funding. Of course, any funding that involves investment is exposed to risks, such as market risks and specific risks.
Market risks can be mitigated by using modern portfolio theory where diversification and asset allocation are crucial to ensure returns optimization. Hence, the common shift is from an aggressive portfolio at a younger age to that of a more conservative nature.
Specific risks can be mitigated by careful selection of investment tools; hence the expertise of the professional fund managers or asset managers will come to play.
73
© INCEIF 2012.
�PROVIDENT FUND AND OTHER RETIREMENT FUND SCHEMES�
74
© INCEIF 2012.
PROVIDENT FUND AND OTHER RETIREMENT FUND SCHEMES (Cont’d)
75
© INCEIF 2012.
PROVIDENT FUND AND OTHER RETIREMENT FUND SCHEMES (Cont’d)
76
A/C | PURPOSE | % OF CONTRIBUTION |
A/C I | For retirement purposes at age 55 | 70 |
A/C II | For housing, education and withdrawal at age of 50. Withdrawal for housing can be made every 3 years | 30 |
| | |
© INCEIF 2012.
PROVIDENT FUND AND OTHER RETIREMENT FUND SCHEMES (Cont’d)
77
© INCEIF 2012.
PROVIDENT FUND AND OTHER RETIREMENT FUND SCHEMES (Cont’d)
78
© INCEIF 2012.
PROVIDENT FUND AND OTHER RETIREMENT FUND SCHEMES (Cont’d)
79
© INCEIF 2012.
PROVIDENT FUND AND OTHER RETIREMENT FUND SCHEMES (Cont’d)
80
© INCEIF 2012.
Advantages and Disadvantages of Payroll Deduction IRA
81
© INCEIF 2012.
PROVIDENT FUND AND OTHER RETIREMENT FUND SCHEMES (Cont’d)
A SEP allows employers to set up a type of IRA for themselves and each of their employees. Although the employer does not have to make contributions every year, they must contribute a uniform percentage of pay for each employee. For the year 2005, employer contributions are limited to the lesser of 25 percent of pay or $42,000. Most employers, including those who are self-employed, can establish a SEP. SEP have low start-up and operating costs. The employer can decide how much to put into a SEP each year since this plan offers some flexibility when business conditions vary.
82
© INCEIF 2012.
Advantages and disadvantages of SEP plan
83
© INCEIF 2012.
PROVIDENT FUND AND OTHER RETIREMENT FUND SCHEMES (Cont’d)
a) 401K Retirement Plans
The 401(k) plan has become a widely accepted retirement savings vehicle for small businesses in the US. It is estimated 42 million American workers participate in 401(k) that have total assets of about $1.9 trillion. A 401(k) is a type of retirement plan which allows the employee to save and invest for their own retirement. It is a special type of account funded through pre-tax payroll deductions. Under this plan, the employee will authorize the employer to deduct a certain portion of their salary before income taxes are taken out or as deferred payment on salary. The money will then be invested in the 401K Plan. These deferrals are accounted separately for each employee.
84
© INCEIF 2012.
PROVIDENT FUND AND OTHER RETIREMENT FUND SCHEMES (Cont’d)
85
© INCEIF 2012.
PROVIDENT FUND AND OTHER RETIREMENT FUND SCHEMES (Cont’d)
86
© INCEIF 2012.
PROVIDENT FUND AND OTHER RETIREMENT FUND SCHEMES (Cont’d)
87
© INCEIF 2012.
Benefits of 401K
88
© INCEIF 2012.
PROVIDENT FUND AND OTHER RETIREMENT FUND SCHEMES (Cont’d)
A safe harbor 401(k) plan is intended to encourage plan participation among rank and file employees and to ease administrative burden by eliminating non discriminating annual testing usually applied under a traditional 401(k) plan. This plan is ideal for businesses with high salaried employees whose contributions would be limited in a traditional 401(k) plan. A safe harbor 401(k) allows employees to contribute a percentage of their salary each paycheck and requires employer contributions. In a safe harbor 401(k) plan, the mandatory employer contribution is always 100 percent vested.
89
© INCEIF 2012.
PROVIDENT FUND AND OTHER RETIREMENT FUND SCHEMES (Cont’d)
90
© INCEIF 2012.
PROVIDENT FUND AND OTHER RETIREMENT FUND SCHEMES (Cont’d)
Contributions to a profit-sharing plan are at the discretionary of the employers. There is often no set amount of what they need to contribute each year and if they choose to, the amount will differ according to their set plans.
The ERISA below illustrates the market risks related to changes in government legislation. In 1974, a law was passed by the United States Congress with the intention of encouraging individuals to save for their own retirement.
91
© INCEIF 2012.
PROVIDENT FUND AND OTHER RETIREMENT FUND SCHEMES (Cont’d)
92
© INCEIF 2012.
PROVIDENT FUND AND OTHER RETIREMENT FUND SCHEMES (Cont’d)
93
© INCEIF 2012.
PROVIDENT FUND AND OTHER RETIREMENT FUND SCHEMES (Cont’d)
Pension systems in the Middle East and North African countries today are at a crossroads. They all have earnings-related pension schemes, in essence financed on a pay-as-you-earn basis, which were formed in the late 1960s and early 1970s.
Basically, pension funds today favor middle and high income workers at the expense of low income wage earners. These schemes cover, on average 30 percent of the labour force. Despite these relatively modest coverage levels and the fact that only 5-10% of the elderly actually receive a pension, expenditures are already in the range of 1-3% of the gross domestic product (GDP), which is above expectations, given international patterns and current demographics.
94
© INCEIF 2012.
PROVIDENT FUND AND OTHER RETIREMENT FUND SCHEMES (Cont’d)
95
© INCEIF 2012.
Barriers to Pension system-MENA
96
© INCEIF 2012.
PROVIDENT FUND AND OTHER RETIREMENT FUND SCHEMES (Cont’d)
The Australian Superannuation program is a defined contribution plan, a private pension plan, albeit mandated by the federal government. Superannuation is a form of savings where money is set aside by the employee and the employer and invested for retirement of the employees. Contributions are made by the employer to a fund the ownership of which is vested in the individual worker. When it was introduced in 1992 the contribution rate was 3% with provision for it to increase by increments to the present 9%. Payouts to workers upon retirement are dependent upon the accumulated value of their individual funds.
97
© INCEIF 2012.
PROVIDENT FUND AND OTHER RETIREMENT FUND SCHEMES (Cont’d)
98
© INCEIF 2012.
PROVIDENT FUND AND OTHER RETIREMENT FUND SCHEMES (Cont’d)
99
© INCEIF 2012.
PROVIDENT FUND AND OTHER RETIREMENT FUND SCHEMES (Cont’d)
100
© INCEIF 2012.
PROVIDENT FUND AND OTHER RETIREMENT FUND SCHEMES (Cont’d)
101
© INCEIF 2012.
PROVIDENT FUND AND OTHER RETIREMENT FUND SCHEMES (Cont’d)
A Registered Retirement Savings Plan (RRSP) is a personal savings plan registered and approved with the Canadian federal government. The program is designed to encourage Canadians to save for their retirement by providing powerful tax reduction options. An RRSP is an investment portfolio designated for retirement savings. It can contain a variety of investments such as RRSP savings deposits, treasury bills, guaranteed investment certificates (GICs), mutual funds, bonds, and even equities.
102
© INCEIF 2012.
PROVIDENT FUND AND OTHER RETIREMENT FUND SCHEMES (Cont’d)
103
© INCEIF 2012.
STREAMING RETIREMENT INCOME
An “income stream” is simply a term used to cover any range of products that bring forth a steady stream of income. Issues of control and management will be of most concern to the retiree.
Pension
Pension schemes have been explained in detail in subsection 8.4.1. In Malaysia, it is common knowledge that government servants receive a monthly pension after retirement, calculated as a percentage of the last drawn salary. In the event of death of the retiree, the pension continues to be paid to the deceased’s spouse.
104
© INCEIF 2012.
STREAMING RETIREMENT INCOME (Cont’d)
105
© INCEIF 2012.
STREAMING RETIREMENT INCOME (Cont’d)
106
© INCEIF 2012.
DISCOUNTED CASH FLOW CALCULATIONS Pre-retirement
107
© INCEIF 2012.
DISCOUNTED CASH FLOW CALCULATIONS Pre-retirement
108
© INCEIF 2012.
DISCOUNTED CASH FLOW CALCULATIONS Pre-retirement
109
FV = PV (1 + r)
© INCEIF 2012.
DISCOUNTED CASH FLOW CALCULATIONS Pre-retirement
110
© INCEIF 2012.
Post retirement – inflation factor
111
© INCEIF 2012.
112
© INCEIF 2012.
b. Principal liquidation method
113
© INCEIF 2012.
Review Questions
1.Discuss the different kinds of Islamic financing instruments that result in incoming streaming
2. Explain the concept of Retirement from Islamic perspective
3. a.Explain the replacement ratio method and expense method and its advantages and disadvantages.
b. Explain the capital retention method and capital liquidation method.
© INCEIF 2012.
REVIEW QUESTIONS (Cont’d)
115
© INCEIF 2012.
Thank you
116
© INCEIF 2012.