TUCK COMMUNITY CONSULTING
2021
Vermont Community Farm
SUMMARY: WE HAVE IDENTIFIED A FEW COMMUNITY AREAS OF INTEREST AND AN INITIAL ESTIMATE OF BUILDING COST
Geography
Building cost estimates
SUMMARY: WE HAVE IDENTIFIED A FEW COMMUNITY AREAS OF INTEREST AND AN INITIAL ESTIMATE OF BUILDING COST
Geography
Building cost estimates
Building cost estimates
DESIRED LOCATIONS
East of the Long Trail on the Northern Sections:
Locations adjacent to the Appalachian Trail:
DESIRED LOCATION PARAMETERS: ROBIN HOOD MODEL
Zip codes with:
Zip codes with:
LOCATION RECOMMENDATIONS GIVEN DESIRED ROBIN HOOD MODEL PARAMETER OVERLAY
East of Essex, near Underhill
Northeast of Rutland & Southwest of Hartford
Zip Codes with:
300+ households with disposable income > $50k annually
300+ households below the poverty level
NOISE POLLUTION SHOULD NOT BE A MAJOR FACTOR NORTHEAST OF BURLINGTON AND RUTLAND
LAND SEARCH PRIORITIZATION CRITERIA
Proximity to identified townships (<1 hour drive)
Access to trail systems
Size (>50 acres)
Paved Road access
Increasing Priority
NORTH LOCATION SAMPLE PLOTS
| #1 Worcester | #2 Waterbury |
Distance from Underhill | 55 mins | 30 mins |
Access to Trails | Yes (Timberlands) | Yes (private) |
Paved Road Access | No (dirt) | Yes |
Size | 3568 Acres | 62 Acres |
Price | $3.7M | $450K |
Price Per Acre | $1037 | $7258 |
SOUTH LOCATION SAMPLE PLOTS
| #1 Fairlee | #2 Bridgewater |
Distance from Rutland | 30 mins | 30 mins |
Access to Trails | Yes (private) | Yes (private) |
Paved Road Access | No (gravel) | No (dirt) |
Size | 83 Acres | 626 Acres |
Price | $147K | $801K |
Price Per Acre | $1771 | $1280 |
LAND SEARCH KEY CONSIDERATIONS AND TRADEOFFS
Availability
Additional Costs
Other Considerations
JERICHO UNDERHILL, UPPER VALLEY AND VERMONT LANDS TRUSTS ARE THE MOST FEASIBLE
Land Trusts | Feasibility |
Charlotte Land Trust | Nothing over 125 acres |
Duxbury Land Trust | Nothing over 30 acres |
Greensboro Land Trust | Not in the area we want |
Jericho Underhill Land Trust | Right area and land >200 acres |
Lake Champlain Land Trust | Not in the area we want |
Northern Rivers Land Trust | Nothing over 121 acres |
Richmond Land Trust | Nothing over 100 acres |
South Hero Land Trust | Not in the area we want |
The Watershed Center | Not in the area we want |
Upper Valley Land Trust | A little east of Royalton and has large tracts of land |
Vermont Family Forests Foundation, Inc. | Plots of right size are “forever wild” |
New England Forestry Foundation | Lands are public |
Northeast Wilderness Trust | Land is “forever wild” |
The Nature Conservancy | Lands are public |
Vermont Land Trust | Right area and has large tracts of land |
SUMMARY: WE HAVE IDENTIFIED A FEW COMMUNITY AREAS OF INTEREST AND AN INITIAL ESTIMATE OF BUILDING COST
Geography
Building cost estimates
ESTIMATED PHASE I BUILDING SQUARE FOOTAGE REQUIRED RANGES FROM ~20K-35K TOTAL
*Buildings not included in architect invoice
Note: assumptions for cost per square foot based on available comparable buildings or cost information from relevant comparable contractors
Horse pasture acreage requirement of ~1-2 acres per horse not included here
ESTIMATED PHASE I BUILDING COST ALONE RANGES FROM ~$6.5M-8.5M BEFORE PROJECT COSTS AND UPLIFT FOR UNKNOWNS
*Buildings not included in architect invoice
Note: assumptions for cost per square foot based on available comparable buildings or cost information from relevant comparable contractors; cost shown here does not include potential unknown costs or ‘uplift’ estimate
ESTIMATED BUILDING COSTS, INCLUDING BUILDING AND PROJECT COSTS, ARE APPROXIMATELY ~11-13M FOR EACH PHASE
Note: assumptions for cost per square foot based on available comparable buildings or cost information from relevant comparable contractors; total cost includes 40% premium given unknowns; project costs estimated for buildings not in scope based on relative size and building cost
Project costs include
Phase 2 architect total estimate is so low given many buildings not included in architect estimate
BUILDING DEEP DIVES
DETAILED ASSUMPTIONS
BUILDING DEEP DIVES: �BUILDING 1 – OFFICES/CO-DIRECTOR LIVING QUARTERS
Total est cost: $1.2m-$2.4m
Premium features that may change cost to build
Information and assumptions
Note: total est cost does not include 40% uplift for unknowns, and is thus a conservative number
BUILDING DEEP DIVES: �BUILDING 2 – ACTIVITY BUILDING/EVENT BARN
Total est cost: $4m-$6m
Premium features that may change cost to build
Information and assumptions
Note: total est cost does not include 40% uplift for unknowns, and is thus a conservative number
BUILDING DEEP DIVES: �BUILDING 3 – BARN (HORSE/DONKEY + ARENA)
Total est cost: $3m-$5m
Premium features that may change cost to build
Information and assumptions
Note: total est cost does not include 40% uplift for unknowns, and is thus a conservative number
BUILDING DEEP DIVES: �BUILDING 4 – STORAGE SHED & VEHICLE STORAGE
Total est cost: $150k-$200k
Premium features that may change cost to build
Information and assumptions
Note: total est cost does not include 40% uplift for unknowns, and is thus a conservative number
BUILDING DEEP DIVES: �PARKING AREAS FOR GUESTS (4-5)
Total est cost: $20k-$50k
Premium features that may change cost to build
Information and assumptions
Note: total est cost does not include 40% uplift for unknowns, and is thus a conservative number
BUILDING DEEP DIVES: �BUILDING 7 – GOAT/CHICKEN BARN
Total est cost: $140k-$200k
Premium features that may change cost to build
Information and assumptions
Note: total est cost does not include 40% uplift for unknowns, and is thus a conservative number
BUILDING DEEP DIVES: �BUILDING 8 – STAFF CABINS
Total est cost: $1.2M
Premium features that may change cost to build
Information and assumptions
Note: total est cost does not include 40% uplift for unknowns, and is thus a conservative number
BUILDING DEEP DIVES: �BUILDING 9 – GUEST CABINS
Total est cost: $2m-$4.5m
Premium features that may change cost to build
Information and assumptions
Note: total est cost does not include 40% uplift for unknowns, and is thus a conservative number
ADDITIONAL COSTS
Total est cost: $2.8m
Costs not yet included
Item | Estimate | Assumption |
Architectural fees | $212,600 | |
Civil Engineering fees | $100,000 | E.g., Grenier engineering |
Mechanical/Electrical Engineering fees | $100,000 | |
Structural Engineering fees | $150,000 | |
Permaculture Consultant | $50,000 | |
Landscape Architect | $50,000 | |
State & Local Permitting fees | $50,000 | |
Starlink wifi | $7,200 | set up & one year |
ADA consultant | $5,000 | |
ADA per building | $45,000 | 2 buildings |
Road | $77,000 | tree clearing, permits, drainage, grading, assumes gravel road of 3,000 feet |
Site related development costs | $2,000,000 | |
x40% uncertainty uplift = ~4m
Note: *These costs are based on mainly phase 1 buildings. As phase 2 is planned and built in addition to any changes in the size or scope of phase 1, additional fees may be needed)