1 of 30

Sean O’Brien (Internet2)

Making Data Informed Decisions on the Use of Cloud Services

“Mostly Cloudy”

6 June 2023

2 of 30

Thanks for having me!

About me:

  • Responsible for Internet2’s NET+, Cloud Scorecard and CLASS programs. With Internet2 since 2014.
  • Based in Washington, DC area.
  • sobrien@internet2.edu�@stob@mastodon.social

Presentation Goals:

  • Why R&E Community-Facilitated Cloud Services?
  • What is the NET+ program
  • Why leverage NET+ cloud services?
  • How to take advantage of the NET+ program.

3 of 30

3

https://leadinginlimbo.weebly.com/leading-in-limbo/if-you-build-it

4 of 30

Supporting the R&E Cloud Journey

Getting Started

Campus Demand

Business Models

Contracts

Identity Integration

Network Access

Moving to Production and Scaling

Enterprise cloud environment and dedicated enablement team

Multi-cloud networking strategy & direct connections

Broad organizational involvement in cloud configuration and support

Surfacing of historic structural challenges

Customization and Optimization

Building secure enclaves

Cloud Management and Governance

Institutional Cloud Strategy

Training and Workforce Development

Financial Operations

Internet2 convenes the community, identifies and discusses barriers, and works with our advisory groups to identify and implement solutions to help them succeed in their cloud journey

5 of 30

In Context

6 of 30

Cloud Service

Brokerage

Training and Workforce Development

Intelligent Cloud

Usage

Vendor Management

at Scale

Research and

Education Cloud Community

INTERNET2 CLOUD ENABLEMENT TEAM

7 of 30

Intelligent Cloud Usage�

Vendor Management

8 of 30

Focus on building what’s unique to research and education and collaborating with other providers on what may be commercially viable at scale.

https://www.softwebsolutions.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/build-vs-buy1.png

9 of 30

10 of 30

10

11 of 30

The Opportunity

Institutions want to make data-informed decisions about the cloud.

We have a lot of data already.

How do we make this data available?

How do we maintain a sense of community in higher education?

Here are three projects we are working on…

12 of 30

Current Projects

13 of 30

A Quick Note

All of these efforts are in various stages of development or in pilot

14 of 30

The Cloud Scorecard helps research and education institutions quickly assess which cloud services meet common requirements to operate in complex technology, security, compliance, and legal environments.

14

15 of 30

Accessibility

VPAT, WCAG, Policy link

Identity and Federation

InCommon, SAML

Network and Connectivity

I2PX, I2 connectivity, throttling, egress charges

Scorecard Questionnaire

39 questions total

Sections include:

Security

SOC2, HECVAT, Audit logs

Privacy

Policy, ISO 27018, data retention, disclosure

Technical Integration

APIs, data formats, SDK, Open source

Other Compliance and Contractual Issues

FERPA, data locale, trademarks, etc.

V1.1 is currently being finalized

16 of 30

Cloud Scorecard Directory

https://tinyurl.com/i2-scorecard

17 of 30

Institutional Profiles Project

The objective of an Institutional Profile is to allow an institution to assert information about themselves to foster collaboration around a certain subject area or service.

��

18 of 30

ServiceNow Institutional Profiles: The Data (Pt 1)

Institutional Background Characteristics

  • Production Environment Release
    • Paris / Quebec / Rome
  • Number of Production Instances
  • Number of Non-Production Instances
  • ITSM License Release
    • ITSM STD / ITSM Pro / SMS / SMS v2 / ITSA Unlimited / ITSA Gold / ITSA Platinum
  • Number of ITSM Licenses
    • 1-50 (small) / 50-250 (medium) / 250+ (large)
  • Information Technology Philosophy
    • Centralized / decentralized / it’s complicated
  • ITSM Philosophy, Structure & Governance
    • Early-adopter / Intermediate / Mature
  • Chargeback model
    • Internal / non-internal / internal plus administrative costs
  • ServiceNow Team Size
  • ServiceNow Customer Since (year)
  • Contract Renewal Date
  • Contact Name
  • Contact Email
  • Profile Last Updated

19 of 30

ServiceNow Institutional Profiles: The Data (Pt 2)

Qualitative Data (paragraph format)

  • Implementation & Usage
  • History
  • Accomplishments
  • Roadmap

20 of 30

ServiceNow Institutional Profiles: The Data (Pt 3)

ServiceNow Specific Use Characteristics

  • Analytics, Intelligence & Reporting
  • Customer Service Management
  • Dev Ops
  • Field Service Management
  • Governance, Risk & Compliance
  • HR Service Delivery
  • IT Asset Management

  • IT Business Management
  • IT Operations Management
  • IT Service Management
  • ServiceNow Mobile
  • Now Platform Administration

21 of 30

Cloud Benchmarking Project:

NET+ AWS & GCP

22 of 30

Cloud Benchmarking Project

Goals

  • Create an interactive dashboard that allows users to identify institutions who utilize certain products and services the most.
  • Create an interactive dashboard that allows institutions to dive deeper into their own product spending and compare with peer institutions.
  • Design an algorithm that identifies correlations between services.

Process

  • Data provided to Internet2 by our cloud brokers (distributor or reseller) – typically .csv.
  • Significant data hygiene process.
  • Data loaded in Google BigQuery platform and analyzed in Looker Studio.
  • Dashboards are currently made available to members upon request.

23 of 30

Insights

24 of 30

Scorecard Questionnaire Review

  • Least Answered Questions:
    • Does your service support IPV6
      • 97% of respondents left this blank
    • Do you have the ability to integrate with other APIs
      • 97% of respondents left this blank
    • Are you willing to evaluate and sign a customer’s standard Business Associate Agreement (required for storage of healthcare records)
      • 91% of respondents left this blank

https://www.cityhyd.info/2012/06/06/ipv6-implementation-in-india-on-world-ipv6-day/

25 of 30

AWS data transfer spend

26 of 30

GCP slide on spend by service

27 of 30

GCP slide on spend by service - removing storage and compute

28 of 30

AWS Products by Org

29 of 30

In Summary

  • Cloud usage is maturing

  • Our value proposition needs to evolve from “getting to the cloud” to “living in the cloud“

  • Three projects are in various stages of development to provide insights on vendor capabilities (Cloud Scorecard) and institutional cloud usage (Institutional Profiles and Cloud Benchmarking)

29;

30 of 30

sobrien@internet2.edu

Any questions?

Thank you