Open Consultation: Recommendations from the CoARA Working Group Recognizing and Rewarding Peer Review.

Academic peer review plays a central role in ensuring fair and justifiable decisions in scholarly publication and funding. Yet, the contributions of peer reviewers are often underappreciated and insufficiently recognized within formal academic structures. To overcome this, the Coalition on Advancing Research Assessment (CoARA) working group Recognizing and Rewarding Peer Review has developed a set of actionable recommendations aimed at integrating peer review activities into research assessment approaches. These recommendations have undergone a first round of revision in response to comments of other CoARA working group chairs.

Through this open consultation, we invite members of the research community to share their feedback* on the draft recommendations. 

* Responses should focus on key issues omitted. Please note that the document is on recognition of peer review, not on enhancements to peer review itself. Only responses submitted via this form will be taken into consideration. The names of contributors will only be disclosed when permission is provided. For questions, please contact Maria Ronald: ronald@allea.org. 

Sign in to Google to save your progress. Learn more
First Name *
Last Name *
E-mail address *
Organization *
My organization is a member of CoARA *
Please visit https://coara.eu/coalition/membership/ for a current overview of the registered CoARA members.
Position within the organization *
Are there any recommendations that you think may have been overlooked or should be given more emphasis? (max. 1000 characters)
Are the key points and recommendations in the document clear? Is there any section or topic that requires further clarification? (max. 1000 characters)
Is anything stated in the recommendations incorrect or demonstrably out of place? (max. 1000 characters)
I agree to be acknowledged as a commenter in the final document. *
My organization would potentially be interested in piloting any of the specific recommendations, and I would like to be contacted for this. *
Indicating your interest does not commit you to participation. Potential pilots may involve one or more actionable steps from Table 1 of the recommendations, and pilot templates will be developed by the working group.
Submit
Clear form
Never submit passwords through Google Forms.
This form was created inside of ALLEA - MV.

Does this form look suspicious? Report

Google Forms