Feedback Form: Paper 2, Part I
Instructions: Read through the author's paper twice. The first time. should be quick - and give you a sense of the topic. The second time, use the MS Word (or Google Doc) review tools and correct for style, grammar, and clarity.

Then, fill out this form to help the author understand your interpretation of the work. The most important part is to HAVE A CONVERSATION with the author. Your comments on the document and this form should serve as the basis for your conversation. Face-to-face communication is alway preferable, but sometimes it's nice to have something to speak to.

If you need a refresher on the instructions: https://drive.google.com/file/d/173uYgAADtUdpHjE3SfaguqAbAc0a40FF/view?usp=sharing
Reviewer's UTD Email
Reviewer's Name
Author's name
What object is author describing?
Could you visualize (or hear) the object?
Where did they focus: substance, form, or content?
What evidence (induction / deduction) did the author employ?
Were there any troublesome, sweeping generalizations that need evidence? List them.
Did you find the evidence convincing?
Clear selection
Were sources used correctly (about one per page)
Clear selection
Rate the grammar
Needs a bit of attention
Perfection
Clear selection
Rate the style (wordiness, flow, organization)
Needs a bit of attention
Perfection
Clear selection
Submit
Never submit passwords through Google Forms.
This content is neither created nor endorsed by Google. Report Abuse - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy