To President Beilock, Dean Kull, and Provost Kotz,
The general body of GOLD understands that the right to engage in a strike of labor is a fundamental right of workers. We take the defense of this right to be a serious and important matter.
Nonetheless, retaliatory threats from Dartmouth management have made some of our most vulnerable members afraid for their livelihoods, careers, and even visa statuses. This is unacceptable. As members of a union we do not stand divided as individuals. Retaliation against any one of us is retaliation against us all, and we are committed to fighting for every last member of our unit. Retaliatory discipline against any single unit member for striking will always be met with a collective response. Even graduate students who are not currently part of the strike action nonetheless respect and support the rights of others to engage in a lawful strike.
As the grading system currently exists, “low passes” (LPs) and “no credits” (NCs) functionally operate as the primary measures for employment discipline. In the context of teaching and research assistant positions, failure to perform job duties results in LP/NC grades. The accrual of multiple LPs or NCs can result in academic probation or removal from our employment as graduate students.
Article 1 of the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA) defines a legal strike as a form of “protected, concerted activity,” and Section 8 states that employers may not “interfere with, restrain, or coerce employees in the exercise of the rights guaranteed in Section 7.” A strike of labor is one such right, and threatening disciplinary grading action for strike participation is one such form of coercion.
The Dartmouth administration has chosen to wield the threat of LP/NC grades as a tool for coercing graduate workers not to strike. In Dartmouth’s “Faculty: Strike Information FAQs,” the Dartmouth administration states, “[g]rades for all courses, including research and teaching courses, should be assigned using same [sic] academic metrics and standards as they would under normal circumstances.” While vague, this language is understood by many graduate workers as permitting individual faculty to implement retaliatory measures of discipline against striking workers if they choose.
There is still time to fix this. We demand that Dartmouth administration publicly affirm that, as a matter of College policy, strike participation will not result in removal from PhD or Masters programs, academic probation, removal of funding, or the implementation of any action that moves students closer to facing these disciplinary actions.
We will not tolerate any graduate worker being retaliated against or disciplined, including with academic probation or program dismissal, due to their participation in the strike. If such retaliation occurs, the signatories below commit to full participation in the strike. We also commit to further collective labor actions until all disciplinary action is undone and any affected workers are made whole.
Signed,
GOLD UE Members:
Dan Murante
George Dufresne
Rayna Rampalli
Jake Willard
Martin Ying
Kai Herron
Dennis Webster
Ankita Sarkar
Kameron McCombs
Jonathan Lindbloom
Yixuan Peng
Genevieve Goebel
Ma. Francesca Santiago
David Freeman
Logan Mann
Aamani Thulluru
Grace Carey
Rendi Rogers
Elora Greiner
Jackson Yant
Cove Geary
Anja Holtz
Ridhi Chandarana Rajesh
Matthew Slein
Will Clendenning
Amy Conaway
Quinn Casey
Wisse Haakma
Joseph Savage
Benjamin Getraer
Sarah Cuprewich
Jamie Good
Magdalina Moses
Galini Poimenidou
Kristen Jovanelly
Montserrat Perez Castro
Casey Latario
Irma Vlasac
Lia Michaels
Smitakshi Goswami
Zachary Boyce
Jannitta Yao
Shan-Chang Lin
Madeline Hoey
Stacie Stuut
Andrew Projansky
Mia Phillips
Ian Raphael
Nesibe Derin Sivrioglu
Tara Tomlinson
Douglas Beahm
Yukuan Tao
Alina Dracheva
James Logan
Kiran Mirpuri
Allison Mann
Robin Zou
Simone Evans
Atticus McWhorter
Keighley Rockcliffe
Beth Anne Castellano
Mayra Flores
Jonathan Conroy
Reina Harding
Aliza Phillips
Lilly Tipton
Alex Gottlieb
Muhammad Qasim Khan
Alex Mule
Anthony Cressman
Jason Necaise
Lucas Dyke
Brent Harrison
Danelle Akanova
Fan Feng
Luke Rein
Jules van Irsel
Sarah Peery
Weishi Wang
Jackson Shimkonis
Samantha Liu
Alex Fu
Stephanie Podjed
João Pedro Teuber Carvalho
Pepper Pennington
Aylin García Soto
Emmanuel Durodola
Linta Joseph
Qianxu Wang
Pradipta Debnath
Matt Rock
Flora Perlmutter
Yiyi Tang
Saima Shikesho
Divya Ravi
Chinaza Nnam
Kate Miller
Maggie O'Shea
Mert Ozkan
Sanjana Pannem
Alexander Getraer
Madeline Morrisson
Helen Jarnagin
Jonathan Alperstein
Bailey Nordin
Sophia Micale
Chloe Sweetman
Lan Nguyen
Karl Biggs
Julianna Donohoe
Quin Shingai
Hieu Nguyen
Dylan Green
Francois LeSage
Rebecca Valls
Supporters:
1. London Warburton - Dartmouth Staff
2. Jonathan Cohn - Postdoc