一地兩檢 割地喪權 千里之堤 潰於蟻穴 "Co-location” surrenders our rights and legal protectionA small hole can bust a great dam
一地兩檢關注組
反對高鐵西九站「一地兩檢」
立場書

一地兩檢關注組由專業界別、學者、民主派議員、民間團體代表、學生代表等人組成。

我們極度關注香港政府以「方便」為由,「租賃」為名,擬將高鐵西九龍總站的出入境大堂部分地方、月台、在香港境內行駛中的高鐵車廂割讓予中國人員執行中國法律。

我們反對此方案,主要理由:

一、違反《基本法》:第十八條訂明中國法律不會在香港實施,除了已載於《基本法》附件三涉及國防外交等幾項條文。第二十二條更訂明中央人民政府各部門在香港的人員必須遵守香港法律。

二、先例一開,後患無窮:香港政府亦可藉詞以其他理由在香港其他口岸或區域照辦煮碗,自廢司法管轄權,交由中國人員執行中國法律。

三、混淆視線,愚弄公眾:西九「一地兩檢」方案與香港政府引用的英法、美加口岸例子根本不能相提並論,因為這幾個國家並沒有因為「一地兩檢」而割讓自己境內的司法管轄權。

四、方案並非唯一選擇:兩地兩檢、福田「一地兩檢」、西九總站改作其他有利香港經濟民生的用途,皆為值得公眾探討的方案,不應任由政府閉門造車一言堂。

千里之堤潰於蟻穴,倘若此例一開,將嚴重破壞本港的自治及我們珍而重之的法治。我們向中國及香港政府表明立場,反對西九「一地兩檢」方案。

2017年8月2日

【發起人 (排名不分先後)】
梁啟智
成名
戴耀廷
陳健民
蔡建誠
巫堃泰
黃偉國
吳靄儀
馮智活
范國威
譚凱邦
劉小麗
姚松炎
羅冠聰
邵家臻
梁繼昌
莫乃光
郭榮鏗
梁國雄
梁家傑
楊岳橋
張超雄
林卓廷
陳志全
陳淑莊
朱凱廸
郭家麒
毛孟靜
譚文豪
胡志偉
梁耀忠
楊彧
江貴生
梁有方
歐贊年
何芝君
譚國僑
何啟明
覃德誠
江鳳儀
甄紹南
楊智恒
張秀賢
施德來
許錦成
衛煥南

【發起團體 (排名不分先後)】
民間人權陣線
真普選救港大聯盟
保衛香港自由聯盟
社區公民約章
民主動力
社區前進
社區發展動力培育
公民社會發展資源中心
大專政改關注組
香港城巿大學學生會
恒生管理學院學生會
香港浸會大學學生會
嶺南大學學生會
香港珠海學院學生會
香港教育大學學生會
香港演藝學院學生會
香港大學學生會
明愛專上學院及明愛白英奇專業學校聯合學生會
香港公開大學學生會
香港樹仁大學學生會
香港中文大學學生會
一地兩檢民間關注團體聯席
傘下爸媽
關注一地兩檢學者及評論人聯席
撐傘落區運動
Um dot dot dot
法政匯思
思言財雋
思政築覺
良心理政
精算思政
進步教師同盟
社工復興運動
放射良心
護政
香港社會工作者總工會
香港廚師聯盟
公民數據
CoVision16
建構康橋
思言行
全民教育局
香港基督徒社關團契
傘城網上教會
18區動保專員
本土研究社
六一七公民約章
曉麗關注Plus

"Co-location" Concern Group
Our opposition statement

"Co-location" Concern Group is a united front of professionals, academics, democratic legislators, civil society and student delegates.

We are extremely concerned by the Government in effect ceding a large part of the heart of Hong Kong for the occupation of Chinese officials to implement Chinese law to the exclusion of Hong Kong law.

We oppose the plan mainly because:

1. It violates the Basic Law: Article 18 guarantees that national laws will not be applied in Hong Kong except laws concerning defence and diplomacy which are specified in Annex 3; Article 22 requires all officials from the Central People's Government in Hong Kong to abide by Hong Kong law.

2. It sets a dangerous precedent and opens the floodgates: If the Government gets away with this, the same device can be used in future under other pretexts to surrender our legal control to Chinese authorities.

3. It covers up the truth and misleads the public: The Government has tried to confuse the public by citing the Britain/France, US/Canada joint checkpoint arrangements, which simply do not involve the ceding of jurisdiction on anyone's part.

4. Other options are available: Separate checkpoints; "co-location" at Futian, Shenzhen; and converting the rail station for better economic and livelihood uses for Hong Kong. Such proposals are all worth considering by the public, who now face only one officially cooked-up choice.

A small hole can bust a great dam. The Government-proposed scheme will undermine Hong Kong's autonomy and our deeply cherished rule of law on which our real freedom and prosperity rely. We should tell Beijing and SAR Governments in no uncertain terms that we oppose the "co-location" scheme.

August 2, 2017

Individual initiator (in no particular order)
LEUNG Kai-chi
Dixon Sing-ming
Benny TAI Yiu-ting
CHAN Kin-man
Franklen CHOI
Michael MO
WONG Wai-kwok Benson
Margaret NG
FUNG Chi-wood
Gary FAN Kwok-wai
Roy TAM
LAU Siu-lai
Edward YIU Chung-yim
Nathan LAW Kwun-chung
SHIU Ka-chun
Kenneth LEUNG
Charles Peter MOK
Dennis KWOK Wing-hang
LEUNG Kwok-hung
Alan LEONG
Alvin YEUNG
Fernando CHEUNG
LAM Cheuk-ting
CHAN Chi-chuen
Tanya CHAN
CHU Hoi-dick
KWOK Ka-ki
Claudia MO
Jeremy TAM Man-ho
WU Chi-wai
LEUNG Yiu-chung
YEUNG Yuk
KONG Kwai-sang
LEUNG Yau-fong
Jeffrey AU
HO Chi-kwan
TAM Kwok-kiu
HO Kai-ming Kalvin
CHUM Tak-shing
KONG Fung-yi
YAN Siu-nam
YEUNG Chi-hang
Tommy CHEUNG
SZE Tak-loy
HUI Kam-shing
WAI Woon-nam


Group initiator (in no particular order)
Civil Human Rights Front
Save Hong Kong Alliance
League in Defense of Hong Kong's Freedoms
Community Citizen Charter
Power for Democracy
Community March
Community Development Initiative
Civil Society Development Resources Centre
大專政改關注組
City University of Hong Kong Students’ Union
Hang Seng Management College Students' Union
Hong Kong Baptist University Students’ Union
Lingnan University Students’ Union
Student Union of Chu Hai College of Higher Education
The Hong Kong Academy for Performing Arts Students' Union
The Education University of Hong Kong Students’ Union
The Hong Kong University Students’ Union
The Joint Students' Union of Caritas Institute of Higher Education and Caritas Bianchi College of Careers
The Open University of Hong Kong Students’ Union
The Student Union of Hong Kong Shue Yan University
The Student Union of The Chinese University of Hong Kong
一地兩檢民間關注團體聯席
Umbrella Parents
關注一地兩檢學者及評論人聯席
Umbrella Blossom
Um dot dot dot
Progressive Lawyers Group
Financier Conscience
ArchiVision
HK Psychologists Concern
Act Voice
Progressive Teachers’ Alliance
Reclaiming Social Work Movement
放射良心
Nurse Politik
Hong Kong Social Workers' General Union
Hong Kong Chef Union
Civic Data
CoVision16
The Bridgian
Civil Renaissance
HKEd4All
City Concern of Christian Fellowship Hong Kong
Umbrella City Cyberchurch
18區動保專員
Liber Research Communtiy
Citizen Charter 617
曉麗關注Plus

個人/團體聯署 Individual/Organisation
個人/團體名稱 Individual/Organisation's Name
Your answer
電郵 E-mail
Your answer
您的意見 Your Opinion
Your answer
是否願意收取資訊?Would you like to receive our information?
收集個人資料聲明 Personal Information Collection Statement
閣下提供的個人資料,「一地兩檢」關注組將作聯絡及發放資訊之用。如欲查詢閣下提供的個人資料,包括查閱及更改資料,請與本組聯絡 (電郵:colocationcg@gmail.com / Facebook:Fb.me/colocationcg)。

Your personal data will be used to provide communications and information. For access or correction requests, please contact us (Email: colocationcg@gmail.com / Facebook:Fb.me/colocationcg)

Submit
Never submit passwords through Google Forms.
This content is neither created nor endorsed by Google. Report Abuse - Terms of Service - Additional Terms