Writing Center Journal Reviewer Form
Thank you for agreeing to review a manuscript for The Writing Center Journal. This form invites you to submit four pieces of information:
1. Manuscript ratings (numerical response)
2. An overall recommendation regarding manuscript acceptance (accept, revise and resubmit, or decline)
3. Comments to the author(s) explaining revision suggestions; and
4. Comments to the editors (if desired).
For your comments to the author(s) and editors, please feel free to copy and paste comments from Word

**Complete this form in one sitting: your input will not be saved if you leave this page**

Reviewer name *
Your answer
Manuscript title (short title okay) *
Your answer
Manuscript Ratings. For each of the descriptions below, please rank the manuscript accordingly. *
Strongly Disagree
Strongly Agree
Not Applicable
The article makes a significant contribution to writing center studies.
The article advances our understanding of the topic it addresses.
The article is well-situated within existing relevant research and scholarship.
If research-driven, the methodology is described clearly.
If theoretical, claims are convincingly explained.
The article avoids heavy reliance on anecdote.
The article is likely to be cited by future scholars.
The article will be of interest to and relevant for readers of The Writing Center Journal.
Readers who are not specialists in the article’s particular area/topic will be able to read and comprehend the article.
This article taught me something new.
Overall Recommendation *
Comments to the author(s). *
Your answer
Comments to the editors (if needed). These will not be directly shared with the authors.
Your answer
Never submit passwords through Google Forms.
This content is neither created nor endorsed by Google. Report Abuse - Terms of Service