CMNS / LENR / Cold Fusion Journal Rejection Database

JavaScript isn't enabled in your browser, so this file can't be opened. Enable and reload.

Database for CMNS/LENR/Cold Fusion researchers to record their journal rejection experiences.

Email *

Full name of Journal *

arXiv

ChemRxiv

Journal of Electroanalytical Chemistry

Nature

Nature Physics

Physics Reports

Review of Moderns Physics

Other:

Journal website address (ie: journal.org) *

Title of submitted paper or abstract *

Date of rejection (actual or estimate) *

YYYY

Describe, succinctly, the details of the chronology of the rejection experience (from submission to last contact.) *

To what extent do you view the submitted paper as being rejected solely or primarily because the topic of the paper is, or is related to, CMNS/LENR/Cold Fusion? *

No doubt

High

Moderate

Slight

Not at all

Choose one

Did you appeal or follow up with the journal offical? *

Yes

If you followed up the receipt of the rejection with further correspondence, what was the response?

Is it your impression that the journal or the official with whom you communicated has a policy (official or unspoken) to dismiss CMNS/LENR/Cold Fusion papers out of hand, or without serious consideration? *

Yes

Other:

Name of the journal official with whom you corresponded

Title of journal official (ie: Editor, Asst. Editor)

Have you published in this journal previously under this or another topic?

Yes

Other:

Clear selection

Additional Comments

Can researchers or journalists contact you about your experience with the rejection of CMNS/LENR/Cold Fusion papers?

Researchers

Journalists

Other:

To support your survey response, we encourage you to optionally create and upload a .pdf of your correspondence with the journal and a copy of your abstract/paper as it was submitted. You may submit these materials at a later time. Please copy the upload link provided below for later use.

Suggestions for what to include in your uploaded materials:

1) Submitted paper and other materials provided to the journal
2) Reviewers comments / questions / suggestions to the editor
3) Authors’ responses
4) Editor’s decision and action
5) Follow-up

Upload at: lenria.org/upload-journal-rejection

If you use the link above to upload your materials now, please make sure
to come back to this page to complete and submit the survey.

Do you intend to upload a file containing your correspondence and abstract/paper?

Yes

Supporting materials have been successfully uploaded

Clear selection

For assistance or questions regarding the survey, please email: cmns.rejections@gmail.com.

A copy of your responses will be emailed to the address you provided.

Submit

Clear form

Never submit passwords through Google Forms.

reCAPTCHA

Privacy Terms

This content is neither created nor endorsed by Google. Report Abuse - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy

Forms