Spirituality Studies Review Form
Sign in to Google to save your progress. Learn more
Reviewer *
Your Name, Surname, Title
Title of the Paper *
Decision *
Significance *
What is the research relevance of the topic/subject? Does the approach develop the current state of knowledge? To what extent does the study combine ideas, methods, approaches of multiple academic fields?
Comment *
Originality *
Is the topic new? Is the approach new? Is the methodology new? Is it an innovative combination of well-known ideas/methods/approaches?
Comment *
Placement within the Current State of Research *
Does the study reflect the current state of research? Does it fit into the framework of previous studies in the field? Are sources relevant and up-to-date?
Comment *
Clarity *
Is the study written comprehensively? Are methods clearly described? Are results described and evaluated thoroughly? Is the study structured in a logical manner?
Comment *
Relevance *
Does the study fit into the thematic focus of the journal? Is its content  interesting also for broader audience? Is it readable in a multidisciplinary context?
Comment *
Formal Requirements *
What is the formal quality of the text? Does it meet the journal's formal requirements? Does it follow guidelines for authors?
Comment *
Language Quality of the Text *
What is the grammatical and stylistic quality of the text?
Comment *
Overall Explanation of the Evaluation *
Submit
Clear form
Never submit passwords through Google Forms.
This content is neither created nor endorsed by Google. Report Abuse - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy