What is the research relevance of the topic/subject? Does the approach develop the current state of knowledge? To what extent does the study combine ideas, methods, approaches of multiple academic fields?
Is the topic new? Is the approach new? Is the methodology new? Is it an innovative combination of well-known ideas/methods/approaches?
Does the study reflect the current state of research? Does it fit into the framework of previous studies in the field? Are sources relevant and up-to-date?
Is the study written comprehensively? Are methods clearly described? Are results described and evaluated thoroughly? Is the study structured in a logical manner?
Does the study fit into the thematic focus of the journal? Is its content interesting also for broader audience? Is it readable in a multidisciplinary context?
What is the formal quality of the text? Does it meet the necessary formal requirements? Does it follow guidelines for authors?
What is the grammatical and stylistic quality of the text?