WikiJournal peer review form
This is a form to return peer reviewer comments for an article submitted to a journal in the WikiJournal User Group.

Review guidelines:

Email *
Your answer
Name *
Your answer
Your answer
Faculty webpage
Your answer
Are you happy to have your identity open? *
WikiJournals aim for maximum transparency. Please indicate whether you are happy to have your name associated with your reviewer comments (currently approx 65% choose to do so)
Relevant credentials/experience to demonstrate suitability as reviewer for this article (strongly advised if anonymous)
Your answer
Title of work reviewed *
Your answer
Review comments *
We recommend that comments are constructive, and include both strengths and areas for improvement, and be referenced whenever possible. Review guidelines:
Your answer
PDF upload
You may optionally upload an annotated version of the manuscript, or your comments as a pdf or docx at this secondary short form at
Competing interests *
If you have any competing interests, please briefly describe them
Second check
You may ask to see the revised article and author responses after the authors have answered the review
Release permission *
Peer reviews and author responses are public and transparent for WikiJournals. Please confirm that you consent to this.
Never submit passwords through Google Forms.
This content is neither created nor endorsed by Google. Report Abuse - Terms of Service