We ask that you avoid personal attacks. A critical review is fine, but a direct attack on the author is not. We will have an objective third party (ie not the author) who decides if a criticism crosses this line. It is possible to discuss/analyze the work without passing judgments on the writer of that work.
Detailed reviews are preferred. If you need prompts you can answer some of our provided questions, but if you have your own format or style feel free to ignore the prompted questions.