Seal of Approval Evaluation Form
Reviewer Procedure:
1. Read the title sent to you.
2. Return this evaluation form by the specified deadline.

Notes:
- You are not required to do extra research. If you find an issue or a topic presented and you’re unsure whether it violates Catholic teaching, note the topic and our team of theology experts will research it.
- Use the Three Chapter Rule: If you find the book so problematic in religious aspects or crafting or so poorly written that to approve it would be a detriment to the reputation of the Guild as a writer's guild, PUT IT DOWN and mark the appropriate box below.
- If you have any concerns with the title being considered for SOA, please bring your concern directly to the SOA Chair at SOA@catholicwritersguild.com. DO NOT contact the author yourself.
Sign in to Google to save your progress. Learn more
Reviewer Name *
Type your name
Reviewer Email *
Type your email address
Book Title *
Type the book title
Book Author *
Type the author
If you are NOT recommending the Seal of Approval, select from these reasons and note your concerns in the space below with page numbers and specific information. *
Select ALL THAT APPLY.
Required
Check these boxes to indicate your agreement. *
Required
This title is (SELECT ONE): *
Please outline and note any concerns you have about this work.
If you selected any of the concerns above, outline your concerns below, citing page numbers and reference from the text.
If you are recommending the Seal of Approval, please verify the following: *
Select ALL THAT APPLY
Required
Submit
Clear form
Never submit passwords through Google Forms.
This form was created inside of Sarah Reinhard/Reinhard Family Ventures. Report Abuse