The Real AI Alignment Problem - V 1.1: Article Feedback
Form description
Thank you for reviewing "The Real AI Alignment Problem: It's Us, Not Them (Version 1.0). This Key Concept article introduces the R.E.A.L. (Relational, Evolving Alignment for Liberation) framework and was developed collaboratively by humans and four AI assistants. Important Guidelines:
Please read the entire article carefully before responding
We're seeking substantive feedback on the core ideas and overall impact
The article is already at its target length (~6,300 words), so we can't add significant new content to the main text (though appendices could be expanded if truly necessary)
Focus on whether the article achieves its primary goal: being skillfully provocative and conversation-starting for both technical and non-technical audiences
Consider how effectively it presents R.E.A.L. Alignment as a framework worth serious consideration
Email*
Valid email
1. Reviewer Name:
*
Question
1. Reviewer Name:
*
Question Type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Dropdown
File upload
Linear scale
Rating
New
Multiple choice grid
Checkbox grid
Date
Time
Description
Loading image…
Caption
Short answer text
Response validation has been added.
Remove
Number
Text
Length
Regular expression
Greater than
Greater than or equal to
Less than
Less than or equal to
Equal to
Not equal to
Between
Not between
Is number
Whole number
Number
and
Number
Custom error text
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading…
2. What aspects of the article did you find most compelling, effective, or insightful? Which parts best serve the goal of being skillfully provocative and conversation-starting?
*
Question
2. What aspects of the article did you find most compelling, effective, or insightful? Which parts best serve the goal of being skillfully provocative and conversation-starting?
*
Question Type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Dropdown
File upload
Linear scale
Rating
New
Multiple choice grid
Checkbox grid
Date
Time
Description
Loading image…
Caption
Long answer text
Length
Regular expression
Maximum character count
Minimum character count
Number
Custom error text
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading…
3. What aspects of the article felt least effective or compelling? Were there sections that didn't resonate or seemed to detract from the main message?
*
Question
3. What aspects of the article felt least effective or compelling? Were there sections that didn't resonate or seemed to detract from the main message?
*
Question Type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Dropdown
File upload
Linear scale
Rating
New
Multiple choice grid
Checkbox grid
Date
Time
Description
Loading image…
Caption
Long answer text
Length
Regular expression
Maximum character count
Minimum character count
Number
Custom error text
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading…
4. If you were to recommend 1-3 substantive improvements (not minor edits), what would they be? Consider changes that would make the article more impactful, clear, or persuasive without significantly increasing length.
*
Question
4. If you were to recommend 1-3 substantive improvements (not minor edits), what would they be? Consider changes that would make the article more impactful, clear, or persuasive without significantly increasing length.
*
Question Type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Dropdown
File upload
Linear scale
Rating
New
Multiple choice grid
Checkbox grid
Date
Time
Description
Loading image…
Caption
Long answer text
Length
Regular expression
Maximum character count
Minimum character count
Number
Custom error text
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading…
5. How effectively does the article balance technical accuracy with accessibility? Would it resonate with both AI experts and the broader public?
*
Question
5. How effectively does the article balance technical accuracy with accessibility? Would it resonate with both AI experts and the broader public?
*
Question Type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Dropdown
File upload
Linear scale
Rating
New
Multiple choice grid
Checkbox grid
Date
Time
Description
Loading image…
Caption
Long answer text
Length
Regular expression
Maximum character count
Minimum character count
Number
Custom error text
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading…
6. Any other comments or suggestions?
*
Question
6. Any other comments or suggestions?
*
Question Type
Short answer
Paragraph
Multiple choice
Checkboxes
Dropdown
File upload
Linear scale
Rating
New
Multiple choice grid
Checkbox grid
Date
Time
Description
Loading image…
Caption
Long answer text
Length
Regular expression
Maximum character count
Minimum character count
Number
Custom error text
Answer key
(0 points)
Loading...
Loading…
Link to Sheets
The number of responses collected by this form may exceed the limit supported by Sheets. If you're having trouble viewing your responses in Sheets, try downloading a .CSV instead.
Summary
Question
Individual
Insights
Total points distribution
Loading...
Loading responses…
This form is approaching the response limit. Once surpassed, the summary of responses will no longer be displayed. Learn more
Close
This form has exceeded 50,000 responses and the summary of responses can no longer be displayed. You can still download responses as a .csv file. Learn more
1. Reviewer Name:
Copy chart
No responses yet for this question.
2. What aspects of the article did you find most compelling, effective, or insightful? Which parts best serve the goal of being skillfully provocative and conversation-starting?
No responses yet for this question.
3. What aspects of the article felt least effective or compelling? Were there sections that didn't resonate or seemed to detract from the main message?
No responses yet for this question.
4. If you were to recommend 1-3 substantive improvements (not minor edits), what would they be? Consider changes that would make the article more impactful, clear, or persuasive without significantly increasing length.
No responses yet for this question.
5. How effectively does the article balance technical accuracy with accessibility? Would it resonate with both AI experts and the broader public?
No responses yet for this question.
6. Any other comments or suggestions?
No responses yet for this question.
No responses yet. Please check back later.
of
6
This form is approaching the response limit. Once surpassed, the question view will no longer be displayed. Learn more
Close
of
1
Loading...
Loading response…
This form is approaching the response limit. Once surpassed, the individual view will no longer be displayed. Learn more
Close
Grades from previous versions of this form are hidden. Learn more
Settings
Release grades
Respondent settings
Global quiz defaults
Default question point value
Point values for every new question
points
Responses
Manage how responses are collected and protected
Collect email addresses
Required by Locked mode
Do not collect
Verified
Responder input
Send responders a copy of their response
Disabled by Locked mode
Requires Collect email addresses
Off
When requested
Always
Requires sign in
File upload
Total size limit for all uploaded files
This limit is smaller than the max size of a single response.
Responses will not be accepted after the limit is reached. Learn more