This document is intended to provide an unbiased summary of the events surrounding OnlyOneOf KB’s TikTok Live and Jbebwilliams’ response. The goal is to present the available information in a clear and factual manner so that readers can form their own informed opinions. While every effort has been made to maintain objectivity, readers should be aware that the author has personal relationships with several individuals mentioned in this document, which may introduce unintentional bias.
Please note that some of the content referenced (such as screenshots and screen recordings) has not been independently verified. This is due to the nature of digital media, which can be subject to editing or manipulation through tools like Photoshop or video editing software.
Additionally, while some Korean language speakers have questioned the naturalness of the Korean used in the screenshots, suggesting it may not have been written by a fluent speaker, others have argued that it could still be considered natural.
It is worth noting that KB has limited proficiency in English and may rely on translation tools such as Papago or Google Translate to interpret English content. These tools are not always accurate.
Legal Disclaimer:
The information presented in this document is based on publicly available materials and is intended for informational purposes only. All claims and screenshots referenced are alleged, and their authenticity has not been independently verified. This document does not intend to make any definitive statements or accusations. As such, the events described should be viewed as part of an ongoing situation, and readers are encouraged to approach the content with caution and critical thinking.
All sources referenced within this document will be linked for transparency and further reading. However, please note that if any links are found to be broken, it may be due to the original author or source having deleted or removed the content.
If all links are not working, please check to see if your internet browser has a content blocker. You may need to download the Google Docs app in order to access the links in this document.
This document was originally created by an OnlyOneOf fan for fellow fans, with no intention of it being shared beyond the fandom. The author recognizes that it is now being read by a broader audience and has revised the content to include additional context to minimize confusion for those unfamiliar with OnlyOneOf.
This document will continue to be updated as new, verifiable information becomes available to ensure accuracy and ongoing clarity.
Last Updated: Tuesday, June 7, 2025, 12:50 p.m. KST [CURRENTLY UPDATING]
KB’s TikTok Live: A Summary of Events and Jbebwilliams’ Response
KB and Nine from OnlyOneOf opened individual TikTok accounts for the first time and began livestreaming shortly before the start of the group’s U.S. tour, 2025 North American Tour: Our Only Odyssey, which began in late March.
Since the beginning of their TikTok Live streams, KB and Nine from OnlyOneOf have received substantial gifts from a user known as lOOOve. These donations have included multiple TikTok Universe gifts, valued at approximately $562.48 USD, as well as Lion gifts, worth around $398.95 USD. In a clip from March 16, 2025, Nine can be seen receiving one of these gifts, and a separate clip from March 23, 2025, also shows him receiving a TikTok Universe gift from user lOOOve. These are only a few of the many instances in which such high-value gifts were sent during their livestreams.
*It should be noted that fans have speculated about potential financial difficulties faced by OnlyOneOf, based on occasional comments made by the members over the years. While such speculation may provide possible context for certain actions taken by the members in relation to finances, there is no official confirmation of any financial issues. The group is managed by 8D Entertainment, which oversees OnlyOneOf's activities and operations.
At the time, KB and Nine appeared unaware of the identity of the user sending the gifts. In a TikTok Live on March 30, 2025, KB asked, 'Who are you?'—indicating uncertainty about the sender’s identity—and later acknowledged the high cost of the gifts, stating, 'First time, I don’t know what it is, but now I know.'
Later on, a user named Alex (@shawolex) began participating in donating the same large gifts to KB. Now aware of the value of these gifts, KB would react by thanking Alex for the donations. Alex was almost always present during KB's TikTok Lives and typically dropped at least one of these large gifts per stream.
In early April, some fans noticed that they had been hard-blocked by both Nine and KB on TikTok without any explanation. This led to confusion and frustration among fans, some of whom had been longtime supporters of the group and were unfamiliar with any rules they might have broken. Some of the affected fans were known within the lyOn (lyOn is the name for OnlyOneOf’s fandom) community, and have even been recognized by some of the OnlyOneOf members themselves.
At the same time, anonymous users began flooding the chat with hate towards both KB and Nine, including threats directed at the members themselves. These users also resorted to doxing members of the chat, revealing their legal names and addresses. In addition, the anonymous accounts started impersonating other chat members, using their names and photos to confuse both the chat participants and KB and Nine. Among those notably targeted were lOOOve and Alex, though many others were also affected.
On May 3, KB's TikTok manager reached out to some fans, asking if they could assist with moderating the chat to help prevent harassment. KB and/or his TikTok manager appointed Alex as one of the moderators.
On May 4, KB posted on his story, urging the anonymous accounts to stop harassing him and other fans, stating that he would take legal action if the harassment continued.
As a result of the doxing, it was revealed that lOOOve was a well-known lyOn, known by others as Jamie, also referred to as jbebwilliams (Instagram).
Jamie is a figure in the OnlyOneOf fandom, particularly recognized as a group order manager. Over the years, many fans have discussed her actions, and some have issued Deal With At Your Own Risk (DWAYOR) warnings related to her behavior, with these warnings first appearing in 2023.
Her actions first became a point of concern when some fans expressed hesitation about participating in group orders with her, fearing that she might prioritize her own collection over her joiners. Jamie has also faced criticism for her behavior during fancalls, particularly for bringing up sensitive topics with idols, which some fans found inappropriate given her background in behavioral health. It is also noted that Jamie is allegedly a therapist by profession.
Throughout the years, various members of the fandom have raised concerns about Jamie's behavior, with some accusing her of crossing boundaries or engaging in parasocial behavior. Additionally, it has been claimed that Jamie attempts to undermine the reputation of other lyOns who call attention to her actions.
The examples included here reflect only a portion of the allegations that have been discussed; additional claims and accounts about Jamie exist and continue to circulate within the fandom.
Jamie has responded to each of these allegations on her Instagram account.
On Monday, May 5, Nine announced via his KakaoTalk Live Announcements that he would be pausing his livestreams, stating, "I will take some time for reorganization." Since then, he has not returned to live streaming. While some fans have speculated that the hiatus may be related to ongoing harassment, a lack of moderation tools, or other external factors, it is also possible that the decision was made for personal or unrelated reasons. The exact cause of the livestream hiatus has not been confirmed.
Since the announcement on May 5, Nine had remained absent from all public and online platforms, with no participation in group or individual activities such as livestreams, social media updates, Fromm messages, or official schedules. This lack of visibility led to speculation that he was on an indefinite hiatus, although neither the artist nor the company had issued a formal statement regarding his status.
Update: As of May 13, Nine has been spotted publicly (see page 8), marking his first confirmed appearance since the announcement.
Following the doxing incident, it was noticeable that the user lOOOve appeared less frequently in the TikTok Live streams.
On May 8, Jamie requested that KB pause his livestreams, citing safety concerns and asking for help with a police report, safety planning, and addressing public allegations against her. Despite this, KB proceeded with his live broadcast, which Jamie interpreted as prioritizing monetization over safety. In expressing her frustration, Jamie stated, “I don’t understand forgetting your friend,” implying a personal connection with KB. This perceived closeness has drawn criticism from some fans, who view it as an example of parasocial behavior. Jamie also claims KB blocked her directly and believes he was personally moderating his livestreams, rather than a manager.
On May 10, 2025, KB held a subscriber-only livestream to address the screenshots and the claims Jamie has made about him. He requested that viewers refrain from recording or posting screen recordings of the livestream. As a result, there is no primary source for the livestream content. The following account is based on the recollections of the author, who is subscribed to KB and attended the full livestream on May 10.
KB alleges that Jamie is responsible for much of the harassment, claiming that she is behind some of the anonymous accounts targeting him and his fans, and that she is currently spreading false information about him. He asks lyOns to believe his side of the story and to ignore her. As a result, he also states that Jamie has been blacklisted from attending any future OnlyOneOf events.
In response to this, Jamie continues to post on her Instagram story to defend her claims. Due to the volume of stories posted, the author will summarize the key points. You can find an archive of these stories here. Please note that all claims and information discussed are alleged.
- Jamie denies all of KB’s accusations.
- Jamie denies being involved in any specific livestream incident and suggests someone else is responsible.
- She describes her relationship with KB as complex and difficult.
- Jamie claims she is open about her identity and involved the police, sharing evidence for investigation.
- She challenges KB to provide proof or file a report if he believes she is responsible for harassment or fake accounts.
- Jamie had planned to stop supporting the group after the concerts and informed KB in advance.
- The reason she created an anonymous account to gift Nine and KB was because she didn’t want attention or to cross boundaries.
- She wanted to help KB and Nine with her donations so they could raise funds for an album via TikTok.
- She mentioned that, if there was a concert in May, she hxad hoped to travel to Korea with her daughter to celebrate OnlyOneOf’s debut anniversary.
- It is important to note that Jamie uses the name 'Emma' in reference to her daughter.
In a screen recording shared on Jamie’s Instagram story, she displays a conversation with KB’s TikTok manager. In the alleged conversation, Jamie references how KB's livestreams have increasingly focused on Alex, likely due to the attention Alex receives from donations.
The manager allegedly mentions that KB considers Jamie a good person and that KB instructed them to block certain individuals, which the manager followed through on. The individuals who were blocked are believed to be longtime fans who were confused by the blocks and felt they had not broken any rules. These fans are the same ones mentioned earlier on page 2.
Jamie later responded to reactions on her instagram story by stating that she did not ask KB to block any fans, with the exception of one individual, Person A, whom she claims to have requested be blocked for reasons that remain unclear.
She also mentioned specific individuals with whom she has personal grievances and offered speculation as to why they may have been blocked. She cited Jess (@jjesselizabethh) for allegedly breaking rules by recording OnlyOneOf during a fan chat in 2024, though this was later disproven as another person was confirmed to have taken the recording. She includes details about the boycott related to JNB Entertainment, which hosted OnlyOneOf’s recent U.S. tour. Jamie referenced Claire (@sapphickyubin), suggesting she was “second in command” for the boycott—though this remains speculative. Lastly, she mentioned Kristin (@emokingjunji), claiming Kristin “lied to him,” but Kristin has stated she does not know what Jamie is referring to.
*Note that there are other accounts/fans that have been blocked, but only those publicly known to be blocked are included here.
As of May 10, 2025, KB has unblocked both Kristin and Jess. As of May 12, KB has unblocked Person A. However, it has not been confirmed whether he has unblocked any other individuals.
On May 11, 2025, KB released a public statement on TikTok
**On May 20, KB deleted his public statement regarding this situation from his TikTok account. During a livestream that same day, when asked whether he would further address the situation, he stated that everything that needed to be said was already in the video he had posted. This response has caused confusion among some viewers, as the video is no longer available for reference.
Video Transcript Key Points:
*Please note that KB used an online translation tool to translate from Korean to English for the following statement, which may affect the clarity and precision of the statement. As a result, certain nuances or intended meanings may not be fully conveyed.
- KB stated that he has been under significant stress and feels compelled to speak out.
- He alleges that Jamie was behind the creation and leaking of her own personal information and convinced him that a fan was responsible.
- Jamie reportedly told KB to stop his live broadcasts, claiming safety concerns, and later allegedly threatened fans and shared a fabricated message portraying KB negatively.
- KB claims Jamie engaged in bullying behavior toward another fan, despite previously presenting herself as a victim of bullying.
- He says she pressured him to advocate for distressed fans but later expressed dissatisfaction with his efforts.
- KB alleges that Jamie attempted to manipulate his live broadcasts and became fixated on a new fan (Alex), contributing to further tension.
- Due to mounting stress, KB says he asked his manager to oversee the fan chatroom. The manager allegedly collected evidence of misconduct and asked Jamie to stop, which she did not.
- KB states he initially believed Jamie had good intentions but now views her behavior as driven by jealousy and control, accusing her of using fake accounts and messages to harm his broadcasts and community.
- He urges fans not to believe or engage with her alleged actions, expressing a desire for harmony and happiness among his fanbase and during broadcasts.
Following this, KB provided a statement in his own voice, without the use of the translation tool:
“That’s what I want to say, and I have insomnia these days and I can’t sleep.”
See full video caption here.
Video Caption Key Points:
- KB alleges that Jamie has claimed for years to be bullied by other lyOn, and that she repeatedly told him she wanted to leave the fandom because of this.
- According to KB, he trusted Jamie and believed Jamie shared the same goal of helping other fans. Based on this belief, he says he blocked individuals who were boycotting events or allegedly bullying others.
- KB claims that Jamie later became controlling and manipulative, expressing anger over his actions and trying to monopolize his attention, which led him to ask his manager to communicate with her on his behalf.
- He further alleges that Jamie fabricated messages and spread false narratives, including the creation of fake accounts that targeted him and his fans with harassment and death threats.
- KB asserts that these threats included demands for him to stop going live and warnings that the safety of his fans could be at risk.
- He states that he has evidence and witnesses supporting his claim that Jamie is behind the false accounts and the spread of misinformation.
- Regarding gifts received during live streams, KB clarifies that the amount of money or gifts does not influence how he feels about fans and that he values all fans equally.
- KB apologizes to anyone affected or disappointed by recent events and reiterates that his intention was always to protect the community.
- He concludes by urging fans not to support or engage with Jamie, whom he accuses of continuing to harass others, and claims that those close to her have since come forward as witnesses after distancing themselves from her actions.
- “Please do not believe anything she says. Once again I want to sincerely apologize to anyone who I have hurt or disappointed because of this situation. I am sorry.”
He also provided this message in korean.
On May 13, 2025, at approximately 7 a.m. KST, Jamie uploaded a screen recording of a conversation with KB where he allegedly refers to specific fans by name and/or username and appears to disclose private messages these individuals sent to him via Fromm—a private messaging platform designed for communication between artists and fans.
Fromm functions similarly to services like Bubble or Weverse DMs, where artists send messages to all subscribers and can view individual responses from fans.
Fromm operates as a paid subscription service, with fans typically subscribing on a monthly or yearly basis to receive messages and interact with the artist.
In response to KB's alleged disclosure of private messages from other fans, Jamie allegedly shared additional material via Google Drive links. The contents and accuracy of these links are unknown, and it is unclear whether they pertain to specific individuals.
KB allegedly responded in English, asking Jamie whether the links contained evidence that could be used for prosecution. He also cited difficulty with English language as a reason for any delay in responding. However, it remains unclear what specific offense or matter the potential prosecution would pertain to.
*In reference to page 2, the fans in question have stated that they were unaware of any rules they may have violated as members of KB’s TikTok chat and expressed genuine confusion over the reason for being blocked.
KB is further alleged to have suggested that Kris (@_krisatris) has been viewing the private Instagram account of Jacky, the CEO of JNB Entertainment, though it is unclear why KB believes this to be the case.
With regard to Kris, KB allegedly stated that "[they] will be prosecute and [they] cannot do anything," possibly referencing their involvement in the boycott against JNB Entertainment and its connection to OnlyOneOf’s 2025 North American Tour.
Fans have confirmed that some of the messages shown in the screenshots shared by Jamie match private messages they had previously sent to KB via Fromm. This confirmation suggests that not all of the messages were fabricated by Jamie, as the only individual with access to those private messages was KB.
On May 13, 2025, Around 10 a.m. KST, OnlyOneOf members—including Nine and KB—were spotted at Gimpo International Airport en route to Tokyo, Japan, for an FC LIVE Fan Event. This marks Nine's first public appearance since May 5.
On May 13, 2025, around 2 p.m. KST, KB’s TikTok manager, @manageribnida, posted a series of screenshots on their story, which allegedly show messages sent by Jamie to KB. According to the manager, these messages were “psychologically damaging” and constituted “gaslighting.” They also allege that the messages included information about other lyOn. The following excerpt is taken from one of the screenshots and is said to contain demands made by Jamie toward KB.
In the first screenshot, the original messages were written in Korean and translated to English by the author.
These demands were allegedly sent in mid-April 2025:
- If Person A joins the live, please block them.
- Send a message to Fromm—you know who started the boycott, right?
- Give me the gift subscription you promised.
- Tell the fandom that I never diagnosed you. I never crossed any boundaries or treated you during a video call.
- Tell the fandom that OnlyOneOf considered me a supportive fan. I've never made anyone uncomfortable. But now, you all treat me like just a friend.
KB’s manager also shared a screen recording of the contents of a Google Drive link that Jamie allegedly sent to KB. Much of the content in the letter that was allegedly in this google drive link has already been addressed earlier in this document. To avoid repetition, the author will briefly summarize only the new points introduced in the letter.
- Jamie allegedly tells KB that she has spent over $100,000 in support of OnlyOneOf.
- In March, Jamie was reportedly involved in an incident with another individual within the lyOn community, which allegedly resulted in an attempt to contact her employer with the intention of prompting disciplinary action.
- Jamie expressed criticism toward OnlyOneOf, alleging that the group has failed to manage the behavior within their fanbase and has, in her view, allowed a toxic environment to persist.
- Jamie further suggests to KB that the actions of the individual who allegedly contacted her employer were a consequence of what she perceives as a direct result of OnlyOneOf not doing their jobs effectively.
- Jamie also claims that "straight people are not welcome or have been bullied out of the fandom." However, there is no evidence provided to support this, and the author was unable to find any that confirms that.
- Jamie suggests that, in her view, OnlyOneOf’s lack of active management over their fan community has contributed to the perception of the group as being primarily characterized as the “queer or gay group” and because of this they “are not taken seriously”. This perception appears to be at odds with the group’s public actions, which indicate a consistent and deliberate embrace of LGBTQ+ themes and representation.
***OnlyOneOf does not appear to express discomfort with being associated with the LGBTQ+ community. The group has released a music video series titled Underground Idol, which depicts all six members in same-sex relationships. Additionally, there are thematic allusions throughout their entire discography, with Instinct Part 1 and Instinct Part 2 containing some of the more explicit references to same-sex relationships through lyrics and visual concepts. The members also starred in a Boys’ Love (BL) series titled Bump Up Business, performed at a gay club in London, and have shown visible support for LGBTQ+ fans—for example, by holding LGBTQ+ flags at every stop of their 2024 world tour. These are just a few examples among many that suggest the group’s support of the LGBTQ+ community.
***Available data indicates that OnlyOneOf has a substantial LGBTQ+ fan base. A survey conducted on X over an eight-day period in April 2025 gathered responses from 210 participants, of whom only 8.6% self-identified as heterosexual. A year prior, in April 2024, a similar survey was conducted on X over a two-week period, receiving 412 responses, with only 7.5% of participants reporting that they were heterosexual.
Both surveys were informal and may only reflect a portion of the group's fan base, rather than constituting a comprehensive or statistically representative demographic profile.
On May 14, 2025, at 8:20 a.m. KST, Koreaboo published an article titled “4th Gen Idol’s Messy Relationship With Alleged Sasaeng Gets Put On Blast,” covering the ongoing situation involving KB. Koreaboo is a U.S.-founded media platform that delivers Korean pop culture content in English to a global audience, with operations in Seoul and Los Angeles.
May, 14, 2025, around 1 p.m. KST
In response to the Koreaboo article, Jamie posted on her Instagram story, stating, “That isn’t what’s even going on”
May 15, around 11 a.m. KST
Jamie states on her Instagram story that this document should not be trusted, asserting that the author holds a bias against her. She writes, “DO NOT BELIEVE THIS DOCUMENT.” As a reminder, all information presented in this document is alleged, and readers are encouraged to review the material and form their own conclusions.
May 20
KB and Nine have returned to livestreaming on TikTok on a regular basis. While KB has unblocked certain individuals, Nine has continued not to address the situation publicly and still has several long-time fans blocked.
May 30
Alex responded to allegations made by Jamie
Jamie’s allegations included:
- Alex gaining the moderator role through favoritism.
- Alex attempting to leverage donations for personal gain— implying romantic or sexual expectations from KB.
- Alex using financial influence to gain power and preferential treatment in live streams.
- Alex shifting the focus of the community, making lives centered around him.
In response to these allegations, Alex posted the following message to his TikTok Story (summarized):
- Asked to be left alone, describing himself as a 20-year-old boy who is struggling with the emotional toll of the ongoing situation.
- Claimed that Jamie, who he characterizes as significantly older, has been harassing him, KB, and the rest of OnlyOneOf.
- Stated that the conflict has negatively impacted his well-being, including his ability to eat and sleep.
- Accused Jamie of:
- Encouraging others to attack him online.
- Sending individuals to confront him at a Japan show.
- Instructing people to search through U.S. group photos to identify him.
- Creating group chats with the alleged intent to frame or discredit him.
- Asserted that the fandom does not support Jamie and implied that the group likely does not either.
- Alex concluded his post with the following direct quote:
- "I'm skinny, sexy, rich and handsome. You're an ugly old lady who's miserable because your 오빠 (oppa) realized you're evil. I won, you lost. Move on! PS your jealousy is flattering."
Shortly after, KB posted a video of himself dancing on his TikTok Story, with part of the caption reading:
"thank you handsome skinny cute Alex"
This was widely interpreted as a reference to Alex’s earlier post.
Reactions to the post were mixed. Some fans viewed it as a playful gesture, while others expressed concern, interpreting it as potentially promoting fatphobic messaging.
Around the same time, a clip from a joint livestream between KB and Nine on March 26 began circulating, in which Nine says that KB called him a "pig" for gaining weight, despite Nine stating he felt healthy. The clip contributed to ongoing discussions among fans about body-related comments made by KB.
[CURRENTLY UPDATING & ADDING SOURCES]
June 2
Jamie released additional screenshots of her alleged conversations with KB. In one of them, KB appears to call fans “stupid” while referencing an incident that took place on April 15.
On April 15, 2025, JNB Canada announced ongoing criminal proceedings regarding the spread of false information and defamation.
A photo of Twitter user @ONFEnthusiast, originally posted to their private Instagram, was shared publicly by JNB Canada, the company that organized OnlyOneOf’s North American tour. Fans widely criticized this action as a form of doxing, as it appeared that JNB accessed private content without consent.
The incident deeply concerned many lyOns, especially those participating in the fan-led boycott of JNB Canada. The boycott was intended to advocate for the safety and well-being of OnlyOneOf and to call attention to what fans described as unethical or unsafe practices by the company. In response to the leak, many fans became fearful that they, too, could be targeted or doxed for their involvement in the boycott.
In the screenshot shared by Jamie, KB’s use of the term “stupid” appears to reference these fans—specifically, those who were distressed by the incident and took part in the boycott out of a desire to protect the group. Many fans who saw the screenshot expressed disappointment, saying they felt unfairly dismissed or insulted despite their intentions being rooted in concern for the members.
June 3
Nine addressed the situation regarding KB calling him a “pig” during a TikTok livestream, clarifying that he was personally unbothered by the joke KB made concerning his weight.
Following Nine’s clarification, KB received support, particularly from non-English-speaking fans. Some of this support appeared to stem from the belief that the backlash was primarily due to the specific comment in question.
Meanwhile, some fans highlighted that, regardless of cultural context or intent, referring to a friend as a “pig” could be seen as inappropriate—especially for someone in the public eye. These fans encouraged a broader conversation about accountability and the expectations placed on idols.