MOSCOW AVIATION INSTITUTE
(National Research University)
Aerospace Institute No. 6
Topic: "development of a method for returning space interplanetary transport rockets to Earth"
Introduction
The purpose of the work: to create a method for returning space interplanetary transport rockets to Earth.
Tasks:
1. To study the literature related to the topic of the work.
2. To analyze existing methods for returning devices from outer space to Earth.
3. To determine the requirements for the return system.
4. To develop a return method.
5. Conclusion.
Section 1. Literature analysis.
Based on literature and electronic resources, the need to develop a method for returning interplanetary space transport rockets was identified[30][31]. Data on descent using a ballistic trajectory[1][2][3], on reusable return of an interplanetary stage[4] were analyzed, and also, for a detailed study of aerodynamic processes and for studying a separate, more developed one-time return method, such return methods were analyzed, where winged and controlled descent vehicles were present[5]. Information from reliable sources was used to determine the requirements of the return system and the minimum requirements for adaptation to other objects[6]. Calculations were made for the selected return method.
Based on the above, it becomes clear that the development of a rocket return method is an important stage in the development of astronautics. The creation of such a method will strengthen the position of man in space, will save large financial costs at the initial stage, save resources for the creation of subsequent rockets. The need to create a method for returning a reusable interplanetary stage is also argued by the fact that they are only at the initial stage of development and the method for returning such rockets has not yet been created or published. The relevance of the coursework lies in the proven need to create a landing method. The novelty of the work is confirmed by the initial stage of development of such missions using the proposed method.
Relevance: economic efficiency due to repeated use, reduced environmental impact due to reduced space debris, the need for technological progress in the field of landing and control, support for long-term missions to explore and colonize planets.
Novelty: the creation of innovative methods of precision landing taking into account high atmospheric entry speeds and various trajectories, the introduction of autonomous navigation and control systems for real-time trajectory correction, as well as in the design of modular structures adapted to the specifics of interplanetary missions, which distinguishes them from technologies used for near-Earth vehicles.
Section 2. Analysis of existing return methods.
Method 1. Return via ballistic trajectory.
The method is one of the simplest and most common. It is used mainly to return objects without significant maneuvering. This is a method of returning a spacecraft (SC) from space to Earth, in which the descent trajectory is determined solely by the gravitational attraction of the Earth and the aerodynamic drag of the atmosphere. Control during such a descent is minimal or absent, which makes this method relatively simple in technical implementation.
1. Advantages.
• Simplicity and proven technology.
• Efficiency of fuel use.
• Minimization of technological complexity.
Such a descent does not require complex and high-energy technologies to ensure control and maneuvering.
2. Disadvantages.
• Limited maneuverability.
• High temperatures during entry into the atmosphere.
• Increased aerodynamic load.
• Inability to land accurately.
3. Technological costs and challenges.
• Precise trajectory development.
• Enhanced thermal protection systems.
• Speed control during atmospheric entry.
• Limited maneuverability.
• Structural strength requirements.
• Navigation errors.
• Aerodynamic instability.
•Limited reusability.
The second method. Reusable return of space interplanetary transport rockets.
Reusable rockets are an important step forward in the space industry, promising to significantly reduce the cost of flights and make them more accessible. The idea of the method of reusable return of the interplanetary stage is to create a cost-effective and technically reliable system that allows the return of the second stage of the rocket to Earth after long missions in deep space[32].
1. Advantages of reusable systems.
• Reduced launch costs.
• Acceleration of preparation time.
• Environmental benefits.
2. Disadvantages of reusable systems.
• Complexity of design.
• Increased requirements for materials.
• Potential risks during landing.
3. Technological costs and challenges.
• Development of complex navigation and control systems.
• Development of more stable heat-protection systems.
• Reusable components.
• Gravity and atmospheric conditions.
The third method. Winged vehicles and controlled descent vehicles.
1) Winged vehicles.
The method of returning winged vehicles involves the use of aerodynamic elements (wings, rudders, stabilizers) for a controlled return to Earth, which makes them more flexible and effective compared to ballistic methods. This approach allows not only to return the vehicle from orbit or deep space, but also to ensure its precise landing on specially prepared airfields [33].
1. Advantages:
• Control and maneuverability.
• Convenience for multiple use.
• Convenience for large cargo and crew.
2. Disadvantages:
• Complexity and high mass.
• Limited altitude and angle of entry into the atmosphere.
• High operating costs.
3. Technological costs.
• Development of complex navigation and control systems.
• Creation of effective heat-protective systems.
• Aerodynamic design.
• Reusable components.
• Gravitational and atmospheric conditions.
• Landscape limitations during landing.
2) Controlled descent vehicles.
Controlled descent vehicles (usually capsule type) are designed for vertical descent using a combination of aerodynamic, parachute and sometimes propulsion braking systems[34].
1. Advantages:
• Simplicity of design and increased reliability.
• Savings on development and operation.
• High strength and heat protection.
2. Disadvantages:
• Limited maneuvering capabilities.
• High overloads for crew and equipment.
• Parachute and propulsion systems require regular maintenance.
3. Technological costs.
• Development of complex navigation and control systems.
• Development of stable heat protection systems.
• Reusable components.
• Gravitational and atmospheric conditions.
• Landscape limitations during landing.
• Development of systems for aerodynamic control.
• Minimization of overloads during the descent stage.
• Emergency landing system.
Section 4. Developing a method for returning interplanetary space transport rockets.
To develop a method for returning a space rocket, it is necessary to take into account the problems that affect the successful outcome of returning space complexes. Factors such as landing accuracy, fuel consumption, descent speed, high overloads, aerodynamic instability, thermal load, all these problems are united by one key reason - speed. It is the main challenge for engineers in this area, since all the difficulties begin with it. The most obvious solution is to reduce the speed to the optimal 25,000 km / h upon entering the atmosphere. The speed of a heavy rocket returning from Mars will be about ~ 45,000 km / h, based on the formula for calculating the maximum speed of a rocket in a vacuum Δv = Iуд⋅g⋅ln (mf / m0), where Iуд is the specific impulse of the Raptor 2 engines (one of the most powerful, taken as an example). Therefore, it is necessary to reduce the speed from ~45,000 km/h to 25,000 km/h, which will require significant fuel consumption. A heavy rocket returns from Mars to Earth, covering a distance of about 55 million kilometers. Its speed on this route will be about 45,000 km/h, and upon entering the Earth's atmosphere, it will need to be reduced to 25,000 km/h. The distance from Earth at which braking should begin is ~20,000 km. Given the fact that the rocket should begin braking, its nozzle must be turned so that it is co-directed with the direction of the rocket. Since we have a case where this rocket complex has a crew, it is necessary to calculate the fuel costs for this turn and overload. Overload: we write down the input data: m = 1000 t, L = 50 m, t = 60 s, θ = 180 degrees, v = 45,000 km/h. The radius of the turning trajectory for the rocket nose: r = L/2 = 25 m, the angular acceleration α is related to the turning time and the turning angle as follows: θ = 1/2 * α * t ^ 2, hence the angular acceleration α = 2 * θ / t ^ 2, the overload for a point on the rocket nose is caused by the centripetal acceleration: aper = ω ^ (2) * r, ω is the angular velocity, which is defined as: ω = αt = 2 * θ / t. Let us substitute ω into the overload formula: aper = (2θ / t) ^ (2) * r. Expressed in overloads: aper, g = aper / g and we get 0.027 g. Fuel consumption: the moment of inertia of the rocket for the cylinder is approximately: I = (1/12) * m * L ^ 2. We take uniform angular acceleration over time t to turn by π rad, hence: ω = α * t, ϕ = (1/2) * α * t ^ 2 and α = 2ϕ / t ^ (2) = 2π / t ^ 2. Torque (M), we use the equation of rotational motion, M = I * α. Thrust (F), the torque is created by the jet thrust M = F * r ⟹ F = M / r. Gas flow velocity and fuel consumption, the force can be expressed through the fuel flow velocity and its mass flow rate (m˙): F = m˙u ⟹ m˙ = F / u. Total fuel consumption for time t: mfuel=m˙t=F*t. Thus, approximately 237 kg of fuel will be required to turn the rocket at a gas outflow velocity of 3750 m/s. Let's calculate the fuel consumption for braking. This maneuver has 2 stages: turn and braking. Let's calculate:
1. turn
A turn in space requires a relatively small impulse, since there is no resistance of the medium. Moment of inertia: I = mL^2/12, angular velocity w=L/I, L is the angular impulse. For a turn by θ=π radians with constant acceleration: θ = athalf^2/2, where a = 2*thalf, the angle in half the time is π/2. Let's calculate the time it takes to turn around (with the calculation of a satisfactory overload for a potential crew, we'll take 1g as a basis): 9.8 = w^2*25, w = 0.625 rad/s, thalf= π/0.625 = 5s, 5*2 = 10 s.
Fuel consumption: torque M = F*r= m*vв*r, L = M*thalf, then m = 277.6 kg/s. 277.6*10= 2782 kg = 2.8 tons.
2. Braking
Initial speed = 45,000 km/h, final speed = 25,000 km/h. ∆v = 12,500 – 6,944 = 5,556 m/s, vist gases = 3,750 m/s.
Tsiolkovsky equation: ∆v = vist gases * ln(mstart/mend) => mend = 997218/e^4.398 = 226698 kg, fuel consumption = 997218 - 226698 = 770520 kg
Total: 2782 + 770520 = 773302 kg
The method of returning the rocket is as follows: it is proposed to carry out a turn maneuver in space, during which vacuum engines will be used to reduce speed, after which preparations are made for the entry of the space rocket into the dense layers of the atmosphere of planet Earth, where the atmosphere will be used for braking and reducing speed to the optimum for landing.
Section 5. Conclusion.
Space development has become one of the key areas of modern science and technology, opening up new horizons and opportunities for humanity. Over the past decades, significant progress has been made in space exploration: from the first flights to near-Earth orbit to grandiose missions to explore other planets and deep space. One of the main tasks of future space development remains reducing the cost and increasing the efficiency of space flights. In addition, active research into space logistics continues, including refueling spacecraft in orbit and resource extraction on other celestial bodies. In the course of studying methods for returning heavy space complexes from long-range missions, emphasis was placed on critical aspects affecting the successful completion of the mission. These include: thermal loads, controllability of the spacecraft, and fuel consumption. All these factors are united by one key problem - the high speed of the returning spacecraft. The most effective way to solve this problem, according to the author, is to reduce the speed to ~7000 - 10000 km/h upon entering the Earth's atmosphere, which will significantly reduce the thermal effect and facilitate control over the rocket's movement. However, to achieve this, it will be necessary to reduce the speed from 28000 km/h, which is accompanied by large fuel costs.
List of references
[1] Curtis, H. D. Orbital Mechanics for Engineering Students [Текст]. — 3-е изд. — Oxford: Butterworth-Heinemann, 2014. — 900 с. (дата обращения: 30.11.2024).
[2] Bate, R. R., Mueller, D. D., White, J. E. Fundamentals of Astrodynamics [Текст]. — New York: Dover Publications, 1971. — 455 с. (дата обращения: 30.11.2024).
[3] NASA Technical Reports Server (NTRS) [Электронный ресурс]. — URL: https://ntrs.nasa.gov/ (дата обращения: 30.11.2024).
[4] Vance, A. Elon Musk: Tesla, SpaceX, and the Quest for a Fantastic Future [Текст]. — New York: HarperCollins, 2015. — 400 с. (дата обращения: 30.11.2024).
[5] Seely, E. K. Reusable Space Transportation Systems [Текст]. — New York: Springer, 2009. — 450 с. (дата обращения: 30.11.2024).
[6] Международная федерация астронавтики (IAF) [Электронный ресурс]. — URL: https://www.iafastro.org/ (дата обращения: 30.11.2024).
[7] Weßling, H. K. Aerothermodynamics of Space Vehicles [Текст]. — Berlin: Springer, 2009. — 308 с. (дата обращения: 30.11.2024).
[8] Wertz, J. R., Everett, D. F., Puschell, J. J. Space Mission Engineering: The New SMAD [Текст]. — Hawthorne: Microcosm Press, 2011. — 1041 с. (дата обращения: 30.11.2024).
[9] NASA. Landing on Mars: Techniques and Technologies [Электронный ресурс]. — URL: https://ntrs.nasa.gov/ (дата обращения: 30.11.2024).
[10] Larson, W. J., Pranke, L. K. Human Spaceflight: Mission Analysis and Design [Текст]. — 2-е изд. — New York: McGraw-Hill, 2000. — 800 с. (дата обращения: 30.11.2024).
[11] Микрин, Е. А. (ред.). Бортовые комплексы управления космических аппаратов [Текст]. — Москва: Изд-во МГУ, 2010. — 530 с. (дата обращения: 30.11.2024).
[12] Никитин, П. В. Тепловая защита [Текст]. — Москва: Машиностроение, 1987. — 278 с. (дата обращения: 30.11.2024).
[13] Калинчев, В. А. Технология теплозащиты и теплоизоляции изделий [Текст]. — Москва: Машиностроение, 1995. — 320 с. (дата обращения: 30.11.2024).
[14] Draper, C. S., Betting, R. H., Hoag, D. G., Wrigley, W. Navigation, Guidance, and Control in Space [Текст]. — New York: Academic Press, 1964. — 515 с. (дата обращения: 30.11.2024).
[15] O'Donnell, C. F. Inertial Navigation [Текст]. — New York: John Wiley & Sons, 2000. — 400 с. (дата обращения: 30.11.2024).
[16] Раушенбах, Б. В., Токарь, Е. Н. Управление ориентацией космических аппаратов [Текст]. — Москва: Наука, 1991. — 245 с. (дата обращения: 30.11.2024).
[17] Симоньянц, Р. П. Методы пассивной ориентации и стабилизации космических аппаратов [Текст]. — Москва: Машиностроение, 1988. — 300 с. (дата обращения: 30.11.2024).
[18] Базилевский, А. Т., Григорьев, Е. И., Ермаков, С. Н. Проектирование спускаемых автоматических космических аппаратов [Текст]. — Москва: Наука, 1985. — 350 с. (дата обращения: 30.11.2024).
[19] Баженов, В. И., Осин, М. С. Посадка космических аппаратов на планеты [Текст]. — Москва: Машиностроение, 1978. — 320 с. (дата обращения: 30.11.2024).
[20] Зайцева, А. В. Системы управления и посадки космических аппаратов [Текст]. — Москва: Изд-во МГТУ им. Баумана, 2010. — 280 с. (дата обращения: 30.11.2024).
[21] Курбатов, Ю. В. Диагностика и контроль технического состояния машин [Текст]. — Москва: Машиностроение, 2005. — 375 с. (дата обращения: 30.11.2024).
[22] Жебрунов, В. А. Введение в диагностику технических систем [Текст]. — Москва: Машиностроение, 1995. — 300 с. (дата обращения: 30.11.2024).
[23] Бетанов, В., и др. Теоретические основы баллистико-навигационного обеспечения космических полетов [Текст]. — Москва: Наука, 1989. — 410 с. (дата обращения: 30.11.2024).
[24] Базилевский, А. Т., Григорьев, Е. И. (ред.). Проектирование спускаемых автоматических космических аппаратов [Текст]. — Москва: Наука, 1985. — 350 с. (дата обращения: 30.11.2024).
[25] Баженов, В. И., Осин, М. С. Посадка космических аппаратов на планеты [Текст]. — Москва: Машиностроение, 1978. — 320 с. (дата обращения: 30.11.2024).
[26] Gilmore, D. Spacecraft Thermal Control Handbook (Vol. I & II) [Текст]. — New York: Springer, 2002. — 650 с. (дата обращения: 30.11.2024).
[27] Silk, E. A. Introduction to Spacecraft Thermal Design [Текст]. — Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2020. — 310 с. (дата обращения: 30.11.2024).
[28] Chatterjee, A., Mukherjee, A. Vision-Based Mobile Robot Control and Path Planning [Текст]. — New York: Springer, 2011. — 400 с. (дата обращения: 30.11.2024).
[29] Latombe, J.-C. Robot Motion Planning [Текст]. — Berlin: Springer, 1991. — 378 с. (дата обращения: 30.11.2024).
[30] SpaseX [электронный ресурс]. – URL: https://www.spacex.com/
[31] NASA [электронный ресурс]. – URL: https://www.nasa.gov/
[32] Wikipedia [электронный ресурс]. –
URL: https://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/SpaceX_Starship
[33] Histrf [электронный ресурс]. – URL: https://histrf.ru/read/articles/dvesti-pyat-minut-triumfa-istoriya-pervogo-poleta-burana
[34] Wikipedia [электронный ресурс]. URL: https://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/%D0%A1%D0%BF%D1%83%D1%81%D0%BA%D0%B0%D0%B5%D0%BC%D1%8B%D0%B9_%D0%B0%D0%BF%D0%BF%D0%B0%D1%80%D0%B0%D1%82?