State Exhibits

 

SE 1 – Snapchat selfie in car

SE 4 – drone video of Mears lot to Monon High Bridge (5 minutes 21 seconds).mp4

SE 5 – digital map of the area including Hoosier Heartland Highway, 300 N, Mears entrance, and location of the CPS building

SE 6 – drone video of Freedom Bridge to Monon High Bridge taken on February 13, 2024 (9 minutes 37 seconds).mp4

SE 7 – Google map of the area

SE 18 – GIS map of the area (1)

SE 19 – GIS map of the area (2)

SE 20 – crime scene diagram

SE 119 – photo of shoe removed, cell found found

SE 182 – Google map of contact with the suspect prepared by CSI Cody

SE 183 – ISP helicopter aerial photo of searchers in the river (1)

SE 184 – ISP helicopter aerial photo of searchers in the river (2)

SE 185 — Sgt. Brian Bunner CV

SE 186 – victim phone post-it note

SE 188 – front of Libby’s phone with case on

SE 189 – back of Libby’s phone with Gryffindor case

SE 190 – photo of the back of Libby’s phone with Gryffindor case removed

SE 191 – close up photo of the back of Libby’s phone showing model #

SE 192 – photo of Libby’s SIM card tray and card

SE 193 – photo of Libby’s screen locked

SE 194 – photo of Libby’s home screen unlocked

SE 195 – photo of Libby’s iPhone About settings

SE 196 — photo of Libby's iCloud settings showing “liberty.german@icloud.com” (landscape mode)

SE 197 – photo of Libby’s iTunes & App Store settings

SE 198 — photo of Libby's iMessage settings

SE 199 — photo of Libby's Snapchat menu settings

SE 200 – 30 second version of Bridge Guy video

SE 206 – photo of Libby’s iPhone EST time zone, AT&T

SE 208 — Jeremy Chapman CV

SE 209 – Bridge Guy video

SE 211 – copies of Bre Wilber’s snapchat photos from 2/13/2017 (1 photo of MHB taken at 12:43 pm and 1 photo at 1:26 pm)

SE 212 – copy of Betsy Blair’s Fitbit data

SE 214 – still frame from HHS video showing Betsy Blair’s vehicle driving eastbound at 12:02 pm

SE 215 – still frame from HHS video showing Betsy Blair’s vehicle driving westbound at 1:15 pm

SE 216 – still frame from HHS video showing Betsy Blair’s vehicle driving eastbound at 1:46 pm

SE 217 – still frame from HHS video showing Kelsi German’s vehicle driving eastbound at 1:49 pm

SE 218 – still frame from HHS video showing Betsy Blair’s vehicle driving westbound at 2:18 pm

SE 219 – Sarah Carbaugh HHS eastbound at 15:56:13

SE 220 — copy of map where Sarah Carbaugh marked seeing a muddy and bloody man

SE 221 – still photo of BG with marks

SE 224 — Christopher Cecil CV

SE 226 — copy of image of Abby on the bridge at 2:07 pm (found online, not on Libby's phone or Snapchat cache)

SE 233 – black vehicle on HHS westbound at 1:27:35 pm

SE 234 – black vehicle on HHS westbound at 1:27:36

SE 235 – black vehicle on HHS westbound at 1:27:37

SE 236 – black vehicle on HHS westbound at 1:27:38

SE 237 – black vehicle on HHS westbound at 1:27:39

SE 238 – black vehicle on HHS westbound at 1:27:40

SE 239 – black vehicle on HHS westbound at 1:27:41

SE 240 – black vehicle on HHS westbound at 1:27:42

SE 241 – black vehicle on HHS westbound at 1:27:43

SE 242 – black vehicle on HHS westbound at 1:27:44

SE 243 – close up of black vehicle on HHS westbound at 1:27:38

SE 244 – photo of RA’s car at CVS that Mullin took a few days after September 21, 2022 (1)

SE 245 – photo of RA’s car at CVS that Mullin took a few days after September 21, 2022 (2)

SE 247 — photo of the exterior of 1967 Whiteman Drive

SE 248 – photo of the exterior of 1967 Whiteman Drive from a different angle and black Ford Focus in garage

SE 249 – photo of RA’s 2016 black Ford Focus hatchback parked in the garage (1)

SE 250 – photo of RA’s 2016 black Ford Focus hatchback parked in the garage

SE 251 – photo of entry from garage to laundry room showing shelf located in the garage next to the laundry room

SE 252 – photo of a workbench on the other side of the garage with knives

SE 253 – photo of knives out of their sheaths

SE 254 – photo of kitchen showing fridge, stove, basket with keys and name tag with “Rick” on it, box cutters, miscellaneous items

SE 255 – photo of plastic bag in home office full of cell phone chargers and cordless phones

SE 256 – photo of 23 phones that were found in 2 locations (office and master bedroom)

SE 257 – photo of knives recovered from the master bedroom in their sheaths

SE 258 – photo of knives recovered from the master bedroom from exhibit 257, but out of their sheaths

SE 259 – photo of master bedroom closet

SE 260 – photo taken inside of master bedroom closet showing shoes, boots, and gun case

SE 261 – photo of boots and shoes

SE 262 – photo of blue coat on hanger

SE 263 – photo of the back of the blue coat

SE 264 – photo of a Sig Sauer .40 caliber handgun in the nightstand and 2 magazines

SE 265 – photo of a Sig Sauer .40 caliber handgun out of the nightstand out of the holster showing serial number

SE 266 – photo of a Sig Sauer .40 caliber handgun out of the nightstand out of the holster from a different angle

SE 267 – photo of a Sig Sauer .40 caliber handgun and ammo

SE 268 – photo of a Sig Sauer .40 caliber handgun with magazine out showing that it has Blazer .40 caliber rounds

SE 269 – photo of the outside of the wooden keepsake box, engraved carvings with a round photo of trees and water in the middle

SE 270 – photo of keepsake box with notes from RA’s mom, graduation cards, prior employment mementos/photos, .40 caliber hollow point round

SE 271 – photo of the outside of the wooden keepsake box with the lid open

SE 272 – closer up photo of .40 caliber Smith & Wesson round found in keepsake box

SE 273 – photo of the back of a .40 caliber Smith & Wesson round

SE 274 – photos from spare bedroom of black and white photographs of MHB, 1 from April 5, 2008

SE 275 – 1 photo of RA dated February 2016, 1 photo of RA wearing a plaid jacket holding a fish dated March 2016, 1 photo of RA looking down on MHB dated April 2016

SE 277 — Melissa Oberg CV

SE 278 – photo of sealed cartridge found at the crime scene

SE 279 – Oberg powerpoint

SE 283 – Stacy Bozinovski CV.pdf

SE 285 — Patrick Cicero CV

SE 289 – RA browser searches

SE 289 — RA Google history

SE 290 – RA 10/13 interview video.mp4

SE 290 – RA 10/13 interview transcript

SE 291 – RA 10/26 interrogation video.mp4

SE 291 – RA 10/26 interrogation transcript

SE 292 – RA request for interview with the Warden

SE 302 — Monica Wala CV

SE 306 – photo of Richard Allen sometime between 2016 and 2017 (1)

SE 307 – photo of Richard Allen sometime between 2016 and 2017 (2)

SE 308 – photo of Richard and Kathy Allen sometime between 2016 and 2017

SE 309 – photo of Richard Allen sometime between 2016 and 2017 (3)

SE 310 – Brad Weber report

SE 311 – Brad Weber’s 2000 Ford Econoline van

SE 313 – RA phone calls transcript

SE 313 – Nov 14, 2022 between Rick and Kathy Allen.wav

SE 313 – Apr 2, 2023 between Rick and Janice Allen.wav

SE 313 – Apr 3, 2023 between Rick and Kathy Allen at 8:45 am.wav

SE 313 – May 10, 2023 between Rick and Kathy Allen at 5:03 am.wav

SE 313 – May 10, 2023 between Rick and Janice Allen at 11:13 am.wav

SE 313 – May 17, 2023 between Rick and Janis Allen.wav

SE 313 – June 5, 2023 between Rick and Kathy Allen.wav

SE 313 – June 11, 2023 between Rick and Kathy Allen.wav

SE 318 – Bre Wilber 12:25 pm Snapchat pic


Defense Exhibit List

 

A – “original” image of Abby on the bridge at 2:07 pm

N – coordinates of Libby’s video

O – map of the trail area labeled Railly Voorhies.pdf

Q – bullet 60x magnification (1)

R – bullet 60x magnification (2)

S – bullet 60x magnification (3)

T – bullet 40x magnification (1)

U – side by side of bullet magnification (1)

V – side by side of bullet magnification (2)

QQ – Google map of Westville Correctional Facility

SS – April 3 phone call at 5:14 transcript.pdf

TT – April 3 phone call at 8:45 transcript.pdf

VV – Cheyenne and Shelby Duncan Snapchat pics

YY – list of camcorder videos from WCF.pdf

AAA — Affidavit of Business Records re: Brad Health's work scans at 1:43 pm and 2:06 pm

BBB – photo of vehicle resembling the one Brad Health saw around 2:06 pm

CCC – initial search dispatch report.pdf

EEE — updated master sheet of itemizing the DDD videos by date, time, and length

FFF — Dr. Polly Westcott CV

GGG — RA's handwritten letter from White Co. Jail and Kathy Allen (for comparison)

KKK – picture of Brad Weber’s garage taken on Feb 19, 2017 showing sticks and a large tree branch that had been cut

LLL – Betsy Blair sketch of vehicle parked at CPS building

MMM — Dr. Stuart Grassian CV

NNN — Eric Warren CV

PPP — Stacy Eldridge CV