3

2

1

0

1.            Favorite Part

Explanation is clear and thoughtful and fully explained

Explanation is not clear and  thoughtful or is not fully explained

Explanation is not clear and thoughtful, nor is it fully explained.

missing

2.            Writer as Thinker

Explanation is complete, convincing, and clear.

Explanation is clear and complete

Explanation is unclear or partially complete

missing

3.            Revision

Provides a clear and complete explanation of revision area AND the effect the revision had on the piece

Provides a clear and complete explanation of revision area.

Explanation is unclear or incomplete OR is not considered revision

Missing

4.            Challenge

Provides a clear and complete explanation of the challenge AND how they worked through it.

Provides a clear and complete explanation of the challenge

Explanation is unclear or incomplete

Missing

5.            Note to Mr. Fulton

Note is clear and thoughtful

Note is not clear or not thoughtful

Missing