Doctor of Philosophy
University of Wollongong
Table Of Contents
Date of Submission | 19th March 2010
Date of Acceptance | 1st June 2010
Commenced | 1st June 2010
Completion | July 2012
Organisation | University of Wollongong
Student Identification | 3929493
Degree | Doctor of Philosophy
School | School of Information Systems & Technology (SISAT)
Research Strength | Institute for Innovation in Business & Social Research (IIBSOR)
Supervisor | Associate professor Katina Michael
Co-supervisor | Professor Teemy Leinonen - Aalto University, Helsinki, Finland
Study Plan | Part-time
Title | The Application of Location Enabled Body Worn Technologies In The Education Sector
The rapid uptake of body worn, location enabled, mobile network accessible solutions for rich media creation and connection in extreme sports, military and medical sectors is now also challenging the mobile learning and distance education stereotype.
The re-purposed application of these technologies in the education and training sector is now opening up new domains for connecting learners with educators, which in turn poses substantial challenges for organisations as they grapple with the implications that this technology imbues. This participatory research will engage the Australian education sector in investigative research of learning settings where it is critical or desirable to:
A recent theory of networked learning which focuses on learning as making connections, namely Connectivist learning will inform this research from a contemporary pedagogical perspective balanced with a vast array of readings and attributions draw upon from other educational and related theoretical discourse.
According to Wikipedia (accessed 10 March 2010 ):
" .......Connectivism is "a learning theory for the digital age," [has been] developed by George Siemens and Stephen Downes based on their analysis of the limitations of behaviourism,cognitivism and constructivism to explain the effect technology has had on how we live, how we communicate, and how we learn."
A key qualitative and quantitative cross-sector analysis of existing policies employed by organisations to protect the identity, cultural and civil rights of both learners and teachers, security of systems and infrastructure will be employed to contextualize individual and organisational stakeholder contribution. Recent findings regarding the socio-ethical dimensions for body worn technologies with an uberveillant potentiality in a sea of federated identity by Micheals, K. Michaels, M. (2010) will inform the parameters of scope to this research.
This participatory research will engage individuals and groups from select Australian education sectors in a qualitative and quantitative, cross-sector analysis of existing use of location enabled body worn technologies. A focus on educational organisations policy development to protect the civil rights of both learners and teachers as they transverse the security of networked systems infrastructure is a perceived outcome to be derived from this body of research.
Considering the array of features and attributes these technologies avail, this research study will draw upon understandings expounded in systems theory, elements of constructivism as a pre-cursor to a connectivist theoretical framework and elements of existentialism to reference the positive applied use of these technologies in a broader social and public context.
This research will interrogate cross-sectorial trial groups and individuals as they articulate implications and socio-ethical dimensions for the 'shape' of learning as organisations come to grip with location enabled, body wearable and embeddable technologies.
Throughout the journey of research inquiry there will be a constancy of reference to examples of current use of these technologies in the field and to the decision making processes employed by organisations as they govern the use of these technologies.
This research inquiry will also detail the challenges that individuals and organisations alike surmount as they endeavor to address the potential of these technologies in their respective learning spaces.
This research will inform:
Background to the Study
The purpose of this research is to identify junctures of organisational vigilance as these body-wearable nodes of connectivity move quickly towards an uberveillant grid. Likewise, the basis of the research is to build a body of evidence of current uses of these data sets to inform critical debate that will influence policy affecting the educational purpose of these wearable and connected technologies.
Four key messages resonate clearly from the latest iteration of the New Media Consortium's publication of the Horizon Report (2010) currently affecting the practice of teaching, learning, and creative inquiry:
A myriad of online social networking and mobile enabled learning technologies are extending these current trends further into the realms of hyper-connectivity where the boundaries between work, study, family life and social engagement are blurred and often inter-connected.
Some would refer to this phenomena as the true advent of networked learning where the individual, the group and the network build social-sense making or a living literacy that embodies electronic connections amongst all other human communication considerations. These networked human relationships according to theorists like George Siemens and Stephen Downes amongst many are evidence of the rise of connectivism, a preferential digestion of life based learning that is connection dependent and technology enabled.
A vast and incredibly rich body of investigative interrogation by Professor Steve Mann, mobile learning application in the tertiary sector by Professor Anthony and Jan Herrington as well as next social revolution activists Howard Rheingold, Joichi Ito and Danah Boyd provide a strong foundation for informing such connectivist notions. A substantial gap exists however in research as to the implications that these networked technologies are presenting for organisations where a greater range of educational sectors adopt an evidence based approach to data collection, authentication and validation of knowledge skill.sets of learners using geo-locative enabled body-wearable technologies ie. PoV.
This research presents an opportunity to rigorously investigate where the applied use of these technologies are having an impact on learning, where the history of my own application of mobile learning in a range of educational and related industry sectors will further inform existing bodies of knowledge and an opportunity to deeply consider the implications that this investigative research may unveil.
Significance of the Study
This research study will examine the affects on learners and educators alike of emergent geo-location bundled 'validation' authentication for evidence based assessment, recognised prior learning process (RPL), recognised current competency (RCC) or general knowledge acquisition service delivery.
There is evidence to suggest that there are socio-ethical dimensions to the use of these technologies to achieve this authentication validation. Given the infancy of measures to provide vigilance of how these data enabled services intersect in a co-operative of industry interests, there is a distinct possibility that this research will provide insight into policy needs for organisations seeking to employ such technology enabled learning.
This research will endeavour to influence education and training policy as it provides answers to networked learning opportunities considering a number of core and essential understandings:
Aims Of The Study
This research aims to analyse, define and describe praxis oriented methodology that informs the development of policy considerations for utilizing body-worn location enabled technologies as part of the greater networked engagement profile in an organisation.
This research endeavor will closely align educational developments in the mobile learning field with that of socio-ethical studies into the use of these technologies for other purposes.
Objectives Of The Study
The objectives of the research are build a body of evidence from situational, theoretical, applied and summative research findings to compose articles that guide organisations utilizing body-worn location enabled mobile learning technologies as part of the greater networked engagement profile.
Objectives can be broken down into six main areas:
The use of body worn, location enabled technologies to provide a rich and authentic body of learning resources and experiences is under investigation, as data bundling is now increasingly incorporating geo-location as a subset of visual, audio and other recorded encrypted information.
The effects upon the individual private learning space and an organisations ability to handle these technologies in the context of existing ICT infrastructures gives rise to serious implications, now and into the future.
The focus of this research is to determine what these implications might mean for those who are using body worn technologies and the potential for what this technology might risk or benefit the user. The lack of information as to the applied use specifically of POV technologies in education and training suggests that there is also a lack of rigour inherent with a mobile learning solution policy inclusive of this technology.
This research posits a Connectivist theoretical framework as most suited to examining the risks inherent with adding more veillance to flexible education settings and provides an inclusive and networked approach to informing policy that currently governs the distance or flexible education in that organisation.
The hypotheses of this research is that location enabled body wearable rich media learning technologies will have a profound impact on the shape of learning design and development as these technologies become a popular and approved way to provide connection, evidence of authenticated participation and evaluation in an educational context.
The study will prove that there is a need to define, describe, and interpret the current socio-ethical dimensions to the applications of these technologies in order to to better direct educational ICTs policy.
Not limited to:
Definition Of Terms
My current employment status is full-time as Operations Manager with Streamfolio Pty Ltd. - http://www.streamfolio.com (formerly EDUPOV)
Streamfolio is an Australasian product and service based company focused on providing the highest quality point-of-view and complementary technologies to a diverse client portfolio. Due to the parallel scope of this research study and the nature of the products and service rendered by Streamfolio I am making an open declaration of my financial position and interest in this commercial venture.
The nature of my employment is to oversee the day-to-day operations of the company, both as an equal share director and as an employee.
This research study will reference theoretical frameworks to guide and form the foundation upon which concepts can be realized as an interrogative praxis with research participants.
References to scholars current thinking on the associative implications and challenges this research may pose for organisations will form the basis for recommendations for those seeking policy development and solutions in this field of endeavor.
A Praxis Approach To Knowledge Inquiry
Contemporary discourse in a cross-sectorial assay of education appears very divided as to the virtues of either school of thought where value of the institution versus it's perceived demise is under question. This is very apparent in current debates between adopting an OER model for organisations building learner engagement as opposed or in conjunction with the use of the closed LMS (Blackall, L. 2010).
Given the rapid adoption of technology mediated learning, in some cases as the only mechanism for learner engagement, it is essential that theory which underpins the development of curriculum to suit differing education and learner needs must also reference the practical application of concepts in education and training settings. This research aims to posit the theory of Connectivism as a benchmark in the praxis approach to knowledge acquisition that embrace the use of technologies and social interaction associated. Some would refer to this as an advent of networked learning where the individual, the group and the network build social-sense making or a living literacy that embodies electronic connections amongst all other human considerations.
Donald G. Perrin, Executive Editor of the International Journal of Instructional Technology and Distance Learning says the theory of Connectivism "combines relevant elements of many learning theories, social structures, and technology to create a powerful theoretical construct for learning in the digital age".
The nexus, or praxis intersection point between research and applied use of technologies to engage the learner and better prepare the educator are a key feature of this body of research into the implications that location enabled body worn technologies are giving birth to, particularly when considering organisational, social and community policies governing their use. With a praxis approach to knowledge inquiry there is an ability to draw upon a vast body of beliefs, theories and doctrines to guide research methodology and likewise to inform it from a theory that posits "know-where" as a new knowledge aptitude.
Chaos, Disruption & The Role Of Network
Global connectivity afforded by internet provision and the extension of this connectivity through the use of mobile enabled technologies has challenged all manners of social, judicial and cultural disposition in the last decade on an immense scale. The access to just-in-time facts, ease of connection between intelligent objects and the economy of simulation and virtual worlds has undoubtedly re-shaped all manner of human interaction.
The re-shaping has also afforded new opportunities for globally networked entities to be less inhibited by a geographical disposition and to embrace "know-where" as a key attribute of node in a networked entity. An extract of George Siemens seminal paper on the theory of Connectivism posits "know-how" "know-what" and "know-where" as crucial conduits in meta-learning, where networked unity is considered just as important as the learning itself.
".....Connectivism is the integration of principles explored by chaos, network, and complexity and self-organization theories. Learning is a process that occurs within nebulous environments of shifting core elements – not entirely under the control of the individual. Learning (defined as actionable knowledge) can reside outside of ourselves (within an organization or a database), is focused on connecting specialized information sets, and the connections that enable us to learn more are more important than our current state of knowing. Connectivism is driven by the understanding that decisions are based on rapidly altering foundations. New information is continually being acquired. The ability to draw distinctions between important and unimportant information is vital. The ability to recognize when new information alters the landscape based on decisions made yesterday is also critical...."
Illich (1971) in his publication Deschooling Society on the other hand purports that any attempt to institutionalize learning in a universal context, despite the proliferation of technology enhanced communication, will fall short of where humans transformation is most acute, that condition of acceptance of difference and the ability to impart social and emotional accord.
These schools of thought, and in some cases rejection of technology as a mediating force, provides a core foundation upon which to test the premise that there are profound implications yet to be discovered in the proposed body of research.
The research may also reveal:
Wearables - Technology As Bodily Function In Education
Steve Mann is credited with the creation of the human intelligence concept where the relationship between human and computer are inextricably intertwined, a theory of the wearer and the computer with its associated input and output facilities not as separate entities, but a synesthesia of wearer's senses and technology grid.
Mann is also credited with creation of mobile blogging (glogging) as part of an existential suite of human learning and many other forms of research into the use of technologies as a human wearable. These are considered foundational references in a variety of contexts that have informed continued investigations of possibilities for networked learning using human wearable technologies.
Challenges - Ethics of The First Person Perspective
Michaels, M.G. and Michael,K. (2009) in their article A Research Note on Ethics in the Emerging Age of Uberveillance (Überveillance) provide a picture of technologies unleashed without a true commensurate assessment of what they will mean in terms of socio-ethical implications.
This perspective provides a guide for consideration in the context of this research study in the privacy, security and civil rights of the individual and the collective when considering the uberveillant advanced location-based services for humans of which are now part of current industry earnest.
Many popular educational discourses posit and refer to technologies by their device type rather than their physical wearable attributes so this research also aims to inform the discourse from a "embodiment" trajectory.
The shift in nomenclature provides a need to protect the interest of the learner and the educator in their endeavors whilst not restricting the commercial, industrial or social aggregation potential of such interrogative activities if required.
Research Based Design
Methodologies employed to derive data that will inform this research;
1. Define the educational sectors:
2. Identify and investigate:
3. Development Framework:
4. Description - Articles and Presentations
* A table containing phases of the project with methodologies down the side axis will be installed here as a picture.
The following methodologies will be employed to derive data that will inform this research:
This research project will draw upon a wide representation of industry, cross-sectorial education, information communication systems, the Arts and broader public interest groups to realize:
This research will be conducted with participants from cross-sectorial organisational, business and individual workplace settings. Anonymity where required or where privacy of individuals participation in case studies or investigative research is required will be adhered to as well as application of all Ethics Committee considerations.
Implications looking outwards in differing age groups will form the basis to conducting analysis of data across all stakeholder groups involved in this research.
Researchers must employ careful consideration when examining the context for, the applied use and the potential misuse of information communication technologies hence the need to employ a variety of approaches to derive useful and valid data for inclusion consideration.
To ensure the rigor of this research, the use of both investigative and participative modes of inquiry will form the basis for the collation of data, composition of findings, presentation and review.
The interrogation of existing ICT policies in the education sector juxtaposed with the applied use of these technologies guided or otherwise by this policy will require a thorough literature review and will require aptitude in impartial separation of opinion from fact. To ensure an autonomy of data collation, the main design of the study will involve action research methodology where immersion as investigator is exclusive of the participative approach to exhaustive inquiry in this field. Where perceived conflicts of interest emerge, delegation of research duties will be involve carefully, informed contingency measures.
Likewise, a number of digital and non-digital research methodologies will only be employed to interrogate selected stakeholders as to their aptitude, attitude, application or intended use of these technologies within the parameters of their respective domains if and when they unconditionally surrendered permission for inclusion in the study. The autonomy and the rights of the individuals and organisations included in this research will be
The realisation of the research study comes with acknowledgement of the many persons and organisations that will form the focus group, the expert review panel, stakeholders, participants and all who contribute to it's inception.
Data Collection and Analysis
This research study will be conducted in 5 sequential modes of engagement known as phases. Each phase contains a series of actions and implementation methods to gain the data required to compose a collection and to conduct a thorough analysis.
As this research involves humans of all ages and from differing geographical jurisdictions there is a distinct need for ethics consideration at the outset to:
All study and project participants will be formally invited to participate in the study and informed that their participation in the project is voluntary with a distinct proviso that they may withdraw from the study at any stage, and that there will be no negative consequences should they choose to do so.
Each phase of the project will be inform participants in order for them to make an informed choice about participating.
Participants will be required to complete a written consent form for all / part participation to ensure anonymity and confidentiality as requested, as identified and in proof of publication.
All matters of open engagement that contribute to publication will be carefully vetted in consultation with the University’s Human Research Ethics Committee and only rendered inclusive to the studies upon such consultation.
The research study will be conducted over a three year period employing a sequential and chronological implementation of each defined phase of the study as follows;
Phase 1 - Systematic Literature Review - Formation of Networked Reference Group
Phase 2 - Stakeholder Engagement - Participative Related Fields Research - Existing Applied Use Analysis
Phase 3 - Collation and Analysis - Quantitative / Qualitative
Phase 4 - Review - Organisation / Peer
Phase 5 - Presentation - Evaluation feedback to inform publication
The expected outcomes of this research project include:
Australian Flexible Learning Framework : New Practices In Flexible Learning (2004) Txt Me: supporting disengaged youth using mobile technologies (2004) - at http://flexiblelearning.net.au/projects/txtme.htm - accessed 8th March, 2010
Blackall, L. (2005) Digital Literacy: How It Affects Teaching Practice and Networked Learning Futures - at http://itdl.org/Journal/Dec_05/article01.htm - accessed 8th March, 2010
Bonabeau, E., Dorigo, M., & Théraulaz, G. (1999). Swarm intelligence: From natural to artificial systems. New York: Oxford University Press
Downes, S. (2005) E-learning 2.0 - E-learning Magazine - at http://www.cmb.ac.lk/newsletter/ext_pages/Vlc/E-learning%202.pdf - accessed 8th March, 2010
Johnson, L., Levine, A., Smith, R., & Stone, S. (2010). (2009). The 2010 Horizon Report. Austin, Texas: The New Media Consortium
Handbook of emerging technologies for learning: Learning Technologies Centre - retrieved 12 April, 2009 from http://ltc.umanitoba.ca/wikis/etl/index.php/Handbook_of_Emerging_Technologies_for_Learning
Herrington, A. and Herrington, J. (2009) Authentic Learning In Higher Education - at https://www.aare.edu.au/07pap/her07131.pdf - accessed March 10th, 2010
Herrington, A. and Herrington, J. & Mantei, J. (2009) Design Principles for Mobile Learning - at http://ro.uow.edu.au/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1089&context=edupapers - accessed March 10th, 2010.
Mann, S. ( 1996) Smart Clothing: ’Wearable Multimedia and Personal Imaging’ to Restore the Balance Between People and Their Intelligent Environments; Proc. ACM Multimedia 96, ACM Press, New York, 1996.
Mann, S. (1994) Wearable Wireless Webcam: personal WWW page at http://wearcam.org - accessed at http://n1nlf-1.media.mit.edu - March 9th, 2010
Mott, J. (2010) Envisioning the Post-LMS Era: The Open Learning Network; Educause Quarterly - at http://www.educause.edu/EDUCAUSE+Quarterly/EDUCAUSEQuarterlyMagazineVolum/EnvisioningthePostLMSEraTheOpe/199389 - accessed 9th March
M. G. Michael, S. J. Fusco, and K. Michael. "A Research Note on Ethics in the Emerging Age of Uberveillance (Überveillance)" Computer Communications 31.6 (2008): 1192-1199.- Available at: http://works.bepress.com/kmichael/
Michael, M.G. & Michael, K. (2009) Uberveillance: Micro-chipping People and the Assault on Privacy. Quadrant, LIII(3), 2009, 85-89.
M.G. Michael and K. Michael. "Uberveillance cements its position as an official dictionary word" UOW News and Media: Latest News Feb. 201
Michael, K. and Michael, M.G.. From Dataveillance to Überveillance (Uberveillance) and the Realpolitik of the Transparent Society (1 ed). Wollongong: University of Wollongong, 2007 - http://works.bepress.com/kmichael/5 - accessed 8th March 2010
mLearn 2005 : 4th World Conference on m-Learning (2005 ) The Australian Mobile Learning Network : Australian Innovations - at http://www.mlearn.org.za/CD/papers/Ragus.pdf - accessed 8th March,2010
Peters, K. (2005) Learning On The Move : Mobile Technologies In Education & Training - at http://pre2009.flexiblelearning.net.au/flx/webdav/site/flxsite/shared/ResourceCentre/14l_LOM.pdf - accessed 8th March 2010
Sharples, M., Taylor, J., & Vavoula, G. (2005). Towards a theory of mobile learning. Paper presented at the mLearn 2005 4th World conference on mLearning, Cape Town. Retrieved August 20, 2006from http://www.mlearn.org.za/papers-full.htm
Siemens, G. (2005) Connectivism: A Learning Theory For A Digital Age - at http://www.elearnspace.org/Articles/connectivism.htm - accessed 10th March 2010
Siemens, G. & Tittenberger, P. (2009). Handbook of emerging technologies for learning. Learning Technologies Centre. Retrieved 12 April, 2009 from http://ltc.umanitoba.ca/wikis/etl/index.php/Handbook_of_Emerging_Technologies_for_Learning
Staron, M & Jasinksi,M. & Weatherley,R. (2006) Life Based Learning: A Strength Based Approach For Capability Development In Vocational & Technical Education - at http://www.icvet.tafensw.edu.au/ezine/year_2006/jul_aug/documents/lifebased_full_report.pdf - accessed 10th March, 2010
Varied. (2010). Connectivism ( Learning Theory ). Available: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Connectivism_(learning_theory). Last accessed 10 March 2010