Logo © NeoGAF. Not used with permission. All rights reserved. But not by us.

 

NeoGAF User-Submitted Feedback List from the  Buy/Trade/Sell Thread


This List Last Updated on March 3, 2011 at Post 1228 (by Crisis)

Make sure to tip your Guru well as he mediates.

Things to Read First!

First Disclaimer

Second Disclaimer

Privacy Information

How We Compile Information

Positive Feedback

Neutral Feedback

Negative Feedback

Reputable Websites

Website Blacklist

 

Things to Read First!

  Please PM questions/problems to MidnightScott, Zaraki_Kenpachi, or Crisis on the forums.

If you need immediate help regarding something, email gafbsthelpline@gmail.com

 

First Disclaimer

“The NeoGAF administration has no authority over any transactions that are facilitated by this thread [linked in this document’s title] or this document, and cannot be held responsible for whatever results from using this thread to buy, sell, or trade goods or services. We [NeoGAF] advise caution and common sense.” -Evilore

 

Second Disclaimer

The authors of this document take great stride to ensure the accuracy the user-submitted feedback in NeoGAF’s Official Buy/Sell/Trade thread, but make no guarantees as to its accuracy. If you believe that your user name appears on this list erroneously, or if another user is not in the correct category, please PM MidnightScott, Zaraki_Kenpachi, or Crisis on the NeoGAF forums with as much information as you can provide as to where something is incorrect. Please remember that we are using user-submitted feedback, and cannot be held responsible for erroneous listings or for trades going badly.

 

Privacy Information

 Participation in the NeoGAF buy/sell/trade User Feedback List is entirely voluntary and up to each individual member to decide for themselves. Since this list is here to catalog feedback publicly posted within the thread and is compiled from that information, your desire to participate in this list is presumed. However, if at any time you want for your username to not appear on this list, please PM Crisis, MidnightScott, or Zaraki_Kenpachi on the NeoGAF forums. You do not need to provide a reason why. However, if you use the thread to scam another user, we will likely not be as accommodating about removing your username from this list.

 

How We Compile Information

This list is comprised of information that is publicly posted on the NeoGAF Forums in the Buy/Sell/Trade thread. We scan the thread for feedback left by a NeoGAF member for a NeoGAF member. In order for user feedback to count towards this list, it must be left by a NeoGAF member after a transaction has completed. We cannot assume that a trade went well and credit you for it without a user having left the feedback. We recommend that in the event of a user not leaving feedback immediately that you get in contact with that user and ask that they leave feedback within the thread.

 

Search this document by pressing control + F on your keyboard in most web browsers and searching for the user or term you wish to find.

Positive = Great User, Neutral = Be Aware, Negative = Bad User

Format:  User Name, Number of Positive Feedback, Details (optional)

NeoGAF Plus: The number of black pluses ( + ) next to user names in the Positive list indicate one successful, positive transaction apiece. For example,  if a user has three pluses next to their name, they have received three positive feedback posts within the thread. When a user has achieved ten positive feedback posts within the thread, instead of having ten black pluses, they will receive one blue plus ( + ). One blue plus represents ten positive feedback posts within the thread. NeoGAF Plus represents only posts from the new and current Buy/Sell/Trade thread.

NeoGAF Gold: A member whose name appears in gold on this list is a legendary buy/sell/trader. These members are well-known to provide exceptional service throughout many, many transactions. They do not have pluses next to their names because they’ve had so many positive trades, it’d be redundant.

 

 

 

 

Positive Feedback

Username

Positive Feedback

Notes

52club

[++]

 

404ender

[++]

 

A Twisty Fluken

[+]

 

Absu

 

 

Adam Prime

[+++]

 

adg1034

[+]

 

afternoon delight

[++]

 

aggro crag

[++]

 

Aigis

[+]

 

akachen ningen

[+]

 

alehousedave

 

 

Allan Holdsworth

[+++++++]

 

allegate

[+++]

 

allreal

[+]

 

Alucrid

[++++++++]

 

aktham

[+]

 

amentori

[++]

 

AmericanNinja

[++++++++]

 

anachronus_one

[+]

 

andyb0y

[+]

 

Andvary

[++++]

 

andymcc

[+++]

 

animlboogy

[+]

 

aparisi2274

[+]

 

Aranhahunter

[+]

 

aristotle

[+]

 

asdad123

[+]

 

Aselith

[++]

 

Aumann

[+]

 

Aurarian

[++]

 

Azure Phoenix

[+]

 

B  Killenger

[++]

 

BABALU

[++++++]

 

Baconbitz

[++]

 

Balb

[+++++++]

 

beelzebozo

[++++]

 

Ben2749

[+]

 

biggyfries

[++]

 

Bii

[++++]

 

biocat

[++]

 

Black Rainbow

NeoGAF Gold

 

blizzardjesus

[++++]

 

Borman

[+]

 

botticus

[+]

 

bPod

[+]

 

brain_stew

[+]

 

Bread

[+]

 

BreakyBoy

[+++++++++]

 

Broadbandito

[+++]

 

BruceLeeRoy

[+++]

 

btothekw

[+]

 

bubnbob

[++++]

 

BumRush

[+]

 

Bunny

[+]

 

Caj814

[++++]

 

Calion82v

[++]

 

Captain N

[+]

 

CaptMcBlack

[++]

 

Cardigan

[+]

 

carlos

[++++]

 

cbjars

[+]

 

ccbfan

[+]

 

CcrooK

 

 

chadderbox77

[+]

 

Chairhome

[+++++]

 

chaoticblue

[+]

 

Chavelo

[+++]

 

Cheetos is Pretty Awesome

[++]

 

chep

[+]

 

chorazin

[+++]

 

Chopperman

[+]

 

CidHighwind89

[+]

 

cityhunter

[+]

 

Classic_Gs

[++]

 

cmagus

[+++++]

 

CO_Andy

[+]

 

Cocopjojo

[+]

Coldnsnap

[+]

coldvein

[++]

coopolon

[+]

corkscrewblow

[++++++]

cr_blah_blah

[+]

crazymoogle

[+]

cress2000

[+]

Crisis

[++]

crispyben

[++]

CrocMother

[+]

Cryptic

[+]

CryptiK

[+]

Cruzader

[++]

cuevas

[+]

cvxfreak

[+]

cwmartin

[+]

cyclenut

[+++]

Dacvak

[+]

dallas

[+]

Darren870

[++]

Dartastic

[+]

Dave Long

[++]

Davidion

[+]

DCX

[++]

demosthenes

[+]

diffusionx

[+]

DigitalDevil

[++]

discohiro

[+]

DJ Lushious

[++]

DontTouchMe

[+]

Doodlebug

[+++]

dork

[++]

dorkimoe

[+]

Doublethink

[++++]

DownLikeBCPowder

[++++++]

(formerly Kureishima)

Dr. Acid Avatar

[+]

Drakken

[++]

drizzle

drtoemo123

[++]

dudeguy24

[+]

dvolovets

[++]

Dwayne

Echo311

[+]

El_TigroX

[+]

elrechazao

[++]

Eltacoman

[++++]

eosos

[++]

Ephemeris

[+]

ermac

[+]

ethelred

[+]

Ettie

[++++++]

EYEL1NER

[+]

His post office sucks.

Fantasy Final

[+]

Fatal Futanari

Firehead

[++++]

flashbandit16

Flavius

[+++++]

Flunkie

[+++++]

FoxMcCloudDS

[++++++++]

friskykillface

[++]

FrostuTheNinja

[+]

g35twinturbo

NeoGAF Gold

galactus_eat_world

[+++]

GamerGeorge

NeoGAF Gold

GatorBait

[+]

GAZERK

[+]

GCNemesis

[+++]

Gerald Preston

[+]

Gillian Seed

[+]

Giolon

[+]

GK86

[+++]

Gloomfire

[++]

God’s Beard

[+]

GoodMorning

[+]

gotee12

[++++]

Gooster

[+]

GQman2121

NeoGAF Gold

Grady Durden

[++]

GraveRobber X

[+]

Greyvvolf

[+]

GrotesqueBeauty

[++]

Gryphter

[++]

GuiltyByAssociation

[+++]

GunnerGlory

[+]

Hazaro

[++]

Hemloco

[++]

Hero

Hex

[+]

Hugbot

INDIGO_CYCLOPS

[+++]

InfiniteNine

[+]

IrishNinja

[+]

IronFistedChampion

[+]

Iron_Scimitar

[+]

isny

[+++]

Jagernaut

[+]

jay

[+]

Jazzy Network

[++]

JdFoX187

[+++]

jeels

[+++++]

JeffDowns

[++]

jeffpm

[+]

jepjepjep

[+]

Jeo

[++]

jhferry

[+]

Jimmy Stav

NeoGAF Gold

Jirotrom

[+]

JLateralus

[++++]

jling84

[+++++++++]

JodyAnthony

[+++]

JohngPR

[++]

Joe Molotov

[+]

Johnny

[+]

JoseDFrog

[+]

Jubs

[+++]

Kagari

[+]

keeblerdrow

[++++]

kennah

[+]

Kerrinck

[+++++++]

KevinRo

[+]

KiKaL

[+]

Killthee

[+]

Kintaco

[+]

kitchenmotors

[++++]

knee

[++++++]

k0ji-wd

[+]

Kotomi

[++++++]

(formerly Koroshi)

Koshiba

[++]

kpop100

[+]

Lambtron

[+++++]

lawblob

[++++]

Leatherface

[+]

Le-mo

[+]

LethaL ImpuLse

[++]

letsbereasonable

[++]

lilralphie

[+]

Linkhero1

[+++]

Litflynt912

[++++++]

LocoMrPollock

[+]

lolmark

[+]

Lombaszko

[+++]

LQX

[++++++++]

Mac the KNife

[+++]

MacDee

[+]

Mamesj

marathonfool

[++]

markatisu

[+]

MarkMan

[+]

Marshmellow

[+]

mattiewheels

[++]

Mattlikewhoa

[+]

McCloud?

[+]

mclaren777

[+]

Menelaus

[+]

Michan

[++]

MidnightRider

[+]

MidnightScott

[+++++]

Mike Works

[+]

MikeE21286

[++++++++]

mizuk_i

[+]

Mizzou Gaming

[++++]

mjc

[+]

mojimbo

[++++]

MomoPufflet

[+++]

MoogPaul

[+]

moop2000

[++++++]

MotorbreathX

[+]

mr_boo

[++]

mr jones

[+]

Mrbob

[+]

muckhole

[+++]

mug

[+]

Mutanthands

[++++++]

Nekobo

[+]

NeOak

[+]

neoness

[++++]

Neverfade

[+++]

Nighthawk17

[+]

Nightz

[+]

Ninja_Hawk

[+]

Nobodyspatzy

[+]

noquarter

[++]

NoRéN

[+]

nodle

[+++]

olubode

[++]

OrangeGrayBlue

[+]

orecrest

[+]

otheradam

[+]

outsidah

[+]

PaiPaiMaster

[+]

pancakesandsex

[+]

Pangya

[++++++]

Patrick Roy

[+]

Patriotsbball5460

[+++]

PepsiManVsJoe

[++]

Phatcorns

[+++]

Phoenix Fang

[+]

PhoenixSFT

[+++++++]

Plinko

[+]

Ponn01

[+++++++]

poweld

[+++++]

ptown

[++++++]

practice02

[+]

Pylon_Trooper

[+]

Rabbitwork

[+]

radiantdreamer

rainking187

[++]

rc213

[+]

rdelaney

[+]

reggieandTFE

[+]

Rewrite

[+]

riceandbeans

[+]

RickA238

[+]

Risible

[+]

RoboGeorgeForeman

[+++++]

robot

[+++++++]

rolio

[+]

RomanticHeroX

[+++]

Ronabo

[+]

ronito

[++++]

roofy

[+]

Rrang129

[+]

RuneFactoryFanboy

[+]

ruroni

[++]

ruxtpin

[+]

Ryuukan

[++]

SabinFigaro

[+++]

Sailor

[++]

SailorDaravon

[+++++++]

SalsaShark

[++]

sambo

[+]

samus4ever

[+]

Sanjuro Tsubaki

NeoGAF Gold

Scott

[++]

schlew

[+]

Scythesurge

[++++++]

Sega1991

[+]

Servotron

[+++++++++]

Shadowlink

[++++++++]

Shanks

[+++++]

Shin JohnPV

[+++]

ShinAmano

[+++]

ShinoguTakeruKoeru

[++++++]

Shinriji

[+]

shiv47

[++]

ShockingAlberto

[+]

ShyGuy

[++]

Simo

[+]

sk3tch

[+++++++]

skads_187

Slappy967

[+]

Smokydave

[+]

smurfx

[+++]

snack

[++]

snaku

[+]

SNIKT!

[++]

Snorggy

[++]

Solsc

[+++++++]

Solune

[+++]

sontii

[+]

sooperkool

[+]

soyboy

[++]

Speevy

Spiderjericho

[++++++]

Square Triangle

starchild excalibur

[+]

Stencil

[++++++++]

steveovig

[+++++]

storl026

[++++++]

suffah

[+++]

Supervlieg

[+]

Synless

[+]

Taoofberg

[+]

TaKeRx

[++]

Tawney Bomb

[+++]

Tedesco!

[+]

TeethMummy

[+]

tetrisgrammaton

[++++]

thatbox

the chris

[+]

The Gaming Gamer

[+]

The Take Out Bandit

NeoGAF Gold

The M.O.B.

[++]

The Rizza

[+]

The_Inquisitor

[+++++]

theviolenthero

[+++]

threenote

[++++]

Thrilltacular

[+]

thundr51

[+]

tim.mbp

[+]

Toki767

[+]

Tomasooie

[+]

toneroni

tpfkanep

[+]

trevelyan

[++]

tribal24

[+++]

Truespeed

[+]

TSAGoodness

[++++]

Tylahedras

[++]

Unregistered007

[++++]

Urban Scholar

[++++]

Valkyray

viciouskillersquirrel

[+]

V_Ben

[+]

variance

[+]

Vasper

[+++]

vermadas

[++]

VendettaXXI

[+]

vgachi57

[++++++]

vgamer1

[+]

ViktVaughn

[+]

vocab

[+++]

vultureparade

[++]

W1SSY

[+]

Wallach

WanderingWind

[+++++++++]

water_wendi

[+]

Weggles

[+]

WickedLaharl

[+]

Willenium

[+]

woodypop

[+++++]

x Maiku x

[+]

xaosslug

NeoGAF Gold

Xdrive05

[+]

xero273

[+]

Xevren

[+]

y2kenjination

[++]

YagizY

[++++++++]

Yes Boss!

[+++]

YianGaruga

[++++]

YuriLowell

[++++++]

Yuripaw

[+++]

yyr

[+]

Zalasta

[+++]

Zaraki_Kenpachi

[+++++]

ZealousD

[+]

Zihark

[+]

Zing

[++]

zlatko

[+++++++]

zugzug

[+++]

ZZMitch

[+]

Neutral Feedback

 

Username

Issues

cbjars

February 21, 2011: User bubnbob reports that as of February 9, cbjars was supposed to send some Dreamcast titles for $10. It’s weeks later and there’s no sign of cbjars. In the unlikely event that he shows up again, do not do business with him. February 24, 2011: Still has yet to show up and ship any of the titles. Updated February 25, 2011: Games were eventually sent, but by that point, the guy had gone silent for literally three weeks or more. Exercise extreme caution.

jecclr2003

August 2, 2010 sold an item to Plinko on July 18, 2010. Plinko pays for it, jecclr2003 says it’s being sent on the coming Tuesday. Later that week, jecclr2003 says it’s being shipped NEXT Tuesday. As of August 2, jecclr isn’t answering PMs and continues to post in the OT section of GAF. Item has yet to reach Plinko. Updated August 3, 2010: jecclr2003 posted in the thread and owned up to his mistakes, and says he will ship the item soon.

soul4ger

July 17, 2010 LethaL ImpuLse ordered $30 worth of PS2 games from him on the 30th of May, around a month passed without any games or any contact from him. Sent a PM about a week ago with no reply.  July 31, 2010: PepsimanVsJoe indicates that he has also had trouble with soul4ger. August 17, 2010: LethaL ImpuLse states that soul4ger has given an explanation for his actions and has refunded his money. No word yet from PepsimanVsJoe on whether his situation has changed yet. October 21, 2010: According to a NeoGAF manhunt in the Gaming Side, soul4ger apparently scammed approximately $1000 from user Zaraki_Kenpachi. Due to a bunch of his personal information being posted, soul4ger can expect that they’ll be climbin’ in his window, snatchin’ his people up. October 24, 2010: According to this post here soul4ger says that the transaction with Zaraki_Kenpachi is a super-large order and that takes time to ship all of it out. Apparently, there is only one box left to go in the shipment. My take on all this? Zaraki_Kenpachi might have jumped the gun a little bit and soul4ger probably should have communicated a little better considering someone sent him thousands of dollars for game stuff that comes in staggered shipments.Updated October 30, 2010: Zaraki_Kenpachi confirms that the last of his items have arrived via mail and that his issues with soul4ger are now resolved.

 

 

Negative Feedback

 

Username

Rap Sheet

Google

slow response & poor communication, signs on but ignores PMs. Updated 07/16/2010: PayPal dispute filed by ethelred and MacDee. No refund or communication in over two weeks. Complaints from TeethMummy, woodypop, and Alucrid as well. Updated 7/23/2010: MacDee reports that Google’s PayPal account has been closed and that his money has been refunded. Do not deal with Google in the unlikely event that he returns to the thread or NeoGAF. Updated August 10, 2010: woodypop and TeethMummy have reported that they still have not received a refund from Google. woodypop indicates that he sent the money for his item as a “gift” over PayPal, so he cannot contest it with them.

ReconYoda

December 31, 2010 ReconYoda has a lot of positive feedback within the thread, but apparently is refusing to respond to private messages from EYEL1NER and other NeoGAF members within the Buy/Sell/Trade thread to resolve a matter involving an iPod Touch. Until this issue is worked out, he is listed here in the neutral feedback section. Be aware. Updated February 13, 2011: EYEL1NER states that ReconYoda never sent him the check back as he promised to do within the thread. A PM to ReconYoda has gone unanswered for several weeks now, and we can no longer assume that he intends to do the right thing here. He is listed in negative feedback for failure to communicate and resolve an issue with a seller.

red shoe paul

NEOGAF HALL OF SHAME ALL-STAR

 

July 7, 2010: owes money, continues to ignore PMs (should be banned!) - Kerrinck - July 31, 2010: TheBrain76 also reports that red shoe paul sold him a Red Dead Redemption t-shirt and never sent it to him. And also refuses to acknowledge PMs or get in contact with anyone. Kerrinck states that red shoe paul still owes him money. red shoe paul is actively trying to “purchase” items within the thread. Be very aware. August 24, 2010: Still hasn’t paid back the entire sum of money. Holy crap. Updated January 4, 2011: red shoe paul has made yet another appearance in the buy/sell/trade thread claiming that a “friend” wants a PSP Go. Is likely a member of al-Qaeda. If you see red shoe paul post anywhere on the forum, make sure that you publicly shame him for being a no-good criminal.

YoshiFtJ

He is pre-emptively added to the list. He says he’s a “friend” of red shoe paul. ProTip: He’s not really a “friend” of red shoe paul. He is red shoe paul. See “red shoe paul” above for why you shouldn’t deal with him.

 

 

Reputable Websites

Amazon- http://www.amazon.com (.ca, .co.uk, .de, .fr, .co.jp, .cn)

Location: USA, Canada, United Kingdom, Germany, France, Japan, China

Details: The worlds largest online retailer. Carrying everything from household goods to consumer electronics. (Best website ever for online shopping, PERIOD!) Are you a university student? Got a .edu address? http://www.amazon.com/gp/student/signup/info . That link gives you free Amazon Prime shipping. You want to use it.

 

Play-Asia - http://www.play-asia.com

Location: Hong Kong, China

Details: An excellent website for buying import videogames and other asian products. Highly recommended, and great customer service.

 

 

 

Website Blacklist

Das¢heap - http://www.dascheap.com

Location: California, USA

Details: This website seems to have a number of issues. First it uses the Better Business Bureau’s logo without permission. Customer service rep seems to use lots of obvious grammatical errors. Customer reviews state they have had trouble communicating with the company.

 

GamesBasement - http://www.gamesbasement.co.uk

Location: United Kingdom

Details: Website either takes forever to ship item or never does whether products are in stock or not, even if they have already charged your credit card. Attempts to reach customer service will be ignored. They will change the price of an item even after you order it and charge your card for a higher amount. Do not use them, several members of Euro NeoGAF have been scammed.