Social Media Lab - Elsevier WebApp Concept Design Competition
Scale: 1- Disagree 2-Neutral 3-Agree 4-Strongly Agree 5-Exceptional
Part 1: Application Design /20 pts
Originality /5 pts
Is the application a new idea? Does the application approach an old problem in a new way? Does the application use the tools available through SciVerse in an innovative way?
Suitability /5 pts
Does the application solve a real need? Does the application identify and suit the target end user?
Feasibility /5 pts
Can the application be reasonably developed by a single programmer? Has the designer considered possible implementation issues? Does the designer understand and work within the constraints of the SciVerse system?
Usability /5 pts
Is the proposed interface clear and easy to use?
Part 2: Presentation /10
Clarity /5 pts
Does the poster/presenter explain the application clearly? Could a programmer take the poster/presentation and develop the idea?
Understanding /5 pts
Does the presenter demonstrate a full understanding of their application? Can the presenter successfully field questions about the application?