Workshop: The Submission Phase  Moodle ISU 2


Introduction

During the Submission Phase students will submit their work according to the instructions and criteria established in the Setup Phase and instructors will allocate the submissions for peer review.  Before moving to the Submission Phase please make sure all the settings are correct. There are many options in creating a workshop.  If you have any questions about the workshop please contact the ITRC for additional assistance.

This guide will help you to:

You will want to see the additional Workshop guides for more information about each phase:

Moving to the Submission Phase

Once you move to the Submission Phase students will be able to begin submitting their work.  If you have set Access Controls during the Setup Phase, submissions will be limited to those dates.  If you would like to set a submission window, you can do that in the Access Controls section of the workshop settings.  See Workshop: The Setup Phase for more information. Please make sure that all the settings are correct before moving to the Submission Phase.

In the Submission Phase, when students click on the name of the workshop they will see the Workshop Planner with a list of the tasks they need to complete and reminders of submission due dates (if you have set a due date).  During the Submission Phase, students are able to edit their submissions.

Note:  The workshop MUST be in the Submission Phase for students to submit their work (even if you have set a submission window using the Access Controls section within the settings).

In order to move to the Submission Phase you will do the following:

  1. Click on the name of the Workshop.
  2. On the Workshop Planner, beneath the Submission Phase title, Click the Light Bulb to begin the phase.

  1. You will see a message that describes what can be done during the Submission Phase.  Click the Continue button to move to the Submission Phase.

Update Instructions for Assessment

The first task in the Submission Phase is to Provide Instructions for Assessment.  These instructions were created in the Setup Phase, however you can modify them at this point if necessary. There are several ways to access the Instructions for Assessment.

  1. Click on the name of the workshop.
  1. On the Workshop Planner you will see a list of tasks to complete in the Submission Phase. Click the Provide Instructions for Assessment option.
  2. Or in the Settings block, Click on Edit Settings.

  1. Scroll down to the Assessment Settings section.
  2. In the Instructions for Assessment text field, Type the instructions the students will see before they assess.

Allocate Submissions

After students have submitted their work you will need to distribute the submissions to other students for the Assessment Phase.  On the Workshop Planner you will see the number of students in your class next to Expected.  As students submit their work, you will see the number of submissions next to Submitted.  You can also see a list of the submissions below the Workshop Planner.

Note: It is best to have an odd number of reviewers for the grade for assessment to be calculated.  Instructors assessments are counted, if the submissions have been allocated to the instructor.

There are several ways to access the Allocate Submissions screen.

  1. Click on the name of the workshop.
  2. On the Workshop Planner you will see a list of tasks to complete in the Submission Phase. Click the Allocate Submissions option.
  3. Or in the Settings block, Click on Allocate Submissions.

You can allocate the submissions manually or randomly.

Manual Allocation

In Manual Allocation you will match pairs of students to review each other’s submissions.  i.e., if you assign Mark to review Beth’s submission, Beth will be assigned to review Mark’s submission.  You can assign as many reviewers and reviewees as there are students in the class.

  1. Click on the Manual Allocation tab.

  1. In the Participant is Reviewed By column use the dropdown menu to designate who will review the submission of the person listed in the Participant column.

  1. Or in the Participant is Reviewer Of column use the dropdown menu to designate who will be reviewed by the person listed in the Participant column.

  1. You will get a confirmation screen showing the matched students with the most recent match highlighted.

  1. If this is not a good match you can Click the Red X to remove the allocation.
  1. You will see a highlighted message above the students’ names asking if you are sure you want to deallocate the selected assessment.  Click the Yes, I am Sure button to remove the allocation.

Note: You can also Click the Red X from the main list of students.

  1. Click the Show All Participants button to return to the list of students.

Note: It is possible to assign a submission to a student who has not submitted yet.  The confirmation screen and the list of participant indicates No submission found for this user.

  1. Repeat steps 2-5 until you have the correct number of reviewers and reviewees.

Note: Remember to check all your students using the Page and Next links at the top and bottom of the list.

Random Allocation

In Random Allocation option you select the number of reviews per student, determine if students without submissions can review and delete any manual allocations you may have indicated.

  1. Click on the Random Allocation tab

  1. If you are using Groups, the group mode will be displayed.
  2. In the first Number of Reviews dropdown menu, Select the number of reviews.
  3. In the second Number of Reviews dropdown menu, Select whether the number is per submission or per reviewer.
  1. Per Submission will make sure that each submission will receive the indicated number of reviews.  
  2. Per Reviewer will make sure that each reviewer receives the indicated number of submissions to review.  

Note: The following option is ONLY available if you have Visible Groups set for the workshop.  If you do not have groups, submissions are allocated across the whole class.  If you have Separate Groups, submissions are only allocated within the group.

  1. If you have Visible Groups, in the Prevent Reviews checkbox, you can check the box or leave it blank.
  1. Checking the Box will prevent allocations within the designated group.  Each student will review work from a different group.
  2. Leaving the Box Blank will allocate the submissions across the whole class.

  1. In the Remove Current Allocations checkbox, you can check the box or leave it blank.
  1. Checking the Box will delete any manual allocations.
  2. Leaving the Box Blank will leave any manual allocations in place.

Hot Tip: You can delete all the allocations, both manual and random, by Selecting 0 in the Number of Reviews dropdown menu and Checking the Remove Current Allocations checkbox.

  1. In the Participants Can Assess without Having Submitted Anything checkbox, you can check the box or leave it blank.
  1. Checking the Box will allow a student to review without having submitted work.
  2. Leaving the Box Blank will not allocate any submissions to a student who did not submit work.

Note: The following option is only available if you selected Students May Assess Their Own Work in the workshop settings.

  1. In the Add Self-Assessments checkbox, you can check the box or leave it blank.
  1. Checking the Box will allow a student to review his or her own work.
  2. Leaving the Box Blank will not allow a student to review his or her own work.

  1. Click the Save Changes button to allocate the submissions.
  2. You will see a screen with a summary of the random allocations, Scroll down to Click the Continue button.
  3. You will see the random allocation screen.  Click the Manual Allocation tab to see the allocated submissions.

Allocate Submission to Instructor or Grader

As this is a peer assessment tool, by default instructors do not show up in the list for allocating the submissions.  However, an instructor can be added as a peer reviewer.  The instructor’s review will be combined with the other reviews to calculate the student’s submission grade.  For more information on how grading works in the workshop see Workshop: Grading Evaluation Phase.

To add the instructor to the list of participants who can review submissions:

  1. Click on the name of the workshop.
  2. In the Settings block, Click on Permissions.

  1. In the Advanced role override dropdown menu, Select the Teacher role.  This change will affect all the individuals with the role of Teacher.

Note: You can select any of the roles listed, e.g., Teacher (Unlisted), Non-editing Teacher, etc.

  1. You will see a list of the Capabilities that the Teacher role is allowed.  Scroll down to Peer Assess (mod/workshop:peerassess).
  2. In the Permission column, Click the radio button above Allow

  1. Scroll to the bottom and Click the Save Changes button.
  2. All the individuals with that role will now appear in the Allocation of Submissions screen.  You will need to manually allocate the student submissions to the instructor to assess.  See the section above on Manual Allocation.

Set the Assessment to be Anonymous

To hide the names of the authors and the reviewers:

  1. Click on the name of the workshop.
  2. In the Settings block, Click on Permissions.
  3. In the Advanced role override dropdown menu, Select the Student role.  This change will affect all the individuals with the role of Student.

Note: By default students are enrolled in your course in the Student role.  If anyone has been added in the Student (Manual Enrollment) role, you will need to change the permissions for both roles.

  1. You will see a list of the Capabilities that the Student role is allowed.  Scroll down to View Author Names (mod/workshop:viewauthornames).
  2. In the Permission column, Click the radio button above Prevent.
  3. Scroll down to View Reviewer Names (mod/workshop:viewreviewernames).
  4. In the Permission column, Click the radio button above Prevent.

Note: The Prevent option will make the workshop anonymous.  Do not use the Prohibit option as it may have some unintended consequences.

  1. Scroll to the bottom and Click the Save Changes button.

Note: When students submit their work, Moodle ISU 2 will not show the name of the file.  When student submit their work, there is a Title field.  If a student uses his/her name in the Title field the reviewer will see the student’s name.  In addition, the assessment will not be anonymous if the student includes their name within the body or heading of the file.

Once all the students have submitted their work and you have allocated the submissions, you are ready to move to the Assessment Phase.

For information on the Assessment Phase see Workshop: The Assessment Phase.

For more Information please visit http://docs.moodle.org/22/en/Workshop_settings


This work was done by Instructional Technology Resource Center at Idaho State University and is licensed under the Creative Commons Unported License. To view a copy of this license, visit Attribution Noncommercial 3.0 United States or send a letter to Creative Commons, 444 Castro Street, Suite 900, Mountain View, California, 94041, USA.