Fair Housing Friday: How to Screen Clients the Right Way (Without Stepping on Legal Landmines)

Because “compliant today” beats “uh-oh tomorrow.”

What sparked today’s post

REBNY’s Fair Housing Friday bulletin—authored by Neil B. Garfinkel (REBNY Broker Counsel)—lays out practical, do‑this‑today guidance for screening prospective clients while staying squarely within fair housing laws. The banner on page 1 signals the theme; the core tips arrive on page 2; and the legal disclaimer and REBNY contact info sit on page 3.

Big idea (short version)

Use the same, standardized screening process for every prospect—every time—across phone, email, or in‑person—and avoid assumptions. Consistency protects consumers and your license.

The 4 Pillars of Compliant Early‑Stage Screening

1) Know the laws that apply to you

• Understand the federal, state, and local frameworks and all protected classes relevant to your market.
  
• In NYC, the Fair Chance for Fair Housing Act imposes specific procedures before you run a criminal background check. Don’t improvise—follow the rulebook.
  

2) Run a uniform screening process

• Use a written checklist or script so your questions and requests are the same for everyone, in sales and rentals.
  
• Document what you ask and what the prospect answers (consistency loves paper trails).
  

3) Avoid steering—full stop

• Let clients define their preferred areas; ask open, unbiased prompts like, “Which neighborhoods would you like to live in?”
  
• Don’t assume where a client might “feel comfortable.” Assumptions are not a business model.
  

4) Respect source‑of‑income protections

• Ask for all sources of income and make clear that all lawful sources (e.g., public assistance, vouchers, benefits) are welcome.
  
• If asked, affirm that you consider all lawful sources of income—because the law and ethics demand it.
  

Why this matters: Applying these practices consistently shows professionalism, aligns with industry best practices, and advances equal housing opportunity for all.

A Simple, Uniform Screening Script (Steal this, adapt it)

Use the same structure for every new inquiry—phone, email, or in person:

1. Basics & Timing
   

• “What’s your target move‑in date and lease term (or purchase timing)?”
  
• “Who will be living in the home?”
  

2. Budget & Capacity
   

• “What is your monthly housing budget (or price range)?”
  
• “What are your sources of income?” (All lawful sources are considered.)
  

3. Location—Your Choice
   

• “Which neighborhoods or areas are you interested in?” (List what they name; do not suggest based on assumptions.)
  

4. Home Requirements
   

• “How many bedrooms/bathrooms?”
  
• “Any accessibility needs or must‑have features?”
  
• “Any pets?”
  

5. Process & Next Steps
   

• “We follow a standard process for everyone. If a background check becomes relevant, we’ll follow all required procedures under local law.”
  

(Yes, it’s a lot to cover in the first two minutes. Breathe. A checklist turns chaos into calendar time.)

“Steering‑Proof” Phrasing You Can Rely On

• ✅ “Which neighborhoods would you like to live in?”
  
• ✅ “Here are options that match the criteria you gave me.”
  
• ❌ “You’d be more comfortable in…”
  
• ❌ “People like you usually prefer…”
  

These habits help you stay neutral, informed, and compliant—not to mention professionally elegant.

Income Conversations (Done Right)

• Ask: “What are all your income sources?”
  
• Clarify: “We consider all lawful sources of income, including vouchers and benefits.”
  
• If questioned: “Yes, we consider all lawful sources of income.”
  

That’s it. Clear, consistent, and compliant.

Quick‑Reference Checklist (Print & Pin)

• I used the same script I use for everyone
  
• I recorded the client’s own neighborhood choices
  
• I asked about all income sources and confirmed we accept all lawful ones
  
• I avoided assumptions and steering language
  
• If a background check is needed, I will follow the specific procedures required locally (e.g., NYC’s Fair Chance for Fair Housing Act)
  
• I documented all steps, questions, and responses
  

Text‑Based “Infographic”: Your First‑Contact Flow

Prospect reaches out

        │

        ▼

Use standardized screening script (same Qs every time)

        │

        ▼

Capture client-defined neighborhoods + home needs

        │

        ▼

Confirm: all lawful income sources considered

        │

        ▼

Share options that match THEIR criteria (no steering)

        │

        ▼

If background check becomes relevant:

→ Follow required local procedures (e.g., NYC Fair Chance for Fair Housing Act)

        │

        ▼

Document everything

(Not as pretty as a skyline banner, but extremely effective.)

Keep Learning & Stay Connected

• REBNY Fair Housing Resources: rebny.com
  
• Broker Counsel (REBNY): REBNYCounsel@rebny.com
  
• REBNY HQ: 570 Lexington Ave., New York, NY 10022; (212) 201‑1178
   These contacts and notices appear in the Fair Housing Friday communication.
  

Important note (legal)

This blog summarizes a REBNY educational email and is not legal advice. For questions about your specific situation, consult your own attorney (REBNY’s bulletin emphasizes this, too).

Final thought

Consistency is your compliance superpower. Build the script, use it every time, and document like a pro. Your future self—and your clients—will thank you.


—

Sydney Harewood is a real estate professional with a passion for NYC’s architectural gems. For inquiries, call or message Syd at 📞646-535-3819. Experience the finest in NYC real estate with Syd’s expert guidance and deep knowledge of the city’s most exquisite properties.

We hope you found this information helpful. If you have any other questions or need more details, feel free to contact us.