Cake Flavors

vanilla, chocolate, red velvet, lemon, pistachio, banana, almond, chocolate chip, coconut, funfetti, rainbow, cranberry carrot, marble, honey spice, pumpkin

Buttercream Frostings

vanilla, chocolate, cream cheese, espresso, cookies & cream, strawberry, peanut butter, passion fruit, salted caramel, maple, raspberry jam

Speciality Frostings

Available for an additional charge:

vanilla meringue buttercream, lemon curd, chocolate mousse, dulce de leche, cannoli cream, sliced strawberries, pistachio, hazelnut

Standard Cake Pricing

Mini cake

1–3 servings

$18

6-inch round

8 –10 servings

$36

8-inch round

12–15 servings

$44

10-inch round

18–25 servings

$60

12-inch round

30–35 servings

$105

3-layer, 1/4-sheet

25–30 servings

$75

2-layer, 1/2-sheet

30–40 servings

$125

3-layer, 1/2-sheet

50–65 servings

$185

All cakes are three layers unless otherwise noted.

Call for a quote for custom cakes and decorations.

Our Favorite Cakes


Please inquire for pricing.

Classic Birthday

vanilla cake, buttercream, and raspberry jam

Double Chocolate

chocolate cake, chocolate buttercream

Red Velvet

cream cheese frosting, chocolate piping

Ultimate Birthday Cake

funfetti cake, chocolate mousse, meringue buttercream, ganache drip

Black & White

vanilla and chocolate cake and buttercream

Vegan Birthday Cakes

vanilla, chocolate or red velvet

Gluten-Free Cake

choose from any of our cake flavors

Cookie Cake

salted nutella, chocolate chunk, or sprinkle

Honey Spice

maple buttercream, toasted pecans

Raspberry Chocolate Mousse

chocolate cake and mousse, raspberry buttercream

Rocher Cake

chocolate cake, hazelnut filling, ganache drip

Cookie Butter Cake

cinnamon & nutmeg cake, vanilla buttercream, cookie butter, cookie crumbles

Pumpkin Lover’s

pumpkin spice cake, cream cheese frosting

Rainbow Cake

five layers of rainbow cake, vanilla buttercream

The Wedding Slice

almond cake, vanilla Swiss buttercream, raspberry jam, lemon curd

Sweets and Minis

Standard Cupcakes and Cookies

$2.75 each / $30 per dozen

Mini Cupcakes and Cookies

$15 per dozen

French Macarons , Cake Pops, Whoopies, Cream Pies, Bars, and Tarts

$21-$36 per dozen

Bake-at-Home Cookies

Choose from salted nutella, chocolate chunk, or sprinkle

$10 per cookie dough pint

Cookie and Bar Platters

small (10-15 servings) $75 / large (20-25 servings) $110

Cake Push-Up Pops and Cake-in-a-Jar  
$48-$54 per dozen

Ordering Information

To place an order, call (347) 987 3941 or

 stop into the shop.

Custom cakes require at least 72-hours notice.

A 50% deposit is required to secure your order.

Daily cake specials available for pick-up.

260 5th Avenue, Brooklyn, NY | Monday – Saturday 11am to 8 pm, Sunday 11am to 7 pm | phone (347) 987 3941 |  www.buttermilkbakeshop.com | info@buttermilkbakeshop.com