National Briefing Paper – Revised Thermal Power Plant emission control norms

Background

When the MoEF notified the revised standards for coal-based Thermal Power Plants (TPPs) on December 7th, 2015, the aim was to drastically cut their harmful SO2, NOx, PM10 and Mercury emissions. This was an obvious and an emergency response to the findings that:

  1. An overwhelming majority of Indian TPPs use coal with high ash content (which varies from 35-45% per unit volume[1], as compared to ~15% in good quality coal used in some other countries). This not only reduces its calorific value (heating capacity), but also results in more particulate matter emissions when burned.

  1. Air quality has deteriorated severely in several Indian cities in recent years due to unchecked emissions from power plants, industrial clusters, vehicular exhaust and crop burning. In fact, 10 of the 20 most polluted cities in the world are in India[2], and as per the medical journal The Lancet, this is killing as many as 18 lakh (1.8 million) men, women and children each year through lung cancer, strokes, chronic respiratory disorders and heart disease[3]. In fact, this year’s smog in Delhi made the city’s air 10X more hazardous than the air in Beijing[4].  

  1. TPPs are responsible for as much as 80% of all industrial emissions of PM10, SO2 and NOx and Mercury in India[5].

The stringent new norms, if implemented by December 7th, 2017 (as had been notified by MoEF), would cut these TPP emissions by as much as 70-85%[6]. However, today is the last day of the two year deadline, and unsurprisingly, the power plants have done precious little to check their emissions.

What TPPs had to do

  1. Install Electrostatic Precipitators (ESPs) to trap particulate matter from the exhaust: Most TPPs in India have installed the technology, but they need to be upgraded to perform to the new standards prescribed.
  2. Install Flue Gas Desulphurization (FGD) technologies to minimise the emission of SO2 and Mercury: A majority of TPPs are still studying the feasibility of the technology.
  3. Modify burner designs for low NOx emissions, and/or install Selective Catalytic Converter (SCR) technology and Selective Non-Catalytic Converter (SNCR) technology[7].

Status: RTI responses

According to the MoEF, all thermal plants need to install the below three technologies before Dec 7, 2017. Out of the 90 power plants that we asked information through RTIs, we got responses only from 17 thermal power plants. Most of these plants have technologies in place for particulate matter, but almost none of them are ready to control sulphur dioxide and nitrogen oxide emissions. The RTI responses show that it will still take several years for TPPs to get compliance in place.

State + number of power plants

Installation of Electrostatic Precipitators (ESPs) for particulate matter

Installation of Flue Gas Desulphurization (FGD) for SOx emissions

Modification of burner designs for low NOx emissions

Timeline for compliance

Notes

Rajasthan - 2 plants

Yes

No

No

None provided

Correspondence is in progress for FGD installation

Tamil Nadu -  1 Plant

Yes

No

Yes

None provided

Maharashtra - 4 plants

Yes

No

No

1 plant mentioned 4-6 years

In the planning phase/conducting feasibility studies for FGD installation

West Bengal - 2 plants

Yes

No

No

1 plant mentioned 3 years

In the initial phase of consideration for FGD installation for 1 plant.
Purchase orders have been placed for NOx emission control for 1 plant.

Haryana - 3 plants

Yes

No

No

None provided

Under process for FGD installation for 1 plant

Karnataka - 1 plant

Yes

No

No

None provided

Feasibility studies underway for FGD installation

Madhya Pradesh - 4 plants

Yes

No

No

March 2021

ESP not installed for all units in any of the plants.

Feasibility studies planned for FGD installation.

The excuses

Since coal still accounts for almost 60% of India’s power generation[8], TPPs love to use the statistic to justify not just their existence, but also their lack of inaction. For instance, the National Thermal Power Corporation (NTPC) has clearly stated that its TPPs - together worth 161GW - cannot be shut down to install FGDs and Catalytic Converters, because that would “plunge the country into darkness”[9].

Well, didn’t it occur to them 2 years ago to shut down one unit of one plant at a time to carry out the retrofitting? Wasn’t that the logical course of action? Or were they deliberately waiting for the deadline to expire, knowing that they would later cry foul and wiggle out of the mess?

The TPPs say the cost of the retrofitting will be close to $38bn[10], and to recover the expense, they will be forced to increase power tariffs. They are therefore asking the government to fund the retrofitting. However, the Centre for Science and Environment (New Delhi) has calculated that the retrofitting can be carried out at less than 3% annual increase to the power tariff for the next three years[11]. Clearly then, inflated power tariffs are not as big of an issue as they are being made out to be.

Interestingly enough, NTPC is now worried that it will be unable to raise international funding for its operations if it fails to comply with the new norms, since international funding is tied to meeting environmental standards10. It is indeed sad that NTPC – a Maharatna company – is more worried about wooing international funding than the consequences of its plants spewing out toxic amounts of pollutants. It’s basically saying that the health of Indians is immaterial, even though it tries to fake concern for them by warning against an increase in power tariffs.

Surprisingly, only Adani Power – a major private player - had agreed to comply with the retrofitting schedule. Unfortunately, together with NTPC, GMR and Reliance Power, it is now lobbying the government to extend the deadline by as many as four-six years.

What needs to be done

Very simply - the polluters need to pay. Not just for the amount of pollutants they dump into the air, but also for their deliberate delay in acting on the new emission control norms. The government needs to understand that it must not relax its stand on the new norms - even though an extension to the deadline is now imminent – and heavily penalise all non-compliant TPPs till they fall in line.  

Doing so will send a clear message that while we do depend on TPPs for a majority of our power needs, they cannot and will not be allowed to use that as an excuse for not taking their power plants offline temporarily to comply with the new emission norms.

About Jhatkaa.org:

Jhatkaa.org is a campaigning organisation committed to building grassroots citizen power across India in effective and innovative ways. Jhatkaa.org helps people take action collectively on issues that interest or affect them, and create change that would not be possible if they acted alone.

Jhatkaa.org also collaborates with civil society to engage citizens to hold corporate, cultural and government leaders accountable in real time at key decision moments through various digital communication platforms. Read more about Jhatkaa.org’s victories and press hits.

For more information, please contact:

Divya Narayanan

+91-9884521072

Noah D’Mello

+91-9902395785


[1] http://www.frontline.in/static/html/fl2522/stories/20081107252205000.htm

[2] https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/life-style/health-fitness/health-news/10-of-worlds-20-most-polluted-cities-in-india-list-inside/articleshow/52249911.cms

[3] http://www.thehindu.com/sci-tech/energy-and-environment/india-ranked-no-1-in-pollution-related-deaths-report/article19887858.ece

[4] https://www.cbsnews.com/news/delhi-smog-chokes-india-capital-air-pollution-10-times-worse-beijing/

[5] https://thewire.in/162256/power-coal-emissions-technology/

[6] http://www.dailypioneer.com/city/thermal-power-main-contributor-to-industrial-emissions-cse.html

[7] http://www.cseindia.org/userfiles/BAT-report-power-plants.pdf

[8] http://powermin.nic.in/en/content/power-sector-glance-all-india

[9] https://www.bloombergquint.com/business/2017/11/26/indias-coal-fired-power-units-will-continue-spewing-toxic-fumes-for-longer

[10] https://in.reuters.com/article/us-india-power/indian-coal-utilities-seek-state-funds-or-tariff-hike-to-cut-emissions-idINKBN1AD062

[11] https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/industry/energy/power/why-coal-plants-will-continue-to-spit-fire/articleshow/61683724.cms