previous notes (2020-2022) click here
Quick Links
2023 Notes
2024 Notes
Acknowledgements:
We acknowledge the following to ensure that coming into this room we are all informed of what guides our practice in this space and we encourage that these acknowledgements are carried out with our comments, affirmations and considerations in this space. We also encourage that the acknowledgments and practice we carry out here you will take with you in all the spaces and places you are in.
- Land acknowledgement: We acknowledge the land that we seek to remediate is on the sovereign land of the Unkechaug Nation. We acknowledge that the land that we occupy in the way that we occupy is based on a system of genocide. That colonialism is violent and it continues today. We must not only acknowledge the violence we must stand together to struggle against it with the guidance from the Indigenous people and demand Brookhaven Town consult with the Unkechaug Nation on the way forward to remediate the landfill. We acknowledge #landback initiatives! native-land.ca. please acknowledge the ancestral land you are currently on.
- Black Lives Matter & Honoring George Floyd acknowledgement The Brookhaven Landfill Action and Remediation Group was formed in support of and a part of a direct action plan to protect Black lives of the people in North Bellport after the murder of George Floyd. George Floyd was not a martyr for our cause. George Floyd deserved to live. We honor his life through this work. His death reminds us that if we do not fight to protect black lives, black lives will continue to be disregarded and prematurely ended through state sanctioned violence. We acknowledge that Black Lives Matter!
- North Bellport acknowledgement: We acknowledge that the community of North Bellport is one of the fenceline communities to the Brookhaven landfill. North Bellport is a diverse community with a large Black, Indigenous and Latinx presence. The North Bellport community shoulders disproportionate harm as opposed to other neighboring communities. Therefore, this group must center the needs of North Bellport community members in this struggle to close down, clean up and stop the transfer of waste to another community.
- Environmental Justice: 17 Principles of Environmental Justice established October 24-27, 1991. We acknowledge these 17 principles as a way to guide our work. Environmental justice = BLM
- Environmental Racism: The father of the term environmental justice, Dr. Robert Bullard, referred to the Brookhaven Landfill as “a textbook case of environmental racism.” We also have referred to the Brookhaven landfill as a “monument to racism on Long Island” ~ Abena Asare. Hannah Thomas refers to the issues of the landfill as a “design of White supremacy.”
- Pronouns acknowledgment: why pronouns? “…we ask cisgender people to lead the change by sharing pronouns. It normalizes the process, has little risk, and actually makes for a safer environment for everyone.”
- Rest: Last week of each month
__________________________________________________________
2023 Notes
__________________________________________________________
1/13/23 Agenda
Housekeeping
- Host: LIPC
- Facilitator: Monique
- CoFacilitator/Chat Monitor/Timekeeper: Vanessa A. / Khadija
- Notetaker 1: Abena
Acknowledgments & Housekeeping: (10 min 5:15 pm)
Check in/in the chat: in a word or short phrase how has 2023 come in for you?: (5 min 5:20 pm)
Tie up loose ends: (20 min 5:40 pm)
- GNI (Good Neighbors Initiative) $5000 grant money spending
- Fiscal sponsor: Long Island Progressive Coalition $500
- Centering needs of North Bellport community: Scholarship/ambassador $500
- Abena: A person was chosen. Anyone know what our plan is now?
- Dennis: We’re still deciding how the person will present to the group
- Mo: There is an effort to collect more $$ to give to the students who applied for the North Bellport Strong award. If you want to give to that effort, Christina is collecting money at her cashapp.
- Community website manager: $500
- Abena: We are looking for people to join a website team to help develop now until March. Erica Cirino may be helpful as she has a lot of website experience.
- Mo: We are going to fundraise to extend the capacity of the website manager.
- Where we are: The op-ed is ready it just has to be sent to Newsday or other media outlets.
- Wins losses from the 2022 legislative session
- Montaukett recognition bill
- Unmarked burial graves protection
- Carpet advance recycling
- Cumulative impacts
- Any others?
Moe: Gov. Hochul continues to be terrible for indigenous folks.
Ryan: The Montaukett Nation wasn’t very disheartened with the Gov. Hochul’s veto. In fact immediately after Hochul vetoed it, she scheduled a meeting with the nation. The nation is actually looking forward to the increased energy around government to government relations that has emerged. Similarly with unmarked burials bills, the folks from Shinnecock etc. are working effectively on next steps.
Moe: I’m looking for the cumulative impacts bill being useful in the ongoing efforts.
John: Is there more details on the unmarked grave bills?
Ryan: Actually the bill was vetoed. My understanding was that Hochul, with her ties to real estate developers, they tried to insert a clause that if remains were found, the property owner after a particular short time, would have the power to do what they want with the remains. Chief Harry Wallace could not accept such a clause.
John: Is there a possibility of transferring the remains?
Moe: NY State is one of the few states that doesn’t have a law like this protecting unmarked burials. Black and Indigenous people have been oppressed, and people’s remains have been treated disrespectfully and so the effort is to try to address this larger history.
Mike Ewall: The language in the cumulative impacts law might be helpful in getting DEC to deny renewal permits... see last part about "no permit may be approved or renewed...."
https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/bills/2021/S8830
Section 7 of the bill adds a new section 70-0118 to the environmental conservation law adding definitions for "disadvantaged communities" and "existing burden report;" requiring the department of environmental conservation to prepare or cause to be prepared an existing burden report for major projects that may cause or contribute to, either directly or indirectly, a disproportionate or inequitable or both disproportionate and inequitable pollution burden on a disadvantaged community; and providing that no permit may be approved or renewed by the department if it may cause or contribute to, either directly or indirectly, a disproportionate or inequitable or both disproportionate and inequitable pollution burden on a disadvantaged community.
Where do we go from here: (15 min 5:55 pm)
- Give three top priorities in the chat
- 1- being sure the ash landfill really gets closed
- 2 - exploring and promoting waste disposal options
- 3- resuming composting project and the community garden
- 4- supporting other groups in their environmental justice efforts such as the indigenous nations efforts to protect their burial grounds
- Building up grassroots resistance around all four trash incinerators on Long Island to get them closed.
- 1. What is the extent of the water pollution at the Brookhaven Town Landfill and what is the plan for the remediation of the plume?
- 2. What is the plan in place after the closing of the Brookhaven Town Landfill?
- 3. How can we curb single use plastics?
- 4. What type of reparations can we put in place for the North Bellport community to make up for the burden that community has had to carry as a result of the Brookhaven Town Landfill?
- Determine how the final CLCPA Scoping Plan can now be applied to the Brookhaven Landfill
- Determine how Hochul’s PFAS announcement in the SoS can be applied to the Brookhaven Landfill
- Continue to illustrate BLARG priorities as the nexus of EJ priorities on Long Island, while connecting to other struggles
- Raising public awareness of the benefits of reducing waste, reusing, and properly recycling (as well as a host of other issues)
- 1. Strengthen statewide connections
- 2. BLARG goes to Albany to meet with Hochul, Basil, Tish James others
- 3. write resolutions for town and county
- 1) having local gov’t and polluters admit they are causing injustice and pollution in North Bellport,
- 2) continue expanding community-led zero-waste systems/projects in North Bellport and on Long Island (and beyond),
- 3) establishing legal protections in North Bellport that kick polluters out, and put people first, and provide clear plans and funds for remediation and reparations for harm done.
- I’d like to become better acquainted with the community most impacted by the landfill. I’d like also to learn how to write grant proposals. I have a question re conversation I overheard a part of: Are remains being discovered that are in danger of removal from sacred spaces? I’d live more publicity about the landfill to be disseminated broadly, across the island and in the country. Perhaps we could emphasize the environmental damage to surrounding areas.
- The quality of air and water in our communities.
- Coalition-building with similar frontline communities across the state to strengthen state strategy
- Exploring setting up meetings with Brookhaven Town officials
Community Announcements
- Jennifer Vorbach: I am an active canvasser and big believer in environmental justice. I’ve been supporting Lisa Di Santo. A lot of people are aware of this election but it still will be a low turnout vote because the Town has been sure to not promote it, which is next Tuesday. Lisa has committed to being an open FOIL officer and scheduling meetings in a way that are more accessible. I am asking you all consider voting for her.
- Monique. BLARG does not endorse candidates. We do allow for folks to share the information on candidates and elections and it will be for folks here to decide what to do with the information.
Action: (4 min 5:59 pm)
- Mike: I’ve reached out to Seneca Guardians asking them to pull this until we can get more consensus on addressing the issues of landfill versus incineration. NYS is the largest exporter of waste already and if incinerators close in the next 10 years and we don’t have other things in place while we are also closing all landfills, we’re setting ourselves up to exporting even more of our waste, most likely to Pennsylvania
- Monique: I thought it addressed some zero waste stuff but I need to look again. We can all get on a call to try to work this out more.
- Kerim: I haven’t read the whole letter but parts of it did make me think because we know with Brookhaven - the landfill is supposed to be closing and right across the street we’re preparing to build the state’s largest waste transfer station
Closing: (1 min 6:00 pm)
“Agitate, agitate, agitate” ~Frederick Douglass
1/20/2023 Agenda
Housekeeping
- Host: LIPC
- Facilitator: Monique
- CoFacilitator/Chat Monitor/Timekeeper: Vanessa is timekeeper
- Notetaker 1: Jennifer
Acknowledgments & Housekeeping: (10 min 5:15 pm)
Check in/in the chat: share your fav podcast, book, song, tv show or movie: (5 min 5:20 pm)
Fiscal sponsorship Report Back (Abena): (20 min 5:40 pm)
- Presentation - Creating a Fiscal Relationship between Energy Justice Network and BLARG [LINK HERE?]
- Discussion -
- Joel D: his org (Multicultural Solidarity) had a fiscal sponsor until it became 501(c)(3), “I believe there is also a restriction for promoting a candidate on social media even when $$ isn’t involved. School bd candidates are not covered by this though.”
- John McN: Would our partnership affect our ability to initiate a lawsuit? Mike E knows it’s possible based on another org they sponsor
- Kerim O: What are other groups currently fiscally sponsored by EJN? Westchester Alliance for Sustainabile Solutions; Clean Air Action Network for some grants; others in other states (like Hawaii, NJ, CT)
- John McN: it’s good to work with other compatible orgs Abena: Yes, Mike E of EJN has been involved with BLARG for years
- Straw poll of attendees in chat showed that many do support exploring this relationship; one commenter wrote “Unsure. My concerns are about this limiting our power to publicly go after Romaine and co, and advocate for zero waste policy.”
Strategy meeting: (20 min 6:05pm)
- Date - looking at another meeting possibly in February
- Time - tbd
- Location - S Country Library in Bellport Village
- Who can/wants to come? Matthew S, Bob B, John McN, Lynne, Barbara, Erica C, Khadija, Jennifer
- Review from last weeks priorities (thank you, Laura L, LINK HERE?)
- Being sure the ash landfill really gets closed
- Exploring and promoting waste disposal options
- Monique met today with Rhonda Keyser of Cafeteria Culture & Matt & Mary Arnold about upcoming plastic waste advocacy days
- Resuming composting project and the community garden
- We’re continuing to get food scraps from Eastern Farm Workers, Monique seeks volunteers to chop them up at garden this weekend
- Supporting other groups in their environmental justice efforts such as the indigenous nations efforts to protect their burial grounds
- Mike Ewall: Building up grassroots resistance around all four trash incinerators on Long Island to get them closed. Monique thinks we all need to be in a room together (various groups).
- Incinerator in Wyandanch is said to be closing in 2027. Mike E would like more details. Monique got that info from a Longwood Library-hosted webinar, she will find & forward to Mike. EJN could use BLARG’s help in connecting with the communities surrounding the incinerators. Mo gave a speech last week in Wyandanch, brought up the incinerator.
- About CLCPA and how it applies to Brookhaven Landfill—Monique didn’t see much about how we can close the landfill. There was info about composting, getting food scraps out of the wastestream to prevent methane. Mike E (in chat): CLCPA has a lot of language that supports keeping incinerators open and sees them as less of a climate problem than landfills (which isn't true... incinerators are twice as bad as landfills for the climate).
- Along with strengthening our connections, maybe we need to take our fight out of town & on the road
Announcements: (2 min 6:07 pm)
- OpEd out the door… (on the Town budget for 2023, which said they would close the landfill to C&D in 2024, which is NOT full closure…Newsday said they loved it)
- GNI funds out the door… (we awarded a $500 stipend for N. Bellport student, and checks to website designer & website manager)
- Compost help!
Actions: (13 min 6:20 pm)
Closing: (2 min 6:22 pm)
“We must rapidly begin the shift from a “thing-oriented” society to a “person-oriented society. When machines and computers, profit motives and property rights are considered more than people the giant triplets of racism, militarism and materialism are incapable of being conquered.”
2/3/2023 Agenda
Housekeeping
- Host: LIPC
- Facilitator: Monique
- CoFacilitator/Chat Monitor/Timekeeper:
- Notetaker 1:
Special acknowledgments
Acknowledgments & Housekeeping: (10 min 5:15 pm)
Nicholas St. Fleur: STAT looking to tell more stories about health disparities and environmental justice. Want to do more local stories.
Check in/in the chat: name, pronouns, land acknowledgement (native-land.ca), name of the orgs you rep (5 min 5:20 pm)
JD Allen WSHU: (20 min 5:40 pm)
- 1057 grew up in Huntington and in Riverhead and is looking to buy a house in Brookhaven. Newsroom embedded on Stony Brook University campus. I have been trying and wanting to do something in depth about the Brookhaven Landfill
- 2019 back to WSHU one of the first people I talked to was Dennis. It has been my guilty conscious not to be able to do stories
- Helped Kerim on the side with FOIL requests and some of my students helped with some things with the landfill.
- Erica is on the call of another great journalist that has written on the landfill.
- Finally found and created a great team to do a story on the landfill. Combined with national and solutions journalism and graduate journalism students working on something by this summer. Looking to stick dynamite in this conversation.
- I consider myself in the know and there is so much disinformation
- I will need your help. We will try to jump on these calls and dig in the details and meet with some of you
- Dennis: What happened? I feel like we developed a great relationship.
- JD Allen: There wasn't much I could find that didn't require rigorous FOILs. I was new at the job. The job moved on and so I had to move on as well
- Dennis: I dont hate you and hopefully you're back and hopefully we can work towards fighting this issue.
- Abena: I am glad about the energy and there are resource and time for it. Dennis is one of the first people who talked about the landfill that opened my eyes. We do this work with the attention of the real human needs. It is great as a teaching moment that folks can keep in touch. There are so many people in Brookhaven hamlet and north bellport. I did all of this in the 80s. People come in and say they are going to help and then we don't get anywhere. It adds to the distrust and inertia.
- JD Allen: I agree with you and got into journalism in a backward way and never really liked the way my field was going. I cannot stand that hit and run style of journalilsm. I am hoping to change that. Also relationships with institutions and looking to buy a house in Brookhaven so theres no running away. WSHU and Stonybrook institutions
- Mr. McNamara: Thank you JD for your honesty and Dennis for your forgiveness
- Bob: I am excited to see WSHU usually tuned into 91.1. Its a wonderful station and potential for a real impact.
- Erica: journalism can be a tool of amplification. I have hope for the new
- Monique: feel in good company
- Katy: what kind of story
- Audio, video trying to put out a series this summer. Hopefully that is the dynamite that gets coverage.
- Bill: I saw the article about the landfill. It was good
- Ryan: Ed Romaine being obstructionist what could you share about your approach with that?
- Part is journalism ethics. There is a lot of pressure a media outlet can put for information. I am seeing a way that…it has different names “a long the way” reporting in piecemeal fashion. There is only so much a pressure a govt can have without havig their voice heard
Bellport Village Environmentalism show (Maya Schindler) (5 min 5:45 pm)
- Brookhaven historic society has an exhibition space (big barn) and are doing a historical show/installation about environmentalism and would like to include BLARG. It will be
- about the stories of the different environmental organizations/movements. There is a forward for the show and they want to make everyone aware of BLARG. Wondering if we want to participate. Without BLARG there will be zero talk of environmental racism. They want a visual (we could use signs, maps, etc.). Need to decide right away because it’s going up in two weeks–mid February.
- Monique: We could bring the conversation offline.
- Maya: Doesn’t mind doing the work, but is curious/concerned about the context. Is this something we would want to participate in.
- We will take this offline.
Information about the exhibit from Tricia Foley
Bellport and Brookhaven Hamlet have a long history of environmental activism, beginning with the Brookhaven Village Association founded in 1906, and the Bellport Village Improvement Society of the 1900. With Birdsall Otis Edey’s work on keeping the highway north of South Country Road, thereby saving the character of Bellport Village, her forward thinking has made a difference in the quality of life in Bellport.
Maurice Wertheim took his love of fishing and his hunting lodge called “Stealaway” located in Southaven, to amass land along the scenic Carmans River. He donated it to the US Government as a gift to the American people in 1947, now The Wertheim National Refuge.
Naturalist Dennis Puleston’s illustrations of the fish and fowl of the south shore and his passion for the endangered ospreys due to the DDT crisis were instrumental in the founding of the Environmental Defense Fund in 1967. Art Cooley, another founding member of EDF, gathered local support and founded Students for Environmental Quality at Bellport High School in the 1970’s. Many SEQ students went on to careers in the environmental and sciences and the law.
The Post-Morrow Foundation, dedicated to keeping the rural countryside safe from suburban encroachment, has preserved the woodlands, meadows, and marshland in our area, enjoyed by all its residents. Elisabeth Post-Morrow and Thomas Morrow left their legacy in the capable hands of President Bruce Wallace and Vice President Tom Williams who continue this mission.
In 2015, Katia Read and Thomas Schultz founded Friends of Bellport Bay
to save the oyster population and the water quality of the bays.
CEED, Center for Environmental Education and Discovery, on South Country Road in Brookhaven Hamlet is dedicated to connecting with nature and nurturing families with their focus on conservation and community.
The farmland preservation movement has saved land from suburban development and graced us with three working farms, due to the efforts of Sean Pilger and the team of HOG farm, Isabella Rossellini and Elettra Wiedemann and Patty Gentry of Mama Farm/Early Girl Farm, and Deer Run Farms, operated by five generations of the Nolan family farm since 1898.
These are the people, who for over a hundred years, have had the vision and have worked hard to save the environment, protect our waterfront, and preserve the rural quality of life that we enjoy today in the Bellport-Brookhaven-East Patchogue area.
Actions: (20 min 6:12 pm)
- Town of Brookhaven board meeting Action (Jennifer Greene) (5 min 5:50 pm)
- Jennifer: Joined Lisa at board meeting last weekend to speak. Brought up environmental racism and the landfill and invited people to join our meetings. Also attended the South Country Unites meeting and talked to Ryan McGarry (Suffolk Leg candidate) about BLARG.
- Monique: always feel free to take action where you see it, where you can. Don’t need to wait for any approval! Attending town halls is always helpful; appreciates Lisa and Jennifer for taking that initiative.
- Monique: Printed out copies of OpEd with info on the back to hand out to, asking people to attend the next town board action. Next meeting is Thursday 2/16 at 2pm; please join. Bill would like to join.
- Joel/Jim Banks: (15 min 6:05 pm)
- Brookhaven town is the only town without an anti-bias task force with representatives from each of the coalition organizations, which he proposes BLARG could be a part of.
- Jim Banks: has been disbanded without any stated rationale. Adamant about the need for a task force in Brookhaven town and each time that disband it makes him agree that we can create a task force without being sanctioned by the town. We are the people. We need a coalition. Hope to bring along associates from other organizations (NAACP, Multicultural Society and more) so we can combine our efforts and stop operating in silos.
- Abena: so grateful for you; when you were the head of the anti-bias task force, the town was trying to push through the ashfill and your organization sent a letter against the ashfill expansion and that strongly worded excellent letter made a difference in our outreach and the outcome of the ashfill. Not surprised that afterwards you got disbanded. Actually the task force does still exist but with right wing people on it. Yes, it’s time for a people’s task force that can’t be sent away when the town wants!
- Kerim: that letter was fire! It really made other state agencies take us more seriously. The new chair was also running the redistricting of the town of Brookhaven. Interesting who ended up being placed in afterwards, g.o.p puppets.
- Jim Banks: Sure this was part of why they got disbanded.
- John McNamara: Are meetings open or closed to the public?
- Jim Banks: Open
- John: this might be a place to be heard
- Jim: Hard to find out when they are happening. So much so that he wasn’t even sure they were still having them until he heard from Abena
- Joel: wonders if people have questions. What is involved for blarg, who to approach next, etc. Would like to see a press conference. Could be timed with JD Allen’s work.
- BLARG Website: (2 min 6:07 pm)
- Maya: team is great. Amanda and Erica are great. Dream team!
Closing: Cop City 4:35-6:48; :44-1:30 (3 min 6:15 pm)
- Police, whomever is on the force, is set up to terrorize Black people. Places like “Cop City” are urban warfare training facilities designed to embolden cops and reproduce more and more violence against Black people.
2/10/2023 Agenda
Housekeeping
- Host: LIPC
- Facilitator: Monique
- CoFacilitator/Chat Monitor/Timekeeper: Jennifer chat monitor
- Notetaker 1: Katy
Acknowledgments & Housekeeping: (10 min 5:15 pm)
Check ins Live:
Updates:
- Town of Brookhaven 2/16/2023 2 pm at the Town Hall
- Lisa Sevimli wants us to help champion our message about closing the landfill in a way that is accessible during the public comment period
- Bill, Monique, Katy, Dennis, Hannah, and Joel will join
- J.D. Allen will be there with microphones in hand
- The People’s Brookhaven Anti Bias Task Force update
- A group is following up with Joel and Mr. Banks. Still deciding on a date and time.
- SCSD - IDA update and discussion
- Kerim went to the school board meeting about the budget
- Abena: South Country School Board discussing issues with the budget. The question was raised about whether they would want to be more active in pushing back on the IDA tendency to give huge tax breaks to the businesses that bring in warehouses of waste and the diesel trucks that come with them. First the board claimed to be uninformed and that this brings in more cash because they bring in fees–fees that are paid in lieu of taxes! They were adamant that it’s “not their lane” and that they don’t plan to get any more active on this issue. A statewide organization has just offered a report and press release about this issue, that school boards across the state are being robbed by these IDA and that there is a new bill trying to remove school taxes from the realm of IDAs. The way the bill is written says that they could waive other taxes, but not school taxes. Emailed the org that did that report and had the chance to talk to them. Some other BLARG members were at that meeting, including Jennifer.
- Jennifer: Greg offered organizing strategies
- Abena: there is a statewide effort around this issue and the South Country District is in the top 10% of districts losing money from this system. His takeaway is that we are a good test case to organize around this issue. They offered to share their resources, statistics, and ways to organize around this particular issue. One idea was to have an offshoot group from BLARG that specifically goes hard on this IDA school tax issue. They would want to work with that group, offer support, offer a spotlight.
- John: thinking about the bill: that school taxes are much higher in LI than in other parts of the state, might discourage businesses from coming here.
- Abena: statistics suggest that this is unlikely. They are companies that can certainly afford it. What this change would allow is more leverage from the affected areas to get the business here. For example, with the warehouses we are giving away our leverage to bargain for electric vehicles, etc.
- John: makes sense that the IDA should be in partnership with the communities
- Jen: Brookhaven IDA has a myths vs. facts sheet on their website which is misleading. Refer to a clawback, so we should hold them accountable on that
- Vanessa: Maybe we could get Good Jobs First back on a call.
- Abena: good idea! They said they would like to do that.
- Vanessa will follow up with them
- Michelle: wrote to the IDA but has not heard back. Someone on the phone assured her that there are not any projects pending in Suffolk.
- North Bellport Strong share
- Students were contacted and notified
- Two students shared written work and one shared a video
- Dennis: appreciates how Jesse hit all of the points–family, community
- Khadija: They were all great and we should applaud them all. Jesse had a really strong focus on North Bellport!
Actions:
- A few petitions we can sign about decarcerating Atlanta and putting pressure on corporations to pull their support from Cop City
- Mike: seemed cool with the suggested changes, but want to get rid of all ten points about what to demand. They took out the most pointed stuff and left in the more problematic parts. Wouldn’t suggest we sign on yet.
- We will hold off and talk about this more
2/17/2023 Agenda
Housekeeping:
- Host: LIPC
- Facilitator:
- CoFacilitator Chat Monitor/Timekeeper:
- Notetaker 1:
- Notetaker 2:
- Participation on zoom - chat, stack, raise hand
- Participation off zoom landfillaction631@gmail.com, FB, IG, website soon come!
Acknowledgements & Housekeeping: (5 min 5:10 pm)
Check Ins:
Black History month presentation: (Monique) (5 min 5:15 pm)
Updates: (30 min 5:45 pm)
- Report back from Brookhaven Town Hall meeting action (Hannah, Monique, Bill, Jennifer, Joel, Christine, John, Dennis, Katy, Barbara…)
- Rose, Bud, Thorn is a debrief framework to discuss
- what went well for an event (Rose);
- what could be improved upon (Bud);
- what did not go well/should not be repeated (Thorn)
- letters from children to the town board
- More town board comments
- Protest in North Bellport
- How can we use media to pressure Suffolk or the county?
- Covanta updates:
- Any IDA report backs:
Action: (15 min 6:00 pm)
- Composting anyone? Possibly Sunday EFWA has a load…
- Join the website team. We are planning to meet on Monday at 7 pm
- Our BLARG 2023 strategy & priorities
- Saturday, February 25th at 11-1pm come early for fellowship and give time to come into the room (Abena)
- DEADLINE 2/28: Arch Community Fund
- DEADLINE 3/1: Unitarian Universalists Fund for a Just Society
- From Michelle: Just came across this resource lately: https://talzli.org/ TALZ – Taking A Lead on Zero Waste Zeroing in on Waste Reduction to Implement a Long Island Regional Zero Waste Plan
- What actions are you supporting these next two weeks
Notes:
BLARG WEEKLY MEETING NOTES 2023 Bob is taking notes-February 16, 2023
Monique gave a presentation on Black History and the origin of the environmental justice movement, very excellent. There are 17 principles first set forth in 1991.
Next was the latest Town Hall meeting yesterday. Many BLARG members gave statements.
A discussion took place on next steps. The suggestion was made to bring children at future Town meetings.
Another suggestion was that we distribute the recording of the Town Hall meeting to other groups.
Several journalists have become involved with the landfill issue.
Help Suffolk is an agency dealing with the shelter.
Bill Kokell recounted his experiences in service during the Korean conflict and the fact that there was much racism in the service at the time.
Further discussions took place on next steps.
Someone talked about the shelter. That person stated that Andrew Cuomo was involved when Help Suffolk was started.
Dennis-thanks to everyone for all the statements made at the Town Hall meeting yesterday.
Barbara-Thought all speakers were terrific yesterday. Barbara made the suggestion to pre-read one’s comments before the presentation and shorten it, if necessary.
Jennifer-public comment portion was extended yesterday.
Lisa- The notion of “circular economy” is good and could be used repeatedly.
Hannah-we need to have another protest in North Bellport. There is a need for more testing-the last testing was in 2017 at the Long School. Hannah has grandchildren that attend the Long school.
Christine-responding to Hannah’s questions. The community is not getting information on their concerns.
Hannah said in earlier times the local churches would interact with the Town. This no longer happens.
Time is now 6:09
Vanessa just spoke
Composting
Composting material coming soon
Covanta
Abena-Court case-all should review things related to Covanta and comment.
Sat, Feb 25 meeting at South Country Library,11-1-can come early.
Michelle Santantonio-22 Station Road, SC Library.
David from PSL. Demo At Jamaica Center re: Matthew Felix.
No meeting next week. Next meeting March 3. This meeting concluded at 6:27 pm.
3/3/2023 Agenda
Housekeeping:
- Host: LIPC
- Facilitator: Katy Johnston
- CoFacilitator Chat Monitor/Timekeeper: Monique
- Notetaker 1: Bob
- Notetaker 2:
- Participation on zoom - chat, stack, raise hand
- Participation off zoom landfillaction631@gmail.com, FB, IG, website soon come!
Acknowledgements & Housekeeping: (15 min 5:15 pm)
Check Ins:
Updates: (40 min 5:55 pm)
- Larry Swanson’s Long Island Environmental Symposium
- a discussion with town supervisors and DEC on solutions to Long Island’s solid waste crisis
- Funding for waste infrastructure
- Where is this funding going?
- Improvements for waste to energy
- Large scale food waste management
- Who can attend? Bob, Annelies, Matthew, Katy
- What are the goals for BLARGers who attend?
- Bring up these things at the meeting: Want to emphasize zero waste, circular economy, regional plan closed means closed 2024, strategize with others, robust groundwater and accountability about ground water, Lisa building the economy circular economy instead of , large scale food composting need environmental justice to be thrown in the conversation. Making the communities whole who have been harmed
- Tony: seeing there any funding ties with Covanta on the solutions being offered (research)
- Start an email thread to talk about strategy
- Maybe meet up outside the door for a mini protest for the attendees
- Maybe meet up afterward for a debrief
- Report back from in person meeting
- Civics Lisa, Myrna, Bob and Hannah
- Create FAQ sheet Erica and Kerim will work on this
- Bob to take a deeper dive into the landfill permit
- Getting more clarity on the election year rules for fiscal sponsorship - (Traci Confer from Energy Justice Network will do a presentation 3/10)
- Bob to convene next in person meeting for June 2023
- Report back on grant submission and possible upcoming grants (Abena, Mike, Monique, Hannah, Erica)
Action: (10 min 6:05)
- Next Town Board meeting March 9th at 2pm: Lisa is coordinating this effort. Who can attend?
Closing:
Notes:
Bob is the notetaker for tonight, March 3, 2023
Katy Johnston is the convener
Event at Stony Brook March 15. Larry Swanson is the lead on this. Monique will attend-there is money available. *
Great interest is a meeting after the 3/15 seminar. Katherine will set up a meeting on campus.
Many suggestions made about topics.
27 persons on zoom
3/10/2023 Agenda
Housekeeping:
- Host: LIPC
- Facilitator: Monique
- CoFacilitator Chat Monitor/Timekeeper:
- Notetaker 1: recording
- Notetaker 2: Monique
- Participation on zoom - chat, stack, raise hand
- Participation off zoom landfillaction631@gmail.com, FB, IG, website soon come!
Acknowledgements & Housekeeping: (15 min 5:15 pm)
Check Ins:
Presentation (record): From All Our Energy on EPR and Q&A (30 min 5:45 pm)
Presentation: from Energy Justice Network and Q&A (5:45 pm 6:15 pm)
- Can’t imply one candidate is better than the other or give the impression that you are strongly doing it.
- Bolderadvocacy.com $60 for the training great investment (correction from the meeting the next training on the election year advocacy is June 13th at 2 pm)
- Make sure to invite all candidates to speak if one asks to speak.
- Make comments directed at the office the person holds not the person
- Speak on behalf of yourself and not BLARG
Actions: (6:15 - 6:30 pm) not discussed will carry over to next meeting
- Young Long Islanders 4 Justice partnering with New Hour and LI Helpers for a clothing drive now until March 27th (Erin)
- Found someone giving away a massive amount of wood chips. Is anyone able to volunteer themselves a big bucket or a truck bed to collect wood chips in middle island? We also can probably do a sawdust pick up in east Patchogue who can help?
- March 15th Larry Swanson Symposium StonyBrook university
- March 22nd International Water Conference NYC official side event to the UN Water Conference 6:30 pm - 8:30 pm 34th and 5th Ave Manhattan register now seating is limited - 113 out of 1300 side event one of the only non corporate
- We have three extra tickets for family and/friends
- March 28th Mass Mobilization to Albany to fight for Climate Jobs and Justice!
- Rally in North Bellport in April 22nd, Earth Day
- Need all hands on deck for outreach and day of logistics
3/17/2023 Agenda
Housekeeping:
- Host: LIPC
- Facilitator: Katy
- CoFacilitator Chat Monitor/Timekeeper:
- Notetaker 1: Erin Curley
- Yellow highlighted = people needed for action
Acknowledgements & Housekeeping: (15 min 5:15 pm)
Check Ins:
Updates:
- Debrief from Larry Swanson LI Symposium
- WSHU article by JD Allen
- Monique attended w 1, 2 - event was extremely white & corporate
- Monique asked if there was any plan to shut the incinerators (esp in North Bellport) - answer was “no plans to shut down) from Covanta
- 4 on LI, 10 incinerators across the state
- Also mentioned the health impacts with no response
- Panel with supervisors (Islip, Babylon, Smithtown, & DEC)
- Questions submitted where not answered at all
- Supervisors & DES pointed their fingers at each other - Smithtown is only town with a solid waste plan
- They do blame each other
- __who said__ they have community involvement
- 3/22 10am in Islip (islip town hall, 655 w main st) another open meeting - to follow up with supervisors on their plan for waste
- Jennifer Greene thoughts of the event
- Winters brothers have learned how to talk / echo environmental language
- Frank Roethel (stony brook waste management department) - interest in ash
- Dr. Georgette said we don’t have waste crisis
- Monique - Dr said we have a waste crisis to push their permits through. Framing/messaging is different from the actual issue. Point is they are trying to adjust the issue not on them & to benefit their message
- Abena - both are right in some ways. Rail waste station building which have already been approved by DEC (Brentwood, Medford). Amount of CND is more than Brookhaven landfill → aka build a huge station so close to the landfill. Corporations are using the word crisis to intensify that THEY should be chosen. BLARG doesn’t want to move the waste to other ppl’s backyards (other states). Brookhaven NAACP taken the lead to have a specific case & fight; BLARG trying to fight for env’t justice which is more than stomping the 1 waste stations which includes the other states that LI waste would be moved towards. This difference is important; inspire other ppl/orgs to take action how they see fit.
- Bob (William Kokell) - read article in newsday about the meeting. Heard that they will need to keep landfill in a few years. Bob’s answer - you take care of your towns garbage and not dump it in Brookhaven town
- NYS Solid Waste Management Plan
- DEC will be hosting an informational webinar Tuesday April 11, 2023 10 am - 11:30 am. During this time DEC will review the key elements of the Plan and allow attendees to ask questions.
- Town Supervisors meeting:
- Wednesday, March 22nd at 10:00AM at Islip Town Hall, 655 W. Main Street in Islip. A solid waste discussion is the main item on the agenda. The group will meet with NYS DEC reps from 10:00-10:30AM, and then they will have a presentation by Dr. Archie Filshill of Aero Aggregates of North America LLC from 10:30 – 11:00AM
- Abena question - are people able to speak / ask questions? What is the format?
- Want for action? Bring press? - also with short time it might not make any sense. Point of using the space/event to our advantage.
- Katy - any journalists we know going?
- LI Advance article regarding teacher at Eastern Suffolk BOCES who acquired cancer and believes there at be a link to the landfill as ESB is a mile away from the landfill. Hannah was interviewed for the article
- Katy - No family history, hearing about the child who passed away lead to this connection
- Katy - mentioned an email Abena referenced with this not being on the budget so it wouldn’t be “wheeled and dealed” the way other issues are
- Voted YES
- Discuss Newsday article from 3/15, "What Will Happen when the Brookhaven Landfill Closes in 2024?". As the landfill closure date approaches and the town is forced to share bits and pieces of its “plan,” how will we best use these opportunities to ensure that environmental justice is not left out of these discussions, that North Bellport and landfill-adjacent communities are not overlooked, and that the waste crisis profiteers do not continue to control the conversation?
- Katy - as the landfill closure date gets closer the township gives out more info. How to make sure waste profiters don’t run the whole conversation. Mentioned a blame of covid delays.
- Mary F - supervisor won’t be closed till 2026 now because of waste slow down due to covid. Said he wouldn’t go on the record for it.
- 3/20 7pm at Hagerman Civic Center (Hagerman fire district, 510 oakdale ave east patchogue)
- Erin - why is covid blamed for this? Wouldn’t waste go up because of more shipping?
- Mary F - Only construction material went in there; since construction stopped the landfill didn’t get packed up (aka ok to be closed)
- Abena - the decision to close the landfill isn’t about convincing it’s that they won’t close because they have no plan. Need to put pressure / feel ashamed to go to DEC/EPA/community saying they need help today to make a plan for the waste so the landfill can be closed. Supervisor continues to extend it & continues to get reelected. Town will be as disrespectful as they want. Continue to make this point so we have clarity
- Mary F - calling DEC because apparently by Brookhaven town “DEC are monitoring the landfill every day”. She’s trying to get answer because she wants to ask town to see if they are lying & ask directly in person
- Bob - ask about location. What Abena said is 110% right. Once they are out of office they aren’t held responsible. Back in 70s when landfill started they never made a plan for closing it then. Mentioned his concern about students lungs/health
- Katy - unless the shame is with a wider audience, they are will be shameless with us [BLARG]
- Hannah - been in community 55 yrs, 2008 they found contaminations and did nothing; 2017 pfas in the ground; DEC and EPA went back and forth. 2022 tested again for pfas - still there. This is all documented but when you ask questions you get no/are not concerned. Brookhaven town is holding hog farms in Bellport with private water supply (Kerim - 500K public water)
- Mary F - Brookhaven town spent millions for developmental right so the township has it always as a far
- Kerim - Hannah is referring to town board water improvement plan for Brookhaven hamlet; wasn’t told what it’s for and why but later found out it’s hog farm. Part non profit and rest private - ½ million dollars. Ppl on his street had to pay $ to hook up to public water. The plume over the farm moves water is contaminated
- Changes in EPA for waste incineration (Mike Ewall)
- Stop promoting trash incineration as sustainable option
- Required to report incineration toxins to the database
- Also required to whats in the ash & where they go - currently no reported anywhere
- Monique - take ash & turn into roadways/aggregates. Point is the worry that this will be pushed through (related to Larry Swanson LI Symposium)
- Kerim - Covanta Paul Gilman refuses to share ash testing with us
- Mike E - ash testing data is available from DEC if we request it
- Monique - Hempstead is doing air monitoring. NYS testing rule. She’s meeting with Hempstead’s senator elect and what type of questions should she ask?
- Mike E - Industry buried ash in LI sound and claims that underwater testing shows that it doesn’t leach. Major Covanta ash recycling plant in Bucks County, PA; increasing trend to recycle ash so they don’t need to pay to dispose of it. Will talk more offline
- Monique - Symposium has a LOT of untrue mess
- Mike E - http://www.energyjustice.net/incineration/ash.pdf
Actions:
- Young Long Islanders 4 Justice partnering with New Hour and LI Helpers for a clothing drive now until March 27th (Erin)
- Erin - ask for someone in Brookhaven area to be the point person/collecting & I can come by weekend of 24 (preferred) or 31st
- Clothes in 2nd hand stores in the US get sold in bags to companies that sell it in African countries then create landfills in these countries when not sold. Causing pollution & impacting sustains farmers of the area
- Found someone giving away a massive amount of wood chips. Is anyone able to volunteer themselves a big bucket or a truck bed to collect wood chips in middle island? We also can probably do a sawdust pick up in east Patchogue who can help?
- Read this press release by our friends at the Brookhaven NAACP. Legislation is advancing in the state legislature seeking to undo the 60 acre conservation easement at the center of the 228-acre plot in order to allow Winters Bros to have its way. Conservation easements are there for a reason; Winters' bought the land knowing the easement was there, and now they are trying to evade the restrictions and responsibilities associated with it. Please consider writing to Joe DeStefano (yes, him again) and Dean Murray. We even have a draft message for you here.
- March 22nd International Water Conference NYC official side event to the UN Water Conference 6:30 pm - 8:30 pm 34th and 5th Ave Manhattan register now seating is limited - 113 out of 1300 side event one of the only non corporate
- We have three extra tickets for family and/friends
- Hannah, Kerim, & Monique will be going for BLARG - have a presentation that they’ll be presenting
- Ppl across the world will be attending
- Climate Justice Working Group votes on the final disadvantaged communities criteria 3/27 1 pm. Register here
- will determine if places like North Bellport are labeled disadvantaged which impact funding
- Worry is because of how the census map was drawn this money might not be spent in North Bellport anyway
- March 28th Mass Mobilization to Albany to fight for Climate Jobs and Justice!
- First nations coming together to advocate in Albany hasn’t happened in decades
- Plan to take the bus together
- Rally in North Bellport in April 22nd, Earth Day
- Need all hands on deck for outreach and day of logistics
- Abena - BLARG do teach in at the event of different parts of the waste crisis. Hope is once it’s created it can be used again.
- Reach out to her about teach in
- Hannah has been doing outreach & connecting for the event
- Reach out to her about community outreach/spreading the word
- Dennis also connecting ppl in the community to the event!
- Hannah - hasn’t gotten response from boys n girls club; BOCES said no (& doesn’t want to be mentioned)
- Hope to lift up spirits of community & hear that others are interested in the plight/issue. THIS is an important part of the event!
- Not highlighting 1 org over another; it’s about environmental issue
- Let the town know we are still here & fighting for our rights
3/24/2023 Agenda
Housekeeping:
- Host: LIPC
- Facilitator: Monique
- CoFacilitator Chat Monitor/Timekeeper: Annelies
- Notetaker 1: Abena
- Notetaker 2: christine
- Participation on zoom - chat, stack, raise hand
- Participation off zoom landfillaction631@gmail.com, FB, IG, website soon come!
Acknowledgements & Housekeeping: (15 min 5:15 pm)
Check Ins (BLARG rest 3/31)
Updates:
- Report back from the Water Conference for International Water week (Hannah, Monique, Ryan)
- Some highlight videos on Facebook. Link here
- Hannah: Enlightening; water pollution struggle and issues with PFAS. All femme panels from all over (Brazil and France in particular): both areas have immense issues with water access and pollution. They are bringing light and trying to get their gov to get water more widely distributed as well as deal with bacterial issues. So they are trying to get their gov to take on these two main issues. Both heartening/disheartening to hear of the shared struggle in these places. Hope to stay connected with folks from this conf (both who invited us and folks we met there).
- Erica: part of webinar link here with lots of info and what we can do. Also blog post about water filtration (link) with really great resources linked. Also reverse osmosis filters are very helpful. Here’s a link to one model from Home Depot:
- Monique: shout out Mike M (invited us to conf); also want to work on more ways to put pressure on agencies that are supposed to be in place to help us.
- Sub groups for capacity and burnout prevention would love some more help
- Website: we are a few weeks out from our launch and it would be helpful for one or two more people to help us get this across the finish line
- We have an awesome web designer, Amanda Rivera, making great strides. We are close to getting our domain and host situated. More hands are welcome.
- Lisa: I’m used to more structure. What is required and what are you looking for?
- Monique: We are looking for ppl to join. Amanda Rivera will guide the process. If there are ppl who have energy to join that process and keep the thread going that would be welcome.
- Lisa: Will the website have the logo? It’s a great logo.
- Annelies: When are the usual meeting day/ time?
- Monique: I am not as available to help take on this process. We usual meet in the evenings.
Lisa: Do we have a campaign for Earth Day?
Monique: We will get to that. Hannah is planning a march/ event and BLARG is hosting an event on Earth Day event on 4/22 (see bullet point below)
- People’s Brookhaven Anti bias task force: met last night (next meeting in 3 weeks, Thursday eves)
- We are currently missing this task force in the town, so we are looking to make this. Folks are meeting to create this structure
- John: mission statement drafted. Also looking for list of groups to invite to be part of this, we can then send info and invite. Looking to set up structure (i.e. bylaws or similar)
- Myrna: working name involving The People’s…
- Joel suggested widening beyond Brookhaven
- Lisa: has been trying to get on Brookhaven’s official anti-bias taskforce for years. Has dealt with opposition to even getting any info(who is on it, running it, meeting minutes, etc).
- John: main focus on Brookhaven and support would most likely come from orgs and in a pro-bono sense.
- North Bellport Strong Day of Unity (4/22 planned date)
- Ideas for speakers/teach-ins/items:
- Bellport boys and Girls (working on connections)
- Brookhaven NAACP
- Local residents (need for canvassing?)
- Local Church Groups
- RAPP and LISJAN
- Communities not Cages
- South Country Peace Group
- North Country Peace Group
- Devon Toney
- BLARG Teach-In (Katy/ Abena/ Barbara Coley)
- Local Chamber of Commerce
- Bellport Rotary
- Miles Malone and new recycling center
- Alesia Olsen (ASL)
- CEED
- South Country Library
- South County Water Authority
- Building Bridges Brookhaven
- Multicultural Solidarity (Laura Lesch)
- UUFellowship at Stony Brook (Laura Lesch)
- East Setauket Presybterian (Laura Lesch)
- LI United for Justice (RAPP and LISJAN contacts may have connections with LIU)
- South Country Unites
- Southaven Church
- Flyer posted on BLARG and in email - if anyone has capacity to help print eap in color, let us know!
- Fb event page
- This needs to be made:
- Once made, please share out. Please share out the FB event after it is created. Share, share! share!
- Share Facebook and IG posts and then share the event page (once made)
- Connect with Hannah to support (calls preferred over email)
- Time/date/info: helpful to approach folks/orgs and gauge interest.
- Hannah reached out to Boys and Girls Club, they are having their own event, still trying to form a connection with new exec.
- Logistics (also connect with Hannah, see above)
- Rally on corner of Station and Montauk and march to Rob Rowley park (route tbd), some music, need posters/flyers, if anyone wants to speak, connect with education, housing, and carceal systems (and anything else)
- Anti landfill Composting Collective
- Garden is opening May 13th (usually a BBQ or something to celebrate)
- What needs doing before “opening”?
- Anyone want to help get us the browns (sawdust and wood chips)
- christine will touch base with M
- 3/30/2023 5 pm at town hall (Lisa has been point person)
- Continue to point out inconvenient times for working folks,
- Continue to use key phrases (circular economy, zero waste, 3 Rs), books and additional info
- Netflix doc rec: Kiss the Ground (talks about soil health) - tho caveat to that film is regenerative ranching might be farfetched. Another doc Divide in Concord (about long struggle about single use plastic)
- Another documentary about soils is called Dirt! Free here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A8mawEmm49o
- Schedule sent to BLARG email?
- Attend and have info to hand out
Actions:
- ABOUT THE WEBINAR
- DISCUSSION & INSIGHT
- Are you interested in a career in clean energy, but not
- • Growth and importance of clean energy careers quite sure what type of job you can get in the field or
- how to find one? Clean energy is an interdisciplinary
- • Major fields of clean energy employment field involving consulting, sales, research, engineering, • Job search tips & resources advocacy, and more. NEST and our panel of clean
- energy professionals will be giving our top
- • O&A with clean energy professionals that are
- recommendations for landing a clean energy career.
- NEST Energy Corps Internship Alumni
- Over 20,000 acres of wetlands, grasslands and woodlands supporting rare, threatened and endangered species are at risk of injury from a 1,263-acre mega-industrial development referred to as STAMP (Science, Technology and Advanced Manufacturing Park) proposed by the Genesee County Economic Development Center (GCEDC) outside of Buffalo NY. Send an email today
- United Nations is launching its first-ever annual International Day of Zero Waste on March 30. Sign on ♡
4/7/2023 Agenda
Housekeeping:
- Host: LIPC
- Facilitator: Monique
- CoFacilitator Chat Monitor/Timekeeper: all
- Notetaker 1: Katy
- Notetaker 2: Monique
- Participation on zoom - chat, stack, raise hand
- Participation off zoom landfillaction631@gmail.com, FB, IG, website soon come!
Acknowledgements & Housekeeping: (15 min 5:15 pm)
Check Ins (BLARG rest 3/31)
Updates:
- North Bellport Strong Day of Unity
- Pitch a story
- Press release/media advisory
- Disadvantaged community?
- Katy, Monique and Monique will ask Scott
- Canvassing and printing flyers
- Saturday 8th 3 pm; Michelle will drop off flyers to Monique at the Boys N Girls Club
- Katy: (in the chat) this will be a good weekend to reach folks at church; will be at UUFSB event and can share the event there if that makes sense
- Christine: (in the chat) will be at a shop swat and will pass out flyers there
-
- Lots of donations (Khadijah, Jennifer, Dennis, Myrna others)
- Try to limit the waste and packaging
- Dennis: Keep everyone safe. Will like to take a longer route once in the community
- Monique: we should use the carts to hold speakers and signs and have two or more bicyclists for amplification
- We can have a caravan for an accessibility option
- Monique, Hannah and Dennis to present a few options or decide by next meeting
- Dennis
- Hannah
- Pastor Sneed
- Michelle will check to see if we can get the county/town mobile stage
- Lisa: “Clap for Earth Day, one, two, three. Let's recycle faithfully. March for Earth Day, four, five, six. Pick up litter quick, quick, quick.”
- LIPC can lend one or two
- Christine has a small megaphone can help if has the chants ahead of time
- Abena: small speaker and mic
- Katy will bring 1
- LIPC might lend some
- South Country Peace Group wants to co sponsor
- Kerim connected with this group
- Blarg at the park for sign making on Friday 4/21 at 5:00
- Abena: Has old signs will bring them
- Christine: Will help mark the route and bring supplies
- Dennis: Kids would love to make signs
- Michelle: Patchogue Library can make signs for low cost
- Reflector jackets at the garden
Actions:
- They have a bus leaving from multiple locations or can carpool with Monique
- Please review and we will call a vote next week
- Sign up for the webinar April 13th for more information on how to fire PSEG for a fully public power utility
- Matthew: Extinction Rebellion and others are having protests April 24-26 in Manhattan against Citi Bank the second largest funder of fossil fuels, including drilling on indigenous land in the Amazon: https://www.xrebellion.nyc/campaign
4/14/2023 Agenda
Housekeeping:
- Host: LIPC
- Facilitator: Lynne
- CoFacilitator Chat Monitor/Timekeeper:
- Notetaker 1:
- Notetaker 2:
- Participation on zoom - chat, stack, raise hand
- Participation off zoom landfillaction631@gmail.com, FB, IG, website soon come!
Acknowledgements & Housekeeping: (15 min 5:15 pm)
Check Ins (BLARG rest 3/31)
Updates: April 22nd North Bellport Strong Day of Unity (Hannah)
- Canvassing dates and times
- Saturday 4-6 pm
- Weekday evenings 4-6 pm Monday -Friday
- Outreach continue to spread the word and share on social media
- Anyone know how to make a QR code?
- Food please bring food or donate for food (we did pizza last year) limited waste food items
- Hannah is bringing a grill
- Katy is bringing buns
- Jennifer is bringing veggie dogs
- Hannah was able to
- Monique has one med sized cooler
- Large Gatorade pitcher/cooler for iced tea (bring your own reusable cup)
- Christine has a big pitcher
- Weigh our trash and compost
- No takers will be a group undertaking
- Information/resource tabling at the park:
- Tables (bring your own, there are tables there, may just need one or two more to supplement)
- Chairs (for the teach in)
- Any other ideas for community and kids
- Chants doc help us modify
- Who wants to wear a reflector jacket and Marshall to keep us safe along the route and liaise with police should they show up.
- Signs for the route
- Bill can bring some posterboards
- Wooden sticks
- Need staple gun
- Mobile stage how are we doing with that
- Michelle not on the call no update
BLARG VOTE:


- Decision
- Yes sign on, no objections
Actions:
- Special Acknowledgment (Monique):
- BLARG at the park for sign making on Friday 4/21 at 5:00pm (not meeting on zoom)
- Read the Draft Solid Waste Management Plan Here: Reading group/comments (Monique)
- (Matthew): Extinction Rebellion and others are having protests April 24-26 in Manhattan against CitiBank the second largest funder of fossil fuels, including drilling on indigenous land in the Amazon: https://www.xrebellion.nyc/campaign
- (Monique) May 2nd Advocacy Day in Albany for Extender Producer Responsibility bill and Bigger Better Bottle Bill. Register here a bus is leaving from Manhattan information in the registration link
5/5/2023 Agenda
Housekeeping:
- Host: LIPC
- Facilitator: Monique
- CoFacilitator Chat Monitor/Timekeeper: Matthew S
- Notetaker 1: Jennifer G
- Notetaker 2:
- Participation on zoom - chat, stack, raise hand
- Participation off zoom landfillaction631@gmail.com, FB, IG, website soon to come!
Acknowledgements & Housekeeping: (15 min 5:15 pm)
Check Ins (BLARG rest 3/31)
Debrief and Appreciation: April 22nd North Bellport Strong Day of Unity (30 min 5:45 pm)
- Roses (positives)
- Thorns (negatives)
- Buds (could’ve been better)
- Appreciation
- Roses
- Thorns - about Devon’s observation that the crowd assembled at the park was majority white, Monique agreed that’s nothing new
- Buds - Ezekiel: we could do better next time, making and installing signage more in advance of the event, to get word out. It was a bit haphazard and last-minute.
- Appreciation - Ezekiel is thankful that someone re-installed the sign he put up the night before
- Roses
- Thorns
- Buds
- Appreciation - Jennifer appreciates Hannah’s granddaughter & grandson in law for staffing the grill! And the folks who contributed vegan pizzas! I got feedback from folks who enjoyed the veggie dogs :)
- Roses
- Thorns
- Buds
- Appreciation - Monique (and Myrna): shout-out to Abena and Katy and Barbara for teach-in!
- Roses - Monique: we were able to help elders; Bob: agreed the “Sag Wag” was good
- Thorns
- Buds
- Appreciation
- Roses
- Thorns
- Buds
- Appreciation - Monique: Thanks to Ezekiel for what you said before the march, and leading during the march
- Roses
- Thorns - Monique: need to be mindful of printing costs,
- Buds - Monique: we might invest in better signs, that are durable & can be reused
- Appreciation - Thanks to Myrna for their signs!
- Roses
- Thorns
- Buds
- Appreciation - Monique: Thanks to Dennis for making sure we were safe during the march; Monique: appreciates Michelle S’s help with the elders.
- Roses - Jennifer: seemed like effective outreach must’ve happened, to get that many reporters there to cover it
- Thorns
- Buds - Monique: we missed opportunity with NBC but hopefully in the future
- Appreciation
- Bill K thought it was real good!
- John McN: Great spirit! Speeches were great. Uplifting event.
- Khadija: Kudos to all the planners and participants. It felt like a community and family coming together for a good cause.
- Dennis: Thanks to everyone who came out and participated!
- Hannah: One of the better rallies that we’ve had, even though there wasn’t a big turnout from the N. Bellport community, but glad that folks seemed to be aware and our presence was felt. Thanks to everyone for their contributions. Is disheartened by the moving of the goalpost of the closure of the landfill & prospect of the waste transfer station
- Monique: Everyone pitched in! Jennifer helped with printing, transporting the speakers…
- Myrna: at the park, loved the opportunities for children to play, and the teach-in led by Abena was excellent, and loved dancing with Hannah & having fun & celebrating community
- Bob: highlights were Devon T’s story, and Abena is a rockstar. Regarding the signage: message needs to get out to entire Town of Brookhaven, and beyond.
NYS DEC Draft Solid Waste Management Plan
- Executive Summary discussion (15 min 6:00 pm)
Bob: thinks we need to push the zero waste concept but also recognize it’s “utopian”.
Monique: we can push for the strongest EPR legislation we can get (not just rely on “personal responsibility”).
Mike E: Extended Producer Responsibility is a good theory, but doesn't work out well in practice, as industry ends up controlling the program, and they don't like reuse (which means they can't sell more stuff), and are happy to greenwash burning stuff, or downcycling, without prioritizing the Zero Waste Hierarchy and the highest and best use of materials. Vanessa: folks are invited to join our NYS Solid Waste Management Plan Brainstorm next Tues 5:30pm — here is the registration page: https://zoom.us/meeting/register/tJIpcOytqjgvHNVw0iFX1tNX0CIM5lK2tTDM
Comments on NYS Draft Solid Waste Management Plan from ZW Capital District: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1kIT1HHFqMWcNJ7tINMQNyvYd8X2XYbeleWY5vFA1-RE/edit?usp=drivesdk
Comments on NYS Draft Solid Waste Management Plan from ZW Capital District: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1kIT1HHFqMWcNJ7tINMQNyvYd8X2XYbeleWY5vFA1-RE/edit?usp=drivesdk
Monique: kudos to Vanessa for giving a great speech in Albany.
John McN: Over several decades, people’s behavior *has* changed in that it’s now normal to put out more than just one can. So new habits are possible.
Mike E: Read 40 of 80 pages so far. Found four main issues:
- The need to have zero waste as a goal and the Zero Waste Definition and Hierarchy as a framework. Zero Waste is not utopian, it’s a goal. Doesn’t mean we’ll get to zero, it’s the idea that we’re not going to stop trying. 90% seems to be a practical goal.
- In the plan, there’s a clear preference for incineration over landfill, it should be the other way around.
- The plan pushes for more dumping of toxic sewage sludge (“biosolids”) on farm fields, which Maine banned last year because of farms being permanently contaminated with PFAS.
- How does NY stop being the biggest exporter of waste?
Need a consensus agenda that can bring groups together instead of dividing the anti-landfill and anti-incinerator movements from each other in the state. The Seneca Lake Guardian letter was released with very problematic language they promised to change, which pits landfill and incinerator communities against each other by calling for no landfills to exist in NYS after 2030 (which means burning and exporting everything). They also promised to include anti-incinerator language, which was removed. LIPC signed onto it, and probably didn’t realize the promised changes didn’t happen. The meeting on Tuesday to work on comments on the SWMP will be the basis for fleshing out the consensus agenda for communities fighting incinerators and landfills in NYS.
- Key accomplishments
- Vision
- Recommendations
Abena: invited folks to say whether we want to use BLARG time or separate time to continue discussion of this draft plan.
Cumulative Impacts with Chris Sellers (20 min 6:20 pm)
Coburn’s definition of cumulative exposure as consider[ing] “multiple hazards, effects, pathways, and populations, including socioeconomic and race-related stressors”
NYS passed a Cumulative Impacts Law in 2022.
Flat (more or less) line graph of “cumulative” mentions in EPA database suggests resistance in govt agencies to employing this notion, despite rise of incidence of “cumulative” term in science research database.
“Determination of Social and Environmental Impacts in Your Community: Useful Investigative Tools” is the MPH students’ capstone presentation being given next Monday.
Abena gave this recap of BLARG’s experience of state DEC: a few years ago, when the permit for the landfill was up, we talked about trying to include EJ processes, and DEC reps said okay, yes, and then a few months later they said no, they won’t include even those basic EJ processes regarding the landfill.
Chris: My hope is that it’ll be harder for them to take that stance, given this new law.
Mike E: Anyone have a link to the text of the new law referenced here?
https://www.eenews.net/articles/n-y-enacts-landmark-gas-ban-carbon-trading-program/
I'd be interested to see how this might impact existing incinerators. Are they all grandfathered? How will they not be forced to close by 2040 if the state is to reach "100 percent carbon-free power grid in 2040?" Of course, they'll probably fall apart of old age by then…
Monique: was hoping the language would be done by now, but haven’t heard anything recently.
Mike E: also wondered what about the landfills that are burning gas for electricity, how will the “carbon-free power grid by 2040” affect that?
NYS Budget (10 min 6:30 pm)
- Unmarked Burials Graves Protection was added to the NYS Budget and it was able to be added the way advocates hoped for - a huge win, advocates were happy with the language that went into the Budget.
- Hochul’s Bad EPR was not included in the NYS Budget!
- Other updates on housing and bail reform?
- Build Public Renewables Act wasn’t gutted, also got passed in the Budget, yay!
5/12/2023 Agenda
Housekeeping:
- Host: LIPC
- Facilitator: Monique
- CoFacilitator Chat Monitor/Timekeeper: Matthew S
- Notetaker 1:
- Notetaker 2:
- Participation on zoom - chat, stack, raise hand
- Participation off zoom landfillaction631@gmail.com, FB, IG, website soon come!
Acknowledgements & Housekeeping: (15 min 5:15 pm)
Check Ins (BLARG rest 5/26)
Discussion: (10 min 5:25 pm)
- EarthJustice Amicus brief for: Fresh Air for the Eastside (FAFE) group filed a case against the city and the state. (Lynne)
- Notes reviewed by Monique and lynne
- Looking for more orgs that do this work to file amicus brief
- Should we take this on? EarthJustice already has our information. It would just be a matter of who would want to meet with them to tell their personal story and follow the updates that EarthJustice provides this could be 1-3 of us or so
- No blocks to taking this on. We will vote next meeting
BLARG VOTE: (5 min 5:30 pm)
- The letter is sponsored by Reimagine LIPA, a campaign of over 40 organizations (publicpowerlipa.org). In the letter, we urge support for the roadmap to public power devised by a commission established by the Legislature, one that will end management of the region's electric utility by PSEG and create a more accountable and better run publicly managed system.
- Ryan: overview and history given
- All who weighed in affirmed BLARG signing on, no one blocked us signing on
Readers Choice: (30 min 6:00 pm)
- GAIA : Draft Document of Environmental Justice Values and Principles for the Waste Sector.
- From GAIA: "As promised, we are sharing the draft of the environmental justice values and principles for the waste sector. We built this draft from all the rich discussions with all of you over the last few months. We are seeking your general feedback on the document at this time, in written form and/or on the consultations conference calls next week.
- Gets the Readers Choice award this week
- Monique: Unregulated corporate influence. Lack of accountability and transparency. Essential to advance an approach to environmental justice founded on fundamental principles of human, political, economic, social and cultural rights democratic decentralization an accountable governance
- Bob: zero waste is a goal. I don’t think it’s attainable in my lifetime. Last time we talked about this (Mike) he said that zero waste doesn’t mean exactly zero just minimally down to about 10 %. We can use this for our comments to the NYS draft solid waste mgmt plan. This shows we have some solutions instead saying we are aggrieved.
- Ezekiel: Missing is there is no policy to ban incinerators or
- NYS DEC Draft Solid Waste Management Plan
- Background on the history of waste mgmt in NY
- Vanessa: Letter to pushback the public comment
- Monday deadline
- Wednesday at 5:30 pm statewide effort to draft unified comments
Media corner
- Shout out to the stony Brook students and Shosh for her LTE🙌🏾🙏🏾❤️ and all the writers over these passed few weeks months.
Actions: (15 min 6:15 pm)
- Continue to read the NYS Draft Solid Waste Mgmt Plan
- Possible separate meeting Wednesday evening
- Randall principles of good EPR. We won’t support anything less
- Anyone want to share action items
- Myrna: veterans for Peace Environmental Justice Peace Ship 1958. Sailed by the Quaker people to stop Jefferson harbor. Welcoming the ship 5/26
- Bill: the cop killed in coram. You have to read between the lines there was no gun found so that makes me think he may even shot himself.
- Bill: Jordan Neely death at the hands of a marine without charges is not right. Wanted to get that out and vent a little
- Monique: thank you for uplifting his life and reminding us that this is not normal and that we cannot accept it
- Happy Mothers Day to those who celebrate and to those who struggle during this time
5/12/2023 Agenda
Housekeeping:
- Host: LIPC
- Facilitator: Katy
- CoFacilitator Chat Monitor/Timekeeper:
- Notetaker 1:
- Notetaker 2:
- Participation on zoom - chat, stack, raise hand
- Participation off zoom landfillaction631@gmail.com, FB, IG, website soon come!
Acknowledgements & Housekeeping: (15 min 5:15 pm)
Check Ins (BLARG rest 5/26)
Update: (10 min 5:25 pm)
- Matt and Monique talked through the first half of the plan
- Statewide groups working on it as well coordinated by Vanessa from WASS
- a press conference in Albany to get extension until August
- Working on putting together comment for the group to sign on to
- Great space to hear from others
Discussion: (20 min 5:45 pm)
- NYS DEC Draft Solid Waste Management Plan
- Break out rooms by chapters
- Group 1: Values and Vision (39-41)
- Group 2: Focus Areas, Goals, and Action Items (42-44)
- Group 3: Waste Prevention, Reduction, and Reuse (45-50)
- Group 4 Recycling and Recycling Market Development and Resiliency (51-56)
- Group 5: Product Stewardship and EPR (57-61)
- Group 6: Organics Reduction and Recycling (62-66)
- Group 7: Toxics Reduction in Products (67-69)
BLARG Vote: (15 min 6:00 pm)
- EarthJustice Amicus brief for: Fresh Air for the Eastside (FAFE) group filed a case against the city and the state. We are voting to see if BLARG can be a client of EarthJustice to file an amicus brief on this matter of FAFE v NYS, NYSDEC and the waste management company of the High Acres Landfill in Macedona, NY
- This is the second largest landfill in NYS
- This lawsuit is based on “newly enacted Section 19 Article I of the NYS Constitution, (the Green Amendment or ERA), which as of January 1 guarantees each person has clean air, clean water and a healthy environment”
- ERA was ballot initiative that BLARG was supportive of and posted a few times about during that campaign
- BLARG vote: Yes
Actions:
- Support for the Brentwood community in their struggle with the Omni waste transfer station
- Long Island Rally on debt ceiling medicaid and Snap cuts. Monique will talk about the permitting reforms how it relates to the debt ceiling and cuts to these programs
- 1705 Brentwood Rd, Brentwood, NY 11717, Monday at 12:00
- EPR & BBBB possible EJ leaders sign on
- What actions are you supporting this week
6/2/2023 Agenda
Housekeeping:
- Host: LIPC
- Facilitator: Monique
- CoFacilitator Chat Monitor/Timekeeper: Katy
- Notetaker 1: lynne
- Notetaker 2:
- Participation on zoom - chat, stack, raise hand
- Participation off zoom landfillaction631@gmail.com, FB, IG, website soon come!
Acknowledgements & Housekeeping: (15 min 5:15 pm)
Check Ins (BLARG rest 6/30)
Actions: (10 min 5:35 pm)
- Request an extension until August 14th. In line with the letter we sign on to and the press release Important to ask for extension individually in addition to as a group. We do need more time.
Update: (10 min 5:45 pm)
- Ruling possible July 27th on the settlement question.
- Should we have an action the day before or of?
- Fair Air For Eastside (FAFE) vs NYS and mgmt company for the High Acres landfill in Macedonia, NY the second largest landfill in NYS. Green amendment they are filing since they are not getting clean air and clean water. Katy, Bill, Bob said they would be interested in helping. Monique and Lynne are communicating with Earth Justice.
- Next steps include signing a retainer and scheduling another meeting sometime this June for amicus brief (This is the appropriate time)
- If you want to included in next steps let us know
- Brookhaven Rail/Yaphank waste transfer station Mark brought up the “Greenwashing” articles written by Winter Bros. A LTE or multiple LTEs would be great to counter their falsehoods. (Advance)
- Christina Compost 10-12 every Saturday
- Sign up for volunteering (form in the chat)
- ALCC and garden
- Met last Saturday
- Budget for landscaping and porta potty
- Garden looks great but will need some help from a professional landscaper. Then regular maintenance (cutting the grass)
- Porta potty
- Compost bins
- There are still plots left
- InReach (Flyering composting program and gardening with us)
- June 3rd soft start
- June 10th BBQ and potluck (charcuterie board)
- Fundraiser Sept 9th (Save the date)!
Breakouts: (15 min 6:00 pm)
- Meeting day and time to help use the notes to put together a draft 6 pm tues wed thurs? We’d or Thursday 7 pm?
- Bob, Mark, Monique Thursday at 4pm
- Barbara verbalized that the document does not address the effect this has on the community. Khadija also stated that the fenceline communities need to be at the table especially in the implementation phase. There is no mention of this in the document.
Discussion/report backs (20 min 6:20 pm)
Closing: let’s take a moment for George Floyd. It’s been three years since his life was taken.
6/8/2023 Agenda
Housekeeping:
- Host: LIPC
- Facilitator: Monique
- CoFacilitator Chat Monitor/Timekeeper: John MC Namara
- Notetaker 1: Katy Johnson
- Notetaker 2:
- Participation on zoom - chat, stack, raise hand
- Participation off zoom landfillaction631@gmail.com, FB, IG, website soon come!
Acknowledgements & Housekeeping: (15 min 5:15 pm)
Check Ins (BLARG rest 6/30)
Actions: (25 min 5:15 pm- 5:40 pm)
- Looking for folks to volunteer dropping off/processing food scraps.
- Covanta case rapid response team
- Update coming on 7/27 with whether or not the judge will allow towns to settle with Covanta on the whistleblower case. Blarg should be ready with a response either way. Besides a press release, should we also have a protest? Perhaps at the courthouse.
- Mark and I met this week. There’s still lots to do.
- J.D.: interested in putting together a “people’s plan” and would like input from Blarg before the end of June
- Congratulations in order!
- Singing congratulations video for Ayden!
- Why? Because we all deserve rest. It is the summer and we all deserve time to enjoy the summer. More room for community actions and InReach.
- July 21
- July 28
- August 18
- August 25
- Sept 1st
- The group agrees
- What we still will do
- Garden maintenance (Khadija)
- BBQ June 23 instead of the Friday meeting or Saturday June 24th
- Mixed response; will decide soon
- Action whether in person or written or both on the Covanta case July 27th
- Clothing giveaway proposed by Hannah
- Helped or offered clothes: Christina, Jennifer, Lynne
- Fundraiser Sept 9th save the date proposed by Christina
- Submit comments to the NYS Draft Solid Waste plan
- Anything else?
Updates: (10 min 5:40 pm - 5:50 pm)
- Montaukett recognition passed
- Still don’t know if it will be vetoed
- Still needs to be signed, but progress!
- EPR did not pass but looks good for next session
- Clean Slate
- To give folk who have been incarcerated a “clean slate” so they can come home and attain jobs without being discriminated against based on their record.
Presentation from Dr Jaimie Meliker and students from Stony Brook University (10 min presentation 10 min Q&A to follow 5:50 pm - 6:10 pm )
- Theme: superfund sites, climate, storm frequency, droughts affecting the movement of contaminants
- As participants we would get 5,000 to attend roughly 12 meetings
- exposure to similar contaminants (e.g., 1,4-Dioxane) in personal care products.
- Can’t focus on landfill but could do some monitoring of water if we knew where and what
- How does this benefit the community?
- Provides information, but arguably info we already know
- Jaymie: yes, there are contaminates in the water, but we need to know how much is getting in the drinking water, perhaps to establish that the drinking water treatment is insufficient.
- Abena: more thought to a design plan that considers how to make this data influential in creating change from the beginning.
- How does this include the community?
- Hannah: We are not an experiment
- What happens after the grant?
- Jaymie: with the data, we could make a stronger case. Perhaps, but perhaps misunderstands what is standing in our way.
- Jaymie: We need to decide if this is worth the time for BLARG because it is not directly aligned with the landfill. They can try to bend it that in direction in certain ways, but it is not the focus of the study.
Closing:
A moment for Riding for Jay
6/16/2023 Agenda
Housekeeping:
- Host: LIPC
- Facilitator: Katy
- CoFacilitator Chat Monitor/Timekeeper:
- Notetaker 1: Lynne
- Notetaker 2:
- Participation on zoom - chat, stack, raise hand
- Participation off zoom landfillaction631@gmail.com, FB, IG, website soon come!
Acknowledgements & Housekeeping: (15 min 5:15 pm)
Check Ins (BLARG rest 6/30)
Debrief:
- Grant presentation given by Dr. Jaymie Meliker
- $5,000 how many meetings? How many people?
- We are currently participating in a grant (Good Neighbors Initiative) that we obtained $5,000 and two of us attend 2hr bi-weekly meetings and offer input at the meeting and in sometimes between meetings
- Not a sure thing that the grant will be funded
- What does the study get us in the end? John’s impression is that it would be helpful if we can get water testing
- Abena speaks with him and he said that the landfill is NOT a superfund site it is not central to what the grant is for. Landfill and wells are owned by the TOB and he would need permission. There is a concern about asking about personal products and putting responsibility on the individual.
- Katy discussed this with Jaime at a social event and he seemed uninterested in BLARG’s core mission.
- Monique thought he was dismissive during the meeting. Responses to Nicole (NAACP) were also dismissive of EJ aspect.
- WE need TRUE allies
- John thinks a seat at the table would be advantageous to us. But we need to keep in mind that he is a scientist.
- Katy brought up the fact that there are 12 meetings to commit to. Do we have that capacity?
- We need to set standards about what we would like in partners.
- Hannah doesn’t see the point of this community participating.
Should we follow up?
- Who is interested in helping if we do?
Updates:
- Very slow start
- Sign up
- Khadija maintenance idea
- Lynne: post-covid people’s lives are busier and we might need to expand the drop-off time.
- Monique: slow, but still operating and doing well. Just looking for ways to expand participation
- BLARG comments on the NYS Draft Solid waste plan
- Next meeting? Weren’t able to have meeting last week.
- Two other groups working on the comments.
- Mike Ewall brought up NYPIRGs suggestion rewrite plan and give explanation document.
- Bob, Mark, Matt and Katy have expressed interest in assisting.
- Maya brought up bandwidth and we need our own BLARG standards
- Abena how to create a structure, weekly meetings? We need to evaluate ourselves. Obviously our goals are the same.
- WSHU article on Fostoria, OH. John commented that they don’t want our trash.
- Monique we don’t want to be bad neighbors
- BBQ 24? Or just meet in person 6/23? Too early to plan with peoples schedules. We should pick a date now so people can prepare and free themselves up. September 9th is a planned fundraiser (fishfry) could spur community interest.
- Community event 7/29 (Hannah) Outreach program Robert Rowley Park or Martha Park. Gordon Heights and Wyandanch communities invited. BLARG is asked to have a table to answer questions about the landfill. Any organizations that would be of interest to community are invited to table.
- Proposed dates of rest: .
- July 21
- July 28
- August 18
- August 25
- Sept 1st
- Should we have more in-person meetings or an adjusted meeting structure?
Actions:
- Randall: Must be compliant with 2019 climate law. National Fuel first to respond with a very inconsist letter with the climate law. If this gets accepted it will set a bad precedent. LIPA has requested rate increase of $30 per gas user. Initial deadline has passed, benefit of signing is group will get updates.
- May get a “rolling deadline”
- Should we sign Alliance for a Green Economy’s collective letter ensuring that the state stays the course with the CLCPA and sends National Fuel back to the drawing board to do better?
- Abena brought up Caithness. Will their plan be in line with the climate law?
- Vote taken to sign the letter
Closing:
6/23/2023 Agenda
Housekeeping:
- Host: LIPC
- Facilitator: Monique
- CoFacilitator Chat Monitor/Timekeeper:
- Notetaker 1:
- Notetaker 2:
- Participation on zoom - comment in the chat, stack, raise hand virtual or physical
- Participation off zoom landfillaction631@gmail.com, FB, IG, website soon come!
Acknowledgements & Housekeeping: (15 min 5:15 pm)
Check Ins (BLARG rest 6/30)
Updates:
- EarthJustice to draft a letter for BLARG to submit to the judge
- Favorable feedback from all
- Website development going well
- Amanda got to join the BLARG call last week to get a feel for our group
- Maya is working on the pictures for the website. Send any pictures to her
- Jennifer inquired if getting the Slack free trial subscription could be beneficial for content that may not exist in other places
- No further extension on the NYS Draft Solid Waste Comments seems to be on the horizon. Folks are going to hold a press conference withState legislators Harkham and Glick to continue to push.
- Mandates monitoring of dioxins continuously as opposed to one point in time
- Summer community event July 29th TBD
- North Bellport park TBD
- Need help sorting clothes
- Town of Brookhaven Bandstand $400 or have the town co-sponsor
- Setalcott Nation Annual Corn Festival Powwow 134 Main St. Setauket, NY 11733
- Would like to have a compost table. Help us compost the corn scraps
Actions:
- Sign on to the SWAB draft letter. Due June 29th for now still in draft form.
- Group agreed to shift the process on sign ons for the waste management comments. Group agreed to have Monique sign onto the letter once finalized. Letter was shared to this group but will not be shared out broadly as the letter is not finalized.
- Individual sign on letter as the Suffolk County Legislators blocked the ballot measure for Clean Water that proposed to fund alternative septic systems and sewers. More actions may follow
- Plastic Free July what can we do
- “Without the subsidies, the company wrote in its application, it would not undertake the project and instead “will seek the assistance it needs from a municipality elsewhere in the United States.”
- “Location of the project in the Town of Lockport or the State of New York is not critical to its success,” the company wrote. “The applicant will begin to actively pursue development incentives in other municipalities and in other states if financial assistance is not provided by the Town of Lockport IDA.”
- This is regarding a proposed Polyvinyl Chloride (PVC) manufacturing plant in Lockport, NY
- “The company, SRI CV Plastics, is requesting more than half a million dollars in taxpayer subsidies from the Lockport Industrial Development Agency (IDA) to manufacture PVC pipes and single-use packaging from carcinogenic vinyl chloride. Vinyl chloride is the compound that was burned in the East Palestine train derailment, and is solely used to produce PVC. This type of facility is not only dangerous for workers, it would take us in the opposite direction of our climate and environmental justice mandates under the NYS Climate Act.” Alexis Goldsmith Beyond Plastics
- Group support for this sign on letter. Will follow up on slack and email and next BLARG call for a possible vote if time permits
- Traffic stops Suffolk County
- Unjust traffic stops targeting Black and Latinx people. A recent report was released that showed the disparity. The was a recent lawsuit against the SCPD.
- Zoom link for the meeting 6/28/2023 7 pm tinyurl/TrafficLearningSession
- Wealth inequality series of events over the summer follow up with Matthew for more information
- ALCC: Come to the garden
Closing: 6:30 pm
7/7/2023 Agenda
Housekeeping:
- Host: LIPC
- Facilitator: Lynne
- CoFacilitator Chat Monitor/Timekeeper:
- Notetaker 1:
- Notetaker 2:
- Participation on zoom - comment in the chat, stack, raise hand virtual or physical
- Participation off zoom landfillaction631@gmail.com, FB, IG, website soon come!
Acknowledgements & Housekeeping: (15 min 5:15 pm)
Check Ins (BLARG rest 6/30)
Updates:
- Debrief on NYS Draft SWMP (Monique)
- Covanta Corner (Abena)
- Updates on letter
- Our plan
- ALCC pumpkin planting and other updates (Lynne)
- Grants and grant writing (Christina)
- New 7,000 grant from the Unitarian Universalists.
- Katy: Maybe some of the funds could be spent on maintaining the website
- Website group: Abena, Maya, Erica, Habiba
- We have amassed so much information (history, EJ, etc.) that it has taken longer than expected to get the website designer up to speed. She has a draft site created and the BLARG group has made the decision to pause the work for the summer. At the end of August, a six week time frame will start to complete the site. She will join a BLARG meeting in early September to gather feedback. Then she will take that feedback and come back at a later date with updates.
- Goals: accessibility, engaging, informative. Website architect has been wonderful.
- North Bellport and the police (Dennis)
- Stop Unjust Stops (Dennis)
- Community event July 29th (Hannah)
Actions:
- Setalcott Nation Annual Corn Festival Powwow
- Saturday, July 8 and Sunday July 9th Setauket Elementary school 134 Main St Setauket, NY 11733 Gates open at 12 pm until 6 pm, Grand entry 2 pm free to get in, donations welcome and please support our vendors.
- What actions are you supporting?
Closing
7/15/2023 Agenda
Housekeeping:
- Host: LIPC
- Facilitator: Katy
- CoFacilitator Chat Monitor/Timekeeper:
- Notetaker 1:
- Notetaker 2:
- Participation on zoom - comment in the chat, stack, raise hand virtual or physical
- Participation off zoom landfillaction631@gmail.com, FB, IG, website soon come!
Acknowledgements & Housekeeping: (15 min 5:15 pm)
Check Ins (BLARG rest 7/21 & 7/28)
Updates:
- BLARG Rest 7/21 & 7/28
- Covanta Corner
- Jennifer found a typo in the first paragraph: “Attorney Generala”
- Press release
- action after a decision comes down?
- Using part of the UU 7,000 grant to expand ALCC
- Second ALCC compost at EFWA (58 Beaver Dam Rd, Bellport)
- We need browns
- Website management
- Community need
- Fiscal sponsor
- Good Neighbors Initiative (GNI) obtained $215,000 (Monique)
- Working on more funding for the next phase $8,500 left and $30,000 grants funds coming in. There are several groups involved but at the moment the funds aren’t there to offer grants for the next phase.
- Does anyone want to join phase II?
- They don’t have the funding to sustain all of the groups moving forward, but are asking us to move forward.
- Looking for Blarg attend meetings on the 2nd and 4th Wednesdays from 11:00-1:00.
- Creating a hashtag that will have a soft launch before a larger public launch.
- Press conference in preparation and subsequent Kickoff event dates TBD
- Youth Day on Environmental Justice hosted by D1 Youth August 12 in Brentwood (Monique)
- Booth sign up
- We have common cause around the waste transfer station and are natural allies.
- Looking for volunteers to table and/or provide a workshop
- Town of Brookhaven officials say in the press that the landfill will now close in 2028.
- How will we respond?
- July 28th protest at town hall, 11:00AM-1:00PM (pre-meetup at 10:30)
- #Floodthelines #Won’twaitTill’28
- Ed Romaine,eromaine@brookhavenny.gov 631 451-9100
- Michael Loguercio CouncilmanLoguercio@brookhavenny.gov 631 451-6968
- Dan Panico 631-451-6502
Actions:
- Unjust stops Press conference 7/15 11 am postponed
- ALCC 7/15 10-12 pm
- LISJAN Picnic at Thera Farms, 1705 Brentwood Rd Brentwood, NY 11715 (repost flyer on socials) BLARG will pull up!
- Next friday, 7/21 4:00-6:00PM
- July 29th Hot Giving Summer Community event
- Flyers are out
- Starts at 2:00, Robert Rowley Community Park
8/4/2023 Agenda
Updates:
- Monique: need to do more protests at the town hall
- Bill: the landfill is up to 2028 I get frustrated
- Dennis: too hot. Thanks for standing up.
- Monique: security made us move in the heat instead of the canopy and bench
- Bill: called romaine and the deputy supervisor and Loguercio. Loguercio came to the door. He went on and on. Call me any day and
- Hannah: how was he able to give that announcement about the landfill. Is that written in stone. We don’t know where it came. Who else is aware of it. Who else is supporting it. We need to keep calling. That is a straight line to nothing the li advance and him together. I don’t know how we can as a community that hear our voice. Our we going to stand on our corners and shout. Still out here in the community talking
- Dennis: lack of them supporting them in the community.
- Laura: missed the protest had family in for vacation and interested to know what the hell they are doing. Is it a true statement
- Mike: happy to be here. Victory against Covanta in Oregon. Sent Abena and Monique a new CHEJ grant opportunity due in ten days (see below).
- Monique: Erica is working on a story and has received statements from Cameron Trent and Lillian Claymen
- Bob: the town election is this year?
- Hannah Christina and Monique will finalize paperwork for reimbursement tomorrow and report back the monetary cost of event
- It was eventful. We have a lot of blessings. Went into at missionary more than blarg. There was a lot of division at the park. Between the communities that live here. We are divided as black and Latinos we have to give information about the harm in the danger. There wasn’t any mixture of cultures in the community. As blarg we are trying to look out for Black Hispanics and indigenous and low income. It was entire black event. Language barrier we only have Spanish flyers and not much else we need to have a bilingual info. They may be in dream land. Next outreach project
- Jennifer: was it two communities showed up or did the Latinx community
- Dennis: bball court conflict left our youth unable to use the bball court while the court was used for soccer instead. s/o to Monique for talking with the woman and her children about coordinating in the future
- Monique: I will follow up with her
- Hannah: we had to fight for that park Robert Rowley with community behind him fought for that park. I will follow up with the Hispanic community to provide education on the history of the community
- The letter to AG James went out
- Covanta submitter their response brief to the Polanski case
- The relator (petitioner) submitted their response brief to the Polanski case
- Mike Ewall nominated us
- Christina met with the funder 7/27
- We (Hannah, Christina, Barbara and Monique) are starting to work on the grant. Anyone else want to join just for this grant? We need help with proofreading and one or two more people that can help with ideas. We will meet online or in person two or four times.
Actions:
- Monique : ground us in the fact that this is an identified need and that after seeing recent events Mike has he is able to get more but in from community institutions than we are so this may be an opportunity to talk and engage more people and that we are were aware that this may be something Mike wants to do as a campaign tactic. Our community came out for their event with tons of institutional support. Whereas our community event was only supported by the Setalcott nation and blarg and idream. Other than that it is also an opportunity to engage Mike on the landfill issues too.
- MCNamara: is there Hispanic leadership
- Jennifer: why wasn’t we invited to that
- I have been working with the Rensselaer Environmental Coalition (REC) to advocate for the closure of the Dunn Landfill. If you're not familiar, it is a construction and demolition landfill outside a Rensselaer City School District, a k-12 public school that houses approximately 1100. More information can be found on the REC website. Additionally, the Times Union and CBS 6 recently reported on the situation here: TU, CBS6.
- DAC Reading Group 8/14 sign up
- South Country Peace Group’s 41st annual World Peace Vigil and Community Dedication to Peace! Sunday, August 6, 2023 Bellport library at 5 pm then march to the shore
8/11/2023 Agenda
Housekeeping:
- Host: LIPC
- Facilitator: Monique
- CoFacilitator Chat Monitor/Timekeeper:
- Notetaker 1:
- Notetaker 2:
- Participation on zoom - comment in the chat, stack, raise hand virtual or physical
- Participation off zoom landfillaction631@gmail.com, FB, IG, website soon come!
Acknowledgements & Housekeeping: (15 min 5:15 pm)
Check Ins (BLARG rest 8/18, 8/25, 9/1)
BLARG Vote:
- I have been working with the Rensselaer Environmental Coalition (REC) to advocate for the closure of the Dunn Landfill. If you're not familiar, it is a construction and demolition landfill outside a Rensselaer City School District, a k-12 public school that houses approximately 1100. More information can be found on the REC website. Additionally, the Times Union and CBS 6 recently reported on the situation here: TU, CBS6.
Updates:
- Just as we try to rest here comes some action:
- What actions do we need to take
- SCDOH
- Virtual/In-Person teach in (video recording of the press release being read) shareable far and wide and then FB Live or In-Person Q&A/ Town Hall about it (Abena) Capacity questions for BLARG to answer: Is this possible within two weeks? Would this reach more people and fit our education goals? Is this a priority? If so– what would we lay down so that we can pick this up in the next two weeks?
- Dennis: I was interviewed by JD Allen. where is the leachate going. Mastic seafood business is dropping off. Where in the water are they dumping it. Sandbagging used to soak up leaky liners
- MCNamara: there is a second plume emerging. Remediation is going cost a lot of money. Who will pay for it. It seems like they will put it off. Abena is coming up with putting together a committee
- Monique: closed means closed campaign means closure, remediated and accountability. Accountability means reparations from govt and corp
- Jennifer: a way to win campaigns values villains visions. Does blarg see alanah as helpful to the cause if that’s the case should she be an ally.
- Monique: we had a meeting with alanah over a year ago and this is the first time we made any headway with her that signals a change in our relationship for the better
- Devon: was on the call with mayor Adams office on one of the blarg call. Legislator Thorne had an event today so he couldn’t been on. His aid said he would like to meet with blarg. What about going to the county board meeting
- Patrick deegan: I was bluntly told to stay out of the landfill issue. Familiar with frank p long school. Previous media could be helpful.
- Hannah: please step back. No one is knocking on doors. Paying for dirty water. As an advocate in the community. I would like someone to contact sc doh to tell us how to proceed. Where are the notices that community knows about this issue.
- Patrick: we need media attention.
- Hannah: why we don’t have access the scdoh.
- Patrick: SCWA it all politics. Bc it’s billions dollars of involved
- Follow up on strategy needed regarding press, press conference, community outreach, attending Suffolk county board meetings: Mark, Devon, Dennis, Hannah want to follow up on strategy
- Feedback from DEC
- Potential press story in the works by Erica
- Follow up question by Jennifer: they did not answer if the town has to reach a certain slope before it closes.
- Grants we are trying to do something about our capacity needs like: comms, people to translate written and live meetings and outreach, media support
- We have bare bones right now but would love fourth and fifth eyes on this and editors. Reviewers/editors please
- Katy cleaned up the document.
- Next steps: cover letter and budget
- Christina is in the process of starting this one. reviewers/editors please
Actions:
8/11/2023 Agenda
Housekeeping:
- Host: LIPC
- Facilitator: Monique
- CoFacilitator Chat Monitor/Timekeeper:
- Notetaker 1:
- Notetaker 2:
- Participation on zoom - comment in the chat, stack, raise hand virtual or physical
- Participation off zoom landfillaction631@gmail.com, FB, IG, website soon come!
Acknowledgements & Housekeeping: (15 min 5:15 pm)
Check Ins (BLARG rest 9/29)
Updates:
- Could be helpful for remediation needs and closure
- Could possibly partner with Brookhaven NAACP
- #WeWontWaitTil28
- DEC Corrective Action
News beyond Long Island
Actions:
9/8/2023 Agenda
Housekeeping:
- Host: LIPC
- Facilitator: Abena
- CoFacilitator Chat Monitor/Timekeeper:
- Notetaker 1: Antonio
- Notetaker 2:
- Participation on zoom - comment in the chat, stack, raise hand virtual or physical
- Participation off zoom landfillaction631@gmail.com, FB, IG, website soon come!
Acknowledgements & Housekeeping:
- Introductions (names, pronouns, etc.) and reconnecting after BLARG’s break.
- Icebreaker: “How’re we dealing with the heat?”
- Staying indoors, going out, staying hydrated, AC and/or fans, sitting under the shade, enjoying it, spending time with others, swimming.
- Reflecting upon the BLARG break and our meetings.
Check Ins:
Updates:
- BLARG rest 9/29
- DEC Orders Corrective Action for Emerging Contaminants (PFAS/PFOA) in Brookhaven Landfill Plume.
- Excessive amounts of PFAS/PFOAs in the water supply, and local reporting and research has been highlighting this for years. Low income, Black, Latino, and Indigenous communities in Bellport have been feeling the effects of this for decades.
- More context on this issue was sent out via BLARG mailing list.
- Why have folks suddenly started reporting on the plume caused by the landfill more?
- According to the DEC letter, another plume formed. What about the costs to do this? The letter mentions the landfill closure and reclamation as a measure to improve environmental quality.
- The report also says the Town of Brookhaven must open an investigation within 60 days of receiving the letter, then test and develop a plan to improve the water quality.
- Afterwards, the Town of Brookhaven must have monthly meetings with the DEC about the steps they’re taking to reduce the contamination, but BLARG is requesting to make these meetings public. The letter would let the Town of Brookhaven host public hearings as late as 2025.
- Although the DEC letter sets precedent, it still doesn’t require a set deadline for the closure and cleanup for the landfill.
- The New York Times released a piece detailing groundwater overuse, which mentions Long Island:
Saltwater is encroaching on parts of the aquifers that provide drinking water for the three million people who live east of Queens and Brooklyn. The Suffolk County Water Authority has had to limit pumping at about 60 of its wells, or 10 percent of the total, according to Dan Dubois, a spokesman.
- Erica pushing out a press release related to the effects of the landfill, and if there’s anything BLARG would like to include, folks are encouraged to reach out.
- Local media have not reported on the landfill with urgency until recent months, nor have they done due diligence to promote the lived experiences of residents.
Community questions?
- BLARG wants to address questions that folks might have.
- Where can people get their water tested?
- PFAS and PFOAs have been found in residential wells, and despite tests being conducted on the water, residents have concerns about the testing.
- Store-bought test kits cannot detect these chemicals (what about store-bought filters removing PFAs?)
- When’s the actual closure of the landfill?
- Unofficial reports put the date back as far as 2028, but the permit itself is currently set to expire in 2026. The town has already reneged on its own timeline, which set the closure at 2024.
- How is it affecting fish use in Beaver Dam Creek?
- Website Meeting Tuesday 9/12 at 7pm
- Fish Fry Tomorrow (Saturday 9/9) at 2pm at the Bellport Community Garden
News beyond Long Island:
- Climate victories and setbacks this past summer.
- Held v. Montana (2023): Montanians win the right to a clean environment, lawsuit led by young climate organizers.
- #StopCopCity: Land defenders targeted in defense of Weelaunee Forest in Atlanta, 61 people indicted on RICO charges.
- African Climate Summit: Held in Nairobi, Nigeria, first ever event held on the continent, but several countries didn’t attend.
Actions:
- *Reach out to Christina via email to get involved with Fish Fry tomorrow afternoon. Set up starts at 1PM tomorrow.*
- Creating hybrid Town Hall event discussing the timeline of the environmental crisis in Brookhaven; BLARG intends on creating flyers and a speaker list. Members are encouraged to get involved as the process goes forward.
- Brainstorm how we can learn more about what people in South Country want to know more about or have access to related to the Landfill.
9/15/2023 Agenda
Housekeeping:
- Host: LIPC
- Facilitator: Monique
- CoFacilitator Chat Monitor/Timekeeper:
- Notetaker 1: Antonio
- Notetaker 2:
- Participation on zoom - comment in the chat, stack, raise hand virtual or physical
- Participation off zoom landfillaction631@gmail.com, FB, IG, website soon come!
Acknowledgements & Housekeeping:
Check Ins:
Updates:
- BLARG rest 9/29 (No meeting)
- Grants and fiscal sponsorship updates
- Compensating people for their labor, especially folks who are affected by the landfill, is important.
- We won a CHEJ Grant for $5,000.00. Our fiscal sponsor, Energy Justice Network, will be receiving the check soon. We have to see if they can send us the total $6,000.00 we’ve secured, but we need to find another sponsor to deposit it because EJN is facing compliance issues.
- We applied for another grant, and we’re reviewing other sponsors like Together We Can.
- LI Progressive Coalition sponsored us for a GNI Grant previously, but it has a smaller number of folks. This can affect the compliance requirements for the nonprofit work. Bob offered to help with the process, but figuring out capacity and labor might help.
- Building Bridges has mentioned supporting BLARG as a fiscal sponsor, but we need to figure out whether they’re in compliance.
- Website process is almost done–it’s been about a year given BLARG’s break! Soft launch for the website expected within a few weeks, just waiting for deliverables.
- Stay tuned for any upcoming meetings.
- GNI (Good Neighbors Initiative) call for support
- Created by local activist organizations on Long Island (groups like Pride for Youth, Women’s Diversity Network, etc.), GNI is meant to be a coalition of justice-oriented groups. It’s also meant to help secure funding for Long Island-based groups (which tend to receive less funds).
- BLARG is a member of the GNI, which has been meeting for over a year. We won the GNI Grant last year to help with our website development and composting program. We completed the first phase of work, but funds are short moving into 2024.
- Meets biweekly on Wednesdays via Zoom from 11 a.m. to 12:30 p.m., and GNI has developed a mission and shared principles. Much of this work will be voluntary given the lack of funds. Zoom retreat set for the end of the month (4hrs). Eventually, a social event to discuss the narrative of GNI will be set up.
- Although Abena and Monique have been going to meetings consistently, getting more members involved with the work is important. Reach out to Monique if you’d like to get involved.
- Eventually, GNI will be coming to BLARG event to discuss their narrative and work.
- DEC notice and public meetings
- DEC notified BLARG and the Town of Brookhaven about the corrective measures for remediation and closure. Brookhaven must notify local and county elected officials about the measures. Among the corrective measures include the closure of the landfill.
- Upon coming up with plans, the town must also meet with DEC officials.
- There aren’t many details about the public hearings required to take place.
- Monique has mentioned to DEC that Brookhaven continues to push the closure of the landfill to 2028, but the DEC hasn’t mandated a closure. The permit for operating the landfill runs to 2026.
- Brookhaven officials have attended BLARG events, but they continue to claim they don’t know about the landfill closure process. They have claimed to send staff members to the process, but it’s very disingenuous.
- Dave Colon (running against Ed Romaine) and Lillian Clayman running for Brookhaven Town Supervisor. Town Councilmembers may also be helpful to reach out to.
- Water testing: Addressing septic mismanagement and wastewater. Hildur aims to conduct tests on Manhasset Waterway. Overuse of fertilizers and their impacts on nitrogen. Illegal dumping of imported soil and waterways. Local waste disposal is an issue. Ash landfills are located generally in Babylon and Brookhaven.
- Bill mentioned previous stonewalling for more information on the industrial zone for the landfill by Brookhaven officials.
- Suffolk Meet the Candidates Night on 9/20; might be an opportunity for BLARG to turnout. There is a possible Q&A open to the public.
- BLARG is considering a public livestream on the DEC letter, corrective measures, etc. (aiming for 10/05). We would be able to post information, but BLARG is looking for members to get involved.
- What questions do people have?
- Instagram might be a better medium to attract more people, especially younger people.
- Reaching out to younger folks to get more engagement.
- Good local turnout to the event.
- Vegan and fish options with friers. We couldnt get a dedicated frier for the vegan fish, so we will have to find a better way next time.
- The event wasn’t free, but it had greater turnout than free events.
- Folks want to know more about the water quality.
- Dead fish in Beaver Dam Creek, and Suffolk Dept. of Health isn’t posting about it.
Actions:
- End Fossil Fuels Climate March this Sunday (at 1 o’clock
- Hearings this week to continue next week.
- 9/20 Southampton at 11 am
9/23/2023 Agenda
Housekeeping:
- Host: LIPC
- Facilitator: Monique
- CoFacilitator Chat Monitor/Timekeeper:
- Notetaker 1: Katy
- Notetaker 2:
- Participation on zoom - comment in the chat, stack, raise hand virtual or physical
- Participation off zoom landfillaction631@gmail.com, FB, IG, website soon come!
Acknowledgements & Housekeeping:
Check Ins:
Updates:
- BLARG rest 9/29 (No meeting) (1 min)
- Grants (10 min)
- Energy Justice is undergoing challenges and might be dissolving (might have happened yesterday), jeopardizing our fiscal sponsorship. We have approximately $5,000 in an account with them and are trying to find a new fiscal sponsor to whom we can transfer the money–which needs to happen ASAP. Mike Ewall recommended the accounting firm, Together We Can, in California. As an accounting firm they should be able to help us avoid any compliance issues and stay organized.
- Would take 6% (as opposed to Energy Justice’s 5%) for philanthropic grants, more for federal grants
- Just notified that we got a $5,000 grant from CHEJ (in addition to the $7,000 we got from the UU). We need a fiscal sponsor to get these funds.
- Applied this grant but, again, need a fiscal sponsor.
- Would like to use some of our grant funds to pay a webmanager
The work:
- Last year we took three weeks at the end of the year and the first week of January
- What’s the org effort look like for the next 4/5 months?
- Town Board Meetings (Oct 3rd at 5 pm & 10/19 at 2 pm) are televised and some members of the community do watch. Relatively easy way to reach people.
- Pumpkin patch/Smash pumpkins/Halloween movie night event at the garden (date TBD)
- Suffolk County legislature public meetings are on YouTube also and are a way to get on record (10/11 at 9:30AM).
- South Country school board meetings: On 10/11 at 6:15PM is a “business meeting” and on 10/25 at 6:15PM is a “workshop meeting”. These are also simple ways to reach a lot of people.
- Close garden sometime in November. Will need volunteers to clean up and prepare for spring.
- 2024 is approaching fast. What do we need to do to acknowledge the fact that we will not have full closure, remediation, accountability or a waste plan Billboard? Protest?
- We have made a real difference and can’t lose heart
- Laura Lesch and Dave Tarbell live in the lifecare community, Jeffersons Ferry, that Ed Romaine and Dave Calone will be visiting for a candidates’ forum on 10/16 at 7:30PM and would like help preparing questions.
- We got a rough estimate on how much a billboard would cost
- Should we launch it in Dec. or early Jan.?
- December folks may be in festive mood so it may be good to wait until January
- Possibly can launch the Billboard and rally around MLK Jr birthday or day
- Perhaps a missed opportunity to connect the landfill to the discussion about clean water happening right now. If anyone hears people organizing around clean water initiative, let’s try to uplift the impact of the landfill on our waters.
- Dennis will be meeting with a member of the Isrealites on Sunday who is interested in joining meetings with fellow members. They are also concerned community members.
- DEC Corrective measures mandate (30 min)
- Acknowledge the work that got us here: Kerim with his relentless efforts
- They added that one of the corrective measures the Town could take is to close the landfill. We should keep pressuring the DEC to impose the closure!!!
- DEC is apparently meeting the Town regularly and we are still trying to find out if these meetings are public. If so, we need to get to those meetings!
- DEC Letter to BLARG 8/8/2023
- DEC Letter to Town of Brookhaven 8/8/2023
- BLARG Press release 8/10/2023
- Submit Questions here
Actions:
- Continue to submit questions to the above form and share it with friends
- Join the Live discussion on FB 10/5/2023 at 7 pm to discuss what these corrective measures mean for the Town and for the people.
- Tell a friend to join the Live discussion
- Think broadly about questions but also think of specific questions about corrective measures
Closing:
10/6/2023 Agenda
Housekeeping:
- Host: LIPC
- Facilitator: Monique
- CoFacilitator Chat Monitor/Timekeeper:
- Notetaker 1:
- Notetaker 2:
- Participation on zoom - comment in the chat, stack, raise hand virtual or physical
- Participation off zoom landfillaction631@gmail.com, FB, IG, website soon come!
Acknowledgements & Housekeeping:
Check Ins: go around (15 min) 5:15 pm
Updates:
- BLARG Rest 10/27 (5 min) 5:20 pm
- December - January rest 3 weeks?
- Affirmations from Michelle and Mr. McNamara
- Onboarding Lynne into GNI
- Working on a presentation of our narrative that we built over the last year
- There will be a large launch of that narrative and hashtag in January
- Website designer will be coming on after the draft is complete
- Dennis affirmed looking forward to the
- Maya: met with our architect today
- Looking for a current image of the landfill if anyone has one please send it Maya
- Laura there are great images in the Newsday piece
- Fiscal Sponsorship and moving existing funds
- AIREF comments (15 min) 5:50
- Send a comment by 10/11 to Peter Fountaine
- DEC Corrective measures (20 min) 6:10 pm
- Review DEC notice to the Town on screen (5 min)
- Time to put together questions everyone submit at least one in the chat (capture on the google form) (15 min)
- Reach out to Monique to work on a possible way to carry forward a plan
Action:
- Newsday articles and series: possible doing something jointly with naacp Monday.
- Calling for an independent investigation (shared ask)
- Spread the word about this public press event
- 350 Horseblock Rd Yaphank, NY 11980
- Paul the reported looked through court files and did extra interviews. The court case has been public for years.
- We have been speaking about it for a long time. There is no wrong way to tell the truth. Our news people, civics are not comfortable telling the truth. It takes years for something that is public. Paul saw all of the things we put out, saw them read them and believed it. He did this work for a year and got it out there. His willingness to listen regardless of what and who
- Brookhaven NAACP award 11/2 5 pm
- Indigenous People’s day events happening on Shinnecock and Randall’s Island all weekend
- Recognize Indigenous People’s Day (5 min)
- Brookhaven Town Board meeting 10/19 5 pm
- Bring this issue to them
- Disrespectful town clerk. Treated the residents and speakers disrespectfully
- South country school board 10/11 6:15 pm & 10/25 6:15 pm
- Public meeting is a platform to let the public teachers, parents staff know what is going on and continue to push for them to relate to working on it in a real way
- Suffolk county board meeting 10/11 9:30 am
- Just Stop Unjust Stops
- Raise hell about the contamination of our groundwater from the landfill
10/13/2023 Agenda
Housekeeping:
- Host: LIPC
- Facilitator: Monique
- CoFacilitator Chat Monitor/Timekeeper:
- Notetaker 1:
- Notetaker 2:
- Participation on zoom - comment in the chat, stack, raise hand virtual or physical
- Participation off zoom landfillaction631@gmail.com, FB, IG, website soon come!
Acknowledgements & Housekeeping:
Check Ins: go around (15 min) 5:15 pm
BLARG Rest: 10/27
Debrief:
- Who was there?
- Who was not?
- Why?
- Where did you see media coverage?
- Anyone have Sunday’s paper?
- Leticia James office: Peter Washburn Policy Advisor and Lem Srolovic, the head of her Environmental Protection Bureau, to lead on this matter.
- 10/23-10/25 or 11/1 at 6:30 pm
- So far 10/23 and 10/25 is leading
Notes:
- Laura: great to be with everyone. Great speakers Monique and Abena press coverage was ok
- Monique: we got great press coverage. We are in communication with the AG office and have a meeting schedule for in person. I will need to supply them with a list of attendees so please let me know if you want to come. AG James won’t be there.
- Dennis: in person is good
- Hannah: thanks to Paul for the article. I can open the doors of My church
- Myrna: I love to see young kids there. When we take our children grandchildren it leaves a long lasting impression. It is those things that keeps the young people involved. I took pictures and sent them to Abena.
- Khadija: is there a location here in Bellport like the boys n girls club
- Dennis: boys n girls club is a good idea
- Monique: will explore that idea and maybe Bellport alliance
- Hannah: it disheartening that you have to get headlines to get any groups or people to come out.
Updates:
- Affirmations that the comment is great!
- Lynne: great work on the comments. do you think that these people read these in depth comments?
- Ezekiel: they are supposed to. That is something we think about in other circles too regarding leng
- MaryEllen: they have
- Monique: I don’t think we know the secret sauce. It is not made public what we need to have in public comments for them to do what it is we ask of them. Sometimes I like to write whatever I’m feeling because it’s therapeutic for me and I write it as raw as I feel it. Sometimes I think in long technical comments they pick them apart and give anecdotes for each thing and say they address the comment and totally disregard the point of the comment, which is to stop the plan permit or proposal.
- Grants & fiscal sponsorship
- Together We Can: we decided against
- Here is a list of fiscal sponsors we are looking to contact
- Any other potential Fiscal Sponsors
- Michelle: CCE or statewide NAACP
- Dennis: Brookhaven NAACP
- Reviewed what we got back from Albert
- Halloween party: Toy Story Terror!
- Anyone know how to get that movie to show it?
- Pot luck dish and bag of candy
- Decorations
- Do you have any?
- Can you help set up?
- Can you stay?
- What date Halloween weekend 27-29th
- So far a vote for Saturday (Dennis, Hannah Khadija can help, Mary Ellen will donate and possibly join, michelle vegetarian chili and some treats and can join, lynne can’t make it but can donate, have some mushrooms and other vegan friendly candy and dishes)
- Be on the lookout for the flyer
BLARG Vote: BLARG Rest 10/27 (5 min) 5:20 pm
- December - January rest 3 weeks?
- Multiple positive Affirmations
- Approved
Actions:
- Javien celebration 10/26 6 pm 2758 middle country rd lake grove
- Town of Brookhaven meeting 10/19 2 pm
- Brookhaven NAACP award 11/2 at 5pm Tickets $125
- S/o to Maya for organizing four tickets for BLARG members Hannah Dennis Monique and Kerim. Dennis wife is also going that they purchased independently
- New link!
- We have one person who submitted questions. Thank you Mark! Please keep it going...
- Building in a Series of TikToks until the end of the year
10/20/2023 Agenda
Housekeeping:
- Host: LIPC
- Facilitator: Monique
- CoFacilitator Chat Monitor/Timekeeper:
- Notetaker 1:
- Notetaker 2:
- Participation on zoom - comment in the chat, stack, raise hand virtual or physical
- Participation off zoom landfillaction631@gmail.com, FB, IG, website soon come!
Acknowledgements & Housekeeping:
BLARG Rest: 10/27
Check Ins: go around (15 min) 5:15 pm
LIVE Action:
Reach out to AG Leticia James 631 231-2424
Ask BLARG anything landfill, water or ej related.
Debrief/Report back:
- Press conference at the landfill part II
- Lynne: different from our press conference. All of the democratic candidates were there. Dozen guys that work at the landfill stood slightly threatening by our side. Getting riled up by the republican tracking. They asked why are we trying to close the dump. Aren’t you concern that the town doesn’t have a plan. They said the town does have a plan.
- MaryEllen: they got probably got sent out there
- Lynne: they were all tall and big
- Dennis: Charlie turcio has the biggest voice loud in the back. He was also at the January 6th. They encourage workers to do that. They did that at that meeting
- Monique: gave an update. STAT staff offered to work with us in the future on possible OpEds and other things
Updates:
- Hannah: offered two grants CHEJ and BEA Fund
- Laura: that’s a great idea or we can ask our church. Multicultural solidarity used a church in Nassau county.
- JD Allen: WSHU public radio use the newsroom to answer questions you all have. Rolled out this new blog on our site for space for asking one off questions or questions that need to FOIL or a deeper story.
- FAFE Amicus brief (Lynne, Hannah, Bill)
- This is finally moving forward Hannah, Bill, Lynne and Monique will help with supplying information for the amicus brief. Megan Carr from NYLPI will be the lead on this with support from EarthJustice
- Halloween/Scary/Pumpkin theme BLARG Movie Night 10/28/2023 6 pm; set up 5 pm
- Meeting with AG James office. Location being finalized. Agenda and asks being finalized.
Actions:
- Javien celebration 10/26 6 pm 2758 middle country rd lake grove
- Town of Brookhaven meeting: 11/9 5 pm
- South Country School board meeting:
- SC legislature meeting:
11/3/2023 Agenda
Housekeeping:
- Host: LIPC
- Facilitator: Katy
- CoFacilitator Chat Monitor/Timekeeper:
- Notetaker 1:
- Notetaker 2:
- Participation on zoom - comment in the chat, stack, raise hand virtual or physical
- Participation off zoom landfillaction631@gmail.com, FB, IG, website soon come!
Acknowledgements & Housekeeping:
BLARG Rest: 10/27
Check Ins: go around (15 min) 5:15 pm
LIVE Action:
Reach out to AG Leticia James 631 231-2424
Ask BLARG anything landfill, water or ej related.
Debrief/Report Backs:
Updates:
- GNI presentation 12/1
- Grants and Fiscal Sponsor update!
Special Update from our BLARG Website Designer: Amanda Rivera
Actions:
- Ceasefire and Humanitarian aid Rally Sunday 1-2:30 pm at resistance corner at port Jefferson station
- Town of Brookhaven meeting: 11/9 5 pm
- South Country School board meeting: Wednesday
- SC legislature meeting:
- Water Talk: November 16th Patchogue-Medford Library 54-60 Main St Patchogue, NY 11772 or virtual. Given by SCWA
- Mary Ellen plans to attend and ask about the two Plumes near the landfill and how that might affect the water. Are they monitoring them?
11/10/2023 Agenda
Housekeeping:
- Host: LIPC
- Facilitator: Lynne
- CoFacilitator Chat Monitor/Timekeeper:
- Notetaker 1:
- Notetaker 2:
- Participation on zoom - comment in the chat, stack, raise hand virtual or physical
- Participation off zoom landfillaction631@gmail.com, FB, IG, website soon come!
Acknowledgements & Housekeeping:
BLARG Rest: 11/24 & 12/15, 12/22, 12/29
Check Ins: go around (15 min) 5:15 pm
LIVE Action:
Ask BLARG anything landfill, water or ej related.
Debrief/Report Backs:
- Adelphi students interested met with graduate student Kelly Andreuzzi and Dr. Susan Kilgore, an ENV Professor and faculty advisor for EAC
Updates:
- Notes finally updated, please add/edit folks who attended there’s a place to add your notes :)
- Update from EarthJustice
- Fiscal Sponsorship: Grassroots Environmental Education, Inc
- Based out of Port Washington, NY (Long Island)
- Share many friends including our composting, environmental and climate buddies with Transition Town Port Washington
- Contact with grant funders and Action Center
- GNI Launch event scheduled for Sunday, January 14th 3 pm - 5 pm day before MLK Jr Day please make a plan to come and represent. More info to come…
- We will have a presentation on this the first week of December
Actions:
- Town of Brookhaven meeting: 11/16 2 pm
- LIPC: LI Climate, Jobs and Justice kickoff event Wednesday, November 15th at 12 pm; 35 Brooklyn Rd Hempstead, NY 11550:
- Focusing on DAC visioning/planning and electrifying our public school buses
- South Country School board meeting: Wednesday, November 15th at 6:15 pm
- Why the Scsd doesn’t believe they should intervene in the IDA tax breaks. When the school is a failing school
- South Country administration building 189 dunton Ave east Patchogue, NY 11772
- https://www.wshu.org/long-island-news/2023-11-03/north-bellport-ny-school-district-community-misinformed-taxes
- SC legislature meeting:
- Water Talk: November 16th 6:30 pm. Patchogue-Medford Library 54-60 Main St Patchogue, NY 11772 or virtual. Given by SCWA
- Mary Ellen plans to attend and ask about the two Plumes near the landfill and how that might affect the water. Are they monitoring them?
- Contact MaryEllen
- Mike Ewall: Sign on letter
- Context: Race-based issues at the root as to what happened. A group that was fiscal sponsored by us was asking for funds that they couldn’t justify. A computer and funds for a org’s spouse were things that got spun into race. Financial mismanagement. Tracy does books in excel. Tracy was working on migrating the work into quickbooks and she was close to finishing. Other orgs are also behind in their filings as well. Tracy’s computer and hard drive was stolen. She was accused of falsifying a police report. This all resulted in this getting spun into racism.
- Monique would like to know who w did not sign or made the accusation.
- Mike: Do not think it is good to give the name at this time
11/17/2023 Agenda
Housekeeping:
- Host: LIPC
- Facilitator:
- CoFacilitator Chat Monitor/Timekeeper:
- Notetaker 1:
- Notetaker 2:
- Participation on zoom - comment in the chat, stack, raise hand virtual or physical
- Participation off zoom landfillaction631@gmail.com, FB, IG, website soon come!
Acknowledgements & Housekeeping:
BLARG Rest: 11/24 & 12/15, 12/22, 12/29; 1/5
Check Ins: go around (15 min) 5:15 pm
Special presentation: Sunday, Nov. 26th 2:00 pm Intersection of Lewis St and South Broadway, Hicksville, NY(Northrop Grumman)
- Discussion on colonization and posting on socials/emails
- Learning and educational opportunities
LIVE Action:
Ask BLARG anything landfill, water or ej related.
Debrief/Report Backs:
- Mary Ellen: about public water, gave presentation that made it sound like the drinking water is safe. Mary Ellen emphasized that the plumes are spreading. Monique made the good point that they routinely pass off responsibility to the various regulatory agencies. They should bring up the landfill as often as possible. Unclear how much they are able to advocate against the town, but they do pass along information to the decision makers and might be able to exert positive influence. They seemed responsive and it’s important to keep applying pressure. ASked about the wells by the landfill and did got get a clear answer.
- Michelle attended with Bill, Kerim, and Lynn. IDA voted against the latest request
- Town Board meeting: no one here to report on this.
- Mike E. follow up: would like to call for a vote when more blarg members are here for discussion. Mary Ellen offers her support.
Updates:
- Will be sharing this out and possibly following up with a letter to Comptroller Thomas Dinapoli
Actions:
- Sunday, Nov. 26th 2:00 pm Intersection of Lewis St and South Broadway, Hicksville, NY(Northrop Grumman)
- Town of Brookhaven meeting:
- South Country School board meeting:
- Suffolk County legislative board meeting:
12/1/2023 Agenda
Housekeeping:
- Host: LIPC
- Facilitator: Lynne
- CoFacilitator Chat Monitor/Timekeeper:
- Notetaker 1:
- Notetaker 2:
- Participation on zoom - comment in the chat, stack, raise hand virtual or physical
- Participation off zoom landfillaction631@gmail.com, FB, IG, website soon come!
Acknowledgements & Housekeeping:
BLARG Rest: 11/24 & 12/15, 12/22, 12/29; 1/5
Check Ins: go around (15 min) 5:15 pm
Special presentation: Good Neighbors Initiative (GNI) Launch January 14th 3-5 pm Massapequa VFW. Encouraging BLARG members to attend it will be a good time with alot of networking.
Debrief/Report Backs:
- Adelphi Good outing. Positive reaction from students. We have been asked to come back
- Political endorsements
- LISSA
- Sierra Club Apologies for not looking into the candidates properly
LIVE Action:
- Ask BLARG: New link!
- Our website is LIVE!!! Landfillaction.org
Actions:
- Website Launch party!!! Next Friday? Library South Country or Brookhaven
- LIPA Public Power Act
- Support Ceasefire actions December 14 Hicksville Lisa will send info to Monique
- Town Board Meeting 12/19 @2pm if anyone wants to speak
- Lisa: Last meeting there it was packed because of an affordable housing project in Port Jefferson
- Lisa: This meeting going to talk about the task forces and committees especially the Women’s task force
- Why can't regular citizens go and read the minutes? No transparency. We need these committees running
12/8/2023 Agenda
Housekeeping:
- Host: LIPC
- Facilitator: Monique
- CoFacilitator Chat Monitor/Timekeeper:
- Notetaker 1: Monique
- Notetaker 2:
- Participation on zoom - comment in the chat, stack, raise hand virtual or physical
- Participation off zoom landfillaction631@gmail.com, FB, IG, website soon come!
Acknowledgements & Housekeeping:
BLARG Rest: 11/24 & 12/15, 12/22, 12/29; 1/5
Check Ins: go around (15 min) 5:15 pm
Adelphi pics: see slack blarg general
Updates:
- Website: landfilllaction.org
- Michelle: we should email our councilman asking them to put it on the town website as a reference/resource
- Laura: can we share the website
- Monique yes it is being shared so this is our soft launch. We will have a launch party to celebrate all those who worked on the website: Abena, Maya, Erica, Habiba, Mike, and the web designer Amanda
- Mike: letter to save energy justice network Wednesday 5 pm meeting. This meeting is for those who signed on already but welcome blarg to sign on still even though the letter was delivered. With poor reception from the board.
- The letter was delivered
- The new chair of ejn took a job with one of the largest oldest incinerators (wheelabrator) just after starting at ejn. This was pointed out and folks were shocked to hear this.
- GNI Launch event January 14th 3-5 pm
- We may possibly have a bus this will be a large celebratory event looking to have press as well. On the eve on Rev. Dr.MLK Jr birthday and holiday hope to bring out more people as a day of service
- Michelle: are you looking to bring more local groups in?
- Monique: yes looking to add more groups to use the hashtag
- Laura: I can possibly help do the BLARG table
- Microgrant $2,500 awarded
- Grant almost solely done by Christina. Even though she does not get on these calls she has been working and helped us secure four out of four grants this year!
- San Francisco, CA February 19-23
- Have asked Christina to go. She is deliberating and while she does that is there anyone else who can go if she cannot?
- Kahdija: I can possibly go
- Monique great we will connect off line
Actions:
- Don’t Blame Poor People 12/15 8-3:30 pm 74 Hauppauge Rd Commack, NY 11725 Suffolk Y Jewish Community Center $35
- Monique will be holding down a workshop for blarg called Environmental devastation and poverty time and details of the workshop still being worked out. Stay tuned. Who can go?
- Khadija may be there!
- Myrna is going. You have to pre register before the event or you won’t be able to get in
- Michelle please share the time of the BLARG workshop so I can go at that time.
- Bill: I know we talked about this before but can we get tshirts with something about what we are about and racism
- Monique: was thinking about this now that we have funding want to double back to this and get tshirts out there to share our message and unify us maybe put the website on it and have them ready for the website launch
- Website Launch party!!! January/February…
- Call Hochul: 877-559-7809
- Email your representative: https://actionnetwork.org/letters/tell-your-reps-to-reimagine-lipa
- Join phone bank 12/12 6 pm
- Support Ceasefire actions December 14 Hicksville Lisa will send info to Monique
- Town Board Meeting 12/19 @2pm
- Bill, Lisa, Khadija
- Romaines last board meeting as a supervisor should be fun times
- The Tri-Coalition Just Stop Unjust Stops Campaign will partner with Spin The Yard to host an educational community event focused on the inequitable and ineffective traffic enforcement strategy employed by Suffolk County Police. Thursday, December 14th 6 pm 1529 Straight Path Wyandanch, NY 11798 RSVP tinyurl.com/TrafficEvent
- Khadija: EFWA they asked about the composting and tumbler.
- Monique: we have a scale and tumbler for them we just need to give that tutorial yo ensure we are giving them the tools to succeed. We will connect offline
- Bill: Bellport playhouse all month of December ice skating: Olympic skater Nancy Kerrigan will be skating. Bill’s granddaughter Shannon Gibbons will be singing!
- Michelle: Shannon has a beautiful voice
- Michelle: January 21st afternoon featuring The Bow of Hiroshima prof. Karl Grossman can BLARG share this?
- Monique: I think we can we would just need to touchbase with Abena
- Myrna: Supporting Ceasefire Actions and other justice actions around Long Island. As tired as we all are put one foot in front of the other and keep going!
__________________________________________________________
2024 Notes
__________________________________________________________
1/12/2024 Agenda
Housekeeping:
- Host: LIPC
- Facilitator: Monique
- CoFacilitator Chat Monitor/Timekeeper:
- Notetaker 1:
- Notetaker 2:
- Participation on zoom - comment in the chat, stack, raise hand virtual or physical
- Participation off zoom landfillaction631@gmail.com, FB, IG, landfillaction.org
Acknowledgements & Housekeeping:
BLARG Rest: 1/26/2024
Check Ins: go around (15 min) 5:15 pm
Updates:
- Brookhaven landfill to remain open to both ash and C&D per Supervisor Dan Panico
- What response does this warrant?
- Abena: We here were not surprised. We would have been aware of a plan for closure. I was interested in getting a bunch of emails from folks expressing shock about it. That helped me to see that. It may be helpful to talk more with people beyond on our blarg space. What does it take? Who could come on and help us understand what it takes to close a landfill. Of course it was a lie. It is an obvious and clear lie. What is the way a landfill actually closes?
- Marc F: in Smithtown, taught ecological design and worked with folks who work on the Staten Island landfill that has become a nature conservancy. Extinction rebellion will be a great ally theres not a chapter on long island but I have started one.
- Monique: we use the staten island as a model and the shirley chisholm
- Matthew: would like to have a XR chapter closer to here
- Laura: I was heartbroken. I appreciate Abena’s words and I still felt let down. I think it is more important than ever to keep the pressure on them. I understand that it may not be time to put our bodies in front of trucks. Think about the MLK Letter of Birmingham
- Khadija: the disappointment should give us more energy to continue the fight. It is political and the only thing is to be persistant
- MaryEllen: what should be our plan forward. Should we be doing that? Or is that not our place? Panico said one of his biggest things is development, which means there will be more waste if it doesnt go to this landfill where will it go? Appeal to the people.
- Monique: the question of who job it is for this plan. We have always had the stance that it is for us to push the electeds for the plan and it is not up to us to make the plan. There may be some shift but ultimately that is where I believe we are.
- Bill: They don’t listen to me even though they always says thank you for your service. In 1978 i worked for town of huntington snowplowing.
- Michelle: I'm thinking I like the idea of XR and try to enlarge the number of voices to help us. Beyond on Plastics is inviting our participation because we live within 10 miles from Covanta in Ronkonkoma. They are asking us to sign on to packaging reduction bill. Maybe we meet with our electeds. I’m glad
- AG James sent a letter to the court informing the judge that the NYSDEC investigation is not yet complete and asked the judge to hold off judgment until after the Dec report is complete, which they believe will be done January 19th.
- Fiscal sponsorship has been secured and all money was approved to be transferred to the fiscal sponsor.
- Outreach and Inreach main focus (winter survival campaign), tech id focus (website etc), advocacy small focus (zero waste coalition, waste coalition and training)
- Monique: looking to have tshirts to help with InReach and out multimedia approach. Hannah is also leading us with a winter survival campaign in north Bellport for the next few months.
- Maya: tshirts so wasteful. We made tshirts using tshirts alredy in circulation rather than buying new ones
- Marc: flyering is better
- Laura: The tshirts have value as far as advertising. I would where one all over the place. I don’t know about handing them out randomly. They have to be for people who will use them for what they are intended for.
- Bill: I belong to SCPG and Veterans for peace, we have parkas tshirts buttons. I wear my shirt bc it is part of my identity
- Dennis: maybe we can have a QR code on the tshirt
- Monique: thank you for feedback we can table the decision for now. We just continue have a struggle with our InReach. We have done tabling, and do a good job getting the word out and support outside of north Bellport. Hannah is moving we will need more support with our InReach plan. If it is not tshirts what is it?
- NAACP filed a lawsuit against the town “Article 78” regarding the Yaphank Waste Transfer Station they recently found out that they lost and are preparing to file an appeal. Should we ask EarthJustice to file an amicus brief for us for this case?
- Clean Deliveries Act in the news. Something we signed onto last year. Update is there will be a press event on Long Island in February. The Youth chapter of the NAACP is signing on to this as well as the organizers there were the lead organizers on the Save Cleveland Park campaign to stop a warehouse from taking over the Cleveland Park space and won that battle with help from the AG Letiticia James office.
- Zero Waste NY Coalition
- Continuing to work post NYSDEC Solid Waste Management Plan
- Working on infrastructure of the coalition
- Membership form
- Do we want to formally join?
- Laura: i think it is good to have BLARG on this group
- Iman: I remember from my past work on grants. The biggest part is networking. Went to a lot of conferences. The funding we got I spent on spreading the word. The NY Conference in May.
- Mike: EPA has a new rule to regulate large trash incinerators. Of the three Long Island trash incinerators that send ash to Brookhaven, Covanta Hempstead is more than twice the size of the other two, and is missing the control system to reduce emissions of mercury and dioxins. If this rule makes them install it, it means less mercury and dioxins in the air, but more in the ash, making the ash more toxic. It also increases dioxins, but puts them in the ash. We may want to weigh in to comment. We could just say shut incinerators down? It’s a lose-lose situation. See:
- Mike: Energy Justice Network is still alive. After the parent organization, Action Center, Inc., board voted in September 2023 to dissolve the nonprofit, 31 Energy Justice Network member groups wrote in November to the three remaining board members who wanted to dissolve, calling for them to step down and appoint directors from membership in their place. See the strongly-worded letter here. The board members refused. In the past week, Energy Justice Network members met and voted unanimously to leave Action Center, Inc. and incorporate as an independent nonprofit organization, which was filed on 1/11/2024. Back in November, we learned that the Action Center, Inc. board chair was working for the parent company of Wheelabrator, the nation’s 2nd largest trash incinerator company, without telling the group, even though Energy Justice Network has long worked to fight this company, nearly forcing their Baltimore plant to close in 2020.
Actions:
- January 14th GNI launch event Massapequa
- January 15th Rev MLK Jr Day 12 pm 1550 Franklin Ave Mineola, Nassau Legislature Liberation From Congo to Palestine
- MLK Event with Leticia James at 6pm Huntington
- Marc: New group forming calling for a Ceasefire January 19th 4-6 Andrew Garbarino office 31 Oak st Patchogue. Looking for sign ons.
- Open to all religions, all groups calling for a Ceasefire.
- Monique: Thank you for sharing we have been in contact with Vincent about this and I asked him to come on the call to share more information, so I am glad you are on to share this. Is this linked to democratic party, are there any Palestinian groups involved? Not linked to democratic party
- Kerim: I would hope that Schumer will be apart of who we would call on for a Ceasefire
- Marc: Patchogue was the most central place to start first.
- Michelle: We are signed on to this as well as North Country Peace Group
- Laura: affirmed us signing on
- Why this is important: so far I have been a part of one of the advising cohorts (the NYSERDA Founding Steering Committee Equity Collaborative) on this plan and so I know that they are planning to include waste industry as a priority in the state. Also, the metro area of NYC-Long Island-New Jersey also applied but I don’t know those plans. However, the CPRG main function is to reduce GHG in DACs and since the town of Brookhaven will more than likely use us if they go after this money I thought it might be good to hear more about the program from a waste reduction advocacy perspective and possibly find out what we can do
- Please review what we have so far. Please add suggestions in the doc
- There is the air permit public comment period ending soon not sure if anyone has bandwidth to add comments
- There is the DAC investment and Reporting public comment period
- Think we should add a comment that communities used in to obtain grants must be partners or share decision making authority and provided a budget for independent consulting & education
FYI:
Closing:
Happy Dr. Rev. Martin Luther King Jr. weekend, day and birthday! May he continue to rest in power!
1/19/2024 Agenda
Housekeeping:
Acknowledgements & Housekeeping:
BLARG Rest: 1/26/2024
Check Ins: go around (15 min) 5:15 pm
Updates:
- Report back from MLK day weekend
- GNI #WeAreLongIsland launch event
- Successful, newsday and LI Herald attended 100 attendees showed up in less than ideal traveling weather
- A call to have more LI based orgs join us in sharing the hashtag and joining the organizing hub
- Report back from meeting at CEED
- No one on the call attended
- Mission statement:
- BLARG possibly joining to work on zero waste planning in New York with other groups impacted by waste industry
- Received affirmations no blocks
Actions & Solidarity work:
Sierra Leone https://www.change.org/p/call-for-urgent-international-intervention-in-sierra-leone
Suffolk Ceasfire
https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSfO2ESGdz6kspY4KZ-fZnv7vQBqpJrtYQNiurw2CBqi0f5YBQ/viewform
Erica: Plastic Pollution: want to uplift the work of BLARG focus on plastic pollution from when plastics are extracted. GAIA is a member organization. Members
- No obligation fill in member
- Send our email blasts
- We can put blarg events on our calendar
- Plasticpollutioncoalition.org/join
- Khadija: affirmed our membership
- Monique: we posted about the movie seaspiracy, so wanted to uplift that here just saw we can have a discussion about it. We are not a vegan group but we do understand that myself and others are vegan so we have been vegan friendly or forward and just wanted to talk about the fishing industry and things we saw with plastic pollution in that movie.
- Erica: we do emphasize plant based but are conscious of different cultures that fish and other marine life as a big part of their diet for many indigenous communities…
- Dr. Robert Bullard. We will be meeting with him
- Monique: Nicholas St Fluer did a podcast regarding the health impacts of the Brookhaven landfill and Dr. Robert Bullard said we are a “textbook case of environmental racism” see our acknowledgements above.
Ezekiel: li for policing accountability, LI united, ??? People’s plan for
- They did not adopt the peoples plan they adopted their own policy. Police advisory was ultimately. Yesterday was first meeting for all the precincts in suffolk. They created the group and now they are hands off. This was created to give us a way to communicate with the police dept. But wont give us any support with organizing it after that. There are 60 people. This is a chaotic system. We have advocates in precinct in 2, 6 coram and 7 Mastic/shirley. We have people who are supporters of the police and advocates so we will have to work with them
- Lynne: I heard that police do not have to report stops
- Ezekiel: Suffolk County has been mandated to report stops. Not sure about the rest of the state. It has been hard to get accurate data.
- Monqiue: can you tell us about the events you held in wyandanch
- Ezekiel: We held this event with Spin the Yard. we presented the report that we analyzed about the report. I have those numbers from three out of the seven districts. We are doing another event in wyandanch feb 20th 6 pm. We would love to find a space in bellport event. We are not able to pursue legislation in suffolk at this time but we are hoping that by pursuing a
Khadija:
Sierra Leone: There was an election in June. There were monitor the incumbent president claimed he won. Everyone said that he did not win. The struggle there is that he is killing people who speak out. The people are being silenced. We started a petition for folks to sign. There are pictures that are very graphic we tried to not share the ones that were too graphic.
Tabling opportunity:
- South country library 3/20 11-2 pm
2/2/2024 Agenda
Housekeeping:
Acknowledgements & Housekeeping:
- Khadija shared a petition for international intervention in Sierra Leone: https://www.change.org/p/call-for-urgent-international-intervention-in-sierra-leone Mike suggested redirecting to a google form to capture signers’ information, as well as additional tactics
- Tonawonda Nation fighting infringements on their sovereignty
- LIPC public power bill introduced in NYS legislature, possibility of getting bipartisan support on LI
- Support for the local peace groups’ actions
- 2/9 7pm training in Massapequa office for safety while protesting
BLARG Rest: 2/23/2024
Check Ins: go around if small crew (15 min) 5:15 pm
Report back/Debrief:
- DEC corrective measure meeting with the DEC hosted by the BVA January 22nd
- Same old story (song-and-dance, finger pointing, etc.), good attendance at BVA. Still no public meetings with DEC and town.
- The Intercept is doing a story on the landfill
- Has already spoken to Abena, Kerim, Hannah. Contact info is available.
- Re: reining in IDA, negative impact on school district. Need an angle for auditing the IDA. Suggestion of legal action and/or go to Gov. Hochul. Legal aspect could be under-assessment, resulting in artificially low PILOTs.
- Hofstra students and interns – public health students
- Possibly want to help with grant reporting and grants
- Possibly want to help with reviewing a report and giving executive summaries
- Possibly want to help with website mgmt
Updates:
- The DEC pushed back their investigation report on the Covanta whistleblower case. The AG’s office sent the judge in the case another letter asking for another month.
- Statewide Zero Waste Coalition
- Helping them to apply for the CHEJ grant for a statewide retreat to plan a strategy for zero waste (grant will be for a strategic planning retreat) anticipated April day of action
- John McNamara reported on Alameda County zero waste efforts/pay as you throw, what could work here. Lynne will research efforts in a different town. Mike shared resources on pay as you throw in the footnotes and narrative on pages 16-17 in this report: https://www.energyjustice.net/md/beyond.pdf Monique mentioned caveats about equity
BLARG Vote:
- Becoming a member of plastic pollution
- Anyone know if there is a follow up to the action
Mike had a few items:
EPA has public meeting coming Wednesday, Friday is EPA something else
Ezikiel reporting on work on precinct-level police advisory boards, also hosting a know-your-rights seminar 2/20 1529 Straight Path, Wyandanch
Actions & Solidarity Work
- Tonawanda Nation opposes the STAMP project as it infringes on their indigenous sovereignty and is an environmental injustice to the people of the Tonawanda nation and to the land
- Remember to support efforts and the lives of the people of Sierra Leone and their democratic process
- Shinnecock Nation: protecting the environment and their sovereignty have two requests to save beech tree and protect Shinnecock sovereignty
- to help support activists with food, water, fire wood and water resistant clothing and other needs.
- LIPA Public Power Act
- Protesters Rights Training at LIPC office 90 Pennsylvania Ave Massapequa NY 11758
- North Country Peace Group Calling for a Ceasefire and demilitarization standing protest Saturdays at 12 pm North Country Rd Setauket, NY 11733
- South Country Peace Group standing protest Saturdays at 12 pm South Country Rd, Bellport, NY 11713
- Closing: “Through the demise my heart is still alive. It looks awful outside, but it’s still worth a try” ~ Yasiin Bey
2/9/2024 Agenda
Housekeeping:
Acknowledgements/Housekeeping & Actions:
Acknowledgements via actions:
- Land Acknowledgement: Indigenous Sovereignty
- Shinnecock: Beech Tree
- Sierra Leone: petition
- Ceasefire in Gaza: Protestors Training today at LIPC office at 7 pm
- Black Lives Matter/Honoring George Floyd: LIU & Spin The Yard et. al/Ezekiel is hosting a know-your-rights seminar 2/20 1529 Straight Path, Wyandanch
- North Bellport: Winter Survival Campaign launching this week. Reach out to Hannah
- Environmental Justice: DAC Reporting Guidance doc submit comments requesting an extension:
- Sample language:
To: Commissioner Basil Seggos
New York State Department of Environmental Conservation
625 Broadway
Albany, New York 12233-1550
CEO and President Doreen M. Harris
New York State Energy Research and Department Authority
17 Columbia Circle
Albany, NY 12203-6399
CC:
Director Alanah Keddell-Tuckey
Office of Environmental Justice
New York State Department of Environmental Conservation
625 Broadway, Albany, New York 12233-1550
February 9, 2024
Dear President Harris, Commissioner Seggos, and Director Keddell-Tuckey,
I am a member of Brookhaven Landfill Action and Remediaiton Group (BLARG) and I am writing to request a comment submission deadline extension on the proposed Disadvantaged Communities Investments and Benefits Reporting Guidance. As indicated in NY State's Final Scoping Plan, interagency coordination and consultation with affected communities to ensure the effective delivery of these resources to disadvantaged communities will be critical to their success. BLARG is a grassroots group in the heart of Brookhaven Census tract identified as a disadvantaged community. We do not see any interagency coordination or consultation with this process. The webinar was insufficient as many of our members were not able to attend and ask their own questions. While the current submission deadline is by close of business on March 15th, we at BLARG would like to request an extension until April 5th, 2024 formally.
- Other Actions:
- North Country Peace Group Calling for a Ceasefire and demilitarization standing protest Saturdays at 12 pm North Country Rd Setauket, NY 11733
- South Country Peace Group standing protest Saturdays at 12 pm South Country Rd, Bellport, NY 11713
- LIPA Public Power Act Fill out postcard to show your support
- Transition Town Port Washington asked us to speak with their youth interns. It will be a Monday at 3:30 pm either April 15th, 29th or May 13th
- Use the hashtag #WeAreLongIsland
BLARG Rest: 2/23/2024
Check in: New folks, folks who haven't been on, any other actions or agenda items
Report Back/Debriefs:
Updates:
Closing:
2/16/2024 Agenda
Housekeeping:
BLARG Rest: 2/23/2024
Check ins
Acknowledgements in actions:
- Land Acknowledgement: Indigenous Sovereignty (15 min)
- SBU students BDS & sign on letter
Monique:
Abena: students at SBU recognizing the ways the university is connected to supporting the mass murder of Palestinians
Bob: what is BDS
Abena:
Christine: BDS website Boycott Divest Sanction
Abena: this is asking folks to step in to use a means which is peaceful and our wealth to try to shift things in this area. Show is real that this is unacceptable. How does BLARG think about escalation? New tactics when trying to deal with issues that are intractable and hard to address
Bob:
- Black Lives Matter & Honoring George Floyd acknowledgement: (5 min)
- LIU & Spin The Yard et. al/Ezekiel is hosting a know-your-rights seminar 2/20 1529 Straight Path, Wyandanch
Update Nassau county leadership deputy commissioner and other sergeants. We showed them their arrest disparities. They are trying to counter our data analysis with their own. They are open dialogue to and working in both counties.
Christine: are they releasing data
Ezekiel: Suffolk county is more transparent and just released a new report today. Nassau is giving data on arrest
Monique: maybe Bellport alliance will be up for a Know Your Rights session
Ezekiel: may be able to get into the schools 25 schools across the island girls inc
Bob: you said Suffolk is better at reporting?
Ezekiel: 2014 federal investigation against them thats why they are “better” Suffolk County PD Traffic data
Fed govt doing a poor job of monitoring and holding them accountable for compliance
Bob: is race data they report on
- North Bellport: (20 min)
- Khadija is taking on representing BLARG at GAIA membership meeting/conference in San Francisco the week of Feb 19th. GAIA is paying for accommodations.
How do we get to a scalable zero waste plan
What does it take to close a landfill responsibly
What does it take to close an incinerator? We have four on Long Island and ten in New York State the highest in the country
Corrective measures on the second plume
Covanta whistleblower case
- Winter Survival Campaign launching this week. We are waiting on some of the funds from our grants to get this going. Reach out to Hannah
- Getting back to the Garden 4/20 for Earth Day!
Iman and Khadija will kickstart us on this day
Add to calendar
Healthcare education project works alongside 1199 May be able to support
- Environmental Justice: (20 min)
- Call to action:
Call office of Basil Seggos: 518-402-8545
- Commissioner of the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC)
Call Sean Maher: 518-402-8560
- Executive Deputy Commissioner
Call David Vitale: 518-402-9401
- Division Director ; Division of Materials Management
Script:
“I am _____ calling from _____. I am calling to express my concern about the letter sent to the Town of Brookhaven from the NYS Department of Conservation dated August 8, 2023.
This letter was sent to the Town of Brookhaven notifying the Town of Brookhaven of a mandate calling for “corrective measures” in the matter of the second plume that was discovered back in 2017.
In that letter it states: “The corrective measures assessment must include a list of possible corrective measures including, but not limited to, landfill closure in accordance with 6 NYCRR Part 363-9 and landfill reclamation in accordance with 6 NYCRR Part 363-11, and an assessment of the effectiveness of each corrective measure.”
I believe this is the corrective measure that the town must take. I believe the closure and remediation must come with no less than a comprehensive zero waste management plan that achieves environmental justice and open inclusive public meetings through the closure, remediation and zero waste planning process. I believe that this must start immediately to ensure least harm through this process.”
- More Actions:
- North Country Peace Group Calling for a Ceasefire and demilitarization standing protest Saturdays at 12 pm North Country Rd Setauket, NY 11733
- South Country Peace Group standing protest Saturdays at 12 pm South Country Rd, Bellport, NY 11713
- LIPA Public Power Act Fill out postcard to show your support share the toolkit
- Transition Town Port Washington asked us to speak with their youth interns. It will be a Monday at 3:30 pm either April 15th, 29th or May 13th
- Use the hashtag #WeAreLongIsland
- Albany Actions
- EPR Bill Advocacy day in Albany feb 27th
- Poor Peoples campaign March 2nd
- NY Renews Climate Jobs and Justice March 20th RSVP here: bit.ly/mobilize_march_20 share the toolkit
Report Back/Debriefs:
- Latino Justice - Was a great meeting. Present were Abena, Monique, and Lynne. LatinoJustice looking to partner with community organizations and offer help using legal instruments (including but not limited to litigation) as part of community-based environmental justice campaigns. Next step: open meeting with individuals and community organizations to learn more about the different legal instruments that may be available and how to leverage them to deal with the range of issues associated with the Landfill.
- CD2 congressional run: meeting at south country club, candidate Lisa Desanto (?) facts-driven. Dem endorsed candidate (Rob Lubin) is not knowledgeable about district. Regardless, Gaberino will be hammered by Desanto facts in primary debate.
Updates:
Closing:
3/1/2024 Agenda
Housekeeping:
BLARG Rest: 3/29/2024
Check ins: Name, pronouns and land acknowledgment in the chat
Acknowledgements in actions:
- Land Acknowledgement: Indigenous Sovereignty (13 min)
- SBU students BDS & sign on letter
Last week’s discussion:
- Monique: We have been sharing ceasefire actions here on BLARG and haven’t formally signed on to anything thus far. This SBU BDS sign on letter is in a sense a step further than ceasefire solidarity and wanted to make that distinction and formally sign on to what the students at SBU is doing and why they are doing it. Abena has been supportive in this effort and can give us so more info
- Abena: students at SBU recognizing the ways the university is connected to supporting the mass murder of Palestinians
- Bob: what is BDS
- Christine: BDS website Boycott Divest Sanction
- Abena: this is asking folks to step in to use a means which is peaceful and our wealth to try to shift things in this area. Show is real that this is unacceptable. How does BLARG think about escalation? New tactics when trying to deal with issues that are intractable and hard to address
BLARG Vote: Can we sign on?
- All Affirmation.
- Black Lives Matter & Honoring George Floyd acknowledgement: (2 min)
- Centering North Bellport: (20 min)
- Khadija report back on the GAIA membership meeting/conference in San Francisco the week of Feb 19th.
Thank you for allowing me to take this trip. It was a unique opportunity to meet GAIA and the member org. I learned so much information. I so excited to share. I have so many power points. It was an honor to be with them. We heard from an org that was successful in shutting down the incinerator in their area. I was introduced to a filmmaker who is interested in the closure of the landfill so hopefully they will reach out to us. The main topic is zero waste. What I learned is to get to close landfill incinerators and other manufacturing facilities that are polluting communities. Stop the manufacturing all the things that are causing the pollution. I wish you all were there. I made a lot of connection and a lot of sharing. I keep getting emails for things that may pertain to us or not. There are too many warehouses popping up in our area.
- Many thank yous in the chat
- Will continue to follow up on the leads and opportunities that manifest over time
- Winter Survival Campaign. Funds were finally secured for this program. Reach out to Hannah
Monique: many challenges in getting this going but doing our best
- ALCC to kickoff 4/20
We need a flyer
- Monique: Iman started a flyer
- Khadija: Potluck need more people involved
- Monique: Hildur please ask Paul to do Bokashi training at the garden. Will follow up
Monique: Hofstra intern,Bobby Kang, is excited to help get some materials together regarding our composting program.
Monique: Composting rap song from a man from Baltimore
- Environmental Justice: (5 min)
- Our Live call to action emails to get the DAC reporting guidelines pushed back was granted to April 5th! Thank you all! Our calls and emails do matter
- Call to action: to Basil Seggos two weeks ago about the DEC “corrective measures” was apparently the last straw for him and got him to send out his notice of resignation effective after the budget session, which is due April 1st 2024; lol :)
- Environmental racism: (5 min)
- Ed Romaine, Dan Panico, Gov. Hochul and others all white got together to celebrate a $4.5 million grant the town received to revitalize North Bellport. In the words of Hannah Thomas this has all the markings of a “design of white supremacy’ in the making. The Greater Bellport Coalition got together to hear what the community would like to see. Dennis attended the meeting and reported the SC leg Dominick Thorne will be putting together an advisory group. Lets see who is on it…
Dennis: attended the Greater Bellport Coalition meeting and wanted to know where the money is going for. I was hoping that we could get an adult center for the seniors. There was a gentleman who want to start a mentorship program. Our kids from the 6th grade are struggling. Co chair Regina for an adult center we will need more money. We don’t need a bagel shop
- Monique: this could be a renewable energy hub and even an cooling center.
- Hildur: I work for cornell coop regional clean energy hub. Funds are available. We can connect offline
- Dennis: it will be best to connect with GBC they are the gatekeepers
Report Back/updates: (25 min)
- Monique: Sent Bobby and prof. Martine from Hofstra the DEC investigative report and he will be pulling some key points to highlight on our socials and other forms of communication. Anyone interested in doing a short tiktok please let me know. I will be meeting with Bobby on Monday I will probably hit you all up about them in the coming weeks
- Thoughts reflection
- Lynne: the amount of media attention we have gotten. The quotes from people having no concern for their fellow human beings. Maybe the EC will be held accountable
- Laura: if the DEC is finding that will the AG office.
- Monique: 3/14 4:30 pm meeting with the AG for site visits and discussion to follow. Location TBD. Hannah did offer the space at her church again. Anyone able to help us secure a location in Bellport please do so. Anyone available to come please let me know.
- Monique: media coverage has been great. Paul LaRocca investigative journalist at Newsday has stayed in contact as well. We were not able to get responses in before his deadline. For me I am really looking for information that is new and furthers our point. This information about violations is what we have been saying so we still need more.
- Monique EarthJustice continues to share pertinent information on how this affects the court proceedings.
- SBU Sunrise Movement is starting to get active and is having an Indigenous panel 4/25 I will be speaking on the panel not sure of the details and if it will be open to the public or just students. They also want to do zero waste initiatives in the school getting plastic out of the school and reaching out to us. Anyone want to help there please let me know (Barbara Coley, Abena, Katy, Myrna, Bob)
- Laura is willing to work with the youth
- Amicus brief filed on our behalf through NYLPI, New York lawyers for the Public Interest, (Megan Carr) and EarthJustice, (Rachel) the Fresh Air For Eastside case regarding the first case using the NYS green amendment entitling New Yorkers to clean air and clean water filed by the Macedon Periton, Penfield, Walcott’s community impacted by local landfill case. Along with us is South Bronx Unite and southeast Queens Residents Environmental Justice Coalition
- We work with EarthJustice on many things and Clean Air Action Network is apart of the zero waste statewide coalition working on statewide waste mgmt planning that we are a member of.
- Monique: gave an overview and requested folks review and see if there’s any blocks in us signing next week.
- Transition Town Port Washington asked us to speak with their youth interns. It will be a Monday at 3:30 pm either April 15th, 29th or May 13th
- North Country Peace Group Calling for a Ceasefire and demilitarization standing protest Saturdays at 12 pm North Country Rd Setauket, NY 11733
- South Country Peace Group standing protest Saturdays at 12 pm South Country Rd, Bellport, NY 11713
- Albany Actions (5 min)
Closing:
3/8/2024 Agenda
Housekeeping:
BLARG Rest: 3/29/2024
Check ins: Name, pronouns and land acknowledgment in the chat
BLARG Vote:
- We work with EarthJustice on many things and Clean Air Action Network is apart of the zero waste statewide coalition working on statewide waste mgmt planning that we are a member of. Advocates of Clean Air Action have dug in on biosolids which is
Acknowledgements in actions:
Special session on AG visit:
- What sites; how long at each:
- Brookhaven Landfill (4:30 pm)
- Yaphank Waste Transfer Station (4:45 pm)
- Horizon Village (5 pm)
- Frank P. Long Memorial (5:15 pm)
- HELP Suffolk (5:30 pm)
- Chris Hobson Bill Neal Community Garden (5:45 pm)
- Boys And Girls Club Bellport (6 pm)
- 471 Atlantic Ave Bellport, NY 11713
- What questions do we have?
- What can the AGs office do differently than DEC?
- What do others think we need to ask?
Actions:
- We have supported this effort so just want to see if folks are ok with us submitting this memo of support and if you want to do one for your organization feel free.
Closing:
4/5/2024 Agenda
Housekeeping:
BLARG Rest: 4/26/2024
Check ins: Name, pronouns and land acknowledgment live
Acknowledgements in actions:
- Land Acknowledgement: Indigenous Sovereignty (13 min)
- Shinnecock Teach in
- Black Lives Matter & Honoring George Floyd acknowledgement: (2 min)
- Anti Landfill Composting Collective is set to start 5/25/24. We will be acknowledging and honoring the life of George Floyd. We will have a teach in on the cycle of food provided by the Healthy Education Project and we will have volunteers from faith based leader
- North Bellport acknowledgement
- InReach (Flyering for both events) Volunteers needed
- Senior Center Desired for the community we as BLARG will support.
- Biwen Liu (Stony Brook University undergrad students wants to interview ppl on 4/20 at the garden
- Environmental Justice:
- Town of Babylon Regional Waste study 17 principles of EJ
Tom Vetri and Jassi Annan former student at Pratt. Now a subcontractor for the Town
Monique asked that the symposium be held so community members can attend
- Environmental racism
- Town Board Resolution #2024-270 “Home Rule Message of Support to the New York State Legislature on Behalf of S. 5215/A. 5365 Authorizing Alienation of Parkland to Allow Rail Access in Yaphank” Put forward by Dean Murphy allows an easement on green area that has been set aside. Was voted on yesterday. John MCNamara attended
- The board meeting Mr Panico stated it was a done deal.
Calls for protest at CM Kornreich’s office
Abena: this is the same bill that has been offered in the last two or three years to allow the huge yaphank waste transfer station. Fighting the same fight year after year(3 years) How do we get this bill killed?
This was county land sold to Northpoint. Now owned by winters bros The conservation easement predates their ownership. They will “swap” the easement to move it around the waste transfer station. They say they will have more Greenspace from 60 acres in the middle to 66 acres around the waste transfer station.
Has anyone looked at the impact.
This is the same acreage that has been clear cut and almost a blight. This is part of a the game plan to make it look unattractive. Some people think this area is spoiled already.
Is there escorted through
Who has fought against this bill? Yes BVA CCE and other south country groups
And what about the DeC? This doesn’t concern Dec because they own the land. They bought the land knowing about the conservation easement. How can we work on NOT seeing this bill reintroduced.
Put together a one pager together and get it to Albany.
Updates:
- Hofstra Public health intern
- BLARG Wikipedia
- ALCC media
- Launch a Do Not Settle campaign. Short video of each person in Brookhaven saying “I live in … in the town of Brookhaven and I say do not settle, Brookhaven because…” (some other unscripted thing or scripted highlight from the report). Individual then a large shot of everyone saying Do Not Settle.
- Adelphi EJ/CJ town hall part II
- Monday April 22nd Rally at 1pm and the forum is 2:00 to 3:30 Update on BLARG and ALCC
- DEC Corrective measure
- Cumulative impacts
- Enhanced public participation
*Inspector General has the authority to shut down a landfill per our conversation with the AG office
- Actions: Check out the BLARG weekly for other action items
4/12/2024 Agenda
Housekeeping:
BLARG Rest: 4/26/2024
Check ins: Name, pronouns and land acknowledgment
Acknowledgements in actions:
- Land Acknowledgement: Indigenous Sovereignty (1 min)
- Black Lives Matter & Honoring George Floyd acknowledgement and action: (2 min)
- Anti Landfill Composting Collective is set to start 5/25/24. We will be acknowledging and honoring the life of George Floyd. We will have a teach in on the cycle of food provided by the Healthy Education Project and we will have volunteers from faith based leader
- North Bellport acknowledgement and action: (2 min)
- InReach (Flyering for both events 4/20 & 5/25) Volunteers needed
- Senior Center Desired for the community we as BLARG will support.
- Environmental Justice acknowledgement and action: (3 min)
- Town of Babylon Regional Waste study
- Discussed the 17 principles of EJ
- Tom Vetri and Jassi Annan former student at Pratt institute. Now a subcontractor for the Town
- Shared case studies of zero waste plans (Delaware Cty, Boulder, CO, GAIA resources)
- Recommendation for EJ symposium be held so community members can attend
- Timeline for the study to be released:
- Environmental racism acknowledgement and action (5 min)
- Town Board Resolution #2024-270 “Home Rule Message of Support to the New York State Legislature on Behalf of S. 5215/A. 5365 Authorizing Alienation of Parkland to Allow Rail Access in Yaphank” Put forward by Dean Murphy allows an easement on green area that has been set aside.
- Who can write memo of opposition template for BLARG and other orgs
- Are we protesting at Kornreich’s office
Special Guest Speaker on Battery Storage: David Alicea, Greenlight America's Northeast Regional Campaign Manager.
Advocate for climate met through work with NY Renews
- Living on Long Island from Medford being Puerto Rican
- Learned about climate change in high school
- Offshore wind organizer 2013 -2015 sierra club
- Moved upstate
- The fossil fuel industry is doing a lot to stay alive
- New org just getting off the ground. We work with developers but don’t have no alligence to developer
- See recording
Sign on- Letter Request:
NY Packaging Reduction and Recycling Infrastructure Act. Sign on here. This was the bill discussed by Alexis Goldsmith at BLARG last month.
- Other groups are encouraged to sign on as BLARG has done
Actions:
- Earth day at the Garden 10-12 pm Chris Hobson Bill Neal Community Garden 604 Macdonald Ave Bellport
- Earth day event Grow Your Food at the Mott house in Gordon heights 3 pm third installment of Brookhaven naacp environmental justice series
- LIPA Public Power Act is in a haile mary moment public hearing April 17th
- BLARG has been a supporter and asked to speak. Monique will speak
- Who else can go or let someone do presentation for their group
- Other Actions: Check out the BLARG weekly for other action items
- South country peace group meeting with Schumers office
- South country library installing a peace pole in memory of one of the founders of the south country peace group
4/19/2024 Agenda
Housekeeping:
BLARG Rest: 4/26/2024
Check ins: Name, pronouns and land acknowledgment
- Land Acknowledgement: Indigenous Sovereignty (1 min)
- Black Lives Matter & Honoring George Floyd acknowledgement and action: (2 min)
- Anti Landfill Composting Collective is set to start 5/25/24. We will be acknowledging and honoring the life of George Floyd. We will have a teach in on the cycle of food provided by the Healthy Education Project and we will have volunteers from faith based leader
- North Bellport acknowledgement and action: (2 min)
- InReach (Flyering for both events 4/20 & 5/25) Volunteers needed
- Senior Center Desired for the community we as BLARG will support.
- 4.5 million dollars given to the TOB for North Bellport we are going to work on getting that money to the COMMUNITY
- Environmental Justice acknowledgement and action: (3 min)
- Town of Babylon Regional Waste study
- Discussed the 17 principles of EJ
- BLARG public comments on the nys solid waste plan
- Tom Vetri and Jassi Annan former student at Pratt institute. Now a subcontractor for the Town. Utilization of $250,000 gotten by Steve Englebright. Mr. Vetri “unaware” of EJ. Monique And John Mcnamara are educating him.
- Shared case studies of zero waste plans (Delaware Cty, Boulder, CO, GAIA resources)
- Recommendation for EJ symposium be held so community members can attend
- Timeline for the study to be released:
- Environmental racism acknowledgement and action (5 min)
- Town Board Resolution #2024-270 “Home Rule Message of Support to the New York State Legislature on Behalf of S. 5215/A. 5365 Authorizing Alienation of Parkland to Allow Rail Access in Yaphank” Put forward by Dean Murphy allows an easement on green area that has been set aside. 60 protected acres, Winter Bros wants this area for their operations.
- Who can write memo of opposition template for BLARG and other orgs
- Are we protesting at Kornreich’s office
Other updates:
- Followed up with AG office and EarthJustice to see if there are any viable next steps
- Hillary at EarthJustice is going to check in with EarthJustice to see if they can help us with
- Sending an email to Scott C. deputy general counsel at DEC to see if we can meet with him about the money that Covanta has to pay for the Hundreds of violations. We are not sure how much they will be fined, but looks like it will be six figures. They will be working with Scott on how much they will be fined. We could try to pressure Scott to settle for a large amount. It is not certain that we could get him to listen to our pressure on getting the largest amount possible. The AGs office believes they want to hear from the community on what projects we want that money to go for. So we could think about things that could help us with zero waste strategies and improving community health
- Earth justice will set up a meeting with Scott C. from DEC.
- Set up a fund where the fines get deposited and the COMMUNITY that has been affected can get together to decide where it goes.
- Send an email to DEC to create a website with all information about the “corrective measures mandate” and opening the meetings with the Town and DEC up to the public and to make sure that the community is able to help create the plan that the town is mandated to submit. EarthJustice let us know that there is precedent for this with the process that the DEC is currently doing with Cap Trade program
- Bill: how do you clean it up?
- Monique: that is thee question
- Mncmara: using carbon filtration to clean up. SCWA has had success with it. a work on parks on top of the landfill and monitor the gases. As far as what to do with the money put it into to asthma treatment and prevention. I think the petition drive is great!
- Giving us some talking points to initiate a campaign to pressure the Town of Brookhaven to not settle with Covanta. For context the other named towns (Garden City and Hempstead) in the whistleblower case had agreed to settle but, Town of Brookhaven did not. Also for context, the last decision that came from the court on this case stipulated that Garden City and Town of Hempstead could not settle, but because the town of Brookhaven was a customer and … the Town of Brookhaven has the authority to settle with Covanta. Therefore, it will be good for us to kick up our campaign to stop the settlement again. Also, for context the relator believes that our first campaign that garnered the Gov. Hochul’s call for the DEC to investigate the case was probably persuasive in stopping the Town of Brookhaven from settling back then. As far as timeline for this, both sides (Covanta and the relator) are currently appealing parts of the decision that they did not agree with. Therefore, we may have some time to put together a strong campaign. Lastly, EarthJustice will check in with the relator to see if they have a sense of timeline.
- Follow up with EarthJustice
- Pressure to mandate closure and clean up as the plan for the “corrective measures mandate
- Boots on the ground for petition to stop Brookhaven settling with Covanta
- Want signatures from all entities Brookhaven to Setauket and Hempstead. Need volunteers for areas. Have your neighbors sign.
- Restart/Start All Eyes on Brookhaven/Stop the Settlement campaign/petition
- Things that are different
- Town of Brookhaven can settle according to the court
- We have already reached Gov. Hochul and AG’s office and they provided what they are willing to do
- Anything else?
- Co-presentation with Melisa Wright student at SUNY Old Westbury for Prof Frisken’s class, American Studies
- Prof Frisken is looking to see if in the Fall she can have some students help us with our work to close down and clean up the landfill
- Earth day rally and forum at Adelphi with LIPC, Adelphi student groups
Actions:
- This Saturday, Earth day at the Garden 10-12 pm Chris Hobson Bill Neal Community Garden 604 Macdonald Ave Bellport
- This Saturday, Earth day event Grow Your Food at the Mott house, 263 Middle Country Rd Coram, NY in Gordon heights 3 pm third installment of Brookhaven naacp environmental justice series
- LIPA Public Power Act is in a hail mary moment next public board meetingMay 27th
- BLARG has been a supporter and asked to speak. Monique will speak
- Who else can go to the public board meeting
- Could LIPC coordinate to have someone do presentation for their group
5/3/2024 Agenda
Housekeeping:
BLARG Rest: 5/24/2024
Check ins: Name, pronouns and land acknowledgment
- Land Acknowledgement: Indigenous Sovereignty (1 min)
- Join the Shinnecock Kelp Farmers in opposing Suffolk County's Aquaculture Lease Program (ALP), formerly and offensively known as SCALP! Leasing land and underwater areas without acknowledging Indigenous rights and seeking tribal consent is unacceptable
- Black Lives Matter & Honoring George Floyd acknowledgement and action: (2 min)
- Anti Landfill Composting Collective is set to start 5/25/24. We will be acknowledging and honoring the life of George Floyd. We will have a teach in on the cycle of food provided by the Healthy Education Project and we will have volunteers from faith based leader
- North Bellport acknowledgement and action: (2 min)
- InReach (Flyering for 5/25) Volunteers needed
- Senior Center Desired for the community we as BLARG will support.
- Half of the $4.5 million granted to the TOB for North Bellport we are going to work on getting that money to the COMMUNITY
- Environmental Justice acknowledgement and action: (3 min)
- Town of Babylon Regional Waste study
- Discussed the 17 principles of EJ
- BLARG public comments on the nys solid waste plan
- Tom Vetri and Jassi Annan former student at Pratt institute. Now a subcontractor for the Town. Utilization of $250,000 gotten by Steve Englebright. Mr. Vetri “unaware” of EJ. Monique And John Mcnamara are educating him.
- Shared case studies of zero waste plans (Delaware Cty, Boulder, CO, GAIA resources)
- Recommendation for EJ symposium be held so community members can attend
- Timeline for the study to be released: following up with Jassi to work on a timeline and engagement outreach tour
- Environmental racism acknowledgement and action (5 min)
Other Updates
- Sen Harckam
- Many objections to what seems to be an omnibus bill
Other Actions
- Covanta Whistleblower case
- Stop the Settlement: Town of Brookhaven and Covanta petition 1000 signatures
- Covered all hamlets in Town of Brookhaven
- Significant sign ons from North Bellport, Brookhaven, Yaphank, Horizon Village, Medford, Gordon Heights, Hempstead
- DEC advocacy to ensure the maximum penalties for the violations
- Create a fund for the fines for the North Bellport and surrounding communities
- Follow up with EarthJustice
- Advocate for a website
- Advocate for open public meetings
- Advocate for an environmental justice regional zero waste waste plan to close and clean up the Brookhaven Landfill
Closing
5/10/2024 Agenda
Housekeeping:
BLARG Rest: 5/24/2024
Check ins: Name, pronouns and land acknowledgment
- Waste Study: town of babylon/StonyBrook partnership. Islandwide project.
- Possibly setting up a meeting to push for a regional comprehensive environmental justice zero waste management plan that includes closure and remediation of the Brookhaven landfill
- Hannah: Why is babylon doing a waste study for the town of Brookhaven
- Monique: the study is Long Island wide but the elephant in the room was
- Laura: the goal is to formulate a plan to handle our waste issue when the landfill closes. We need a plan for closure of the landfill. This money $250,000 needs to be accounted for and we should be able to know what it is. The landfill
- Bill: what is the slope that the councilman was talking about last week
- The councilman said that there needs to be a certain slope according to permit
- Mark: they don’t have a plan
- McNamara: they have a plan to take it away on rail. They are full speed ahead. NYC trash from goes out of nyc from rail
- Bill: in nyc took barges for years put in the ocean.
- McNamara: Long Island is all sand and the trash goes down into the aquifer. They have to transport it another place. Unless they adopt the McNamara plan is a zero waste plan I have been advocating for 100 years.
- Hannah: we are only allowed 25 lbs of garbage weekly for community. If you need to drop off more you have to pay $55. They do a lot of recycling every two weeks. Neighbors are complaint that they have twice that much. We had to change our behavior to reduce waste.
- Michelle: loss of revenue to the town we should be pushing for them to look for more Environmentally sound revenue sources. Glass could use different uses for glass.
- Laura: glass works better for cinderblocks rather than roadways bc it’s not good for the tires. It takes more to keep it separate from paper. It also takes going to a drop off site.
- Monique: all of this has to be addressed
Other Actions
Other Updates
- Packaging Reduction Recycling Infrastructure Act PRRIA updates
- Green Amendment case (Fresh Air For Eastside appeal) BLARG amicus was accepted by the court. Now we are waiting for decision.
- Statewide advocacy effort happening July 12th in Albany delivering letters to AGs office, Gov Hochul’s office and the DEC
- Anyone able to attend?
- We can check into a group rate train ride or van depending on if our funds are able to be used for this
- Reviewed a proposal for a state solid waste bill (offered by Maggie from SWAB who met on her own with Sen. Harkham), but most of the contingency was against it. Seneca Lake Meadows seemed to be opposed to the consensus against it.
- Still working on a retreat
- Covanta Whistleblower case
- Stop the Settlement: Town of Brookhaven and Covanta petition 1000 signatures
- Covered all hamlets in Town of Brookhaven
- Significant sign ons from North Bellport, Brookhaven, Yaphank, Horizon Village, Medford, Gordon Heights, Hempstead
- Lynne: i am for the petition. We need to make sure that t
- DEC advocacy to ensure the maximum penalties for the violations
- Create a fund for the fines for the North Bellport and surrounding communities
- Follow up with EarthJustice
- Advocate for a website
- Advocate for open public meetings
- Advocate for an environmental justice regional zero waste waste plan to close and clean up the Brookhaven Landfill
5/17/2024 Agenda
Housekeeping:
BLARG Rest: 5/31/2024* updated
Check ins: Name, pronouns and land acknowledgment
A Win is a Win!
- AIREF Warehouse IDA tax break denied!
- Mr. McNamara: The comments submitted were excellent! Great job!
- MaryEllen: Goes to show what putting effort to something can do. Looks like they got tired of hearing from us.
- Mr. McNamara: It was also good that the folks from Horizon Village was there.
Work in progress in the BLARG universe
- Lynne: Jennifer Devito, who has supported BLARG in the past, son is an eagle scout. He has a proposal to make another garden bed and seating for our meetings. He is driven and wants to bring folks to the garden to help with garden
- Khadija: good idea to have children involved
- Monique: We want to make the garden more accessible and add a sensory component in the garden
- Michelle: Suffolk Independent Living Organization could be a resource to help with accessibility in the garden. They have assisted with other types of places in the past.
- Monique: Another thing we can think about is how we bring food accessibility to the community. In an article that hannah was featured in two other organizations were also featured. One is Eileen’s Bodega which is an organization that places refrigerator pantries in communities to bring more fresh food to the community rather than can food that you normally see at food pantries. At the garden we have talked about teaming up with Eastern farm workers and using the harvest from the garden to share with the community. Eileen’s Bodega would pair very well with that vision. We would need to do some checking in with garden mgmt before going forward, but after that I would encourage anyone with a direct connection to see if there is a way to partner.
- Lynne: Wavemakers program want to partner with us.
- They want to teach/have them learn about Environmental Justice
- Students may want to bring composting to their school
- May do a tour of the landfill (Brookhaven and/or Babylon)
- BLARG may go with them
- We will support
- The program manager Karthik is newly graduated from StonyBrook and seems to have great energy and enthusiasm
- MaryEllen: Tremont School is doing composting in their school
- Mr McNamara: great work Lynne!
Updates:
- Covanta Whistleblower case
- Stop the Settlement: Town of Brookhaven and Covanta petition 1000 signatures
- Cover all hamlets in Town of Brookhaven
- Significant sign ons from North Bellport, Brookhaven, Yaphank, Horizon Village, Medford, Gordon Heights, Hempstead
- DEC advocacy to ensure the maximum penalties for the violations
- Create a fund for the fines for the North Bellport and surrounding communities
- Mr. McNamara: We should hold a community meeting to work out a list of priorities. Whether it is to address the water, health or some other issue. Have the meeting first to have them interested. The
- Follow up with EarthJustice
- They sent an email to Scott Crisafull (DEC)i. We haven’t heard back. We will try to get Peter Washburn at the AGs office to help amplify our email.
- We also can make a few calls
- You could try reaching Scott Crisafulli via the office of General Counsel in Albany: (518) 402-9185
- You can also try reaching the Region 1 Regional Attorney via the Region 1 office: (631) 444-0260
- Sample script: Hello my name is....I am a member of BLARG and we are requesting a meeting with Scott Crisafulli in regards to the hundreds of violations that Covanta committed during the DEC investigation of the Covanta whistleblower case. We believe the community's input is necessary in these deliberations on holding Covanta accountable
- Advocate for a website
- Advocate for open public meetings
- Advocate for an environmental justice regional zero waste waste plan to close and clean up the Brookhaven Landfill
- Monique: Reached out to follow up
- Lynne: will reach out Julia
- Mcnamara: Who is in charge at the DEC Region 1
- Monique: I will follow up on that
- Mr McNamara: Cathy Haas: Her phone number is (631)444-0345
- Cumulative impacts law: DEC rule making
- Info listening only sessions this week.
- Contact Alanah with comments, questions, concerns
- Input session will be open for the public in June
Other Actions
- Mr. McNamara: Juneteenth community wide meeting regarding peace in the corridor of heritage center Mt Sinai rt 25A/Rocky Point Rd. 7p - 9pm. Rocky Point, Mt. Sinai, Sound Beach, Coram, Middle Island, Shoreham and Wading River.
- Ezekiel: With the PLABs precinct level advisory board next quarterly meeting June
- Just Stop Unjust Traffic Stops: Together, the tri-coalition (LI United, UJP-LI, and LIAFPA) and organizations across Long Island are building a movement to address Suffolk County's HARMFUL and INEFFECTIVE traffic enforcement strategy: one that results in egregious racial disparities and leads to Suffolk County's extremely unasafe roadways june 13th 7 pm on zoom tinyurl.com/TrafficLearningSession3
Monique: our Anti Landfill Composting kickoff event is happening 5/25 at the garden. We moved the time up to 12 pm to help allow for folks to do other things the holiday weekend
Maryellen: come out and support the south country peace group every Saturday at 12 pm corner of station rd and south country rd. Also, support at the Memorial Day parade 5/27
- Michelle: we have participated in the parade as the south country peace group since the 80’s. The people love us but the officials give us a hard time. We could use your support.
Mike:
- Covanta ash recycling plant in PA - he has the PA DEP records on it now, including violations and that the ash into asphalt part of it seems to have stopped (not sure if they’ll manage to restart or just lost their one market for it altogether)
- Energy Justice Network is back and up and running will give updates as things get back.
GAIA is looking for advisory people in the region. BLARG is a member and can vote
FORM IS HERE: https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLScoBoVjqEn5Rw7fR34k0XzZiIs7Ab3Ewc4K2A57fe_hLQ6dvg/viewform
NOMINEES: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1uplptk1h8ncOrn6SfW8JILOakSOwrhYlSKMI-Oexm5Q/edit
Recommendations: Bianca Lopez, Marvin Hayes, Sue Maxwell
5/24/2024 Agenda
Housekeeping:
BLARG Rest: 5/31/2024* updated
Check ins: Name, pronouns and land acknowledgment
Support!
- Donations
- UU Fellowship of Stony Brook $1373
- Healthcare Education Project $750
- How Can I Compost Guide up on our website HERE
- Communications support (language, multimedia, grants) Need a graphic for this
- Thoughts…
- Mike: it’s a lot of the work to put it out there and get someone who knows the work. In DC Preshona Ambri (Mike E knows/can connect?) Here's one place to find her stuff: https://www.instagram.com/browngirlsthink/
- Khadija: would love students or professors may be able to help with that.
- Maryellen: would love it if we had someone connected to us in some way. A professional working with a student.
- McNamara: I’m thinking Matthew
- Monique: christine is really good at things like that too
- Christine: peeking my head out a little bit but might be interested in doing some comms work esp around the community composting!)
- Laura: the Long Island (?) has a funded program to do community justice work. We wouldn’t have to do the pay we would just need to have the position
North Bellport Strong Student Ambassador Awards
- Looking to award North Bellport Juniors and Seniors
- Want to broaden the award to South Country School District area as well
- Quick turnaround time
- Need a graphic
- Thoughts…
- Abena: last year we tried to advertise it in the high school first. We worked with word of mouth. We won’t be overwhelmed
- Maryellen: we did this through the s country peace group. They may be busy at this time
- Maybe extend it as a summer award program (instead of being tied to end of school year)
- Monique: maybe we
- McNamara: residential qualification is ok to do as long as you are up front.
Covanta Stop the Settlement Petition & Violations
- Updates
- Lynne, Mark
- Scott Crisafulli (518) 402-9185
- Region 1 Regional Attorney via the Region 1 office: (631) 444-0260
- Cathy Haas (631 )444-0345 (regional director, LI)
- Thoughts…
- Monique: we haven’t heard back from Scott or any of the other contacts
Any other updates:
- DEC Corrective Measures follow up
- Peter Washburn from the AG’s office and Hillary from EarthJustice inquired if we want to write a letter on what we believe the process for the corrective measures should be. CCE wrote a letter with BVA back in the Fall
- Advocate for a website
- Advocate for open public meetings
- Advocate for an environmental justice regional zero waste waste plan to close and clean up the Brookhaven Landfill
- Community fund possible
- Mike: pushing for better test methods and to stop using ash as alternative daily cover material (if that’s happening)
- Abena (I’m the chat): Dec and town mandated to meet since the corrective measures letter 8/8. Meetings were to start 30 days after the letter was received. Can these meetings be public? Are there notes from the meetings?
- Peter also inquired if we wanted to hire our own consultant to be able to compare results.
- Mike: what’s the timeline
- Monique: not sure but the updated plan the town put together is due to start in June so next month. Jd Allen received documents from his foil request that include the latest plan
- McNamara: it might be more financially advisable if we work with partner
- Maryellen: will a consultant have enough time to get up to speed?
- Monique: I don’t know about consultants. and what would be our process to obtain a consultant?
- Mike may have a consultant. The expert on the Covanta whistleblower case. Ask Dr. Paul Connett, Dr. Ron Sahu; or ask Dr. Stephen Lester at CHEJ.org who he knows.
- Updated corrective measures plan to start in June
- Mark, John, Laura interested in diving in on this. Monique will start an email thread.
- GAIA Regional Advisory Committee Vote
- Khadija: screening documentary that we will watch features Bianca. Bianca is willing to join us for the screening. Marvin passionate about composting from Baltimore also willing to share with us. Will vote for them two.
- Mike: I work with these candidates and think they are a good to choose. Also Sue Maxwell is a good choice.
- Khadija castes BLARG vote for these candidates.
- Karthik is continuing to work on a plan for the students to learn about environmental justice. No further updates available at this time.
- Monique: we usually have an extended break from blarg Fridays in the summer and winter. In the past we have had extended break in August as many of the BLARG members have birthdays in August. Would like folks to think about what makes sense for a break this summer.
Actions:
- “From Garden to Table to Black Gold,” Anti Landfill Composting Collective is kicking of it’s composting collection initiative in partnership with Healthcare Education Project, Long Island Jobs With Justice and New York Farmist Saturday, May 25th 12 pm come early stay late
- GAIA and other organizations like Ironbound in New Jersey and Friends of the Earth are organizing to stop the Biden Administration from including incinerators as
Zero emissions” for a tax credit program.The Treasury Department is beginning to determine whether incineration should qualify as a “zero emissions” technology under the 45Y Clean Electricity Production Tax Credit.
- Actions: There will be a webinar, On May 29th, 2024 at 12-1 pm PST / 3-4 pm EST, join
- Actions: BLARG to potentially meet with key Biden officials against incinerators getting this tax credit
- South Country Peace Group Saturdays corner of South Country and Station Rd
- South Country Peace Group support as they march in the Memorial Day Parade 5/27 Bellport Village/Station Rd
- Just Stop Unjust Stops tri coalition LI United, UJP-LI, and LIAFPA June 13th 7 pm on zoom tinyurl.com/TrafficLearningSession3
- Brookhaven Town Board meeting June 6th 3 pm planning board 5 pm board meeting
- Others…
June 7th Agenda
Housekeeping:
BLARG Rest: 6/28/2024
Check ins: Name, pronouns and land acknowledgment
Support needed:
- Table at Wheels on the Bus Electric School bus for the environment event in Hempstead. BLARG could potentially table there and obtain signatures regarding Covanta. Saturday, June 22nd 12 pm
- Table this as events have changed
- Facilitator for June 21st
- Cancel the meeting if no one is able facilitate.
- Christine may be able to facilitate.
North Bellport Strong Ambassador awards
- North Bellport Student 11th and 12th
- South Country Central School District Student
- Shared on socials and in community. Anyone have links to the school please share it
Updates:
- From Garden to Table to Black Gold event went extraordinarily well and ALCC
- Mr. McNamara: pic look great
- Mark: the demonstrations were excellent
- Christine: loved it!
- Monique:
- Incinerator Alternatives webinar
- Zero waste plan Baltimore: a mix of text, pictures, video, graphic and free space
- The tri coalition on policing came up with a people’s plan with consultants and everything and most of it was not used.
- Monique: yea and this was with the mandate. How do we get it accepted or adopted with localities
- Mike: this is a problem. The city hasn’t brought in but the council is on board but the executive board is not on board. In Delaware the state has a mandate that each county has to have a ten year plan for where waste will go. Montgomery county Maryland. He agreed to close down the incinerator. We got our zero waste team get hired by that county. Then we were able to get we got hijacked because the
- Monique: how much does a consultant cost
- Mike: $150k-$300k depending on how detailed.
- Laura: it seems like you know a lot about what doesn’t work. Do you know what will work
- Mike having good folks in govt.
- Monique: Ed romaine putting together a conglomerate of the towns on waste in some realm.
- Mr. McNamara: he is pooling the towns to find reuse for glass
- $1 mill
- Newsday article dropped today
- Laura: billions of dollars needed for clean up. There are plumes
- Amicus brief:
- Hannah: we are going to submit an amicus brief. Does this change or bring more awareness
- Monique:
- Bill: I called Dec about Bethpage to ask about the barrels. They shipping it out of state
- Folks are interested in the consultant idea but do not want to partner with CCE. Reached back out to Peter to discuss but haven’t heard from him.
- Let Hillary know what we would like to see in a letter to the DEC. In the process of signing a retainer for this work
- Approved characterization plan (link?) this week. Let’s review it.
- Brookhaven Town Board & Planning Board meetings
- Community members continue to say they saw us speak at the meetings. This gives us a chance to speak directly to the town board and the community
- Should we include not settling in the Covanta case along with zero waste plan to address the Dec corrective measures
- Candidates; Goroff and John:
- Myrna: they had a event and didn’t
- Laura: He is really committed to the Brookhaven landfill issue and is a media. Rebecca and Skylar,
- Monique: we can always ask question
- Proposal to have no meetings in August and first week of school Sept 13th we will reconvene..
- Possible Summer events at the garden
- Pumpkin planting May, picking October and composting November
- Strawberry/berry fest with ice cream truck and all things berries end of June
- Mushroom installation event late July/early august
- Fried green tomatoes giveaway and/or fry with fish possibly and possibly could be the fundraiser event
- Movie nights screening in September about the incinerator closure in California
- Foraging event tbd who wants to join
Actions:
- Just Stop Unjust Stops tri coalition LI United, UJP-LI, and LIAFPA June 13th 7 pm on zoom tinyurl.com/TrafficLearningSession3
- Wednesday June 19th corridor of peace in heritage park in my Sinai 7-9 pm
- Gay pride Sunday in Patchogue village 12 pm
- Pro choice rally at resistance corner 1-3 pm
- Setalcott Nation Annual Corn Festival Powwow Saturday, July 13th and Sunday, July 14th. Free admission Donations welcome! Rain or shine bring a blanket or chair to enjoy the cultural dance, song and other offerings
Closing
#WeAreLongIsland video
June 14th Agenda
Housekeeping:
BLARG Rest: 6/28/2024
Check ins: Name, pronouns and land acknowledgment
Support needed:
- Facilitator for June 21st
- Cancel the meeting if no one is able to facilitate.
- Christine may be able to facilitate.
Updates:
- Covanta settlement case: three points of pressure:
- The Town: modify the petition from reject to withdraw. Let’s get to a significant number of signatories and get to the town before the court makes a decision.
- EarthJustice and JD foil’d for more info on the voting process/how the town decided to agree to the settlement. Think we won’t get that back until July.
- We need everyone out getting a ton of signatures
- The court: Amicus brief to be filed June 27th
- The AG: letter to AG to intervene as the AG office left this door open
- This afternoon we submitted a letter to the Office of the Attorney General asking the AG to intervene in the Covanta lawsuit and oppose the settlement. That letter was also forwarded to Peter Washburn.
- Please feel free to share the letter with the NAACP.
- Press conference and press release once drops
- Anyone want to give a quote?
- Foil’d for town of Brookhaven permit renewal
- This morning we with help of Earthjustice submitted a letter to DEC asking for more transparency and public participation in the corrective measures process related to the landfill plume. It was also forwarded to Peter Washburn at the AG office
- Mike: seeing multiple incinerators having trouble with ash aggregation is a good sign. Will look into it more.
- Funding for a zero waste consultant
- Mike: will need anywhere from $30,000-$200,000 for a zero waste consultant depending on what your trying to cover.
- BEA fund may be able to fund it. Mike is looking to getting a BEA fund member to nominate BLARG as they are starting to accept. Nominations. This round is less money and may be more difficult to get the funds. There are groups like Catskill Mountainkeeper, WASS, Energy Justice Network. This is a general grant fund.
- Monique: We can and probably need to work with a university for the zero waste consultation. Stonybrook would be good. Abena has lightly pushed for stony Brook to go zero waste already so we can hopefully get them to do it through this process if we are unable to move the town to do it. Sunrise movement stinybrook campus is interested in zero waste
- Stonybrook is doing the waste characterization for the whole state. Can get access to this information through a friend working at Stonybrook
- Mike: also it may be good to also see if you can get another municipality to do a zero waste plan they could also model and push Brookhaven. This way a municipality has the authority to do zero waste and you wouldn’t have to push them to adopt the plan once they create it
- Proposal to have no meetings in August and first week of school Sept 13th we will reconvene..
- June 21st is cancelled due to no facilitator for the meeting
- July 5th also cancelled due to the holiday.
- Therefore we will only meet twice this summer July 12th and July 19th.
- Please see us in the garden on Saturdays and get the petition signed.
Actions:
- EJ Siting Law (Cumulative impacts law) input session Long Island city Monday at 6 pm.
- What constitutes a de minimis impact?
- What criteria should DEC consider when identifying a disproportionate burden?
- What makes constitutes a disproportionate burden
- What qualifies as a significant increase in the disproportionate pollution burden within a disadvantaged community?
- What indicators or baseline data should be considered or present to make the determination?
- What methodologies or best management practices should DEC consider?
- Brookhaven Town Board & Planning Board meetings
- Wednesday June 19th corridor of peace in heritage park in my Sinai 7-9 pm
- Setalcott Nation Annual Corn Festival Powwow Saturday, July 13th and Sunday, July 14th. Free admission Donations welcome! Rain or shine bring a blanket or chair to enjoy the cultural dance, song and other offerings
July 12th Agenda
Housekeeping:
BLARG Rest: 7/26/2024-9/13/2024
Check ins: Name, pronouns and land acknowledgment
Support needed:
- Please get the petition signed
- Volunteers in the garden
- Help us table at the Setalcott powwow (help us encourage folks to compost as well)
- International Youth day (august 12th? not sure of exact date of the event). D1 Youth is hosting a back to school event and want to feature waste as a critical issue can anyone help table or speak at that event
- Mushroom workshop and foraging events in Sept and October. Our pumpkin seeds are doing fabulous! Pumpkin picking in October as well. Any other events you all want blarg to host?
Updates:
- The Town: Petition - to be delivered at the town board meeting July 18th at 5 pm. Join us at … for a rally
- We are tabling at the Setalcott Powwow please let us know if you can help us get some signatures at the table and help encourage folks to compost their food scraps
- The Court: Amicus brief submitted by EarthJustice to the court June 27th
- From EarthJustice: I am also sharing the briefs that the Relator filed to oppose the proposed settlement. One brief argues that Brookhaven has no authority to settle.Another brief—which I think will be more interesting to BLARG— argues that, if the Court thinks that Brookhaven has the authority to settle,the settlement should still not be approved because it is not fair, adequate, or reasonable. That brief argues that Brookhaven has consistently acted only in its political interest, based on emails between Covanta and Brookhaven as well as newspaper articles. The brief also asks the Court to hold a hearing on Brookhaven’s decision-making, if the Court is considering approving the settlement. I will let you know, of course, if a hearing happens and if there might be an opportunity for BLARG members to participate. Please let me know if you want to see any of the exhibits referenced in either brief.
- Covanta has to respond by today (July 8th) to our amicus brief, and then we can file a reply brief by Friday. I will share Covanta’s response and a draft of our reply.
- Covanta did not file an opposition to our amicus brief. This means that we don’t need to file a reply brief.
- The AG: letter submitted back in early/mid June
- From Earth Justice: Last Friday the AG’s Office filed the attached letter asking the Court not to rule yet on the proposed Covanta-Brookhaven settlement. The letter says that the AG’s Office needs time to review the proposed settlement and, if necessary, confer with the relator, Covanta, Brookhaven, and/or state agencies. I will of course let you know if the AG’s Office says anything more or indicates that it plans to intervene.
- The Relator’s attorneys spoke with the AG’s Office, and due to vacation schedules it will likely be two weeks before they weigh in on the settlement in any way. However, I would still advise continuing to work on submitting the petition to Brookhaven soon.
- We are planning to go to the next town board meeting July 18th at 5 pm. This will be a light touch just giving testimony and encouragement to withdraw the settlement.
- Given the status of the Covanta whistleblower case, the pending fines from the DEC for the violations, the DEC Correctives measures mandate and the landfill permit expired 2026 and they already submitted a renewal. We have an opportunity to pressure the DEC to reject the permit renewal or demand the permit renewal comes with a closure and clean up plan.
- Zero waste consultant
- Incinerators policy & trends
- Mike on trends?
- The draft language for the 45Y tax credit has been released, and written comments are due on August 2nd, 2024. There will also be a virtual public hearing for verbal comments on August 12th and 13th. More information can be found HERE.
Actions:
- Town of Brookhaven Board meeting July 18th 5 pm
- Setalcott Nation Annual Corn Festival Powwow Saturday, July 13th and Sunday, July 14th. Free admission Donations welcome! Rain or shine bring a blanket or chair to enjoy the cultural dance, song and other offerings
- D1Youth Advisory Board Day International Youth Day event second week of August
Closing: see you next week, June 19th for our last BLARG Friday for the summer! Enjoy your summer, get into some good trouble, get the petition signed stay tuned for updates via email/social media/slack and see us in the garden!
July 19th agenda
Big thank you’s to Christina, Lynne and Christine For holding down the BLARG table this weekend at the Setalcott Nation Powwow. It was great to get engagement from our tribal members and the Setauket community.
Big shout out to all who came to support the Setalcott Nation powwow
Updates:
Debrief Town Board Meeting
Covanta Whistleblower Case:
- Debrief Town Board Meeting
- Petition 400 signatures submitted thank you Lynne
- Maryellen: do we know when the court will decide
- Lynne: I timed my speech and I read all the briefs. I don’t know if I was from blarg but as soon as I talked it was like they had shades over their faces. Because they interacted with the
- Maryellen I’m gonna call councilman Karen and ask them why don’t respond us.
- Lynne: at the landfill press conference the workers. We said to the workers that the town needs a plan and they say they have a plan.
- Maryellen:
- Lynne: the long-standing relationship with the town and the Covanta is why they accepted the $1 mill. After this Covanta will be absolved of all responsibility
- Mr McNamara brought this up about the towns competition to incentivize composting.
- Winter Bros selling to WM
- Bill asked about it this at the town board meeting. The town did not respond.
- Bill: I can contact WM.
- Monique: yes
- Mike: San Diego report is a damning report. They are huge and they love to sue anyone at the drop of a dime.
- Attorney General pressure:
- No further updates more than last week
- Brookhaven nor did Covanta respond to our amicus brief. But they did submit briefs the week reupping their claim that Brookhaven has the right to settle and that the town of Brookhaven has no damages.
- No court ruling has been made on this settlement thus far
Covanta DEC investigation follow up:
- The DEC investigated the whistleblower case and found hundreds of violations. We need to reach the DEC lawyer Scott Crisafulli to find out what the violation will be and to see if a community fund can be created for those funds. I think we may want to reach out to the DEC EJ office/Director Alannah Keddel-Tuckey to see if she will be able to help. Also will follow up with EarthJustice about this pathway.
Mike Ewall Long Island Municipal environmental boards
- Might be issues of BLARG (bellport interacting with bellport village as their history is…..varied) - but new mayor might be a good sign (seems more open than previous administrations).
- Michelle possibility to reach out to the Mayor/members of the Environmental committee about feasibility of a municipality to adopt a zero waste plan.
- July 27 - Bellport Day - maybe share some of BLARG printable info to share there (community compost flier, anything else, maybe something about zero waste plan possibilities).
- Maybe a day at the garden to show off, or have someone come to a BLARG meeting (next meeting in Sep btw).
- We Are Long Island - might have connections to a possible consultant or other municipalities who can help with zero waste plan
Actions:
- WHAT: South Country Peace Group Sponsors the 41st Annual World Peace Vigil & Community Dedication to Peace. Commemorating the 78th anniversary of Nuclear Destruction of Hiroshima & Nagasaki
- WHEN: Sun., August 6, 2023 5pm Gather; 5:45pm Program
- WHERE: Meet South Country Library by Peace Pole
- Silent Procession 5:15pm to Osborn Park by Village Marina, end of Bellport Lane 5:45pm Program
- What: Participants’ Share Visions & Actions for Peace Featuring
- Invocation: Jason Neal, Deacon, Old South Haven Presbyterian Church
Closing: Have a wonderful summer! See you in the garden :)
Agenda Sept 13, 2024
Reading and review of acknowledgements
Actions:
- D1 Youth Advisory Board Press conference Saturday, Sept 14th at 12 pm Roberto Clemente Park, Brentwood, NY
- South Country Peace Group meets at corner South Country Rd and Station Rd Saturdays as 11 am
- BLARG Fish Fry Fundraiser Saturday, Sept 14th at 2 pm Chris Hobson Bill Neal Community Garden 604 MacDonald Ave Bellport, NY
- Catskills No to Incineration Sullivan County webinar 9/16 at 5 pm register here
- South Country Peace Group Sept 21 at 5:30 pm, Sayville Rotary Park: International Peace Day
Updates:
- Covanta Reworld whistleblower case
- EarthJustice meeting with DEC lawyer Craig Eglut
- Possibilities going forward
- We will ask folks to help us with recordings.
- NY in a rat race with Florida to be the oasis for Covanta Reworld incineration
- EarthJustice working on more transparency measure with DEC. EarthJustice
- EPA DEC EJ Listening Session in Wyandanch was a successful event. We got waste issues on the center of their unpacking
- sign on letter. Will BLARG sign on? Sept 20th we vote
Breaking news:
- Delco written a zero bill passed one phase
Misc News
- facility approved on station rd
- Another facility on Long Island Ave and Horseblock in Medford
- Does anyone want to meet with the developer?
- Mayor Adams at Covanta Reworld Hempstead burning cannabis products
Agenda Sept, 20, 2024
Facilitator: Monique
Participants:
Intros:
Acknowledgements:
Notetaker: christine
Actions:
- South Country Peace Group Sept 21 at 5:30 pm, Sayville Rotary Park: International Peace Day! ☮️
- South Country Peace Group meets at corner South Country Rd and Station Rd Saturdays at 11 am
- North country Peace group meets on Saturdays at 11am(?) corner of Bennetts Rd and Main
BLARG VOTE:
- Approved by folks attending, section in red will be edited down slightly
- Planned to be sent by the 30th
Report back:
- Raised $1,399 🎉
- The team will debrief
- Love to see the kids!
- Great way to intro the kids and their families to what we’re doing!
- Noelle (?) did a great job speaking! (Mo, Abena, folks recorded it somewhere)
- Bill - volunteered for over 15 yrs at Frank P Long, the school affected most by the landfill (students and teachers esp)
Updates:
- Review of our first meeting: talked about collaborating previously and Mariana got back in touch (saw the article about car fluff and the landfill). We love to see it!
- Project: working with community orgs to really highlight environmental issues in the community thru litigation esp. Right now very flexible project parameters, so being able to talk and plan more flexibly atm (and in its early stages).
- We know a void in our group has been Spanish speaking; we started out being able to at least release our social media info in English/Spanish but over time we have not been able to maintain that. Would love to collaborate with groups who can help us reach the growing Latinx population in the area who may not be as aware of the long-standing issues of and from the landfill.
- The shelter and the prison are also right in the area: that is also an avenue to possibly explore
- Town of Brookhaven is not transparent; everything we have dug up has been on our own, so would love to have that info more organized (and in more languages) and available for outreach
- John (in chat): Are we familiar with the Latino leaders in North Bellport?
- Covanta (renamed to Reworld)
- Letter the town wrote: the town uninterested in pursuing this case further, but can initiate action in future. Do we have faith that the town would ever do this, no, so why not continue the active case we currently have.
- Lynne in chat: My understanding is that with environmental issues and health damage it's very difficult to prove direct effect. But they can't disprove the damage.
- Mike: They don't need to disprove if the burden of proof is on our side. Unless there's a rebuttable presumption of liability (rare and probably not applying in this case), the burden isn't on Reworld (Covanta).
- Mary Ellen in chat: the DEC delineated the ash pollution
- Green amendment
- The Fluff
- Ideas from meeting with EarthJustice:
- Community funds
- Landfill was slated to become a park when closed; how can funds go towards that
- Fines for the violations seem like another (minimal) settlement for Covanta to keep polluting; there needs to be another action that would affect Covanta
- This would require an immense amount of pressure from us on a campaign of this sort.
- Mary Ellen’s thoughts: Hillary gave some ideas in her letter. Craig consulted with EJ office, so we might reach out to them.
- Any additional questions from both
- Possible collaborations
- Connect LatinoJustice and EarthJustice via email? Would like to connect!
- Samples of settlements: those that include restorations to communities if those exist.
- Connect with latino church and/or Eastern Farmworks Association in the area. Sepa Mujer in Patchogue is also a good org to connect with esp about outreach (Michelle has connections to ED possibly).
Closing: “There is no such thing as single-issue struggle because we do not live single-issue lives” ~Audre Lorde
Agenda Oct 4, 2024
Facilitator: Monique
Participants: Bill, Mariana, Laura, Michelle, Mcnamara, MaryEllen, Christine, BP, Mike, Myrna
Intros:
Acknowledgements
Notetaker:
Actions:
- Looking for personal and organizational support
- Table opportunity request from the Multicultural Society sat. Oct. 26th 3-6 pm UUF Stony Brook
- Laura will have info next week. Laura might be able to (will let Mo know by next week), christine might be available (tentative but may not be in town). If anyone else is available let Mo know
- Possible upcoming event Mushroom Forage Hike Sat. 10/19 we want to grow these in the upcoming spring.
- Conner, Lynn, and co - lead hike and forage at Southaven Park or Calverton (more details to be worked on)
- Possible upcoming event pop up pumpkin patch October 20th 2 pm
- Pumpkins, candy and caramel apples, cider, pumpkin carving, scarecrow build, other activities TBA
- Michelle: peace pole at the
- Possible Closing garden event in November with over winter foods like garlic and similar (low-to-no maintenance crops to harvest in Spring)
- Will get more fleshed out later this month.
Updates:
- EPA DEC Sign on letter ready to go… (will send out Monday or Tuesday depending)
- Maryellen/SCPG - board members present in meeting and in favor of signing on
- Send Myrna/NCPG this info too for their sign on
- Onboarding meeting on Tuesday at 7PM
- Air monitoring grants possible to apply?
- Yaphank Waste Transfer Station canceled!.
- Shout out to the NAACP Brookhaven chapter and advocates
- WB can still have the warehouses there
- Persistence CAN work
- They HEARD us and made their moves based on what they heard
- Does this maybe have anything to do with the WB takeover and bad PR - John
- Article mentions that they think LI already has sufficient capacity for transfer stations
- Medford transfer station is already approved and covers this
- Waste study in the hands of Winter Bros Michael White (FYi and recap)
- Buck has been passed all over the LI waste management gamut and ended up in Michael White’s hands
- Covanta whistleblower case (Three-pronged approach)
- Made a concession to keep the door open to cover any lawsuits that may still come
- Hillary (EarthJustice) will draft a letter in objection to the settlement. Should we have Hillary draft this letter in objection to the settlement?
- All in meeting agree we should move forward with drafting this letter
- Connect with Hillary also about anything we should/shouldn’t say at next town board meeting
- Officially: they will not intervene. They do not need the court to hold off on their decision and the AGs office does not have a position on it.
- This pressure on the AG office did give us time, which was good to have.
- Lynne in meeting: It also may have frightened the TOB a bit Knowing we had the AG looking at it
- Prepare a statement with two options?
- Accept decision in favor
- Denounce decision in opposition
- Response to Craig Eglut (DEC lawyer) meeting with EarthJustice
- Asked about community funds, penalties, what else is an option in this.
- He is going to reach out to the DEC EJ office so we can possibly write a letter to that office. What do folks think about reaching out to the DEC EJ office?
- Lynne: Can we ask DEC to have in-smoke stack monitors for this? (is this an appropriate ask in this instance?)
- County or Local laws could make this mandatory, but DEC could also require it (though it may not be as feasible/enforceable)
- DEC Corrective Measures mandate
- We continue to push for transparency
- Brookhaven landfill permit
- Mariana offered to help draft a public comment on it.
- Can mail in a public comment objecting to the renewal to the permit.
- Maryellen: they said they contracted to accept car fluff til 2027 but the permit is only good to 2026
- Mariana: they are working backwards.
- Monique: the town always does this they continue to say they will close the landfill but work to continue plans to keep the landfill open
- Green Amendment case (Fresh Air For The East side) follow up
- Megan Carr (New York Lawyers For the Public Interest- who helped us file an amicus brief on the Fresh Air For The East Side case for the right to clean air clean water under the green amendment.
- Mariana Lopez (LatinoJustice)
- Megan is trying to build up case law to guarantee clean air and water for everyone in New York State. One of the good parts of the case law is that it leaves the door open for landfills owned by public entities. Waiting for the green light from Megan’s supervisor.
- Monique: Interested in bringing this back once the we hear back from NYLPI
- For events with Latinx folks in north bellport
- Possibly screening the documentary we can collaborate around the tech.
Agenda Oct 11, 2024 (cancelled)
Facilitator: Monique
Participants:
Intros:
Acknowledgements
Notetaker:
Actions:
Sign on letter for orgs and BLARG to consider. Please review BLARG will vote next week:
Agenda Oct 18, 2024
Facilitator: Monique
Participants:
Intros:
Acknowledgements
Notetaker:
Actions:
- South Country School Board meeting Thursday November 7th at
- Residents in the district come down
- Media WSHU
Agenda Oct 18, 2024
Facilitator: Monique
Participants:
Intros:
Acknowledgements
Notetaker:
Actions:
Sign on letter about Nuclear energy for orgs
- Comments from NY Orgs on Advanced SMR Blueprint
- South country library presentation. Sustainability and the State of Waste on Long Island in January. If folks want to help with the presentation and planning let me know
- Pumpkin picking patch at the garden Oct 20th at 2 pm -who can come and help?
- We need someone to make chili
- Someone to help carve pumpkins
- Someone to grill hot dogs
- Someone to help make scarecrow(s)
- Someone to help with the pinata
- Set up tables/decor
- Clean up
- Virtual toxic waste tour at the Brookhaven landfill and Covanta Hempstead 1-5 min dialogue at each site about the site. 1-6 people at each location. Looking at December.
- maryEllen, Bill, Christine
- Housing event: Mr. McNamara
- Dear Friends,
- There is a new effort underway to build Affordable Housing on the property of churches. Many of us worked on this last year because of the need for more housing that people can actually fit into their budgets.
- Help us to advocate for more housing for our people in need!
Updates:
- EPA/DEC EJ Listening letter was sent. Thanks everyone :)
- Letter was sent to the court stating that the adjustment in the settlement is not sufficient and that the covanta violations are an example of the need to know what is in the dump that is toxic as well as the corrective measures- groundwater contamination.
- Latino Justice updates
- Brookhaven landfill permit public comment on the proposal. Will get another opportunity to submit a public comment after DEC review (EarthJustice)
- Green Amendment - NYLPI is not able to assist at this time but may help after we propose a strategy/plan.
- What are the pros and cons of litigation
- Can others join publicly owned/community orgs
- What do we want to win
- The landfill could possibly be closed by time we finish
- Coordinating efforts with LatinoJustice
- Brookhaven landfill permit may not be subject to the cumulative impacts law because it was submitted before the law goes into effect. However, this was probably deliberate as the permit was late last time
- Brookhaven landfill solid waste plan proposal submitted to DEC. DEC responded to the plan. If you want to see the plan and response drop your email.
- EarthJustice may help us with comment once the plan is public
In the news:
- Poor planning leads to economic shortfall. A piece by the lawyer of Patrick fahey
Agenda Nov 1, 2024
Facilitator: Monique
Participants: Annelies, Bill, Mr. McNamara, Christine, Lynne, Mike, Renee, Sylas, Barbara, Ezekiel
Intros: Halloween or election check in no judgment
Acknowledgements
Notetaker:
BLARG Rest:
11/29; 12/20- Jan 3
Actions:
- Suffolk County Leg Meeting November 26th 9:30 am 725 Veterans Mem hwy hauppauge NY 11788
- Monique: Myrna let me know they changed the date to the 26th which is right before the holiday.
- Ezekiel: they always do things like this. Dropping their agenda right before the meeting.
- South Country School Board meeting November 7th Dunton Ave East Patchogue 5 pm
- We are going to work with LatinoJustice at the intersection of environment/education justice and legal advocacy
- Brookhaven Town Board meeting November 19th 3-8 pm
- Let’s let Panico that incineration is not renewable energy in response to the letter him and other supervisors on Long Island sent to the governor.
- In the garden: grants, maintenance, event possibilities, solar powered generators
- Smash Pumpkins Movie Night 🎃
- Mr. McNamara can possibly help with the presentation on zero waste
- Khadija can help depending on the day
- Rally possible when, where: end of 2024 no closure?
- Bill interested in a rally about the dump. Will connect him with Hannah
- Wed Dec 11 7pm The Corridor Peace will be gathering the civic groups from gordon heights miller place etc. and talk about how to promote peace in the area and improve the area. All are welcome. Increase the Peace. Longwood Public Library 800 Middle Country Rd Middle Island, NY 11953
- Lynne: Would someone be speaking about the landfill.
- McNamara: an attendee can bring up the landfill in this forum. It would be a perfect opportunity to raise this.
BLARG Requests:
- Communications, Language Accessibility, canvassers, carpenters
- Paid contractual work if anyone is interested reach out to monique
Updates:
- Next meeting scheduled for 11/14 at 5pm with EarthJustice on zoom. Reach out if you want to join that meeting.
- Community tour 11/15 am 11 am 1pm. Reach put if you want to join.
- Brookhaven landfill
- Horizon Village
- Frank p Long/HELP Suffolk
- Garden
- and EFWA December presentation
- Bill will be interested in helping with that
- Renee: can I get that info
- Monique will share the info once the meeting is scheduled
- Co counsel with EarthJustice on the landfill permit
- Want to reach out to pta and parents of Frank P Long School district children.
- Lynne: Should we quote from GAIA? Would they help with this but
- Monique: they heard about the article and reached out to us and got us going on the LTE.
- Mike: Can help. recommended doing a OpEd instead of LTE because of the word count.
- Monique: besides the LTE/OpEd should we write a letter to the Gov?
- Mike: we can ask the Zero Waste NY group to sign on as well as others.
- Lynne: I can connect with Mike to do the sign on letter
- Mike: agreed it wouldn’t be to hard. Can we get a copy of the letter they sent to the governor so we can go line by line.
- Report back from the Multicultural event at UUF Stony Brook
- Monique: Laura is working the polls so sending out thanks for her help doing the table. We encourage others to do that. Laura was able to get a few people to sign up so we just need to follow up with them.
- Report back from SUNY Old Westbury
- Karl Grossman’s investigative journalist class was there and so were a class studying environment. Will hopefully follow up for students to work with us.
- WALI website to see the events from all of the organizations happening
- Report back from Zero Waste NY
- Review the town solid waste plan
- First local waste plan since the 1990s
- Be prepared for public comments.
Agenda Nov 8, 2024
Facilitator: Monique
Notetaker: christine
Participants: Mike, Lynne, Michelle, BP, Christine, Khadija, William, Mary Ellen, Laura, Justin Low Title six environmental justice how to use fair housing to combat environment issues. O’Neil at DOJ
Intros:
Acknowledgements
BLARG Rest:
11/29; 12/20- Jan 3; (Dec 13 possible)
Actions:
- BLARG, EarthJustice & LatinoJustice 11/14 landfill permit
- BLARG EarthJustice 11/14 DEC corrective measures & Brookhaven solid waste plan
- Tour with LatinoJustice 11/15 11 am
- Brookhaven Town Board meeting November 19th 3-8 pm
- Talk about waste plan, permit, c&d will you stop taking it?
- Christine: we should have all of the articles (or other announcements) of them saying they will close the landfill. Starting from the first time they gave a closure date (if we can find it) and just having all those as materials to submit to the record.
- Lynne: agree with Christine, and maybe even just getting a bigger group who can make repeat messaging on outright asking when the landfill is closing (when public comment is coming up) that can help with folks who maybe are less sureo
- about giving a small speech but still having a good impact on their meeting.
- Michelle: the proclamation is still up (about not accepting C&D after 2024), but they haven't clarified any way on how they will stop.
- Mary Ellen: Christine ?? is the manager for waste management, the Smell Something Say Something campaign? Write to them for update, maybe?Mary Ellen to her about C&D and what is going to happen to that waste, also car fluff (until 2028).
- Monique: shared presentation (from when?) that showed small historical article talking about the landfill’s planned closure in 1995 (and some other fun “facts” about waste management in the 70s-80s).
- Should we show the documentary as well it’s only 18 min
- In the meeting we say YES! Shop that documentary around so we get use of it and spread the message far and wide.
- Rally possible when, where: end of 2024 no closure?
- Anything else
Updates:
- Communications specialists to start soon!
- LTE in response to article about town supervisors letter to Gov Hochul on incineration being classified as renewable energy
- Sign on letter to Gov Hochul in response to the town supervisors letter about incineration being classified as renewable energy
- Mike and Lynne worked the doc over for fact checking and have an outline made for the rebuttal/response.
- Re: the settlement between Covanta and the Town of Brookhaven in the whistleblower case (State of New York et al. ex rel. EPR Corp. et al. v. Covanta Hempstead Co. & Covanta Holding Corp., No. 7549/2013).
- At our request, Covanta and the Town of Brookhaven clarified in a supplemental agreement that the release contained in the proposed settlement pending for approval by the court does not release any claims that the Town may have against Covanta if the Brookhaven Landfill needs remediation in the future. See attached.
- We have been assured by DEC that the webpage for the Corrective Measures proceeding for the Brookhaven landfill will contain all relevant documents. If you believe that there are now or in the future missing documents on that site please: a) contract DEC’s regional office; and b) let me know.
- Michelle results of the monitoring
Agenda 15, 2024
Facilitator: Monique
Notetaker:
Participants: Mike, BP, Bill, MaryEllen, Lynne, Michelle, Laura, Mr. McNamara, Abena, Jwollay, Paul Merkelson,
Intros:
Acknowledgements:
BLARG Rest:
11/29; 12/20- Jan 3; (Dec 13 possible)
Special guest: Paul Merkelson, Transition Town Port Washington
- Bokashi composting pilot loading any thoughts takers?
- Is anyone recycling their food
- Pre Fermenting process can be part of a composting process. It is most commonly used in Asia. This can be such a small undertaking by doing it in your home. Folks in Asia do it in their apartments.
- All it really is putting food scraps in a bin and putting Bokashi bran on it. Which is yeast and microorganism. This is an anaerobic process. So the bucket has to be sealed. You can do meat and dairy. If you are doing a larger scale operation it will have a lot of bones or things like that.
- What I do now is after I cook I put it in a five gallon bucket. The bucket has to be sealed and a weight on it.
- Laura: where do you get Bokashi bran
- Paul: You can make it yourself. I actually sent a bag to Monique that is about 2 lbs.
- The pre fermenting process is great for starting a garden and to go into the compost pile.
- A community garden is good place to do this
- Once you close the bucket it will take two weeks. White mold will start to grow and that is good. Black mold is not good means there is something rotting
- Liquid accumulates at the bottom.You can use it as a fertilizer but it needs to be watered down. It also cleans your drain because of all of the microorganisms.
- Lynne: does it speed up the composting process
- Paul: yes it does heat it up and speeds up the composting process.
- They pick up garbage three times a week in port Washington. If we did this
- Monique: composting has been seen as elitist
- Lynne: We are having an issue getting our compost hot enough. The town needs to do more education
- McNamara: recycle and save less trash less cost
- Five programs one is composts
- Paul will connect with us at the garden to help us get started
Actions:
- South Country Library declined to sponsor our presentation which had me a little disgruntled. But that is what I expect from our district. I’m wondering if folks have connections with Brookhaven free library to see if they would sponsor us and I will try Longwood library tomorrow as I’m going to an event on climate that Nicole from the Brookhaven NAACP is hosting under the banner of her position at dept of state.
- Laura: Jefferson’s ferry 400 people who are retired.
- In the spring earth day Tuesday April 22nd
- McNamara: could we do it at the churches. Yes
- Michelle: I can ask the Brookhaven library.
- Khadija: is there a way to appeal ?
- Brookhaven Town Board meeting November 19th 3-8 pm
- Who can go
- What do we want to say about the permit, plan and incinerators as renewable energy opposition
- Toxic Tour with Beyond Plastics and others across the state tbd. This could be our end of year rally
Updates:
- $5,689.89 as of 11/11
- We have someone who will do our zero waste comms($2,000) and someone else to do comms narrative specialist ($2,000), two north bellport strong awards for $1,000 or holiday baskets (gift cards) and $244.40 for slack
- $445.49 (left if this all goes out)
- Projected Budget 2025-2026
- ALCC
- Garden maintenance
- North Bellport Strong
- 4-8 events
- $25k-$50K Keeps the following going and all the above and:
- Website
- Slack
- Action network
- Google Storage
- DropBox
- Web manager
- Comms
- Garden upgrades
- 50K - 100k+ if we find a partner we could include
- Tech assistance with water testing
- Tech assist with air monitoring
- Tech assist language access
- Zero waste consultant
- Mike G:
- Khadija: north bellport strong
- Mike G: mass comms and newsletter support using Action Network
- Mike G: 140% of salary for benefits
- Wish list donations wanted
- Larger gate
- Larger shed 12x12 or bigger
- Wood chip delivery
- Top soil
- Blower
- Window planter boxes
- Irrigation drip system
- Solar panel generator system
- Solar lights
- Garden carpentry assistance
- Outreach communications
- Legal strategy
- Tech assistance zero waste
- Website management
- Communications media
- General Tech and tools
- Language access tech assistance
- North Bellport Strong Awards
- North Bellport Strong Fund
- Trainings
- Honorariums
- Holiday baskets & movie night?
- All we want for Christmas is a full closure, remediation, stop the transfer of waste, end incineration and a comprehensive environmental justice zero waste plan (this needs to be a Christmas card for socials and the Town reps)
In The News:
- “…This isn't unusual. A significant number of loads that go into the landfill contain soiled materials and household trash from individuals who are undergoing medical treatments.”
Agenda November 22, 2024
Facilitator: Monique
Notetaker:
Participants: Quinn, Christine P, BP, Lynne, Mariana, Khadija
Intros:
Acknowledgements:
BLARG Rest:
Nov 29 - Jan 3
Welcome:
Christine, Jordan and Quinn
- We will use the rest time to onboard and work plans
Wins:
Updates:
- LatinoJustice 3 points of support
- Mariana: amazing two hour tour. We stopped at the EFWA and did a tour there as well
- Community organizer who speak Spanish and English
- In order to hire someone we will need funding. We spoke to monique about a grant we are applying for through Fordham Flourishing in Community (An EPA) they would work on other issues on long island and BLARG as a focus. We are hoping that BLARG would be a partner on the grant. We are talking about contingency plans if we don't get that funding.
- Ethics advisor to advise us on some questions as we would like to nominate for the grant.
- Monique on the grant since the new administration
- Host some bi-lingual community events
- EFWA connection made but slow to commit to a date
- Been connected to sepa mujer in Patchogue they have done events in spanish in north Bellport before.
- Exploring if this is a pathway. Doing research see if there is a viable claim. After that would come back to the BLARG commitment
- The environmental constitutional amendment that was guarantees the right to clean air and water. The highest court in nys has not define what it actually means yet.
- Monique: how BLARG has been involved
- Lynne: has any case one yet
- Mariana: I read a bunch of cases and it is hard to say definitively. There is zero precedent from the highest court. There may be appellate courts where the green amendment has been successfully used, but I haven't had any
- LatinoJustice is going to FOIL around odor complaints.
- Brookhaven landfill permit
- Working with EarthJustice to try to stop the Brookhaven Landfill permit
- Budget part II (see projected budgets below)
Updates:
- $5,689.89 as of 11/11
- We have someone who will do our zero waste comms($2,000) and someone else to do comms narrative specialist ($2,000), two north bellport strong awards for $1,000 or holiday baskets (gift cards) and $244.40 for slack
- $445.49 (left if this all goes out)
- Projected Budget 2025-2026
- ALCC
- Garden maintenance
- North Bellport Strong
- 4-8 events
- $25k-$50K Keeps the following going and all the above and:
- Website
- Slack
- Action network
- Google Storage
- DropBox
- Web manager
- Comms
- Garden upgrades
- 50K - 100k+ if we find a partner we could include
- Tech assistance with water testing
- Tech assist with air monitoring
- Tech assist language access
- Zero waste consultant
- Mike G:
- Khadija: north bellport strong
- Mike G: mass comms and newsletter support using Action Network
- Mike G: 140% of salary for benefits
Report Backs:
- Onboarding and strategy report back
- Jordan: pretty good felt like confident with some of the building blocks getting a better feel for the organization.
- Christine: They had some good ideas to offer us take for zero waste plans
Actions before we go…
- Sign this letter to AG about plastics from Beyond Plastics:
- Suffolk county leg meeting 11/26 at 9:30 am 725 veterans memorial Hwy hauppauge NY 11718
- Any other actions
Close
New Year, New Notes - Click HERE for 2025 Notes