STARTERS

GIANT PRETZEL  14

A giant soft pretzel to share served with salt and Düsseldorf mustard. Add cheese sauce 50¢

SOFT PRETZEL  3.50

Soft pretzel served with salt and Düsseldorf mustard. Add cheese sauce 50¢

BAKED CHEESE CURDS  8

Cheese curds breaded with a house-made batter, sprinkled with Spice House Vulcan Fire Salt and served with a side of ranch

FLATBREAD  11

Flatbread topped with, marinara sauce, italian sausage, arugula,  artichoke hearts, and mozzarella cheese

SALAD

HOUSE SALAD  8.00

Mixed greens or arugula topped with sliced apples, tomatoes, cheddar and dressing..

ADDITIONAL TOPPINGS

Chicken Strips $2.00 -Sun-dried                Bacon $2.00                  Tomatoes

Blue Cheese $1.00      - Onions

DRESINGS

- House         - 1000 Island

- Ranch          - Italian

- Raspberry Vinaigrette

GRILLED CHEESE SANDWICHES

Bread choice of whole grain, sourdough, Italian panini, or Ciabatta.

Sandwiches include one side:

Choice of fruit, salad, or chips.

Substitute for $3: tater tots, breaded cheese curds, cup of soup.

CLASSIC CHEESE  7

American and mild cheddar on white bread

GOURMET CHEESE 9

Gruyere, five-year cheddar, sun-dried tomatoes and garlic aioli

WAFFLE GRILLED CHEESE  10  NEW MENU ITEM

Cheddar, American cheese, bacon, waffles,

topped with maple syrup.

Add 2 chicken strips for $2

HONEY HAM  9

Smoked honey ham, baby swiss and gruyere drizzled with honey

THE ITALIAN  8  NEW

Farmers basil, mozzarella, balsamic soaked tomato on Ciabatta

PESTO TURKEY  9

Oven-roasted turkey, baby swiss, and gruyere and pesto aioli

TURKEY BACON  10  NEW

Turkey, bacon, baby swiss, gruyere, and garlic aioli

SALAMI & CHEESE  9

Usinger’s hard salami, garlic aioli and your choice of 2 cheeses: mild cheddar, smoked swiss, gruyere, baby swiss, or American

BLOODY MARY SANDWICH  10   NEW MENU ITEM

Havarti cheese with horseradish and chives, mozzarella, German salami, sun-dried tomatoes, and balsamic drizzle with fire and celery salt

CUBAN BBQ  11  NEW

Honey ham, swiss, gruyere, pickles, BBQ pork, and Düsseldorf mustard

SPICY GOURMET  9

Smoked pepper jack, ghost pepper cheddar, sun-dried tomatoes, garlic aioli

BBQ GRILLED CHEESE  10  NEW

Smoked pepper jack, smoked gouda, and BBQ pork

SAUSAGES

Served on a pretzel bun with

ketchup & mustard. Includes 1 side:

Choice of fruit, side salad, or chips.

Add cheese for 50¢.

USINGER’S BRATWURST  7

Usinger’s classic, coarse ground bratwurst

USINGER’S CHEDDAR-BACON CHICKEN BRAT  7

Usinger’s smoked bratwurst with bacon and Wisconsin cheddar

USINGER’S FRANKFURTER 8

Usinger’s ¼ lb sausage

USINGER’S CHEDDAR- JALAPEÑO BRAT  8

Usinger’s smoked brat filled with cheddar cheese and jalapeños


CHEESE BOARDS  Served with nuts, fruit, and crackers. Serves 2 people.                                                                                                 Add Gluten-free crackers for $2.00.

WISCONSIN SAMPLER  15.50

BLUE AFFINÉE  

Creamy double buttermilk blue cheese, served with honey

GRUYERE GRAND CRU RESERVE

Rich and creamy with a nutty aroma

EIGHT-YEAR CHEDDAR  

Extremely sharp and intense with a complex flavor

and crunchy texture

MERLOT BELLAVITANO

A cheddar parmesan blend with a merlot soaked rind

WISCONSIN AWARD WINNERS  19.50

MARIEKE AGED GOUDA

Smooth and creamy with a slightly sweet & nutty aroma  

U.S. GRAND CHEESE CHAMPION

BLACK TRUFFLE SHEEP’S MILK

A pungent, earthy aroma  1ST PLACE 2013 WORLD CHEESE CONTEST             

PLEASANT RIDGE RESERVE

Alpine style, unpasteurized cheese with a sweet, grassy flavor

MOST AWARDED CHEESE IN AMERICAN HISTORY

MUENSTER

Creamy, mild, and savory  1ST PLACE 2008 WORLD CHEESE CONTEST

BEER CHEESE  13.50

FIVE-YEAR CHEDDAR

A perfect balance of sharp and creamy

FUEL CAFE BEER CHEDDAR

Mild cheddar infused with beer

SMOKED PEPPER JACK

Smoked Monterey jack with spicy jalapeño peppers

WISCONSIN BRICK

Widmer’s Wisconsin brick, traditionally pressed with bricks

UBER FAVORITES  17.50

GOUDA GOLD RESERVE

A smooth and creamy gouda

APPLEWOOD SMOKED CHEDDAR

Smoked cheddar hand rubbed with paprika

SNOWFIELDS BUTTERKASE

Aged cheese inspired by Austrian butterkase (butter cheese)

MONTAMORÉ

A sweet and creamy cheese that finishes with a tangy bite

CHEDDAR PLATE  15.50

FIVE-YEAR CHEDDAR

A perfect balance of sharp and creamy

FUEL CAFE BEER CHEDDAR

Mild cheddar infused with beer

AGED BANDAGED CHEDDAR

Aged in cheese cloth, a hard and dry texture with a full flavor profile

CRANBERRY WHITE CHEDDAR

Creamy white cheddar with tart Wisconsin cranberries

CUSTOM CHEESE BOARD

Choose any of the following cheeses - $5 each 

Served with nuts, fruit, and crackers

MARIEKE FIVE-YEAR GOUDA

Aged, caramelized, rock hard gouda

BLUE AFFINÉE

Creamy double buttermilk blue cheese

ENGLISH HOLLOW

Small-batch, English style cheddar cheese

PLEASANT RIDGE RESERVE

Alpine-style, unpasteurized cheese with a sweet, grassy flavor

MOST AWARDED CHEESE IN AMERICAN HISTORY

BLACK TRUFFLE SHEEP’S MILK

A pungent, earthy aroma

RED ROCK

Cheddar-style blue cheese, crumbly with earthy tones and blue veins

GRAND CRU SURCHOIX

Extra-aged gruyere

2016 WORLD CHAMPION

MEAT & CHEESE

MEAT & CHEESE SAMPLER  9

German salami, baby swiss, and mild cheddar with a side of bread

CHICKEN STRIPS  8

Three breaded chicken tenderloin strips  served with ketchup, mustard and tater tots


MACARONI & CHEESE

CLASSIC MAC  10

Homemade mac and cheese topped with five-year cheddar and  panko bread crumbs

FRANK ‘N’ MAC  11

Our homemade mac and cheese made with Usinger’s frankfurters, topped with mild cheddar and panko bread crumbs

BACON CHEVRE MAC 11

Homemade mac and cheese topped with fresh goat cheese, crunchy bacon,  and panko bread crumbs

SIDES

$3 EXCEPT FOR CHIPS/CURDS

CHIPS $2

Choice of Sprecher Kettle chips, Lays, or Ruffles

FRUIT

Sliced green apples and oranges

SIDE SALAD

Smaller portion of our house salad

TATER TOTS  

Crispy tots baked to perfection

BAKED CHEESE CURDS  $4

House battered and seasoned with Spice House Vulcan Fire Salt. Served with side of ranch.

WHITE WINE

LIGHT & SWEET

House Riesling - 5.5/20
Moscato d’Asti - 9.75

AROMATIC & ENTICING

House Pinot Grigio - 5.5/20

BOLD & STRONG

Chardonnay  - 8
Sauvignon Blanc - 7/24

RED WINE

LIGHT & FRUITY

Pinot Noir - 8

MEDIUM & EARTHY

House Cabernet Sauvignon - 5.5/20

Zinfandel - 6/22

Merlot - 7

BEER

DRAUGHT

36 Wisconsin beers available on tap
Please see our beer list for current selections

FLIGHTS

Bestseller Flight - 8

Build Your Own Flight - 10

BOTTLES

Check our beer menu for current selections

N/A

SPRECHER  2

Root beer, low calorie root beer, cherry cola, orange, ginger ale, grape, cream soda

FOUNTAIN DRINKS  1.50

Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Iced Tea, and Lemonade

JUICE  2.25

Cranberry, orange, and pineapple

HOUSE COCKTAILS                

NEW OLD FASHIONED  7

New Glarus Raspberry Tart, sugar, orange, Angostura bitters, muddled, topped with Korbel brandy, soda

WISCO MULE  9.50

Rehorst Vodka, Belfast ginger beer and lime

CUCUMBER MULE  10

Muddled cucumbers and limes, Rehorst vodka, Belfast ginger beer

3RD STREET MANGO  7

Mango rum, cranberry juice, and pineapple juice

WISCONSIN BLOODY  8.75

Our signature bloody recipe, rail vodka, topped with salami and a spicy 3 cheese garnish. Served with a PBR chaser.

DELUXE BLOODY  12.75

Our signature bloody recipe, Rehorst vodka, topped with salami, a spicy 3 cheese garnish, hickory stick, and string cheese. With your choice of beer tap chaser.

UPDATED 5.17.18