Invitation to debate disability benefit cuts with Swansea DPAC
21st April 2025
For the attention of:
- Torsten Bell MP for Swansea West, Parliamentary Secretary for the Treasury and Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Pensions.
- Tonia Antoniazzi MP for Gower, and chair of the Northern Ireland Affairs Select Committee.
- Carolyn Harris MP for Swansea East, and deputy leader of the Welsh Labour Party.
Dear Torsten, Tonia, and Carolyn,
Disabled People Against Cuts (DPAC) members in Swansea would like to, once again, repeat our invitation for you to publicly debate the issue of disability benefit cuts with us. We would ensure that the debate is carried out fairly, respectfully, and in an orderly fashion.
We hope that you respond before the end of the month to coordinate on a suitable date, otherwise we will have to book a venue for a time that may be less convenient for you.
We think holding the debate in public is important, given the way disabled people and carers have generally been ignored and "spoken about", rather than listened to, by MPs. We found much of the language used upsetting and insulting, and would appreciate a proper "right of reply". We also have serious concerns with the green paper consultation process itself, and do not have confidence that it will properly take our views into account.
For these reasons, we hope that you will accept our invitation to explain your views to our members, and publicly debate with us. Either way, we are determined to make sure that disabled people and carers are heard, and we will hold a public debate regardless of your attendance. Given multiple attempts to contact you so far, we would appreciate a reply no later than the 30th of April.
In this case, we have decided to make our letter public. We will be appealing to Labour-affiliated trade union branches and to the public for support. The South Wales Evening Post, the Western Mail, and the South Wales Echo have now also printed multiple letters inviting you to debate with us.
Yours faithfully,
Swansea Disabled People Against Cuts
https://linktr.ee/swanseaDPAC
swanseadpac@gmail.com
Support this letter:
Share URL: bit.ly/swansea-dpac-debate-invite
Add your signature: bit.ly/swansea-dpac-sign-letter
Labour-affiliated trade union members: bit.ly/swansea-dpac-labour-appeal
Replies from MPs.
We thank Tonia Antoniazzi MP for holding a respectful meeting with us. Here’s our report.
Carolyn Harris MP has so far just given us a copy & paste response in favour of the cuts, and refuses to talk to us further.
Torsten Bell MP has flatly refused to attend a public debate and has publicly insulted us.
Supported by (over 250 signatures):
Signatories state:
- I instruct Labour MPs to attend debates organised by Disabled People Against Cuts (DPAC) and allies.
- I support the letter from Swansea DPAC, challenging Torsten Bell MP, Tonia Antoniazzi MP, and Carolyne Harris MP to a public debate.
Signed by:
- TSSA, union for the transport and travel industries.
- Universities Against Disability Cuts UK
- Welfare Scotland
- VOICES ADFOCAD (Charity by and for unpaid carers in Wales)
- Swansea Council LG UNISON
- The Trade Unionist and Socialist Coalition (TUSC)
- Dr Jay Watts - https://sites.google.com/view/openletterdisabilitybenefits/
- Progressive Independent Group, Wrexham County Borough Council
- Cllr Anthony Wedlake, Wrexham (TUSC / Progressive Independent Group)
- Swansea Socialist Party
- Cardiff Socialist Party
- Aberystwyth Socialist Party
- Aberystwyth Socialist Students
- Cas Metcalf, City and County of Swansea UNISON equalities officer (personal capacity)
- Luke Dukinfield, Unite Workplace Representative
- Ben Golightly, Swansea (Gower)
- Jenna Mae, Swansea
- Erica Thomas
- Amie Curry
- Lucie G
- Jonathan Golding, Cardiff
- Tristan Gjertsen, Swansea
- Matthew Shephard, Swansea West
- Karen Acton
- Roberts Caroline
- Susan Stuart
- Vixen
- Joe Fathallah
- A bryan
- Diane Cooper
- C Brannigan
- Caroline Sanchez Del Pino
- Georgia Miggins Swansea
- Joanne Patterson, Caerphilly
- Lorna Watts
- Andrew Angus
- Steven Tavernor
- Katie Walker
- Lucy Nabijou
- Mr G Barfield
- CC West Midlands
- D Mackenzie, Chester
- Natalie Toppin
- Carron Pierre
- Sean Warren
- Matthew Winters
- Di Heenan
- Philip Leworthy, Swansea
- Jason Alcock
- Jason Owen
- Rhys, Swansea
- Elli Pattison
- Susie Jess, Southampton.
- Christine Jardine
- Jamie Churchill, Cardiff
- Siân, Swansea
- Mandy Haywood
- Sally Dodgson
- Marc Burton
- E Spence
- Jason Barrow
- William Orr
- Claire Keenan
- Dave Swansea
- Mark Parry
- A Reilly
- Simon J Keenan
- Catherine Edgson
- Lorraine Smith
- J, Osborne
- Dennis b
- Thomas Connolly
- Angela Torr
- Lauren Poché
- Janis whitehead
- Sam Oldham
- P Deans
- Terrified chronically sick and disabled person
- Erica Thomas
- Christine Hallworth Stockport
- Chris Bligh
- Asad Ali
- A Seels Chesterfield
- Caitlin, Plymouth
- SDT
- Kathy kelly northampton
- Michelle Eccles
- Jean Eveleigh
- Jonathan Maher
- Mr P , Merseyside
- Alison James
- Diane Hempsall, Lancashire
- Alex (Bridgend south wales )
- Sam Y
- Ann Sartori
- Ian K
- Matt Thompson
- Victoria langley
- Mark H
- N Thompson, Neath
- Emma Ann Louise Jones
- Rebecca Flanagan, Nottingham
- Kim Foster
- Stephen Lockwood
- MD Swansea
- Merch Rebecca
- Olivia Mowll
- Sue
- D Dempsey
- R Campbell
- G Tanner
- Christine Connell
- Simon Connell
- Nina
- Darren Smith
- Dawn Sharples, Stockport
- Jason northern
- Richard Green
- Dusty
- Steve Jackson Chesterfield
- Andrew Leng
- Jane Scott
- Dylan Lintern-Mole
- Jane M
- Tony Michael
- Helen Moore
- I m Bridgend
- Anonymous please (scared about my name being on the bill and being targeted by the government)
- Matthew Campbell, Motherwell
- Matthew Casbolt, Sheffield
- Clare Patton
- Jacquelyn Haley
- K. Condon
- Leo branton
- Freya Sheldon-Burtoft, Mexborough
- C Currier
- Tamara Epps, Lowestoft
- Shaben Begum
- Jennifer Parry, Cardiff
- KyleH
- Marc
- Porl Rannik
- Michael Harrison
- Julie Warren
- Tyler Hilton
- Serena
- Samantha Eva, Barry
- Georgia Stewart Norwich
- Leanne Hubbard
- Jen Cox
- Nikki C
- Mandy Moore Barnsley
- Diane mantle
- Kevin Geals, Worcester
- Rebecca Devitt, Isle of Wight
- Eugene Battini, Neath
- Erin Ladeinde, London
- Chloe Angharad Morgan
- Jasper Molloy, Northampton
- Sarah Parkin Cheshire
- Kathryn ford
- LW
- J Green
- Jamie Akerman, Swansea
- Phil Coleman, Pontardawe
- Adam.E Swansea
- Maria C J
- Luke Young, Swansea
- Plus many anonymous signatures in support!