Published using Google Docs
Michael-comment-3
Updated automatically every 5 minutes

^Comment above said:"So what is the flaw or the hidden assumption that is being violated?"

----------------------------------------------------

I am surprised that none of the regulars here have attempted to tackle this curious conundrum. I think there may be some concern among blog-participants that Michael may get upset if they were to suggest that he has made a mistake. This concern is completely unfounded, because Michael is NEVER wrong. Of course, he may make some typographical errors now and then, but that is hardly the same as 'being wrong'.

In this case, Michael seems to have made a typographical error when he typed, "As Thin Air pays wages, the workers will spend 75% of those wages on their own consumption, and they will save 25%."

What matters in this case is the NATIONAL (or overall) savings rate and not the personal savings-rate of those workers. As long as the newly-hired workers SPEND their income (i.e. they don't hoard money), what proportion of it they spend on consumption is not relevant. Even if they spend 100% of their income on consumption (i.e. their personal savings-rate is 0%), the GDP multiplier still remains the same at M = Deficit/NATIONAL-Savings-rate.

This is because the national savings-rate includes the savings rates of individual workers as well as the savings-rates of businesses and government. When the workers spend their wages, the prices they will pay for goods & services already include the profits of businesses as well as the taxes levied by governments. So the effective-savings rate associated with the whole spending-cascade generated by the initial burst of deficit spending will finally turn out to closer to the overall NATIONAL savings-rate rather than the personal savings-rate.

So let us look at the NATIONAL (or overall) savings rate in America today:

https://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/W206RC1Q156SBEA

Again following the original example offered by Michael, we can calculate the resulting increase in GDP "created by the additional spending unleashed" as follows:

Increase in GDP = Original-Deficit/NATIONAL-Savings-rate = 440 billion$/(0.18) = 2.44 Trillion$, with a rise in consumption of 2.0 Trillion$ and a corresponding rise in savings of 440 Billion$ (equal to the deficit).

This is clearly a lot better that the absurd 8.36 Trillion$ figure we had as the rise in consumption before, but it STILL seems much TOO HIGH. I must have missed something.

What have I missed? Would someone like to comment? DvD? Marko? Anyone?