VIEWS ON THE BOYCOTT: PROTECTION FOR XDINARY HEROES AND JUSTICE FOR GOO GUNIL

WHAT IS HAPPENING

Goo Gunil, the drummer and leader of Xdinary Heroes, was terminated from the group and ended his activities with JYP Entertainment on August 13, 2026, due to the controversy that arose over his private conversation being recorded and spread to the public. In that conversation, Gunil used several harsh words and inappropriate expressions. Through his legal counsel, he acknowledged his actions for using inappropriate language was a mistake and he apologized to fans and the members of Xdinary Heroes for the effect it caused.

However, the context of the conversation needs to be considered. According to Gunil's explanation, those words were directed at sasaengs who broke into Xdinary Heroes' dorm, placed a GPS tracker on his private car, and followed him around, as well as malicious anonymous accounts whose posts and comments went far beyond criticism, not at Xdinary Heroes fans. His legal counsel also explained that the conversation remarks in private must not get leaked anywhere. The pressure caused by repeated privacy violations left him in need of a safe space. Yet the agency failed to properly protect Xdinary Heroes, including their privacy and well-being. Now, there is no guarantee that the remaining members are protected, despite being exposed to the same threats. Acknowledging Gunil's harsh venting does not mean we should ignore the context behind them. Both things can be acknowledged at the same time: Gunil is responsible for his words, and an artist still deserves protection of their privacy, safety, and personal life.

On August 13, 2026, JYP Entertainment announced that Gunil was "leaving" Xdinary Heroes and that his exclusive contract was terminated based on a "mutual agreement." JYP stated, after discussions with Gunil, they had decided that group activities could not continue with him. However, on August 20, 2026, through his legal counsel Sung Jae-hwan of Joowon Law Firm, Gunil's side officially stated that Gunil did not leave the group of his own volition and never agreed to the termination of his contract. (Source: Official Statement by Attorney Sung Jae-Hwan, Legal Counsel of Goo Gunil, Member of Xdinary Heroes) His side also expressed a desire to continue discussions with JYP Entertainment.

Thus, there are two different versions of how the contract termination occurred. JYP Entertainment stated that the termination was carried out by mutual agreement. Meanwhile, Gunil's side stated that he did not agree to the termination. This discrepancy is one of the main base of our demands. We will not pretend to know what happened behind the closed doors of JYP's meeting room. We also will not claim that the legal outcome of this matter has already been determined. On September 18, 2026, Gunil's legal counsel was also reported to have filed a Certification of Contents regarding the continuation status of the exclusive contract, along with a request for related documents and data. If that document is available and can be verified, this step shows that the issue of the contract's status has not stopped at public statements but has been brought into formal legal communication.

Because this process is still ongoing, our demand is not to claim that the legal outcome has already been determined, but to ask JYP Entertainment for transparency about what actually happened, what the basis for the contract termination was, and how that decision was made.

WHO IS THIS BOYCOTT TARGETED AT AND WHY THROUGH XDINARY HEROES

This boycott movement is directed at JYP Entertainment, the agency that manages Xdinary Heroes, not at the members of Xdinary Heroes personally and individuals. We are not boycotting because we hate Xdinary Heroes. We do not want to see the remaining members fail. We also do not believe that supporting Xdinary Heroes means ceasing to love them.

Quite the opposite. We are doing this because we believe that the relationship between artist, agency, and consumer goes both ways. Fans give their support through streaming, purchasing albums and merchandise, concert tickets, and various other forms of consumption. At the same time, the agency has a responsibility to manage their artists' careers, provide a decent working environment, and handle matters concerning artists responsibly.

When we have no access to the company's internal decision-making room, one of the forms of voice that we can control as consumers is the decision for what we choose to buy and support. Therefore, Xdinary Heroes commercial activities can be used as a pressure point against JYP Entertainment.

This boycott is not about punishing Xdinary Heroes. It is about using the consumer's voice to convey to the company that some of their consumers do not simply accept this decision and demand transparency. The boycott is not measured solely by how much financial loss can be caused. The aim is to send a clear signal to the company: this decision has negative consequences to consumer trust.

WHY DO WE DO THIS BOYCOTT MOVEMENT

1. The Failure of Protecting the Privacy and Artist’s Well-Being

This controversy does not stand alone. Gunil's side cites heavy pressure related to online posts as well as invasion of his private life. His legal counsel explained that this pressure was part of Gunil’s reason for venting his emotions in the mentioned private conversation. We are not pointing this issue to justify his wrong doing. However, we also reject the idea that an artist's mistake could automatically abolish the company's obligation to protect the artist's privacy and safety. If an artist experiences harassment, pressure, or intrusion into their private life, the agency still has an obligation to protect the artist, and that responsibility should not be dismissed because of the artist's mistake.

This question becomes more relevant in light of JYP Entertainment's own stated commitment. On May 20, 2026, JYP released an official notice stating that the company enforces a zero-tolerance policy against all forms of malicious content and stalking behavior that threaten the safety and privacy of its artists, including active monitoring across major online platforms and uncompromising legal action against perpetrators. If the pressure that Gunil experienced, including the alleged trespassing to the dorm and the installation of a tracking device on his personal vehicle, as well as the massive acts of malicious online comments targeting Gunil and other Xdinary Heroes members as mentioned by his side, did in fact happened, then the public has the right to ask how far this safety provider commitment was actually upheld for this case. (Source: JYP Entertainment, Update on Legal Actions for the Protection of Artist Rights.) 

Protecting an artist does not mean justifying their actions. Protecting an artist means ensuring that when problems arise, the company handles the entire issue with responsibility and right judgement, and not using the easiest way for making a decision.

2. Lack Of Transparency Regarding Gunil's Contract Termination Status

JYP Entertainment states that Gunil's contract was terminated based on mutual agreement. However, Gunil's side later officially stated that he did not agree to the contract termination. The discrepancy between these two statements is not something that should simply be overlooked. We are not asking the public to determine who is right before the process is complete. We are asking JYP Entertainment to provide clarity regarding the basis, process, and status of the contract termination. When a company issues a decision that can drastically change the artist's future, consumers have the right to question how the decision was made.

3. Various Forms of Protest Were Carried Out Before The Financial Boycott

A financial boycott was not the first form of resistance we chose. Previously, fans had used various ways of voicing their aspirations, including hashtag campaigns, mass emails, protest flower wreaths, and truck protests. When these methods did not bring any transparency we demand, the decision to limit JYP’s financial income became the form of consumer pressure we chose. Because in the end, consumers have one basic form of voice: we can choose not to buy.

JYP Entertainment's FY2025 report records consolidated revenue of KRW 821.9 billion. Revenue from albums and music was recorded at approximately KRW 257.9 billion, or 31.4% of total revenue, while concerts contributed approximately KRW 188.9 billion, or 23.0%. These figures are for JYP as a whole and cannot be used to determine Xdinary Heroes' specific contribution. However, the data shows that albums/music and concerts are important parts of the company's business activities. Therefore, delaying the purchase of albums and merchandise, especially during the comeback period, was chosen as one concrete way to convey consumers' objections to the company. (Source: JYP Entertainment Annual Report FY2025)

WHERE TO SPREAD BOYCOTT AWARENESS

This action requires collective support and can be carried out across various social media platforms. Information can be spread through Instagram, X, TikTok, and other platforms. However, the spread of information must remain responsible. Focus the information on the chronology, official statements, documents, demands, and verifiable facts.

Do not spread rumors. Do not launch personal attacks. Do not turn this movement into a fan war. Our goal is to make the demands toward JYP Entertainment clearer, and not to cause new victims among fans. The more people understand the issue from verifiable information, the greater the chance these demands will become known to the public and to the party they are addressed to.

WHEN DO WE DO THE BOYCOTT

The boycott is carried out primarily during the first-week sales period until approximately 1–2 months after the comeback, or until the comeback promotion and hype begin to subside. The first-week period was chosen because it is one of the important periods for a release's initial performance.

However, this does not mean that support must stop forever. The aim of this movement is to delay commercial support, not to erase Xdinary Heroes from our lives. We want the company to understand that there are consumers who are willing to hold back their purchases until this demand for transparency receives a proper response.

HOW THIS MOVEMENT SEEKS ACCOUNTABILITY FOR GUNIL AND BETTER PROTECTION FOR THE REMAINING MEMBERS.

We understand the concern that the boycott may affect the remaining members of Xdinary Heroes. That concern is valid. However, we also need to distinguish between consumer decisions and company decisions.

The company can make decisions to respond and change the sales by reducing the artists' activities or work opportunities. Consumers cannot be asked to keep buying out of fear that the company will make certain decisions regarding its own artists.

On the contrary, if the company truly values Xdinary Heroes and the remaining members, then JYP should have the responsibility to ensure that the group's future does not depend on whether consumers agree or disagree with an internal decision.

We do not want Xdinary Heroes to stop. We want them to keep creating. We want the remaining members to continue to have the opportunity to make music, work, and grow in a safe environment. At the same time, we want the matter of concern about Gunil to receive clarity. Those two things can be chosen mutually. We can support the members without having to give financial approval to every decision the company makes.

HOW DO WE DO THE BOYCOTT WHILE SUPPORTING XDINARY HEROES EFFECTIVELY

1. Delay Purchasing Albums and Merchandise

Delay purchasing albums and merchandise The first-week sales period is the priority, since it is the period most widely used to measure a comeback's performance. But the signal is strongest when it is sustained, so we strongly encourage everyone to keep holding their purchases until approximately 1–2 months after the comeback, when the promotional period ends and the comeback hype begins to subside. After that, fans who still want to own the album can consider the second-hand market or albums previously purchased by sellers for fansign/fancall purposes. The same can be applied to merchandise. In this way, we can still own and enjoy Xdinary Heroes' work without making direct purchases from the company during the boycott period.

The point is not to stop loving Xdinary Heroes. The point is to limit direct financial income to the company for as long as these demands have not received a proper answer.

2. Keep Supporting The Music Through Streaming

While purchases of physical products are delayed, supporting Xdinary Heroes' work still can be done through official streaming platforms such as Spotify, Youtube, Apple Music, Melon, and others. Streaming can help maintain the exposure of their music and shows that a boycott of the company's commercial activities is not the same as abandoning the members' work.

For members who hold credits as lyricists, composers, or arrangers, the holders of economic rights in the work may be entitled to royalties in accordance with rights ownership, work credits, applicable contracts, and relevant royalty distribution mechanisms. However, it should be understood that not all streaming revenue automatically goes directly to the members. Distribution depends on the rights and contracts of each work.

3. Limit Engagement With Promotional Content

Fans who wish to participate further in the boycott can also limit their engagement with comeback promotional posts on Xdinary Heroes' official accounts during the boycott period. This does not mean attacking the official accounts, deleting comments, or taking action against other fans. It is enough to choose not to actively engage with promotional content.

A FINAL NOTE

We know that this movement will not be approved by some Villains. Some of us might fear the boycott will affect the remaining members. Some of us might feel that buying albums and supporting the comeback is their way of showing love for Xdinary Heroes. There may also be those who feel that the decision not to buy is a form of guilt-tripping other fans. We understand that. but this boycott is not about who loves Xdinary Heroes the most. We are not measuring a fan's level of love by the contents of their basket. We are also not asking anyone to hate the remaining members, attack them, or hope that their activities fail. We are doing this precisely because we still care. We care about Xdinary Heroes. We care about the members who are still there. And we care about Gunil, whose situation to this day still leaves questions about how the termination of his contract actually took place.

We know that we do not have access to JYP's meeting room. We do not know the entire contents of their contract. We do not know everything that was discussed behind the scenes. And that is why we will not fabricate answers for the parts that are not yet known. What we have are the official statements from both sides, the differences between them, and questions that remain unanswered to a degree we consider inadequate.

And as fans and consumers, there is one thing that is truly within our control: our own money. We choose to hold back that money. We choose not to give direct financial support to the company until these demands receive a proper answer. We can still listen to the music. We can still love the members. We can still hope that they are doing well. We can still celebrate their work. Without having to consider that we must support every decision the company makes.

So, to those of you who are still questioning the same things: don’t let our objections end with a timeline. Don’t just repost. Don’t just ask, “How could JYP do this?” and then continue giving the company the same money the next day. If our objections are genuine, let’s turn them into actions that the company cannot ignore.

If our objections are real, let us turn them into real consumer action. Delay purchases. Reduce commercial support. Spread verified information. Convey our demands clearly. And do not let this discussion stop just because the comeback has begun.

We are not asking JYP Entertainment to give a perfect answer. We are asking them to provide clarity regarding a decision that concerns an artist who has worked under their company. Because in the end, we are not just sales numbers. We are consumers. And consumers have the right to say "no" when they disagree.

If we have always said that Xdinary Heroes is six people we love, then at the very least, for Gunil, do not let his name end at a single company announcement.

Do not let the questions end there.

We are not abandoning Xdinary Heroes.

We are refusing to pretend that nothing happened.

This is about refusing to stay silent.

BOYCOTT JYPE UNTIL THERE IS TRANSPARENCY.

ADDITIONAL REFERENCE

Developing "Subversive Common" Through Boycott and Buycott ; K-pop Fans Activism of Producing and Consuming Unofficial Merchandise

Submission of a Certification of Contents by Attorney Sung Jae-hwan, Legal Representative of Goo Gunil. September 18, 2026.