Published using Google Docs
GeoPolitics of Sustainable Energy
Updated automatically every 5 minutes

GeoPolitics of Sustainable Energy

……………………………………………………………………………………………………………

Purpose:

You are a team of energy policy advisors with various backgrounds tasked with trying to research and draft an international climate/energy agreement.  The agreement is an initiative by the energy advisors to the US government and to the Chinese government to promote long-term environmental, economic and industrial health.  In a group of 4, compose a 5-10 minute proposal (with Google Docs) with visuals that clearly state what you think governments are, can, and should, and/or shouldn’t be doing to promote green/alternative/sustainable energy and curb carbon emissions.  You can create a general argument or choose a specific energy to focus on.

>> QUESTIONS to ANSWER DURING THE COURSE OF YOUR PRESENTATION <<

 

1.     WINNERS AND LOSERS: Who are the losers with this plan?  Who stands to gain the most?  How will these constituents be convinced/dealt with/brought on board?

 

2.     PROJECTED REDUCTION: What is the actual predicted long-term and short-term reduction in dangerous fossil fuel emissions?  What technologies/methods are most supporting?

 

3.     PUBLIC PERCEPTION: What do your average citizens of both countries think, and what are the obstacles and challenges to gaining support of public opinion?

 

4.     LEGISLATION: How will you pass legislation to support it?  

 

5.     COST: Who will pay for this?  How will it affect the global economy?  How will it affect local and national economies?  How does this affect a highly developed country like the US, vs. a growing country like China?

 

6.    POLICY NAME: Come up with a catchy and/or meaningful name.

 

 

Any or all of the following topics can also be included in your argument:

  •  Energy Subsidies
  • Taxes and Tax Incentives
  • Public Opinion Challenges and Opportunities in various regions
  • Mandates
  • Climate Bills
  • Education and Social Awareness
  • Investment in Research (private or public)
  • Cap and Trade Laws
  • Long-Term Regional Agreements
  • Trade Tariffs

 

What will make your argument good?:

  • Use examples of methods that have worked in the past or may be working now
  • Cite viable sources for your argument
  • Talk about broad and specific examples (i.e. what can be done in general?  What can be done with bio-fuel in the Midwest?)
  • If you know there are specific drawbacks to an idea, point them out but also point out why the positives out way drawbacks.
  • Include goals and dates.
  • Include good visuals and graphs.
  • Consider all economic classes.
  • Consider the realities of globalization and the current national economy.
  • Divide and conquer! Don’t all research the same things.

 

Participation rule:

  • Everyone must speak during the presentation.
  • Split up the work so that your argument covers multiple perspectives

 

TIMELINE:

Class 1: (3/3) Project Introduced + Groups Created: Begin Research and Design

 

Class 2:  (3/5) Research and Design in Team Work Day

 

Class 3:  (3/9) 10 min Work Day in Teams – Start Presentation (4 groups)

 

Class 4: (3/11) Presentations - Reflection (2 groups)

Assessment

A = Class time used to prepare argument.  Clearly demonstrate research during presentation by actively participating.

B = Class time used to prepare argument.  Unclear argument but participation still apparent.

C and Below = Time used poorly and/or unclear that you were an active member of your group.

 



RESOURCES:

EVERYONE READS:

An Overview of China and the US:  A Comparison of Green Energy Programs and Policies Congressional Research Review

https://www.fas.org/sgp/crs/row/R41748.pdf

 


BACKGROUND READINGS

On the 2014 Obama US/China Climate Deal (Emissions Reduction Agreement)

http://www.cfr.org/environmental-policy/obama-china-climate-deal-cant-save-world-so-/p33831

 

Positive View of the Historic Climate Deal

http://thinkprogress.org/climate/2014/11/12/3591433/china-renewable-energy-commitment/

 

On the Chinese Energy Protection Law just passed, 2015

http://www.cfr.org/china/chinas-environmental-enforcement-glitch/p36021

 

On the Crisis of Energy specific to China

http://www.cfr.org/china/chinas-environmental-future-power-people/p31193

http://www.cfr.org/china/chinas-environmental-crisis/p12608

 

On China’s energy Plans/From Greenpeace (as published in the NyTimes)

http://www.nytimes.com/2014/07/24/world/asia/greenpeace-says-chinas-energy-plans-exacerbate-climate-change.html?_r=0

 



BACKGROUND VIDEOS

A proposal from former Michigan Governor Jennifer Granholm(Ted):

Jennifer Granholm: A clean energy proposal -- race to the top! | Talk Video | TED.com

 

A short on a recent sanctions toward Chinese Solar Panels:

U.S. Solar Energy Stocks Shines After Sanctions on China Video - ABC News

 

This is a long 45 discussion on recent carbon reduction deal (watch excerpts):

Washington Journal Thomas Lorenzen US-China | Video | C-SPAN.org

 

A republican take on recent US China recent carbon reduction deal:

China Climate Deal? ‘Pffffft,' Say Republicans

 

A general proposal for a sustainable long term energy system:

Powering the People 2014 - DOE Quadrennial Energy Review Briefing - Jonathan Pershing - YouTube

 

A take on energy challenges in China:

Mikkal E. Herberg on China’s Energy Future | US-China Institute

 

China US Nuclear Policies (Short):

IdeasLabs 2013 - David M Lampton - Chinese Domestic Energy Politics and Civil Nuclear Power - YouTube

Renewable Energy and the Clash of Civilizations

http://www.theglobalist.com/storyid.aspx?storyid=9890 

The Dangerous Appeal of China’s Green Mercantilism

http://www.theglobalist.com/storyid.aspx?storyid=9894

 

 

Sabrina

Troy

John

Shelby

Monday

Natalie

Joelle

Zach O

Caio

Anderson

Monday

Will

Zach H

Lawrie

Oliver

Wednesday

Riley

Clara

Iman

Zeli

Matt L.

Monday

Amelia

Joyce

Charles

Cole

Eugene

Monday

Dylan

Jacqueline

Matt J.

John

Wednesday