Evaluating Your Sources

Use a Rat TRAP:

               How can I tell the good information from the bad?                              What do you look at when buying milk?

Why do we need to critically evaluate?

1. Keep out the "rats" (bad, inaccurate, or biased information)
2. Better research sources = better paper = better grades
3. Save time & effort: if it doesn't fit your needs, why use it?
4. Critical reading leads to creative output which leads to #2 above
5. Bias is everywhere, but can be identified with critical reading
6. Web: professional-looking sites can be produced cheaply & quickly by anyone
7. Evaluating information = lifelong skill; can be applied to all aspects of modern life
8. Accurate information = informed citizens = stronger democracy

4 Evaluation Factors:

Timeliness (when?)

• Does the topic you are researching require current data?
• When was the information authored/created or last updated?

Reliability (how?)

• Are the author's sources documented? Research methods revealed?
• Is the publication peer-reviewed/scholarly?

Authority (who?)

• Author credentials available?
• Is the author qualified to write on the topic?

Purpose (why?)

• Is there a discernable bias or agenda? Misinformation or propaganda?
• More information on identifying purpose / bias: http://tinyurl.com/idpurpose