Click Here to Sign this Letter. Or copy and paste this link into your browser: https://forms.gle/Ej4Gofzd3snTWYM37 You are invited to sign as Survivor, Survivor of [Program Name], Unaffiliated, or with your Professional Association. |
Purpose This letter is written in response to the death of a 12-year old boy in the care of a residential Outdoor Behavioral Healthcare (Wilderness Therapy) program. This is the second child to have died at Trails Carolina in the last decade and others have died at different programs due to involvement in the United States’ troubled teen industry. We urge practitioners to raise awareness of the harm of youth in the name of mental and behavioral healthcare. The non-profit Unsilenced maintains an exhaustive list of program deaths associated with this troubled teen industry, wilderness therapy included. We publicly declare these practices are contrary to the purpose of mental health care, and the mission and vision of adventure and outdoor therapies. This letter was written collaboratively by practitioners, researchers, past participants / clients, stakeholders, and those who refer to themselves as survivors of practices described as therapeutic in the outdoors. Contained in this Document:
|
A Collaborative Open Letter to the International Adventure Therapy Community
Created: February 14, 2024 | Signatures & Media Last Updated: October 10, 2024 |
“Dignity is our lowest standard of care.” -Christine Forner, MSW
On February 2nd, 2024, a 12-year-old boy was transported from New York to Trails Carolina, a residential Outdoor Behavioral Healthcare (Wilderness Therapy) program in North Carolina.[1] We know that upon arrival at these programs, it is common practice for staff to conduct a strip search and assign uniform clothing and camping equipment to young people. All of the young person’s personal clothing, jewellery, and mobile phones are confiscated.
According to police and news reports, the young boy was angry upon arrival and refused dinner, though he did snack later in the evening. Following the program’s written protocol, the boy would have to sleep on the floor for his first night in the program in a cabin. He would sleep with a ground sheet (tarp), and a bivy sack, with his sleeping bag inside.
A bivy is much like a lightweight single-person tent and can be quite constricting. They often have an insect net and a second zipper that seals the bag closed with no air opening. A bivy is useful in that the bag maintains heat and warm air by preventing cold air from entering from the outside.
Most bivy sacks are described as “breathable”, though maintaining a breathing hole to help expel CO2 from the bivy is described as a best practice. For safe use, the bivy should not be zipped entirely, as this prevents fresh air from entering the bag. Mountain Safety Research advises to “Cinch the bivy’s hood down around your face, but avoid breathing inside the bivy.”
We found no recommendations or guidance for use of a bivy indoors.
The boy’s bivy had an alarm taped to the zipper to alert staff should he exit the bivy. Police reported that staff said that they would release the boy if he needed to get out. Whether the boy could easily get himself out of the bag has not been stated.
Around midnight, it was reported the boy experienced a panic attack. That is about all that has been made public at this stage.
The boy was found dead at 7:45am with rigor mortis and was reported “cold to the touch and stiff.” He was wearing a hoodie, but with no pants or underwear.
The FBI are involved in the investigation, and on the 16th of February, the North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services announced all children enrolled in Trails Carolina had been removed from the program because “it was determined that action needed to be taken to ensure the health and safety of the children.” The “character and degree of conditions at Trails Carolina are detrimental to the health or safety of the children in your care,” the Chief Deputy Secretary Mark Benton wrote.
Trails Carolina responded with a press release stating:
The children were receiving high-level clinical care for complex mental health diagnoses requiring experienced professionals with full knowledge of critical medications and specialized treatment regimens. Normally, locating alternative programs and matching children for placement takes several weeks. This negligent and reckless move by the State denied parents the opportunity to continue to care for their children in the appropriate manner. 100% of parents did not want their children to leave the program.
As this story emerged, another lawsuit filed against Trails Carolina in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of North Carolina accusing the program of creating “an environment where troubled children have and do sexually assault other children” and failing “to provide adequate medical care, food, and shelter for the children in its custody.” A similar lawsuit was made one year earlier.
At the time of the child’s death in early February, Trails Carolina was an accredited Outdoor Behavioral Healthcare (Wilderness Therapy) program by the Association of Experiential Education (AEE) and a research designated program for the National Association of Therapeutic Schools and Programs (NATSAP). We question the grounds on which an experiential education association can, or should, accredit “therapeutic” programs and the validity of recognition from an industry trade organization, like NATSAP which has “no process for checking up on this compliance, nor correcting any programs that stray from these guidelines.”
Readers can view Trails Carolina’s five Statements of Deficiencies from 2019 to 2023 from the North Carolina Division of Health Service Regulation totalling 59 collective pages of numerous concerns. The program remains a member of the trade organization NATSAP, who celebrated Trails Carolina in June 2023 despite these deficiencies for being “consistently recognized for its excellence and commitment to quality care.” NATSAP also released the following statement regarding the child’s death. The program has been an AEE accredited OBH program since 2017 and their accreditation is currently listed as Under Review.
Despite multiple examples of AEE accredited therapeutic programs and NATSAP member programs failing in their duty of care to minors, thousands of young people remain held in similar programs today. These programs are researched, accredited, and advocated for in the adventure therapy literature and by related associations. Our plea to the international adventure therapy community is to publicly condemn the United States’ wilderness therapy industry and, more broadly, the troubled teen industry within the U.S. for failing to protect the safety of youth.
In response to growing public awareness, a conflation of language is occurring in response to this event impacting adventure therapy providers internationally. The Associated Press referred to Trails Carolina as a “nature-based therapy” program, which is a specific type of therapeutic practice with no relation to Wilderness Therapy or Outdoor Behavioral Healthcare. The Anasazi Foundation, one of the first member wilderness therapy programs to establish the Outdoor Behavioral Healthcare Council, is now referring to itself as an “Outdoor Therapy Treatment Center.” As awareness increases about the practices these wilderness therapy programs and accrediting bodies endorse, wilderness therapy advocates are adopting language, like nature-based or outdoor therapy, to appear as an evolution, when the same coercive and harmful practices continue.
Adventure therapy, however, must remain a voluntary mental health practice occurring both indoors or out, typically involving some sort of active bodily engagement, and in pursuit of an ethic of relational dignity.
In contrast, Outdoor Behavioral Healthcare (Wilderness Therapy), and programs like Trails Carolina, is an involuntary (clients may not disengage freely), residential treatment occurring far from the participant’s home and community, from which the majority of participants are involuntarily referred to ongoing residential treatment, such as a residential treatment center or therapeutic boarding school.
Our call for action is timely in that Outdoor Behavioral Healthcare (Wilderness Therapy) programs are closing, rebranding, and/or re-emerging. Public awareness of the United States' troubled teen industry has grown over the previous decade. The adventure therapy community of practitioners, advocates, and researchers alike providing voluntary, dignified, and effective services must reconcile 25-plus years of influence from wilderness therapy research and how this impacts any evidence-base for claiming effectiveness for adventure-based and outdoor therapies. Our community was misled by unjustified claims of superior outcomes, public claims of accreditation protecting youth, and a lack of transparency about harmful and unethical accredited practices.
Below are initial actions adventure therapy providers and advocates can understand to help protect service users, families, and youth.
Actions for United States’ Organizations
“(a) provisions that would ensure basic protections for children and adolescents against all forms of abuse and neglect; (b) access to an appropriate education and necessary medical care; (c) freedom from inappropriate physical, mechanical or chemical restraint; (d) freedom from solitary confinement, forced silence or restricted communication with trusted caregivers including parents, state agencies, advocacy organizations and first responders; and (e) the freedom to report mistreatment anonymously without fear of reprisal; and FURTHER RESOLVED, That the American Bar Association supports the adoption of state, local, territorial and tribal legislation that facilitate uniform standards for preventing child abuse in residential facilities.” (p. 1) |
Actions for Researchers
|
Actions for Providers
|
Name | Affiliation |
Dr. Will Dobud | |
Chelsea Maldonado | |
Dr. Graham Pringle | |
Senator Sara Gelser Blouin | |
Maia Szalavitz | Author, Help At Any Cost: How the Troubled-Teen Industry Cons Parents and Hurts Kids, Journalist Co-Author, The Boy Who Was Raised as a Dog: And Other Stories from a Child Psychiatrist’s Notebook - What Traumatized Children Can Teach Us About Loss, Love, and Healing with Bruce D. Perry, M.D., Ph.D. |
Paris Hilton | |
Dr. Sarah Golightley | |
Dr. Nevin Harper | |
Marcus Chatfield | |
Dr. Heather Mooney | Unaffiliated |
Professor Emeritus of Law Michael L. Perlin, Esq. | New York Law School, International Mental Disability Law Reform Project, Mental Disability Law and Policy Associates |
Nathaniel Lichfield | Unaffiliated |
Jamie Mater | |
Megan Appelgate | |
Kyra Frankowski | |
Amanda Simmons, Esq. | |
Annette Smith, Esq. | |
Zoey Read | International Coalition Against Restraint and Seclusion (ICARS) |
Becky Gillespie | International Coalition Against Restraint and Seclusion (ICARS) |
Jenna Bulis | |
Chelsea Filer | |
Dawn. J. Post, Esq. | |
Aubrey Edwards-Luce | Sayra and Neil Meyerhoff Center for Families, Children and the Courts |
Maximiliano Prieto Monson | Via Silvestre |
Mario Bilodeau | Université du Québec a Chicoutimi, Fondation sur la Pointe des Pieds |
Luk Peeters | |
Lynn Van Hoof | |
Alexander Rose | |
Dr. Andrew Brookes | |
Emeritus Professor Chris Loynes | |
Dr. Simon Kennedy Beames | |
Dr. Michela Marinelli | Associate Professor of Neuroscience, University of Texas at Austin |
Dr. Paul Leighton | |
Katherine Sharp, MSW | |
Jasmyne Arianna | |
Paul Keith | Survivor |
Dr. Trish McCluskey | Unaffiliated |
Associate Professor Susan Huhana Mlcek | |
Krystle Augustine | Advocate |
Dr. Stephan Natynczuk | Ironbridge School of Therapy Outdoors / Spare Krab Adventure Therapy |
Mache Treviño | Crecimiento y Aventura (Mexico) / University of Wales Trinity Saint David (Wales) |
Per Wijnands | |
Maggie Gelen, LMSW | Unaffiliated |
Dr. Audrey Zatopek, PhD, LPC-S, LCDC | |
Peter Mayfield | |
Aimee Frazier | |
Robyn Bennett-Healy | Unaffiliated |
Dr. Jennifer Murdoch Dohlman, LPC, NCC, ACS | |
Chris Hodgson | Unaffiliated |
Dr. John Paul Healy | |
Doug Moczynski | |
Ben Fineman, AMFT | |
Jaimee Galloway | |
Kylie Agnew, Assoc MAPS, CF, BPsych(Hons), Bsc, Grad Dip Ed (Secondary), Grad Dip Clin Rehab | |
Doug Magnuson, PhD | |
Lynette Nikkel, BSW, MSW, RSW | |
Heidi Shingler, MA, BSc, DipC, MBACP | |
Mark Cartner | |
Andi Dickmeyer, MClinPsych | |
Andrew Bach, BSW | |
Lakisha Shears, LCSW-C, LISW | DMV Wellness Center |
Benjamin Israel, MD | |
Siddhesh Barale | |
Dr. Daniel J. Winarick | Private Practice |
Elizabeth Hinkle, LMFT | |
Dr. Eric Brymer | |
Gerald Joseph, MSW, LCSW, ACM, PATP | |
Alisa May Johnson | Person |
Max Loomes, BPsych (Hons) I, MClinPsych | |
Laura Myer | |
James Flom | |
Nicholas A. Pierorazio | |
Cindy Hansen | |
Nicolas Kruize | |
Daniella Morga | |
Kate Greene | |
Aaron Seipel | Unaffiliated |
Russell Chamberlain LCSW, CADC-III | |
Rachel Robinson | |
Carrolyn Moczynski | |
Unda Avota | |
JessAnn Smith | NASW (Student Member), AEE (Student Member), IASWG (Student Member) |
Renee Duncan | Concerned |
Joni Neave | |
Will Hobbs, PhD | Former Outdoor Education Faculty; Unaffiliated |
Joshua Anderson | Unaffiliated |
Simon Watts | In Nature Therapy (Australian Association of Social Workers, Outdoor Health Australia member) |
Millie Wilkin | |
Soren Enright-DuBon | Unaffiliated |
Hélène Faure | Registered Social Worker & Registered Mental (Health) Nurse |
Bernadette Moorhead | |
Dr. Steven Sassaman | |
Ben Branch | Outdoor Education, Unaffiliated |
Maria Guido | Licensed Clinical Social Worker |
Gerald Beeck | |
Jane Barr | |
Vanessa Twelftree | Australian State Paramedic, Australian Army Combat Paramedic, & Social Work |
Michael Jensen | Previously Alaska Crossing & Take a Hike Foundation |
Noelle Dobud | Unaffiliated |
George Dobud | Unaffiliated |
Rachael Chamberlin-Bee | |
Mel Gurr | |
Lucas Bernardi | Unaffiliated |
Jasper van der Bijl | |
Molly Pettie | |
Charlotte Bye | Unaffiliated |
Alyssa Mortensen | Unaffiliated |
Shinayde Dean | Unaffiliated |
Prof. Dr. Inga Schalinski | |
Associate Professor Belinda Cash | |
Emily Jolly | |
Andy Hamilton, Psychologist | |
Darin Panasiuk | Unaffiliated |
Chris Davies | |
Olivia Braastad | Unaffiliated |
Mukta Joshie | Independent Practitioner |
Tony Cox | |
Ellie Lawrence-Wood | Clinical Advisory Committee Chair for the Operation Flinders Foundation |
Ruth Hodgson | |
Christina Blankenship | Unaffiliated |
Izzat Yaganagi | |
Rohan Tedmanson | |
Lauren Anderson | Educator |
Rob Saxton | |
Javan Stamp, BSC, OT | Unaffiliated |
Dr. Laurel George | |
Brendon Munge | |
Mathias Roitman | Unaffiliated |
Dr. Casey Delmara | |
Julia Sands | |
Paul Smith | |
Dwayne Shenandoah | Unaffiliated |
Will Trimble | Unaffiliated |
Chris Ruder, LMFT | |
Rotam Yanai | |
Michael Thompson | Melbourne Grammar School |
Thirsa Verdoold | Social Worker |
Emily Magee | West Highland College, University of the Highlands and Islands |
Ben Trewren | |
Jennifer Schwind | |
Maryrose Yerger | Private Practice |
Lucas Bester | |
Benjamin Harlow | Private Practice |
Guðrún Friðriks | Occupational Therapist, Unaffiliated |
Henry Begner LCMHC | |
Sean Lappin | |
Tristan Avella-O’Brien | |
Max Joseph Rosenberg | |
Brent Dean | Unaffiliated |
Jason Nordin | |
Bonnie Dyck | |
Max Rosenberg | Survivor of Second Nature Duchesne Wilderness Program |
Brian Lombrowski | Unaffiliated |
Matt Matteini, MPH-LCSW | Unaffiliated |
Clayton Wells | |
Sarah Gardner | Unaffiliated |
John Wheeler | Retired Psychologist |
Christina Huffer | Unaffiliated |
Conor Moore | Unaffiliated |
Jack Carruthers | Student |
Mac Brant | Unaffiliated |
Geraldine Haywood-Mercer | Psychologist |
Marshall DuVal | Unaffiliated |
Phillip Hindes | Unaffiliated |
David Segal | Unaffiliated |
Elise Fenna | Unaffiliated |
Justin Steward | Unaffiliated |
Tahentahawi Chubb-Smith | Unaffiliated |
Karina Deans | Unaffiliated |
Sierra McDaniel | Unaffiliated |
Elaine Moore | Unaffiliated |
Judith Emond | Unaffiliated |
Teresa Byrne | Educator |
Tricia Honkasalo | Unaffiliated |
Serena Phillips | Unaffiliated |
Reece Stoker | |
Abbie Goodridge | |
Marissa Phillips | |
Aden Hemmerling | |
Natasha Franklin | Unaffiliated |
Renee Slade | |
Natasha Olynick | |
Izabella Palmero | |
Alex Tonu | |
Victoria Lourdaise | |
Amanda-Lee Brookes | |
Peta Ajkunic | |
Rebecca Murdoch | |
Mike Salomo | |
Beck Barnes | Unaffiliated |
Ewa Ainsworth | Unaffiliated |
Emily McFarland | |
Breanna Alderman-Bates | |
Lynn York | |
Emilia Monteleone | |
Jessica Mannion | Unaffiliated |
Tayla Grogan | |
Sara Lewis | |
Ewa Ainsworth | Unaffiliated |
Antoinetta Tartaro | Social Work Student, Counsellor Grief and Bereavement |
Shannon Harman Sharpe | Unaffiliated |
Samantha Martinez | |
Joanna Gibson | |
Jennifer Delaine Taylor, LCSW-S | Unaffiliated |
Adelle Rose Salter | |
Jessica Hardiman | |
Mary Beth Kruger, MSW, LSW | |
Felix Machiridza | Functional Family Therapy Consultant |
Involuntary Treatment: Removing shoes, clothing, equipment when asleep; no access to a map & not telling location; harsh environmental hazards; heavy load carrying for long periods (above 25% bodyweight); close supervision (under visual and auditory reach during all awake time including when toileting, guides watch during sleep time).
These practices includes extremes such as; being observed directly (watching silhouette) and indirectly (within arm's reach but back turned away) during toileting; being wrapped in a tarp when asleep with guides sleeping on either side, within arm's reach and tied to a guide during all awake hours if escape is attempted. |
Degradation: constantly calling your name/number while toileting out of sight so guides know you have not run away; mixed gender groups (sometimes one or two girls in all male groups) and close living (no walls when toileting/sleeping); rare access to full hygiene standards (three pair underwear per week or less often); showers available weekly to once in three months; fresh clothes weekly to monthly; removal of all personal items (includes strip search with squat and cough to void bodily cavities on intake); issuing badly fitting bras, shoes, clothes; using sticks-sage-rocks in lieu of toilet paper; reading life story / letter of accountability by self or from parents to peers within days of arrival; peers forced to criticize content on these stories and daily behavior; denying access to peers until confessing to a problem; isolation from group for first few days (within sight but not allowed to participate with peers); non-binary gender preferences (him/her) ignored; guides bringing in special food items and consuming in front of young people; some items retained by guides who must be asked for access (eg toothpaste, torch); weekly inspection of skin for infection (i.e., butt inspection). |
Neglect: medical attention restricted despite boils, broken bones, illness; females (in particular) often developed urinary tract infections due to inadequate hygiene (clean water, cleansing products, privacy, clean underwear); forced to work/walk with untreated (and denied) injury/illness (includes young people losing control of bladder and continuing to walk/work); food eaten cold/raw if young person cannot make fire by friction; ground water supply not purified; malnourishment and bland unvaried diet; frequent mention of frostbite, chilblains-nerve damage, trench foot and skin infection, ligament injury; breathing difficulty daily after crushing charcoal from fire and dispersing to adhere to minimal impact rules; guides having little skill or training (despite overseeing extraordinary coercive and risky daily living for a week at a time with no direct supervision). |
Coercive control: program specific language (e.g., groover means toilet); no or limited contact with family; letters to family written but censored with pen and cutting out of sections, or un-mailed; letters from family only when therapist arrives once weekly; therapist and guides misleading/lying to young people; program specific skills rewarded (fire by friction); group punishments for failing to adhere to the program standards (e.g., walking pace, speed of erecting shelters); requiring peers to criticize peers daily during campfire ritual; verbal abuse and name calling by guides; security staff involuntary transporting 65% and more of young people from home to program (includes use of restraints and false information about duration of the program); use of nature in harsh seasonal conditions as a restraint-barrier-test; all peer to peer conversation being listened to by guides; no access of future information (e.g., destination of the days walking, outside news, day of departure from program, access to clock); phone calls to home listened to by therapists sitting next to young person; frequent emotional/psychotic collapse of peers/self; frequent peer verbal and physical assaults; frequent physical restraint/holds; encouraging compliance and rewarding dissociative change; forced to accept blame for being admitted to program and the actions of others in the program and at home (includes accepting fault for being assaulted and violated, detachment from family, engaging with peers and activities disapproved by family); forcing confessions for misdemeanors (young people often admitted to things they had not done in order to stop the coercion to confess); changing behavior to suit expectation of the program while maintaining inner commitment to not changing; program duration varies with some watching many peers arrive and depart while they remain for weeks and months (average 93 days). |
Secure Transport Literature Dobud, W. W. (2022). Experiences of secure transport in outdoor behavioral healthcare: A narrative inquiry. Qualitative Social Work, 21(4), 697-713. Harper, N. J., Magnuson, D., & Dobud, W. W. (2021). A closer look at involuntary treatment and the use of transport service in outdoor behavioral healthcare (wilderness therapy). Child & youth services, 42(2), 200-219. Magnuson, D., Dobud, W., & Harper, N. J. (2022). Can involuntary youth transport into outdoor behavioral healthcare treatment programs (wilderness therapy) ever be ethical?. Child and Adolescent Social Work Journal, 1-9. Mooney, H. E. (2023). Reflection: Transported to the troubled teen industry. In Mass Incarceration in the 21st Century (pp. 161-164). Routledge. |
Troubled Teen Industry Literature Chatfield, M. (2018). Cultural islands: The subjective experience of treatment and maltreatment within insular programs. Child maltreatment in insular & isolated communities, 15-31. Chatfield, M. M. (2019). Totalistic programs for youth: A thematic analysis of retrospective accounts. Journal of Extreme Anthropology, 3(2), 44-71. Chatfield, M. M. (2023). “That Hurts You Badder Than Punchin’”: The Troubled Teen Industry and Therapeutic Violence in Group Rehabilitation Programs since World War II. The Social History of Alcohol and Drugs, 37(2), 268-292. Chatfield, M. M., Diehl, D. C., Johns, T. L., Smith, S., & Galindo‐Gonzalez, S. (2021). Quality of experience in residential care programmes: Retrospective perspectives of former youth participants. Child & Family Social Work, 26(1), 132-143. Golightley, S. (2023). ‘I’m Gay! I’m Gay! I’m Gay! I’m a Homosexual!’: Overt and Covert Conversion Therapy Practices in Therapeutic Boarding Schools. The British Journal of Social Work, 53(3), 1426-1444. Golightley, S. (2020). Troubling the ‘troubled teen’ industry: Adult reflections on youth experiences of therapeutic boarding schools. Global Studies of Childhood, 10(1), 53-63. Mater, C. J. (2022). The troubled teen industry and its effects: an oral history. Inquiry Journal. Mooney, H. E. (2022). Conflicting Consequences and the Carceral State: Troubled Teens in Therapeutic Boarding Schools (Doctoral dissertation, Wayne State University). Mooney, H., & Leighton, P. (2019). Troubled affluent youth’s experiences in a therapeutic boarding school: The elite arm of the youth control complex and its implications for youth justice. Critical Criminology, 27(4), 611-626. |
[1] Transporting is the process widely used in the United States troubled teen industry and wilderness therapy where a young person is removed from their home at night unknowingly and involuntarily and then taken to a residential program, such as Outdoor Behavioral Healthcare (Wilderness Therapy) against their will.