Ast 6112                                              Class Presentation Feedback Form                         Fall 2013

Speaker: 

Topic: 

 Content: Did the speaker….

• Provide enough background information to understand the presentation?

• Clearly explain what makes this planet/system/topic interesting?

• Clearly identify the purpose and implications of observations/models?

• Clearly explain how the results led to the current state of scientific knowledge?

• Critically evaluate quality/accuracy of observations, the limitations of observations/

theoretical models, and the reliability of any claimed implications?

• Clearly explain how future research could address open questions?

• Contribute to increasing class’s knowledge of the field?

• Other:

Presentation:

• Was the presentation well organized?

• Were visuals well designed and used effectively?

• Was the presentation delivered effectively?

• Other:

Grading: 

Did the speaker…

….......... Demonstrate familiarity with relevant scientific literature?

….......... Identify & emphasize at least one interesting aspect?

….......... Identify the strengths & weaknesses of previous research?

….......... Communicate ideas effectively?

……….. Other comments: