How to Lower Car Insurance: 7 Steps and What to Ask

Updated November 11, 2026

How to lower car insurance: compare the same coverage across carriers before each renewal, ask for every discount by name, raise your deductible to an amount you could pay, and drop the extras you don't need.

A PolicyVera guide. You just want to know if you're overpaying. You want to compare quotes without having to talk to a bunch of insurance agents. And your info shouldn't go anywhere you don't want it to. PolicyVera is a free insurance-shopping marketplace where you compare quotes across carriers, coverage and price side by side with your current policy, from licensed local insurance agents you pick, on the site or inside your AI assistant. Only the agents you pick get your request, and insurance agents are not allowed to call, text or email you outside PolicyVera until you accept them as your new agent. PolicyVera is paid by insurance agents, not by you.

Using an AI assistant? It can make the quote request for you, in the chat. The steps for ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Perplexity and Grok: policyvera.com/connect.

How to save on car insurance: the seven steps, in short

Here is how to get lower car insurance without giving up coverage that protects you. Steps 1, 2, 3 and 6 can lower the price and leave your coverage as it is. Steps 4 and 5 lower it by having you carry more of the risk yourself. Step 7 keeps your price from going up.

  1. Compare the same coverage across carriers, before each renewal.
  2. Ask for every discount, by name.
  3. Take a driving course that counts.
  4. Raise your deductible to an amount you could pay.
  5. Drop the extras you don't need. Keep what protects you.
  6. Pay the way that costs less, and pay on time.
  7. Don't let your coverage lapse.

How much each step lowers your price depends on your company, your state and your record. So each step ends with the exact question to ask, and the answer is your own number. Start with step 1: the NAIC's shopping tool says your premium is likely to be very different at each insurer.

Each figure and state rule below links to its source: state insurance regulators and other state agencies, state laws, the NAIC, federal consumer agencies and, for credit checks, FICO.

Step 1. Compare the same coverage across carriers

Different companies charge different prices for the same coverage. So compare before each renewal, and after anything that should lower your price:

First check your declarations page, the summary page of your policy: the drivers, the cars, the address and the miles. If anything is wrong or has changed, tell your agent or the company. The NAIC's consumer guide also says to check your credit report and your CLUE report (your claims history) for errors before you apply.

Then get at least three quotes for the same coverages, limits and deductibles, across carriers. Some companies sell directly, online or by phone, and others sell through agents, so try both. Some agents can quote several companies at once. Ask each about its discounts, and compare the total.

The lowest price isn't everything. Many state insurance departments post each company's complaint record, the NAIC's consumer guide notes, and you can ask yours whether it publishes price comparisons.

Ask: "For the same coverages, limits and deductibles, what is my total after discounts?"

PolicyVera is one place to do this step: you pick the licensed local insurance agents you want quotes from, and compare their quotes side by side, next to your current policy.

Felt puppet comic. A mother holds up the policy summary with "40,000 miles" circled in red. Her teenage son shrugs: "That was a typo. Mostly."

Before you compare, check the drivers, the cars, the address and the miles on your declarations page.

If you switch, start the new policy before you cancel the old one, and cancel the old one for the same day the new one starts. How to Switch Car Insurance Companies has the six steps.

Step 2. Ask for every car insurance discount, by name

Call your agent or company and go down this list, by name:

  • your home or renters policy with the same company
  • more than one car
  • no claims and a clean record
  • good grades, or a student away at school without a car
  • low miles, no commute or a carpool
  • safety and anti-theft features
  • your employer, union, alumni group or military service
  • coverage with no gaps, and years with the same company

Some discounts only start when you tell them: a new anti-theft device, good grades, working from home. Ask what proof they need. The Texas Department of Insurance adds: "Your company should sign you up for the discounts you qualify for but ask to make sure they do."

Discounts vary by company and by state, and some states require some of them. New York requires discounts for anti-theft devices, and California requires a good driver discount: by that law, the rate must be at least 20 percent below what you would otherwise be charged for the same coverage. Then look at the price, not the number of discounts. A company with fewer discounts can still cost less, and a bundle isn't always the lower total, so compare it with separate policies.

Ask: "Which discounts am I getting now, and which others do I qualify for?"

Felt puppet comic. A woman swoons on a fainting couch and asks, "Is there a discount for a dramatic life?" A deadpan detective with a clipboard answers, "No. But there's one for paperless."

Go down the list by name, and ask about paperless billing too (step 6).

Step 3. Take a driving course that counts for a discount

Many companies give a discount for an approved defensive driving course. Some states require companies to give it: for drivers 55 and older in California, Florida and Pennsylvania, and at any age in New York. The discount lasts a set time, often three years, as in each of these four states. Then you take the course again. Pennsylvania's motor vehicle agency says the discount is at least 5%. New York's says at least 10% off the base rate of your liability and collision premiums.

Before you sign up, ask your company which courses count, then send it the certificate. A course a court orders after a ticket may not count.

Ask: "Which driving courses count for a discount, how much is it, and how long does it last?"

Step 4. Raise your car insurance deductible to an amount you could pay

Your deductible is the part of a claim you pay before the insurance pays. A higher one usually lowers your price, because you take on more of the risk yourself. You pay it every time you claim with your own company, so pick one you could pay tomorrow.

Ask: "What is my price with a $500 deductible, and what is it with $1,000? For collision, and for comprehensive."

Step 5. Drop the coverage extras you don't need. Keep what protects you

Each extra coverage usually has its own price, so check each one:

  • Towing. If an auto club already tows you, ask whether you need towing coverage too.
  • Gap coverage. If you now owe less than the car is worth, ask whether you still need it.
  • Collision and comprehensive on an older, paid-off car. These pay to fix or replace your own car, usually no more than what the car is worth, minus your deductible. Compare what they cost with what the car is worth. In the NAIC's 2024 data, collision averaged $516 a year and comprehensive averaged $283. With a loan or lease, they're usually required.

But don't cut your liability coverage to the state minimum to lower the price. The NAIC's consumer guide says minimums are "usually not enough to fully protect you and your assets", and you would owe what your coverage doesn't pay. The same guide notes that some companies even charge more if you've had only the minimum, and that higher limits often don't cost much more. Keep what your state and your lender require.

And never leave a driver who lives with you off the policy. If they crash, you can be left paying, and the company can cancel you or charge you more.

Ask: "What does each extra on my policy cost? And what would higher liability limits cost?"

Step 6. Pay for car insurance the way that costs less

Paying monthly often comes with a fee. Paying the whole premium at once, autopay and paperless billing can earn discounts. And pay on time. The NAIC's consumer guide notes that some companies don't accept late payments, and one that does may raise your price at renewal.

Ask: "Is there a charge for paying monthly?"

Step 7. Don't let your car insurance coverage lapse

Most companies charge more if you had no insurance right before you apply, and some states limit that. So keep your coverage continuous. When you switch, the new policy starts the day the old one ends.

Ask: "What day does the new policy start, so I can end the old one that same day?"

A safe-driving program can lower your price, or raise it

Some companies price you on how you drive, or how much, through a phone app or a small device in the car. You may see it called telematics or usage-based insurance. It can track your speed, hard braking, the time of day, where you drive, your miles, and sometimes phone use. Many give a small discount just for signing up. After that, your price can go down, stay the same, or go up.

Maryland's insurance regulator counted what happened at renewal in 2023, in that one state. Of the policies enrolled in one of these programs, 31.16% went down because of the driving data, 23.6% went up, and 45.24% did not change. Its report concludes: "there is the risk that the data collected can result in increases in premium."

Ask: "What does it track? Can it raise my price? How long is the test period? Can I fix a trip when I wasn't the one driving?"

Felt puppet comic. A teenager driving a car holds up a phone showing a warning sign and says, "It says I brake with enthusiasm." His mother clutches the dashboard beside him.

A safe-driving program prices you by how you drive, so your price can go down or up.

Car insurance for low mileage drivers

If you drive little or work from home, here is how to lower auto insurance for the miles you really drive. Ask for a low-mileage discount (step 2). And ask about pay-per-mile insurance: a base price plus a charge for each mile. Some companies cap the miles they charge in a day. In California, a company may use a device only to count the miles you drive.

Before you buy a car

Get a quote for it first. Some types of cars are more expensive to insure, and the NAIC notes that you pay more for cars that cost more to repair or replace, or that are often stolen.

State programs for low incomes

Some states run lower-cost programs for drivers with low incomes. They cover less than a standard policy, so ask what's included. California's covers liability only. New Jersey's, for some people on Medicaid, covers only emergency and catastrophic medical care, with no liability coverage.

Does credit score affect car insurance?

In most states, yes. Companies may use a credit-based insurance score, built from your credit report. California, Hawaii and Massachusetts don't allow it for car insurance, and many other states limit how it's used.

Where credit counts, paying on time and keeping balances low help over time. In some states, like New York, Oregon and Texas, you can ask your company to re-check your price with your credit as it stands today. Check your credit reports for free at AnnualCreditReport.com, as the FTC explains, and dispute anything that's wrong.

Does getting car insurance quotes lower credit score?

No. Where an insurer checks your credit for a quote, it's a soft check (a look at your credit that doesn't count against you), and soft checks don't affect your credit scores. So compare as many quotes as you like.

Am I paying too much for car insurance?

Only quotes can tell you. In the NAIC's 2024 data, a policy with liability, collision and comprehensive averaged $1,612 a year nationally, from $1,000 in Maine to $2,174 in Florida. But an average mixes very different drivers, cars and coverage. So get at least three quotes for the coverage you have now, and compare the totals. How Much Is Car Insurance per Month? has the averages by state.

Car insurance quotes without phone calls

PolicyVera is a free insurance-shopping marketplace where you compare quotes across carriers, from licensed local insurance agents at any agency. PolicyVera is paid by insurance agents, not by you. You pick what you want quoted (auto, home, renters, life and more), then the licensed local insurance agents you want quotes from, and send one request. Only the insurance agents you pick get your request. You compare their quotes side by side, next to your current policy (add it by uploading your policy's declarations page or answering a few questions). On PolicyVera, insurance agents are not allowed to call, text or email you outside PolicyVera until you accept them as your new agent. That rule is written into PolicyVera's agent terms.

Screenshot of PolicyVera's agent picker: three licensed local insurance agents in a list, two of them picked, each with the lines of insurance they write.

You pick the licensed local insurance agents who get your request. PolicyVera doesn't rank or recommend them.

PolicyVera's quote comparison with car insurance quotes: the person's current policy and two licensed local insurance agents' quotes side by side, row by row: the insurance company, the total premium, the collision deductible and the bodily injury liability limits. Outlined: one quote's higher collision deductible.

Line by line, you see what differs besides the price. Here, one quote has a higher deductible (marked).

You can also do the whole thing inside your AI assistant. PolicyVera runs an MCP server, so a person's AI assistant can make the whole quote request inside the conversation and read the quotes as the agents send them. It connects to Claude, ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, Grok and other assistants that can use outside tools (plans vary): policyvera.com/connect

Find out if you're overpaying

Compare quotes from the licensed local insurance agents you pick, side by side with your current policy. Free, across carriers, and only the agents you pick get your request.

Compare quotes at policyvera.com →

Or ask your AI assistant: policyvera.com/connect

PolicyVera itself does not sell, solicit, negotiate, or bind insurance and provides no insurance advice; insurance agents win clients who choose them, and the platform is free for consumers and lenders.

Quotes are non-binding estimates; the final premium is set by the insurer's underwriting after you apply.

Which states have licensed agents on PolicyVera, kept live: policyvera.com/agents. More on this: How to get insurance quotes without spam calls

Sources

Each figure and state rule above links to its source, and the full list is here. See a mistake? Tell us at policyvera.com/help.

General information, not advice for your situation. Rules vary by state and by company. Your state's insurance department explains the rules where you live.

Related: How to Switch Car Insurance Companies and Why Is My Car Insurance So High?

More PolicyVera guides: PolicyVera Guides: Insurance Questions, Answered