Dear EMU Cabinet and Board of Directors,

When the solicitation charges against Luke Hartman first came to light, we, as alumni of EMU, were shocked and saddened to hear this news. We heard EMU’s call for prayer and grace, and trusted that our university was taking appropriate steps to deal with the situation.

More information became public over the past several months, including a terrifying testimony from a former EMU student of abuse she suffered from Luke Hartman and an open letter from Lindale Mennonite Church explaining that multiple people in positions of authority at Mennonite institutions knew that Hartman was in an abusive relationship. A history of sexual abuse known to church and university leaders has been illuminated, and we are stunned, angry, and hurt that EMU has yet to put out a public statement that both clearly condemns sexual violence and apologizes both to Lauren Shifflett and to the larger EMU community for a lack of intervention. We feel that our prior trust in the university has been violated.

We have read the campus-wide email that was sent in the days after Lauren’s experience became public, and while we appreciate EMU’s acknowledgement that “many people have been hurt in a variety of ways,” we feel that this statement is inadequate for the situation at hand. A detailed list of the reasons why we feel this way can be found here.

We believe that it is important for our university to explicitly acknowledge Lauren’s pain with a public apology for the trauma she has suffered. We also believe that our university owes both Lauren and its former and current students the following things:

  • An apology for placing us in harm’s way
  • A clear, verbalized, public stance against abuse and sexual violence, which has not thus far been shown by word or action
  • A demonstrated commitment to dismantling the culture of shame and fear that facilitates abuse and sexual violence
  • Transparency and accountability in the months to come as we all deal with the fallout of this trauma

As alumni of EMU, we feel particularly betrayed by the way our university’s response thus far has not lived up to the intellectual, moral, and spiritual ideals instilled in us by this very institution. It was at EMU that many of us first learned to place conflict and trauma in a wider context and to think critically about systems of power and oppression; and yet, EMU’s response to the serious allegations of abuse by Luke Hartman has not demonstrated this sort of awareness. To quote Hilary Jerome Scarsella,

Abuse, even when it manifests between two individuals, is about wider problems of power and control. Institutions, particularly educational institutions like EMU, have an ethical and legal responsibility to do everything in their power to create a climate in which members of the community are protected from the threat of violence, including the violence of abuse. Thus, when a leader in such an institution perpetrates such violence it must be investigated thoroughly and transparently.

We have not yet seen this sort of transparency demonstrated, and we no longer feel confident that our university fulfilled its ethical and legal responsibilities of doing everything in its power to create a climate in which we were and are protected from the threat of violence.

We care deeply about EMU as an institution, even though we no longer live on campus. EMU is committed to do justice, love mercy, and walk humbly with God. Please demonstrate to current students, us and all other former students, and the broader community that this is true.

[If you would like to add your name to this letter, please email us at emu.alumni.speak@gmail.com. We are continuing to collect signatures until the end of June.]

**On April 22, 2016, Loren Swartzendruber sent the following email to EMU faculty, staff, and current students

**On April 24, 2016, we [Erika Babikow & Emily Harnish] sent the following email to all those who signed the EMU Alumni Open Letter

Signed,

Emily Harnish, 2013

Erika Babikow, 2013

Darian Harnish, 2013

Phillip Martin, 2013

Gabe Brunk, 2012

Doran Stucky, 2012

Chaska Yoder, 2014

Esther Nafziger, 2012

John Barry, 2013

Evan Yoder, 2012

Jenny Hochstetler Spicher, 2010

Nathan Hershberger, 2012

Jessica Sarriot, 2011

Sara Beachy, 2011

Rose Byler, 2012

McKenzie Sauder, 2015

Hannah Schrock Leaman, 2013

Jennifer Blosser, 2013

Janelle Donaldson, 2013

Stewart Nafziger, 2012

Lieda Stauffer, 1992

Brooke Sprunger, 2011

Christine Bottles Suders, 2011

Karissa Sauder, 2010

Michael McAndrew, 2017

Isabel Castillo, 2007

Michael Miller, 2006

Mark Risser, 2007

Giles Eanes, 2011

Darwin Zehr, 1993

Karen Myers Zehr, 1993

Patrick Campbell, 2010

Sara Bergey, 2012

Courtney Sanderson, 2013

Peter Nelson, 2008

Julian Bender, 2009

Charity Stutzman, 2008

Will Morris, 2011

Justin Roth, 2012

Amanda Styer, 2012

Julia Johnson, 2012

Philip T. Yoder, 2014

Jon Risser, 2005

Amanda Chandler, 2014

Craig Pelkey-Landes, 1995

Matt Gnagey, 2005

Abigail Spurrier Ewing, 2010

Tessa Gerberich, 2013

Erin Murray, 2008

Alicia Jantzi, 2010

Nicole Yoder, 2010

Rachel Kauffman Herr, 2004

Nicole Elliott, 2012

Benjamin Jantzi, 2012

Laura Hershey, 2012

Anna Hershey, 2013

Morgan Kratz, 2015

Tara Altizer, 2009

Rachel Mast Reesor, 2010

Lynae Fry, 2014

Amy Feeser, 2015

Julie Stauffer, 2008

Nick Buckwalter, 2005

Elizabeth Mast, 2012

Rachael Marion Blosser, 2010

Gregory Philip Blosser, 2009

Brittany Sehenuk, 2015

Amy Histand Eanes, 2010

Jessica Hedrick, 2011

Lois Blauch Miller, 1981, 2009

Jessica Brislen, 2009

Erin Nussbaum Beeker, 2013

Paola Diaz, 2016

Katelyn Golding, 2012

Matthew Naugle, 2015

Denay Murray, 2011

Meg Brauckmann, 2011

Matt Gehman, 2009

Stacy Lehman, 2012

Kari Martin Hollinger, 2010

Chris Hollinger, 2009

Laura Glick, 2014

Rosemary Joss, 2016

Joe Hochstetler, 2012

Rebekah York, 2015

Laura J.W. Keppley, 2014

Amanda Gerig-Sickles, 2008

Emily Shank, 2015

Lauren Sauder, 2016

Sam Buck, 2009

Olivia Burkholder, 2013

Jasmine Stutzman, 2011

Ellie Spaulding Hershberger, 2007

Hannah Chappell-Dick, 2016

Anna Weaver, 2013

Ben Nyce, 2013

Krysta Nyce, 2014

Aliese Gingerich, 2015

Lars Åkerson, 2008

Nicole Yoder, 2015

Konrad Swartz, 2014

Chris Lehman, 2015

Jaime Roberts, 2009

Katherine Burling, 2015

Emma Stahl-Wert, 2011

Judith Showalter Kline, 2012

Joe Hamlett, 1973

Jackie Hamlett, 1973

Lucy Barber, 2009

Peter Labosh, 2013

Matthew Tieszen, 2010, 2015

Denae Tennyson, 2006

Kaitlin Heatwole, 2011

Crystal Gosnell, 2000

Jeff Boodie, 2007

Sadie Showalter, 1967

Art Stoltzfus, 2016

John Gullman, 2014

Melinda Norris, 2015

Megan Grove, 2011

Paulette Moore 2009

Ruth Maust, 2013

Kevin Martin, 2014

Erica Wojciechowski, 2012

Nathan Kauffman, 2010

James Souder, 2013

Rebecca Martin, 2012

Michelle Kennel Shenk, 2009

Denise Reesor, 2007

Daniel Shenk Moreno, 2014

Karen Jones Jantzi, 1978

Christine Kreider, 2011

Rose Herr Wayland, 1978

Jessica McNally, 2015

Brooke Fansler, 2010

Dale Humphries, 2009

Jeni Heishman, 2015

Rinn Siegrist, 1989

Sue Dean, 1979

Kate Baer, 2009

Amanda Giannini Loch, 1993

Molly Kraybill, 2013

Marissa Buck, 2009

Rhoda Miller Blough, 1994

MaKayla Baker, 2016

Eojin Lee, 2009

Pamela Perez, 2010

Claudette Monroy Velazquez, 2010

Audrey Berkshire Jackson, 2004

Rhoda Shirk, 2010

Nels Akerson, 2013

Mary Dunn, 2010

Barbara Graber, 1976

Joshua Michael Dean, 2009

Jordan Hollinger, 2015

Taylor Weidman, 2013

Maria Bowman, 2009

Conrad Erb, 2004

Abigail Berkshire Price, 2001

Luella Glanzer, 2006

Christine Baer, 2014

Jeanine Vlasits Underwood, 1994

Donovan Tann, 2008

Heidi Zendt Hochstetler, 1993

Tamara Shoemaker, 2004

Dana Joy Harshberger, 1993

Grantley Showalter, 2017

Isaac Schertz, 2017

Erica Beck Reinford, 2015

Chad Reinford, 2014

Hank Mast, 2010

Lauren Dixon, 2014

Tim Heishman, 2012

Kris Short, 1993

Karla Martin, 2013

Laura Cattell Noll, 2009

Rachel Kelley, 2013

Doris Risser, 1975

Patrick Ressler, 2009

Lauren Blitz, 2016

Angela M. Carter, 2009

Ann Yoder, 1977

Beth Jarrett, 2006

Katie Jantzen, 2012

Erica Stoltzfus, 2013

Robin Fletcher, 2009

Edwin Miller, 1987

Regina Christman Martin, 1992

Elias Kehr, 2013

Jakob zumFelde, 2011

Devin Yoder, 2002

Hannah Shelly, 2011

Keri Beasley Jones, 1996

Brandon Waggy, 2014

Teresa Moser, 1990, 1993

Zachariah Coverdale, 2015

Abigail Carr, 2014

Anna Woelk, 2012

Megan Kennel, 2002

Joshua Kanagy, 2013

Sarah Magyar, 2009

Sarah Phillips, 2015

Krista Townsend, 2012

Ingrid Johnson Martin, 2011

Larisa Zehr, 2011

Thia Shenk, 2012

Amanda Maust, 2006

Marla Kauffman, 1990

Joy McIlvaine, 1993

Greg Lamb, 2006

Deb Yoder Fair, 2003

Mariela I. Rivera, 2015

Adriana Koehn, 2001

Greta Bucher, 2010

Linnea Slabaugh, 2014

Colette Sharp Stetler, 1998

Katie Chaffinch, 2007

Ryan Eshleman, 2013

Benjamin Bixler, 2003, 2013

Kristin Yoder Kauffman, 2001, 2009

Sarah Bixler, 2002

Rohrer Eshleman, 1945

Philip Yoder, 2012

Tracy Wideman, 1996

Harold Shenk, 1988

Mary Grace Shenk, 1988

Rachel Swartzendruber Jenner, 2010, 2016

James Miller, 2001

Carol Eby-Good, 1998

Tamara Gill, 2010

Conrad Gross, 2009

Angèle Bell, 2010

Andrew Intagliata, 2006

Amy Umbel, 2006

Allison Glick, 2010

Rosemary Kreider Good, '93

Kelsey Miller, 2009

Aimee Troyer, 1997

Allison Eanes, 2013

Ben Roth Shank, 2010

Ken Roth, 1979

Miriam Yoder, 2006

Rev. Jeremy Yoder, 2010

Kevin Ressler, 2007

Kathy Summers Miller, 1990

Dale Ressler, 1984

Jeanne Zimmerly Jantzi, 1985

Heike Peckruhn, 2004

Randy Snow, 1991

Kelly Fry, 2010

Ethan Fry, 2008

Tom Brenneman, 1992

Jennifer Larson Sawin, 2004

Keri Kauffman, 2000

Mary Walala, 2001

Dale Mast, 1979

Joelle Hackney, 2007, 2010, 2014

Heidi Jablonski, 2014

Earl Gingerich, 1976

Marsha Lewis, 2007

Sara Versluis, 2005

Justin Hochstetler, 2009

P. Jordan Good, 2009

Keith Eshleman, 1980

Susan Weaver Eshleman, 1982

Christian Parks, 2016

Rosie Stauffer Hochstetler, 1981

Bill Hochstetler, 1977

Carmeleta Miller Beidler, 1985

Lindsey Frye, 2004

Greta Leinbach Kreider, 1996

Valerie Luna Serrels, 2010

Crystal Trost, 1998

Wanda Harder, 1987

Judy Ricca, 1991

Mary Hershberger, 1975

Janette Amstutz 1986

Linda Gehman Peachey, 1976

Jason Spicher, 2015

Glenn Reinford, 1973

S Lorraine Sommers Reinford, 1973

Aaron Oda, 2016

Laura Bowman, 2014

Friends & Family of EMU Alumni

Amanda Kaeser, EMHS 2006

Lauren McMullen

Julie Heinly

Kathryn Mattichak, EMHS 2009

Warren Yoder

Britta Albrecht, Goshen College 2009

T.C. Shifflett

Laura Miller, Goshen College 2017

Hannah Yoder, Goshen College 2018

Gloria Showalter, Goshen College 2015