The Book-Loving Texan’s Guide to the November 2023 School Board Elections

(This is a mobilization tool. Use it to volunteer, donate, and organize in your community.)

Contact: booklovingtexanvotes@gmail.com 

Table of Contents

        Introduction (Principles, Methodology, Scope)

        National and Statewide Resources

  1. Cy-Fair ISD
  2. Granbury ISD
  3. Houston ISD
  4. Princeton ISD (NEW! Added 10/23/23)

Eyes On:

  1. Aldine ISD
  2. Alief ISD
  3. Bryan ISD
  4. College Station ISD
  5. Midland ISD

How to Use This Guide & Color-Coded Designations:

I designed this document as a mobilization tool. In other words, while I hope you find it informative, what really matters is that we use the information here to act. Specifically, I hope this document can help people:

  1. Support school board candidates who resist book bans and stand up for all students in their district.
  2. Connect like-minded voters with each other and with groups already working in each district.
  3. Tie extremist candidates to their extreme positions.

To use this document:

  • Collaborate. This is a working document, and I want to add updates from people closer to the action than I am. If you know something that should be added, please email me: booklovingtexanvotes@gmail.com.
  • Check back. Candidate filings were just finalized in late February, and some school districts still haven’t updated their webpages with candidate names. Some candidates still don’t have websites. Information is going to come in quickly, so check back often!
  • Start with groups on the ground. One of the most important sections on each page is the “Contacts on the ground” box–these are people who either know a lot about what’s going on in a district or have already been working to prop up good candidates and challenge powerful PACs. If you want to organize in a district, start by contacting them.
  • Share. The more people who see this and use it, the better.

Terminology & Designations:

Candidates highlighted in red are either members of pro-censorship groups (Moms for Liberty, local PACs) or have the support of such groups.

 

Candidates highlighted in orange echo pro-censorship talking points but don’t have documented links to those groups.

 

Candidates highlighted in green either have a record of standing up for academic freedom, diversity and inclusion or have been targeted by pro-censorship groups and thus need support. This is not necessarily an endorsement–in races with multiple candidates, there may be more than one candidate worthy of this designation.

Candidates not highlighted could be great, or awful, or somewhere in between. As I get more information on them I’ll add it in the notes and change their designations if necessary.

“Contacts on the Ground” are local resources for organizing and information. If this is you, please let me add your name/group here!

Introduction

November 2023 Overview: Not an Off-Cycle

This will be the shortest of the four Texas school board voting guides I’ve put together because there just aren’t many contested school board races on the slate for this November. Only seven of the 100 largest districts in Texas have elections scheduled for this cycle. On top of that, several expected electoral hotspots ended up with uncontested races–most notably Klein ISD, which has been a flashpoint for book controversies and where two great candidates, Dustin Qualls and Doug James, will cruise unopposed to seats on the board.

It would be tempting to write off November as an off-cycle, to start looking ahead to the elections of next May and November, which will be much more packed. Here’s why that would be a mistake:

  • Two of the four largest school districts in the state–Houston ISD (200,000 students) and Cy-Fair ISD (116,000 students) will have multiple seats up for grabs this November. And both look to be statement elections. The stakes are particularly high in Cy-Fair, where extremists currently hold three of seven spots on the board and four seats will be decided in November. If even one of those goes the wrong way, the whole tenor of the board will change.
  • Granbury has been one of the state’s most conservative districts for several years, but activists in the district are disappointed with how few books have been removed from schools. Voters will decide on two trustees in November, and those elections will determine if Granbury continues its race towards Christian Nationalism.

 

Those are the three races I’m leading with, and the direction those votes take will shape the narrative for 2024. More importantly, they will shape the education of hundreds of thousands of Texas students.

Basic Background: The Way to Win

This is the fourth cycle I’ve made this document, and once again I bring you good news: it is very possible to avoid a pro-censorship school board takeover, even in deep red districts in Texas. This May, extremist candidates lost in many districts across Texas, from Fredericksburg to Plano to Canyon ISD. And last November, of the 38 red- and orange-highlighted candidates I tracked in the last version of this document, 30 lost.

 

The rules for defeating pro-censorship candidates are simple: organize and inform. Banning books and attacking vulnerable students are unpopular positions, but candidates who support those positions have won way too many races for three reasons: 1) pro-censorship forces have a massive organization and fundraising advantage; 2) voters don’t know who the book-banning candidates are; and (to a lesser extent), 3) pro-censorship forces have been able to activate partisan instincts in red districts by turning non-partisan school board elections into a fight between Democrats and Republicans.

So what do we do? In the second edition of this guide, I called the path to victory the Eanes/Richardson playbook because of the great groups in those districts that have effectively fought off well-funded slates of pro-censorship candidates. But recent elections have given us many more examples of outstanding community groups doing great work to combat the better-funded, more-established PACs on the anti-inclusion side. Two very different but similarly effective groups that deserve mention are Access Education Round Rock ISD and the “StandUp” groups in the Houston suburbs Tomball, Klein, and (post-election) Conroe. If there’s a group like that in your community, join it now. If there’s not, start one. Reach out to the leaders of successful groups to learn how.

 

Those groups can help you with the “organize” part of the job. But organization depends on information, and that’s where this document comes in. Share what you see here; make it your goal that every voter going to the polls in May knows exactly who wants to ban books from and attack students in your district’s schools.

 

Guiding Principles & Methodology

A few principles guided the construction of this document:

  1. Education requires free inquiry and the exploration of diverse topics and perspectives.
  2. Educators have a responsibility to the truth.
  3. The classroom should be a welcoming environment for all students.
  4. Educators are accountable to all students and to the parents of all students in a classroom–not just the loudest parents or the ones that comprise the majority.
  5. We can and should consider age-appropriateness when selecting texts for libraries and classrooms, but that’s not the same thing as calling award-winning literature “pornography” or accusing teachers and librarians of being pedophiles who are “grooming” or “sexualizing” students.

 

With those guiding principles in mind, I looked for information on candidates’ positions on academic freedom, on LGBTQ acceptance in the classroom, and on honest discussions of American history and race relations. I tried to find out: Which candidates are trying to protect academic freedom and which ones are trying to remove books and ideas from schools? Which candidates are scaremongering about “critical race theory” or “porn in schools”? Which candidates are supporting inclusive classrooms and which ones are sending the message that some students are unwelcome in the district?

 

For each of the contested races in a district, I went through these steps:

  1. I looked at the language on hot-button issues on candidates’ campaign websites or Facebook pages. If candidates listed endorsements, I took note of any high-profile supporters.
  2. I checked the social media of each candidate (though many have scrubbed or locked their personal accounts).
  3. I checked to see what PACs are dedicated to hot-button issues in each district. I tried to discern if PACs have endorsed any candidates yet (not usually) or spent any money to support or attack anyone in the race. When possible, I checked their donor list and membership rolls, and looked at their social media pages to see if any candidates have been active there or have attended their events.
  4. Where possible, I tried to determine if each candidate is a member of a Moms for Liberty Facebook group (or a similar group) and, if so, if they are an active member–commenting, sharing, liking, etc.
  5. I went through minutes and videos of school board meetings in the district over the past year to see if any candidates have spoken during public comment periods and, if so, what they’ve said.
  6. Finally, I checked to see what candidates are saying on local media (local news articles, podcasts, radio hits) or what’s being said about them.

NEW for 2023: This year, I also looked up every candidate’s primary voting history using the Reach app. My goal was not to inject partisanship into these races, but rather the opposite. I had a hunch that doing so would show the dividing line between pro-censorship and anti-censorship candidates isn’t a partisan one. Turns out I was right. In the first place, there just aren’t many Democrats running for school board in rural or suburban Texas. The majority of candidates in the races I’m covering are Republicans. In other words, this isn’t a question of partisanship; it’s about principles. Some people–Democrat and Republican–stand up for the value of education. Some oppose it.

That’s important to keep in mind in the next few months, because you’re going to hear the green-highlighted candidates in this guide called “leftists,” “Marxists” or “communists.” They’re not.

Scope:

I’m from North Texas (Fort Worth), live in Central Texas (Austin), and started my teaching career in Houston (Spring Branch ISD). A lot of book challenges and attacks on educators have taken place in suburban and exurban districts surrounding those places. So, just by focusing on the areas I know best, I’ve been well situated to report on some of the most explosive school district battles in the state.

But the war on education is spreading through the whole state. I will expand this list to include as many districts as I can (prioritizing the most contentious elections), but I’ll need help. If you have information or know of a district that you think needs to be on this list, please email me at booklovingtexanvotes@gmail.com.

Also note: I’ve only looked at contested school board races. Some of the best (or worst) candidates may be running unopposed.

Finally: What if I don’t live in any of these districts?

This is still your fight! I’m a teacher in Austin, and I’m forbidden by law from assigning any essay or poem from the Pulitzer Prize-winning 1619 Project, even as a part of a balanced collection of perspectives on race in the US. Why? I’d argue it’s a direct result of what has happened in school board meetings and elections since 2021.

 

In other words: What happens in these districts doesn’t stay in these districts. As long as politicians perceive that bullying trans kids, protecting white innocence, or accusing teachers of “grooming” is a winning political issue, they will continue to do it.

 

So adopt a race and see how you can help. Can you plan a road trip to knock doors? Can you donate to a candidate or a group doing the work on the ground? Can you support great statewide groups like Mothers Against Greg Abbott and Blue Action Democrats/Safe Schools for All/2 Million Texans?  Can you amplify good voices and call out bad actors online?

We need your help!

National and Statewide Resources

DISTRICTS

Cy-Fair ISD

Notes: This is the board election to watch in November. Cy-Fair is a diverse (and rapidly diversifying) district just outside of Houston. And with nearly 120,000 students, it is one of the largest districts in the state. It was also the site of one of the earliest battles in the current rightwing push to take over Texas school boards. In November 2021, three candidates–Natalie Blasingame, Scott Henry, and Lucas Scanlon–campaigned for the board against “critical race theory” and district diversity initiatives. All three won.

Since then, those three trustees have brought division and controversy to the district. Soon after taking his seat on the board, Henry made headlines for the racist implications of comments he made opposing a district plan to hire more Black teachers. [NOTE: Henry objected to the way his comments were characterized, saying, “Any suggestion that I said ‘More Black teachers leads to worse student outcomes' is a lie, and those spreading it should be ashamed of themselves.” But it’s hard to read his words as suggesting anything else.] Henry, Scanlon, and Blasingame have supported more restrictive library policies, and Scanlon’s wife, Bethany, has led efforts to remove books from district libraries.

Now the other four seats on the board are up for election, and the extremists aligned with Henry, Blasingame, and Scanlon hope to take full control of the board. The good news is that immediately after the 2021 election, district parents realized they had been out-organized and formed two overlapping groups, Cypress Families for Public Schools and Cy-Fair Strong Schools, to organize, inform, and turn out voters in order to resist a full takeover of the district.

Both groups are impressive, active, large, and energetic. And they’re doing everything you need to do to resist a school board takeover. That said, two of CFISD’s four races feature more than one good candidate, and I’m worried that those candidates will split votes, allowing an extremist to take one or both of those seats. That’s what happened in Leander’s Place 5 race last November, and in Grapevine-Colleyville this May.

The Place 1 race is particularly worrisome, since Cypress Families for Public Schools has endorsed Tonia Jaeggi while Cy-Fair Strong Schools endorsed Cleveland O. Lane, Jr. Both are strong candidates, and their opponent, Todd LeCompte, is one of the district’s more extreme voices. Again, the issue isn’t just that LeCompte is awful; the issue is that if LeCompte wins, he’ll join forces with three like-minded extremists already on the board to form a majority. The stakes couldn’t be higher.

Contested Races

Candidates

Position 1

Position 2

Position 3

Position 4

Tonia Jaeggi

Cleveland O. Lane, Jr. 

Todd LeCompte

George Edwards, Jr. 

Julie Hinaman (I)

Ayse Indemaio

Michelle Fennick

Leslie Martone

Justin Ray

Christine Kalmbach

Frances Ramirez Romero

Notes on Red Flag Candidate(s)

Position 1

  • Todd LeCompte announced his candidacy on Facebook this April with a complaint that schools are focusing too much on “social justice ideology, instead of academics.”
  • LeCompte tried to get Mike Curato’s book Flamer removed from Bridgeland High School by arguing that it’s illegal for a school library to carry the book. Notably, LeCompte argued that the book is obscene under the Texas Penal Code, meaning it’s not protected by the First Amendment.
  • LeCompte attended and spoke at a meeting of book banners in Tomball this summer that was so extreme its original sponsors, the Yellow Rose of Texas Republican Women, pulled their sponsorship after previewing the featured speaker’s presentation. In that presentation, the speaker argued that libraries need to stock books that show the “negatives” of homosexuality, and shared strategies for getting “thousands” of books removed from schools.
  • LeCompte’s campaign treasurer is Monica Dean, who regularly speaks at board meetings about books she finds inappropriate. In June, she berated the board, asking, “Did you bring out the best for children by stocking the library shelves with sexually explicit books so innocent children could access them? And yet they still remain on the shelves, as we speak. And online. How about allowing an afterschool club to invite a drag queen to speak? Did you bring out the best for children by exposing them to harmful material on chromebooks or tenets of CRT in lesson plans?”
  • In April, Dean expressed her anger that The Handmaid’s Tale graphic novel was retained after a district committee found it “meets requirements for retention, varying levels of difficulty, and diversity of appeal.” And in April of 2022, she clutched her pearls about The Glass Castle, a book I’ve taught several times, asking, “Will Cy-Fair clean up the campus and online offerings and choose to be educators instead of groomers?”
  • LeCompte has made fewer board meeting appearances than his treasurer, but he did speak at the January 2022 meeting suggesting that equity initiatives teach minorities to be victims and could lead to people being fired for the color of their skin. “Seems like lots of things being discussed in the school district is more focused on race these days, rather than performance,” he said.
  • LeCompte has been endorsed by Conservative CFISD, a book-banning organization, and by Texans for Educational Freedom, an anti-public-education, pro-censorship group that has been financing candidates across the state in recent elections.

Position 2

  • George Edwards, Jr. is a retired accountant with a history of voting in Republican primaries. His campaign secretary is a member of Conroe book-banning group The Force for CISD.  
  • Edwards has been endorsed by the Republican Party of Texas. He has also been endorsed by Texans for Educational Freedom.

  • Ayse Indemaio has made removing books from schools the centerpiece of her campaign. Her campaign website connects to her Texas Messengers website, which lists as her accomplishments that she “proved the No Place for Hate program socially shamed children, was divisive, and of questionable sources, resulting in the program being suspended” and “brought to light the blurring of biological sexes being taught in elementary lessons, educational games, books and counselor training, and got some removed.”
  • Indemaio spoke at the same Tomball book-banning meeting LeCompte attended this summer, saying she was radicalized to go after books after discovering that a book her then-3rd-grader son was reading “had the word ‘racism’ in it nine times.” “I started to think maybe I shouldn’t be trusting the schools,” she said.
  • In a bizarre rant at a board meeting in April of 2022, Indemaio accused incumbent Julie Hinaman of conspiring with members of Cypress Families for Public Schools (then Cy-Fair Civic Alliance) to get Flamer returned to library shelves. “I want to NOT thank a board member,” she said, “who took extra care and effort and worked and went out of her way to get the book Flamer back in our libraries after it was pulled by the Bridgeland High School administration.”
  • In addition to board member Lucas Scanlon and book-banning former Conroe ISD trustee Dale Inman, Indemaio has the endorsement of Tammy Nakamura, the Grapevine-Colleyville ISD trustee who claimed last year to have a list of teachers she wanted to chase from the district for political reasons, and Andrew Yeager, one of the extremists who has reshaped the Carroll ISD board in Southlake.
  • Indemaio also has the support of Conservative CFISD, a group focused on banning books from the district.

Position 3

  • Podcaster and former mayor of Jersey Village Justin Ray announced his campaign with a video in which he said, “I’m running to protect Cy-Fair from the pitfalls too many school districts across this country have fallen victim to. Instead, we have to reinforce that education, individual freedom, merit, and personal responsibility are the keys to success.”
  • Ray has expressed support for Katy ISD’s recently enacted anti-trans policies which, among other draconian measures, would require teachers to “out” students by informing parents if a student “requests he or she be identified as transgender, change his or her name, or use different pronouns at school.”
  • Ray is claiming the endorsement of Texans for Educational Freedom, a wealthy group opposed to public education that has been pumping money into school board races across the state.

Position 4

  • Christine Kalmbach’s campaign website avoids the incendiary controversies that seem to drive the campaigns of LeCompte and Indemaio, but Kalmbach has a history of public comments every bit as extreme as those two.
  • She ran for the Texas House in 2022, but lost in the primary. In an illuminating campaign survey for that race, she listed her favorite book as “The Bible first, then books on learning and biographies.” She also listed her priorities as “eliminating lockdowns, CRT, Comprehensive Sex Ed, and special classes.” Also: “Parental Rights, School Choice” and abolishing property taxes. In an interview for Community Impact she echoed those themes, saying that she hoped to Stop the alarming agenda being pushed on children— Comprehensive sex ed, CRT, SEL and gender confusion.”
  • Kalmbach’s opposition to sex ed runs deep. In 2012, she argued against the district’s adoption of a sex ed curriculum that one parent called “soft porn.” “I don’t need the school district showing my student how to put a condom on,” said Kalmbach.
  • Kalmbach wrote the legislature in support of HB 900, the bill that could remove thousands of books from Texas schools that was recently enjoined by a Trump-appointed judge. Kalmbach wrote: This bill is an outstanding example of what the State can do to mitigate exposure and exploitation of students in regards to lewd, lascivious and objectionable material in our schools and their libraries. Children are being exposed to disgusting content without their parents knowledge or consent. Please everyone should support and endorse this HB900 bill by Patterson!” 
  • Kalmbach is a member of book-banning group Mama Bears Rising, and has been endorsed by the True Texas Project as well as Texans for Educational Freedom.

Alternative Candidate(s)

Position 1

  • Tonia Jaeggi is a realtor and CFISD graduate who has been deeply involved in the district for years, serving on the Long Range Planning Committee, Superintendent Parent Leadership Committee, and the 2019 Bond Committee and volunteering at many of the district’s schools. Jaeggi has volunteered for an astounding 5000 hours in the district, and in 2022 was named a “Hero for Children” by the State Board of Education.
  • Jaeggi is endorsed by Cypress Families for Public Schools.
  • Volunteer for or donate to Tonia Jaeggi.

 

  • Cleveland O. Lane, Jr., is an Associate Professor at Prairie View A&M University with a doctorate in Curriculum and Instruction from A&M. Lane has 26 years of experience in education, and has volunteered for a number of district outreach groups.  
  • Lane has been endorsed by Cy-Fair Strong Schools.
  • Volunteer for or donate to Cleveland O. Lane, Jr.

Position 2

  • Incumbent Julie Hinaman has served on the board since 2019, and is emphasizing her experience and competence as a sitting trustee. She also has extensive experience volunteering with and leading in CFISD, having served as chair of the CFISD Community Leadership Committee and co-chair of the CFISD Long Range Planning Committee, as well as working on several PTO and booster organizations. She’s also a parent to two CFISD graduates. 
  • In three of the last four elections, Hinaman has voted in the Republican primary.
  • Hinaman has been endorsed by Cypress Families for Public Schools and Cy-Fair Strong Schools.
  • Volunteer for or donate to Julie Hinaman.

Position 3

  • Michelle Fennick is a fourth-generation educator who holds a PhD in educational administration and has trained principals in several Houston-area school districts. In addition to teaching, she has worked as a coach, assistant principal, principal, and adjunct professor, and previously served as Director of Instruction at Campbell Middle School in CFISD.
  • Volunteer for or donate to Michelle Fennick.

Position 4

  • Frances Ramirez Romero is the mom of two CFISD graduates and has been a teacher, PTO president, and regular volunteer in the district. She has regularly spoken at board meetings. Among other topics, she has argued against vouchers and advocated for the equity plan and representative hiring. At the contentious meeting after Scott Henry’s racist comments in January of 2022, Romero said, “It is important that in a school district with a 78% non-white population, that the faculty reflect the demographics of all of our kids. Teachers, administrators, and all staff are role models and can impact student success. A component of this is students seeing a reflection of those who look like them–but also those who are different.” She concluded, “There is no reason that academic distinction and outreach to a diverse workforce have to be mutually exclusive.”
  • Romero has been endorsed by Cypress Families for Public Schools and Cy-Fair Strong Schools.
  • Volunteer for or donate to Frances Ramirez Romero.

Contacts on the Ground

If you’re looking for a way to help out in CFISD, these two groups are an excellent place to start:

Organizing steps/upcoming events

  • PLEASE CONTACT ME TO ADD–Canvasses, organizing meetings, other events!

Granbury ISD

Notes: If you want to see how quickly a district can spin out of control, look no further than Granbury ISD. Granbury has always been conservative, but after 2020 it got swept up in the rightward pull of one-party Texas politics. For perspective: in 2021 and 2022, trustee Paula McDonald hosted a speech by “Critical Race Theory expert” Carole Haynes, superintendent Jeremy Glenn oversaw the removal of hundreds of books with the explicit aim of getting “transgender, LGBTQ” themes out from the libraries, and podcast co-host Courtney Gore ran for and won a trustee position because “our American Education System has been hijacked by Leftists into the ‘progressive’ way of thinking.”

By 2023, all three–McDonald, Glenn, and Gore–have been dismissed by Granbury activists as insufficiently conservative, maybe even “woke.” McDonald lost her spot on the board last November to Karen Lowery, who ran on a platform of banning even more books than the rest of the board. Lowery took this pledge so seriously that one Saturday she snuck into a high school library when she was supposed to be volunteering to distribute school supplies in the cafeteria and used a cell phone flashlight to survey titles on the library shelves. This egregious and (let’s face it) hilarious behavior brought embarrassment to the district and earned censure from all members of the board except fellow radical Melanie Graft. The vote cemented what district activists are calling a 5-2 split on the board.

Why are the numbers 5 and 2 significant? Because two spots are up for election in November, and the wacky extremists are hoping to gain the board’s majority (again) by turning the 2 into a 4 and the 5 into 3.

I want to be clear: there are no Democrats, liberals, or progressives on or running for the Granbury ISD school board. There are not even any moderate Republicans on or running for the board. Voters in Granbury will be choosing between different flavors of conservative Republican. That said, there are clear differences between the candidates, and between the supporters who are driving their campaign priorities. And those differences will matter to the students in the district. Granbury may be a deep red district, but, like everywhere else in Texas, it is diversifying. There are students of color in Granbury schools, and there are as many LGBTQ kids at Granbury High School as there are at any school in Fort Worth or Houston or Austin. Those students deserve to be represented by trustees who value education and who see them as human beings deserving of respect and dignity.  

Contested Races

Candidates

Place 1

Place 2

Jessica Wark

Rhonda Rogers Williams

Mike Moore (I)

Alejandra Muñoz 

Nancy Alana

Notes on Red Flag Candidate(s)

Place 1

  • Rhonda Rogers Williams has the support of the district’s Christian Nationalist faction, including political consultant Nate Criswell. Williams is also endorsed by Monica Brown, who regularly appears at board meetings to demand book removals and who even called the police on Granbury ISD libraries after a book review committee returned books to the shelves that she thought constituted obscene material.
  • Williams wrote to the legislature in March in support of book-banning bill HB 900, saying, “Please rid our schools of filthy sexually explicit books.”
  • At a sort of campaign launch party in August, Williams threw red meat to the district’s extremists, saying, “Our children are our future and need our guidance. Guidance to make sure our schools promote education and not sexual materials or age inappropriate materials. I am not for any critical race theory curriculums in our schools.”

Place 2

  • Alejandra Muñoz is running alongside Williams and, like Williams, has the support of Nate Criswell and Monica Brown. She also has the support of Kyle ‘KD’ Sims, a McKinney-based social media influencer in a cowboy hat who hops from district to district in North Texas demanding that school boards remove books.

Alternative Candidate(s)

Place 1

  • I’ve found very little information about Jessica Wark, except that she regularly votes in Republican primaries. She was honored with a “Superfan” award in April 2023 by the district for her volunteer work with the Brawner Elementary PTO.

  • Incumbent Mike Moore is a parent of two GISD students, and his wife is a district employee. Moore has been a trustee since 2017. He’s a consistent Republican primary voter.
  • While Moore expressed support for Superintendent Jeremy Glenn after Glenn told librarians to remove LGBTQ books and “hide” any viewpoints other than conservative ones, he has pushed back on extremism in the district, not only voting to censure Lowery, but also sharing a Facebook post from a local teacher bemoaning the “vitriol and hate that is being constantly spewed at teachers not only in Granbury, but across Texas, and across the country.
  • Donate to or volunteer for Mike Moore (website pending).

Place 2

  • Nancy Alana, who taught and worked as a principal in the district before serving as a trustee for 12 years, has a solid Republican primary voting history and is an administrator of the group United Republicans of Hood County. She is running alongside incumbent Moore–she’s using the slogan “We need Moore Alana” (witty!).
  • In a sign of just how extreme things have become in Granbury, Alana told the Texas Tribune in 2022 that she “shares views similar to those of Graft and Gore on books and curriculum, but was pegged by some far-right Republican activists as too passive for their vision of a more uncompromising ‘new Granbury.’” Further, “Alana said she worried that the focus on culture-war battles over books and curriculum could distract leaders from important issues like overcrowding in the growing district.” Melanie Graft  is one of the district’s loudest anti-LGBTQ and anti-book voices; Courtney Gore, who defeated Alana in 2021, applauded the removal of hundreds of books from libraries in 2022.
  • At the end of public comment during a contentious board meeting in March, Alana spoke to remind the board that their job is to make schools better for the district’s students, chided those trying to “create drama for personal attention.” Alana also pointed out that public schools work with students “from all political backgrounds.”
  • Donate to or volunteer for Nancy Alana (website pending).  

   

Contacts on the Ground

  • Former Granbury ISD trustee Chris Tackett and his wife, Mendi, have been documenting the district’s slide into Christian Nationalism for years. The two are tenacious and absolutely worth following on social media for information on GISD.
  • Adrienne Martin has been courageous in speaking up for Granbury students at board meetings, and has also been a key source of information on district happenings.  

Organizing steps/upcoming events

  • PLEASE CONTACT ME TO ADD–Canvasses, organizing meetings, other events!

Houston ISD

Notes: This is a strange race. You probably know that Governor Greg Abbott used shady auspices to force a state takeover of Houston ISD this summer. That means the superintendent was dismissed and replaced with a hand-picked (and controversial) district leader, Mike Miles. And the elected school board was divested of all of its power and replaced by an appointed board of managers.

Nonetheless, the elected board of trustees still exists, and serves in an advisory capacity to Miles and the appointed board of advisors. And there will be a school board election this November for four spots on the board. Presumably, those members of the board will be poised to resume power when the conservatorship (or whatever we’re calling it) ends. And, just as importantly, the election has the potential to send a message–to Abbott, to Houston, to legislators who are always looking for cues as they plan their initiatives and messages for elections in 2024 and the next legislative session.

Two of the four open spots in HISD are contested, and in both of those races the incumbents have drawn opponents who give some reasons for concern. One is explicitly hoping to show the state that Houston’s previously elected board members are to blame for whatever people think Houston’s schools are bad at. So, while I’m worried that voters might find it hard to get excited about voting for powerless trustees, I’m more concerned about the message it could send if a tiny minority of voters choose to replace their current trustees with extremists.

 

Contested Races

Candidates

District 3

District 4

Dani Hernandez (I)

FeLiza (Fe) Bencosme

Patricia K. Allen (I)

Meg Seff

Notes on Red Flag Candidate(s)

District 3

  • FeLiza (Fe) Bencosme  appeared on the Angela Box Show over the summer and expressed support for the state takeover of HISD. “There were a lot of changes that needed to be made that never would have been made with an elected board,” she said. That’s a strange and wildly anti-democratic thing for a candidate for that elected board to say. Bencosme also specifically endorsed appointed superintendent Mike Miles’ decision to fire librarians in struggling schools and turn their libraries into discipline centers. “I think it’s a good move,” she said.  
  • Her interviewer, Angela Box, described parents objecting to the takeover as “for lack of a better word, ghetto-ass parents.” Not only did Bencosme not object, she agreed, saying, “I saw community leaders, respected community leaders who have time on Sunday morning talk shows yelling through a bullhorn.”
  • Bencosme has published a book entitled You Are Not Your Race: Embracing Our Shared Identity in a Chaotic Age, which she says she wrote to “counter flawed racialized theories causing harm to children and the posterity of the nation.”
  • Bencosme is a member of the book-banning conspiracist group (and Moms for Liberty spinoff) Families Engaged for Effective Education. She has described HISD’s sex education program as “teaching perversity,” expressed support for Katy ISD’s draconian anti-LGBTQ policies, and described HISD’s current policies as a “sexualized curriculum.”

District 4

  • Meg Seff has been planning her run for the Houston ISD board since at least August of 2022, when she started looking for campaign support in the Northwest Harris County True Texas Project Facebook page. A consistent Republican primary voter, Seff has continued courting extremists, emphasizing “parental rights” as an issue that matters to her on her campaign website.
  • To her credit, Seff has been critical on social media of the state takeover of HISD, specifically calling out schemes to replace school libraries with discipline centers.

Alternative Candidate(s)

District 3

  • Dani Hernandez is a realtor and former bilingual teacher and school administrator with a degree in sociology from Boston University and a Masters in Education from the University of St. Thomas in Houston. She is the daughter of immigrants and a first-generation graduate of both high school and college. She says that one of her priorities as a trustee is “eliminating educational inequities and closing the achievement gap between children from different socioeconomic backgrounds.”
  • Donate to or volunteer for Dani Hernandez. (website pending)

District 4

  • Patricia K. Allen is a former teacher and principal with a doctorate in Curriculum and Instruction from the University of Houston. She was elected to the board in 2019.
  • Allen spoke out forcefully against the state takeover of the district, saying, “The board is supposed to be the voice of the people” and “as long as the district was moving forward, I think it should have been left that way.”
  • Donate to or volunteer for Patricia K. Allen. (website pending)

   

Contacts on the Ground

  • Charles Kuffner’s website Off the Kuff  (“Texas’ longest running progressive political blog”) is a rich source of information on Houston ISD elections and Houston politics in general. In particular, do not miss his interviews of HISD candidates.

Organizing steps/upcoming events

  • PLEASE CONTACT ME TO ADD–Canvasses, organizing meetings, other events!

Princeton ISD

Contested Races

Candidates

Two at-large trustees will be elected from the field of four.

Starla Sharpe

Chad Jones (I)

Cyndi Darland (I)

Melissa Ait Belaid

Notes on Red Flag Candidate(s)

At-Large Candidates

  • Incumbent Cyndi Darland is the current board president, and a member of the incendiary Facebook group McKinney Talks Politics, where she regularly makes anti-trans and anti-LGBTQ comments in response to community posts.
  • For example, regarding a Pride display at the McKinney public library that included the book Jacob’s New Dress, Darland wrote on Facebook, “God is going to need to apologize to Soddom [sic] and Gomorrah....”
  • Darland responded to a survey question about book bans from the League of Women Voters by conflating books like The Bluest Eye, Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close, and Raina Telgemaier’s Drama (all of which have been restricted in Princeton ISD since 2022) with pornography: “Pornography in schools is illegal. That is not book banning. It is simply following the law. If you gave an under-aged child one of those books on the street- you would be arrested. I have had an in-depth talk with Collin County Sheriff Skinner about this topic. Penal codes are associated with these books. The Board and the Superintendent can be arrested for making pornography available to children.”
  • Princeton ISD actually removed or restricted more books than any other North Texas district in 2022, and Darland is claiming that as one of her accomplishments as she runs for reelection. Announcing her reelection bid on Facebook, Darland bragged that in her first term as president, she championed “getting rid of pornographic material in our school libraries.” Again, the books she means include novels by Nobel-prize-winning author Toni Morrison.

  • Chad Jones is another incumbent and the current board vice president. Jones responded with a troubling answer to the question on book bans from the League of Women Voters, saying, “I agree with banning controversial books that don’t serve a meaningful role in educating students. I think book reviews need to take place and criteria set for what material will not be acceptable. Any books that fall into that category will not be allowed in the school to begin with.”

Alternative Candidate(s)

At-Large Candidates

  • Starla Sharpe was Princeton ISD’s first female trustee of color when she served on the board from 2021 to 2022. Though she is running in tandem with Chad Jones, her position on book bans is much better than his: “I support a balanced approach to book selection in schools, considering age-appropriateness and diverse viewpoints. Outright book banning should be a last resort. Instead, transparent procedures with review committees, including educators, parents, and experts, should address complaints. Goal being to create open, transparent dialogue, respecting diverse perspectives, and providing access to a wide range of literature. I think similar principles apply to content on the internet, emphasizing responsible use and education.”
  • Donate to or volunteer for Starla Sharpe.

  • Melissa Ait Belaid, who is running to be the “Teacher Trustee for Princeton ISD,” has worked as an educator and instructional coach for fifteen years.
  • She has said that her vision for the district is “that our local schools would reflect the inclusive, multicultural education she sought for herself”
  • Aid Belaid had the best answer to the League of Women Voters’ question on school book bans, stating, “I am committed to maintaining free access to books and educational materials aligned with student curiosity and developmental stage, including access to books and other educational materials that allow students to explore topics outside of prescribed curriculum. I support a formal appeal process to dispute the curriculum. Curriculum is set through the district, so choosing to remove books from curriculum would need to be up for annual review, with new consideration each year.”
  • Donate to or volunteer for Melissa Ait Belaid.

 

   

Contacts on the Ground

  • TBD

Organizing steps/upcoming events

  • PLEASE CONTACT ME TO ADD–Canvasses, organizing meetings, other events!