FABRIC MASK BEST PRACTICES

Things to consider before you start sewing masks

First and foremost, homemade protective gear is *not an acceptable substitute for PPE* and we need to do everything in our power to demand that front line responders get the gear they need and that the government is held responsible for this shortfall.

This petition is a small step but I would love to know more options for political action around this issue:https://www.change.org/p/hospital-administrators-us-physicians-healthcare-workers-for-personal-protective-equipment-in-covid-19-pandemic?recruiter=574573&utm_source=share_petition&utm_medium=facebook&utm_campaign=psf_combo_share_abi&utm_term=psf_combo_share_abi&recruited_by_id=34137820-c0e2-012f-3b1f-4040b91ba155&utm_content=fht-20916933-en-us%3Av10&use_react=false

These patterns and materials suggestions below are the best that I can find right now, but this is community based harm reduction at best. There is no guarantee that these will be effective against the novel coronavirus. In the long term, only real, standardized, tested protective gear will get us through this crisis. Regardless of what anyone claims none of these are “CDC approved.” The official CDC policy is do whatever you can if you have nothing else, and we should not accept that as a standard.

It appears that the medical centers that are putting fabric masks into use are using them for patients, and for non-COVID-19 procedures which allow the remaining PPE to be used where it is most effective.

: Please ensure that there are people/institutions that want/can use the masks you are making and that you are in touch with them about their specifications. This kind of craftivism is notorious for causing deluges of donations that do not meet the needs of their intended recipients and cause more harm than good.

That said, after speaking to the friends and family of front line medical personnel who will be entirely out of protective gear in a matter of days, I have put together this roundup of patterns and suggestions for DIY face masks. Please let me know if you have any edits, additions, or suggestions: Rachel.a.wallis@gmail.com

I’m currently sewing and donating masks to prisoners at Cook County Correctional Center (currently the largest coronavirus outbreak in the country) and the Logan Women’s Correctional Center in Illinois. These are both places I've taught and volunteered, and where thousands of people are being held in desperate overcrowded conditions without access to basic hygiene and sanitary supplies let alone adequate healthcare.

If you have the capacity to sew and donate masks to prisoners in Illinois, please follow this link for more information: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/10I6Xn1xZqCntsdW8TGqF8G-X7rHKm7yAmhDxgus9Q7M/edit?fbclid=IwAR3FsGKZ4pqwNKzjwTRGQkZjR1W3PVXdMNhZcNWxpsqHPMq101oLOX0NcOc#gid=0

Please do not use elastics which contain latex. They can be deadly to people with latex allergies, fabric ties are preferable if you don’t know the latex content of your elastic.

Mask Patterns

We don’t have specific suggestions for patterns, but have heard that [a][b]the “duck billed” masks are more comfortable to wear, and that the mask pattern that is circulating from Deaconess hospital is gappy and doesn’t fit securely against the face. I personally think the Properfit mask (available for purchase here or email me for the link) is the best fitting pattern I’ve made, but is somewhat complicated to assemble.

This mask is designed by a nurse and can fit either directly on the face or over an N95 filter:

AB Mask - for a Nurse by a Nurse : 15 Steps (with Pictures)

Two patterns from Regional Medical Center in Manchester, both with a pocket for a filter:

Regional Medical Center Page

If you are interested in the pattern in the link above that is available for purchase, let me know and I will send you a copy.

Another “duck bill” style mask with instructions:

https://freesewing.org/blog/facemask-frenzy/?fbclid=IwAR3uC2hVZD2dFxmkME95ZfEK-utQBWTZ8tWJhy_P5oEKBDoOKYcYqmvwoPU

This video is for a pattern of a rectangular pleated mask with filter pocket that has been approved for use by the incident command team at a hospital in Bozeman MT
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BCJcE-r7kcg&fbclid=IwAR1hT5WX8hUXwwtc-3kUsSpDIMV_MmT49aYpABSc73iFQWKFDpQWxbXZF58

This pattern (for purchase) is designed to be made on home embroidery machines  https://www.zippydesignz.com/index.php?act=viewProd&productId=258 

It has Pleats (both layers), Option for elastic or ties, Casing for pipe cleaner to pinch nose piece, A pocket for a removable filter, Two sizes - adults & kids

Suggested Fabrics:

Please do not use elastics which contain latex. They can be deadly to people with latex allergies, fabric ties are preferable if you don’t know the latex content of your elastic.

From what we have heard from providers:

  • DO USE:

Fabric should be new, unused, breathable and tightly woven, such as 100% cotton, quilting cottons or cotton flannels. For ear loops: elastic, fold over elastic (or cotton twill tape if that’s all you have.) Include a pocket that providers can put a removable filter in. Use different fabric for the “inside” and “outside” of the mask so that the wearer doesn’t accidentally put the side that has been exposed to germs back on against their face.

  • DO NOT USE:

No vintage, stretchy, knit, used towels/sheets, clothing, metal, plastics, filters, vacuum bags, interfacing or unknown material fabrics. Ear loops: no hair bands, ties, or rubber bands.

Additional fabric suggestions and discussion 

This is information we’ve gathered online, some of which is contradictory. Always default to what the medical center you are sewing for recommends. Also consider making a prototype first to check for fit (does it fit tightly against the face without gaps) and breathability (could you wear this and breath comfortably through it for an extended period of time).

We don’t have good information about filters, which is why we recommend including a pocket, but not sewing in or creating filters at this time.

Lighter solids and non-patterned fabrics may be preferable. One of the nurses we’re in contact with has said that as her medical center is bleaching masks between uses.

From physicians at Portland clinics requesting masks: 100% cotton and cotton flannel. NOT poly, NOT vintage fabrics! Including cotton thread as poly can melt at high temperatures and we don’t know how they plan on disinfecting these cloth masks.

A physician in the COVID19 Physician Community posted that she is designing a washable reusable cloth mask with a 1 micron filter. Her thoughts are

"Covid-19 is 0.1 microns in size, but it travels in aerosolized respiratory droplets 5 microns in size. N95 filters only 95% of 0.3 micron sized particles, yet it is effective. The N95 may be capturing some virus particles through electrostatic charges. My thought is that the polyester felt filter also carries a negative electrostatic charge and may repel the negatively charged virus particles. The fabric mask doesn’t provide a complete seal, but neither do surgical masks which on a clinical level are considered to prevent flu just as well as N95".

If anyone can pull sources and get the appropriate cloth and elastic band (heck, we can use plastic bag metal ties or pipe cleaners sewn at the nose bridge for better fit), I am sure there are a few of us, including myself, that are willing to sew these for our the frontline physicians in need of them."

That said, other people have asked for no metal to be used in the masks, as they will have to be washed frequently. A removable nose bridge is one possible option.

These bed bug mattress covers and pillowcases have one micron filters and would be suitable for an outer layer https://www.amazon.com/Eco-Living-Friendly-Protector-Encasement/dp/B002UBMM4O/ref=sr_1_2?dchild=1&keywords=evolon+allergy&qid=1584684791&sr=8-2&swrs=6EC3E342B9A9C370C8A5BD5C01781F30&pldnSite=1

From folks who are making prototypes, I have heard an outer layer of tightly woven cotton canvas, duck cloth, or a fabric you are not able to see the space between the individual thread,  an absorbing inner layer (like performance jersey or cotton flannel) and an optional inner layer of mesh or felt works best, but make a prototype and see what feels comfortable and breathable enough to wear all day.

From my sister (a nurse midwife) 

  • -Best filter material: single layer vacuum cleaner bag which is comparable to an ordinary surgical mask.[c] 
  • Next best: 2-layer tea towel or poly blend t-shirt, (or 1 layer) depending on denseness of fabric.
  • Must balance effectiveness with breathability.
  • One study found that dense sweatshirt fleece was moderately better as an inner filter than cotton cloth.
  • To improve the mask design for a multi-layer mask, the weave of the material should be rotated with each layer
  • Must pre-shrink fabric before sewing
  • Elastic straps age quickly and need to be replaced after 100 uses or if fit loosens at all
  • DISINFECTING -Mask should be boiled to sterilize (remove filter first)
  • NOT USEFUL - 2-layer quilting cotton [d][e][f][g][h][i][j]fabric masks

-Here is one mask model for people with really limited sewing skills, made out of t-shirt layers: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3373043/

REFERENCES

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4420971/

https://www.hongkongfp.com/2020/02/21/coronavirus-made-hong-kong-face-masks-joint-effort-chemistry-godfather-social-enterprise/

2013 study from Disaster Medicine and Public Health Preparedness, Volume 7, Issue 4 August 2013 , pp. 413-418: Testing the Efficacy of Homemade Masks: Would They Protect in an Influenza Pandemic?https://www.researchgate.net/publication/258525804_Testing_the_Efficacy_of_Homemade_Masks_Would_They_Protect_in_an_Influenza_Pandemic

https://smartairfilters.com/en/blog/best-materials-make-diy-face-mask-virus/

https://smartairfilters.com/en/blog/diy-homemade-mask-protect-virus-coronavirus/?rel=1

https://smartairfilters.com/en/blog/pitta-masks-protect-capture-coronavirus-virus/?rel=1

 

A Note on Mask Production and Safety

From the Crafters Against Covid 19 Facebook Group

Mask Production Phase 1

This announcement is ONLY for master sewers in the Portland, Oregon area who are confident and healthy. Please read this entire announcement before starting. This directive is coming from healthcare professionals at Providence Portland. If you are nervous or unsure, please wait for more detailed instructions coming soon, including a video tutorial.

We are ready for you to begin production of masks for patient use in the hospital. These masks will be given to patients showing symptoms entering the hospital and in waiting rooms to prevent spread to others, as well as immunocompromised patients receiving care in infusion centers, and other hospital based settings.  This will help alleviate our mask shortage and reserve medical grade masks for health care workers.

  1. Begin by washing your hands and clearing/cleaning a space in your home free of food, smoke, pets, and kids.
  2. Launder the fabric you intend to use, ideally with unscented detergent.
  3. You may use whichever pattern you feel most comfortable with, including from elsewhere online. The video I posted when this group was born has a great 3 layered mask, but for the moment, we are not prepared to endorse something specific.
  4. The fabric should be new and unused. Ideally it will be moisture-wicking, breathable, tightly woven fabric. If you only have cotton but still wish to begin, we will accept that but is not ideal because it is absorbent and needs to be washed more frequently. Please do [k]NOT use vintage fabrics, unknown material content, or used towels/clothing.
  5. If you are trying on your prototypes, please do not include them with your finished product.

For more information please see the Crafters Against Covid facebook group, which is being updated regularly.

Here’s a video from the Henry Ford Allegiance Health on DIY PPE

Hospitals Currently Requesting Support - Updated 3/23/20

These hospitals want local sewers:

STATE BY STATE LISTINGS OF HOSPITALS

Deaconess Hospital - Searchable and sortable listing of organizations in need of masks. Global locations.

COLORADO

Denver: Colorado Commission for the Homeless - Masks can be dropped off Monday-Friday 8:00am-5:00pm at our office at 2111 Champa Street, Denver 80205.

IOWA

Cedar Rapids: Iowa - MercyOne - They have a specific pattern and material list with a video. They are looking for local sewers.

Completed masks may be dropped off by pulling up to Mercy's 10th St. entrance and putting the masks in a collection box. Mercy is located at 701 10th St. SE in Cedar Rapids. Drop-off hours are 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. on weekdays.

Iowa - Unity Point - They have a specific pattern and requirements and provide a video.

Enclose completed masks in a closed plastic bag or closed plastic box. We will launder them prior to use so no need to wash before delivering. Please deliver to the St. Luke's Foundation, 855 A Ave. NE,  1st floor, Cedar Rapids. Phone (319) 369-7716.

NORTH CAROLINA

Chapel Hill: UNC Hospital is requesting homemade masks in addition to a number of other medical supplies. Here is the link where they lay out their request: https://www.unchealthcare.org/coronavirus/ways-to-help/?fbclid=IwAR3OrHlNs9JGd18Ak_muh_a9dQ3k-OWcv8UyGkzrK1tb3FQkkFvxgqftwFc

OKLAHOMA

Stillwater: Oklahoma - Stillwater Medical Center - Anyone who would like to help and has questions about sewing the masks is asked to contact the hospital’s volunteer coordinator, Lisa Eckels, at 405-742-5680

[a]Would be great to stear clear of "we've heard" and cite your sources, like you've done SUCH A GREAT JOB OF throughout.  

Might also reiterate -- check with the local requesters for what pattern they'd like us to use, less conjecture of what works and what doesn't -- that depends on who is accepting/requesting them.

[b]I'm using "we have heard" for stuff that friends and family have told me directly about their experience using either masks they've made or bought online.

[c]I really appreciate your effort here, but  this conflicts with the findings of the Cambridge researchers, expand my comment below for an exact quote from their study.

[d]Does this mean quilting cotton is NOT effective? There are already MANY groups out there making masks with quilting cotton, so this is a critical point to clarify.

Or, does it mean that specifically TWO LAYERS of quilting cotton is not effective?

[e]So that was part of the notes from my sister (a nurse) on materials. None of use are experts on this, but looking through her research she felt that a mask with just two layers of quilting cotton would not be effective. We're suggesting using a more tightly woven exterior and leaving a pocket for a filter. But please follow the requests from the healthcare professionals or institutions you're making masks for.

[f]Rachel are you local to Portland? I am working with a team in Minneapolis to share more information on what is needed in our local communities. Just wanting to see where this information is posted and if we can utilize any of it for our own communities. Thanks!

[g]I'm actually in Columbus, OH. Please steal/borrow/adapt this info however you need. If you're interested in adding to the doc or helping edit it you can email me at Rachel.a.wallis@gmail.com and I can give you editing access.

[h]Hi every one the masks dr are asking me for are not the covid 19 masks they don’t have any masks are using bandannas ... cotton woven fabric works well. .... these are for non covid 19.    Anything better than a bandana   Some are putting room for filters but weather coffee or vacuum bag filters no medical will approve for covid 19.    FYI. Working with textile manufacturers to make 1 million gowns a 100 thousand masks next week and when we can locate the material covid 19 masks

[i]FYI while vacuum cleaner bags may filter out more particles can you breathe out of it? A lot of people aren't reading the whole study that information came from which if you read further down has the breathability of the masks. So while they may not allow particles to enter you still have to check the breathability of wearing a mask for many hours. So just check if you can still breathe out of them =)

[j]Paula Riess's point about breathability and paper vacuum cleaner filters is a valid point. I noted when reading the Cambridge study report that they recommended 100% cotton rather than the tea towel (dish cloth in US?) or the vacuum cleaner bag for the same reason, better filtration but bigger reduction in air pressure.

[k]The use of a moisture wicking fabric (synthetic like polyester or nylon) conflicts with the info I'm reading (in your links at bottom of doc) that say polyester is poor at stopping virus particles versus 100% cotton. I was looking for the article I saw that in but can't find it.

I realize there is a lot of conflicting information on best practices but wanted to bring this up to start a conversation around fabric content.

Thanks Rachel for starting this document!