MJCP | Review form MJCP University of Messina, Italy
Review Form - MJCP
Title of the article *: ____________________________________________________
Is the article original and of interest of MJCP *?
____________________________________________
Please summarize the main findings of the study * |
Please highlight limitations and strengths * |
Please comment the methods (e.g. Participants, Statistical analysis, Inclusion criteria, Exclusion criteria, Used instruments, proper indexes, alphas, reliability indexes etc..), highlighting missing information, missing data, errors, missing references referred to instruments etc. * |
Please, answer and comment the following items *
Is the introduction well structured? Does it include relevant research findings, items and previous published research?
__________________________________________
Is the considered literature sufficiently adherent to the article’s themes? Are the included articles compliant numerically enough?
________________________________________
Are the hypotheses well presented, clear and subsequently confirmed/disconfirmed?
_______________________________________
Did the authors include enough data in order to reach high article replicability?
_______________________________________
Is the quality of results interpretation sufficient? Did the authors comment their results highlighting the extent of their findings?
_______________________________________
Did the authors compare their findings with previous existing results in the discussions?
_______________________________________
English language: Is it of sufficient quality?
_______________________________________
Tables and figures: are they reported in an acceptable form?
_______________________________________
References: are they reported following APA Style 7th Edition both in the text and in the final list?
_______________________________________
Did the authors report the hyperlink form of every DOI (if existing)
_______________________________________
Did the authors report their Ethical Statement?
_______________________________________
Did the authors report their Disclosure and Conflict of interest statement?
_______________________________________
Is the article compliant with MJCP submission requirements? (https://cab.unime.it/journals/index.php/MJCP/about/submissions#onlineSubmissions)
_______________________________________
What is your final decision suggestion? (Accept submission, Revisions required, Resubmit for review, Decline submission).
______________________________________
Please state your final report including all previous items (long extended version including all the above-mentioned fields) * |
Final decision: ___________________ |