Performance Indicator

Exceeds Expectation

20-19

Meets Expectation

18-16

Working Toward Expectation

15-13

Has Not Met Expectation

12 & below

Craftsmanship

(Develop Artistic Skills)

Demonstrates excellent craftsmanship and great care is taken in the production of work.

Demonstrates good craftsmanship and care is taken in the production of work.

Demonstrates craftsmanship, some care is taken in the production of work.

Limited demonstration of craftsmanship, limited care is taken in the production of work.

Innovative Thinking

(Express Ideas Creatively Across the Curriculum)

Expresses ideas through innovative design. Uses materials and ideas in an unexpected way. Originality of thought and action.

Materials and ideas often develop in unique ways without significant guidance.

Materials and ideas occasionally developed in unique ways, but only with guidance and encouragement.

Materials and ideas lack originality.

Content

Covers topic in-depth with details and examples. Subject knowledge is excellent.

Includes essential knowledge about the topic. Subject knowledge appears to be good.

Includes some information but more is needed to clearly illustrate topic and/or there are 1-2 factual errors.

Content is minimal and/or  there are several factual errors.

Introduction /

Conclusion

Unique and memorable

introduction engages the

audience immediately and

communicates the purpose

of the piece.  End is clear.

Introduces the topic and

purpose in an engaging

manner.

End is clear.

General introduction of the

topic and purpose. Little

creativity and only

somewhat engaging.

End is not very clear.

Introduction is not included

or does not make sense.

The topic and purpose are

not clear.

Audience Engagement

(Express Ideas Creatively Across the Curriculum)

Consistently expresses ideas in a way which fosters an actively engaged audience.

Delivery, Eye Contact , Posture, Volume is excellent.

Sometimes expresses ideas in a way which often encourages active audience engagement.

Delivery, Eye Contact , Posture, Volume is good.

Expresses ideas in a way which attempts to encourage active audience engagement with some success.

Delivery, Eye Contact , Posture, Volume needs improvement.

Ideas are not expressed in an engaging manner.

Work as a

Whole & Effort

Project exceeds

expectations.

Superior effort is

recognized.

Clearly shows that much effort went into it.

Project deadline was met.

Project meets

expectations.

Average effort is

recognized.

Project shows some effort.

Project deadline was met.

Project barely

meets expectations.

Little or no effort  recognized.

It looks as if it was put together at the last minute - in a hurry!.

Still needs quite a bit of work, just doesn't look done.

Project one day late.

Project does not meet expectations.

Project more than one day late.