Email id: Cji@sci.nic.in ,supremecourt@nic.in
Mail 1:
Subject: Appeal Against the Mass Confinement of Stray Dogs in Delhi NCR
To
Hon’ble Chief Justice of India
Supreme Court of India
Tilak Marg, New Delhi – 110001
Respected Lordship,
I write to you with the deepest respect, but also with great concern and urgency, regarding the Hon’ble Supreme Court’s recent order to move all stray dogs in the Delhi NCR region into shelters within eight weeks.
As someone closely associated with animal welfare on the ground, I feel compelled to highlight that this directive, though well-intentioned for public safety, will, in its current form, cause immense suffering to these animals and will be impossible to implement humanely.
Street dogs are not criminals, they have lived in their communities for years, often cared for by local feeders, and play a role in controlling garbage and intruding wildlife.
Confinement is cruelty, in reality, “pounds” in India have long been overcrowded, underfunded, and poorly managed. Moving thousands of dogs into such facilities will not protect them, it will condemn them to slow neglect, disease, and death.
ABC Rules and Constitutional Values, the Animal Birth Control (Dogs) Rules, 2023, and previous court rulings recognise that sterilised, vaccinated dogs should be returned to their territories. This approach ensures population control while respecting their right to live freely, in line with the spirit of Article 51A(g) of the Constitution.
Practical impossibility, Delhi NCR has neither the infrastructure, staff, nor budget to house tens of thousands of dogs humanely. The eight-week deadline will inevitably lead to rushed, inhumane capture and confinement.
In addition, as per Hindu traditions and rituals, I and many others feed dogs as an act of religious observance, considering them the embodiment of Bhairav Swaroop and associated with Rahu and Ketu. This practice is rooted in faith and is a recognised part of cultural and spiritual life. I humbly request that no order should go against such deeply held religious customs, which are protected under the Constitution of India.
I respectfully submit that removal and permanent sheltering is not the solution. The path forward should be,
1. Strict enforcement of mass sterilisation and vaccination drives,
2. Strengthening waste management to reduce food sources and control population growth,
3. Promoting community dog caretakers and mediation between residents and feeders,
4. Punishing those who commit cruelty or abandonment, not the dogs who are victims of human neglect.
I urge the Hon’ble Court to reconsider this directive and allow dogs to remain in their own territories after sterilisation and vaccination, as per existing law.
To take away their freedom is to sentence them to a life of captivity they neither deserve nor can survive.
With deep faith in the Hon’ble Court’s commitment to justice, compassion, and respect for the cultural and religious fabric of this nation,
Yours faithfully,
[Your Full Name]
[Your Address]
[Your Email ID]
[Your Contact Number]
Mail 2:
Subject: Appeal Against the Mass Confinement of Stray Dogs in Delhi NCR
To
Hon’ble Chief Justice of India
Supreme Court of India
Tilak Marg, New Delhi – 110001
Respected Lordship,
I write to you with the deepest respect, but also with great concern and urgency, regarding the Hon’ble Supreme Court’s recent order to move all stray dogs in the Delhi NCR region into shelters within eight weeks.
As someone closely associated with animal welfare on the ground, I feel compelled to highlight that this directive, though well-intentioned for public safety, will, in its current form, cause immense suffering to these animals and will be impossible to implement humanely.
Street dogs are not criminals; they have lived in their communities for years, often cared for by local feeders, and play a role in controlling garbage and intruding wildlife.
Confinement is cruelty—in reality, “pounds” in India have long been overcrowded, underfunded, and poorly managed. Moving thousands of dogs into such facilities will not protect them; it will condemn them to slow neglect, disease, and death.
ABC Rules and Constitutional Values
The Animal Birth Control (Dogs) Rules, 2023, and previous court rulings recognise that sterilised, vaccinated dogs should be returned to their territories. This approach ensures population control while respecting their right to live freely, in line with the spirit of Article 51A(g) of the Constitution.
Practical Impossibility
Delhi NCR has neither the infrastructure, staff, nor budget to house tens of thousands of dogs humanely. The eight-week deadline will inevitably lead to rushed, inhumane capture and confinement.
I respectfully submit that removal and permanent sheltering is not the solution. The path forward should be:
I urge the Hon’ble Court to reconsider this directive and allow dogs to remain in their own territories after sterilisation and vaccination, as per existing law.
To take away their freedom is to sentence them to a life of captivity they neither deserve nor can survive.
With deep faith in the Hon’ble Court’s commitment to justice, compassion, and protection of the vulnerable,
Yours faithfully,
[Your Full Name]
[Your Address]
[Your Email ID]
[Your Contact Number]