If
you see some-'thing', and you don't now what it is, how do you call it?
Alright, in most cases 'thing' will do. That must have been the case
around 1850 when the abstract rock art in England and Scotland was
discovered. "Have you seen those strange things on the rocks?". But
more serious people, like the Duke of Northumberland, the Clergyman and
the Bishop couldn't use this common indication. So they tried to be
more specific. But that wasn't easy for 'things' you don't know! The
following descriptions were used between 1830 and 1977:
Lapidary
Art, Ring Cuttings, Sculptured Stones, Circular Carvings, Incised
Markings, Ancient Sculpturings of Cups and Concentric Rings, Incised
Sculpturings, Cup-marked Stones, Cup-and-ring Carvings, Rock Carvings
and Petroglyphs.
It
was not until 1977 that Ronald B. W. Morris introduced the, now fully
accepted, summarizing phrase: "Rock Art" for the abstract open-air rock
carvings in Britain as a whole. By doing so, this special rock art
category was linked to the great worldwide "Rock Art" tradition.
The
late Ronald Morris, a solicitor from Glasgow, who gave such a great
part of his time and live to the research of abstract rock art, was a
serious man. So thanks to him we use the term "Rock Art" instead of a
more trendy term like UCO's (Unidentified Carved Objects)
Classification of abstract Rock Art
(1852-1983)
Right
from the start in 1852, efforts were made to classify the different
motifs. With gradually more motifs found, it became difficult to create
a clear classification system. In 1852 Mr. George Tate made an attempt
to classify the different forms by numbers (1-12)
Mr Tate's early classification of carvings (1852)
(Beckensall, 1983, p. 31)
In
1934 Mr Breuil published his classification system of British and Irish
rock art. He believed that the motifs were representations of the human
figure. The drawings strongly enhance this believe (note the arms, legs
and eyes). (Bradley, 1997, p. 39).
In
1967, 1969 and 1977, Morris made several classification diagrams, a.o.
with (capital) letters. This was followed by Stan Beckensall in 1983
with drawings of the motifs combined with short descriptions.
Classification and vocabulary of abstract Rock Art (1999)
In
his book "British Prehistoric Rock Art" (Tempus, 1999), Stan Beckensall
gives a clear outline of how we should refer to the 'things' we see. He
gives a logic build up:
Elements form symbols or motifs. The arrangement of symbols or motifs on a rock forms a panel.
This
important classification scheme may well end the 'confusion of tongues'
in prehistoric abstract rock art. That's why we took the liberty to
copy the drawings and descriptions from Mr Beckensall's outstanding
book.
Elements
- Cups,
are the most common symbols, and can appear (1) singly, (2) randomly
clustered, (3) in domnino patterns and parallel lines, (4) a rosette,
(5) in a straight line and (6) countersunk;
- Cups at the centre of curved grooves,
(1) Cup and ring, (2) cup and multiple rings, (3) cup and penannular,
(4) cup and multi pennanulars, (5) cup and arc (or semi-ovoid), (6) cup
and multiple arcs;
- Cups with grooves running from them,
(1) cup with groove cutting through ring, (2) cup with groove cutting
through multiple rings, (3) cup and groove with penannular, (4) cup and
groove with multiple penannulars, (5) cup and groove with arc, (6) cup
and groove with multiple arcs;
- Rings, penannulars and arcs, (1) ring, (2) concentric rings, (3) penannular (or gapped ring), (4) multiple penannulars, (5) arc, (6) multiple arcs;
- Keyhole patterns, the seven examples illustrate a number of variations on the theme;
- Grooves enclosing multiple cups,
(1) a rosette enclosed by a ring, (2) a rosette enclosed by two
concentric rings, the central cup having a groove that cuts the ring,
(4) an oval groove enclosing cups, (5) a heart-shaped groove containing
cups, some connected, and one with a groove leading out, (6) multiple
rectangular grooves enclosing cups;
- Grooves, (1) linear, (2) parallel, (3) chevron, (4) serpentine, and (5) grid/hatchings
-
Variations,
above you see some sketches of a number of markings taken out of
context, from all over Britain, not drawn to scale, that illustrate
many 'variations'.
- Spirals (to come)