Table: Characterising learning designs


Format of representation
Abstract or
Contextualisation
Level of granularity
Degree of structure
Compendium LD

Download compendium
(PC only)

View slideshare show
(or view useful presentation)
Visual diagram with textual labeling and annotation
Would vary according to how it was used. In H800 use it was highly contextualised. Each step within the learning activity is mapped to required resources etc, so the diagram is highly specific to a particular implementation.
Fine grained (highly detailed)
Unstructured vocabulary.
Hybrid learning model

HLM website


Visual components on flash cards, with form-based text
The 8 learning events model is abstract, so an learning activity is captured in a simple, highly reusabe formulation such as:
RECEIVES
CREATES
DEBATES
The form-based text is more contextualised and specific



8 learning events model is high level.
The form-based text can be much more detailed
The 8 events are pre-defined:
RECEIVES
DEBATES
EXPERIMENTS
CREATES
EXPLORES
PRACTICES
IMITATES
META-LEARNS.
There is also a pre-defined set of verbs to use for describing the roles of teachers and learners.
Phoebe Pedagogic Planner


Phoebe web site
Template based textual forms
Would vary according to how it was used, but in general would be highly contextualised to a specific implementation.
However, the use of a template with context sensitive guidance would lead users towards filling in some sections in a general, more abstract way (e.g. what are the learning outcomes) and other sections in a highly specific way (e.g. where and when is the session taking place).
Would vary according to how it was used, but in general would be detailed.
In general, unstructured vocabulary.
However, it would be possible to build in to the context sensitive guidance information about structured vocabularies for the relevant sections of the template.


This table is based on the characteristics of learning designs defined by Conole (2008).

References

Conole, G. (2008), 'The role of mediating artefacts in learning design' in Lockyer, L., Bennett, S., Agostinho, S. and Harper, B. (eds) Handbook of Research on Learning Design and Learning Objects: Issues, Applications and Technologies, pp. 187-209, Hersey PA, IGI Global.